ABUNDANCE MACHINES STAGE 1 V4 — FULL CONTEXT # Abundance Machines · Stage 1 v4 A what-if model of a chosen doubling scenario, not a prediction of the future economy. Model snapshot efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445. All output amounts use billion 2026 PPP dollars unless explicitly stated. This site serves its explanatory pages as static HTML and plain text. ## Begin here - [What targets, projections and gaps mean](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.txt) - [Beginner introduction](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/start.txt) - [Methods and limitations](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.txt) - [Evidence labels](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.txt) - [Full text context](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/llms-full.txt) ## Calculations and data - [All model outputs in JSON](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/model.json) - [Schema and units](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/schema.json) - [Source manifest](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/manifest.json) - [Page index and complete page text](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/pages.json) - [Complete downloadable context](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/context.zip) ## Interpretation - This is a what-if analysis. The doubling goal and sector mix are chosen scenarios, not forecasts. On course is a conditional baseline projection; tiers are calculated gaps and shortage blocks are conditional input tests. - Sector targets use estimated spending-response factors for household categories and a default of 1 outside them. The original target labels are E even where that default assumption enters. Choosing another mix changes targets, gaps and requirements. - Own shortage blocks overlap. The model credits the maximum block within each layer/tier, which assumes smaller blocks are contained within it. - The six picks include only two SOLID S/E entries. The code relaxes the brief's minimum of three. - Saving and building permission exceed $1T and have no alternative tests. The code labels saving SOLID under an accounting-identity exemption. - Clinical approval and cropland each have two S6 variants. The ranking columns take the first, while the ranges include both. - The allocation protects on-course output and uses a fixed ordering. Remaining input shortfalls are recorded in diagnostic fields. - Buyer demand assumes target world income. Construction and public services have price elasticity set to zero. - Source registries preserve the original citations. This website build does not constitute a fresh verification of those publications. ## Individual explanations - [A what-if model, not a prediction](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.txt) - [What does today's output mean?](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/today.txt) - [Why choose this 2035 target?](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/target.txt) - [What does the baseline project?](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/growth.txt) - [Tier 1: output growth within historical benchmarks](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.txt) - [Tier 2: required output growth to reach 2×](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.txt) - [Start with the question](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/start.txt) - [How to read the map](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/reading-the-map.txt) - [Food at home](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c01.txt) - [Clothing](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c02.txt) - [Shelter and utilities](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c03.txt) - [Household equipment](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c04.txt) - [Health care](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c05.txt) - [Mobility](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c06.txt) - [Communication](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c07.txt) - [Recreation](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c08.txt) - [Education](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c09.txt) - [Food service, lodging](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c10.txt) - [Personal and financial services](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c11.txt) - [Public services](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c12.txt) - [Built structures](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c13.txt) - [Productive equipment](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c14.txt) - [Knowledge and software](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c15.txt) - [Alcohol, tobacco, narcotics](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u1.txt) - [Net purchases abroad](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u2.txt) - [Inventories](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u3.txt) - [Net exports](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u4.txt) - [What makes up the chosen target economy?](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layers.txt) - [Accounting rows](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u.txt) - [Electricity](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.txt) - [Fuels](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k02.txt) - [Machine cognition (AI agents)](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k03.txt) - [Physical machine labour (robots)](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.txt) - [AI compute](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k05.txt) - [Copper](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k06.txt) - [Lithium](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k07.txt) - [Rare earths](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k08.txt) - [Steel](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k09.txt) - [Cement](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k10.txt) - [Saving for investment](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k11.txt) - [Building permission](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k12.txt) - [Grid connection approval](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.txt) - [Transformers and grid equipment](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.txt) - [Clinical approval](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k15.txt) - [Professional licensing](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k16.txt) - [Construction trades](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k17.txt) - [Human workforce](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k18.txt) - [Aluminium](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k20.txt) - [Capital stock](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.txt) - [Cropland](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.txt) - [Buyers for built structures](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c13.txt) - [Buyers for public services](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c12.txt) - [What could constrain this scenario?](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortages.txt) - [How the model works](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.txt) - [What do the labels mean?](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.txt) - [Where does the unexplained gap come from?](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.txt) - [Why these six picks?](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/picks.txt) - [What changes between scenarios?](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.txt) - [Would people buy the extra output?](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/demand.txt) - [Frontier technologies](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-1.txt) - [Physical ratios](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-2.txt) - [Human needs](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-3.txt) - [Bottlenecks](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-4.txt) - [New capabilities](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-5.txt) - [Cheaper inputs](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-6.txt) - [Where the research comes from](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agents.txt) - [Follow the evidence](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.txt) - [Ask your own AI](https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/ask.txt) EXPLANATIONS A what-if model, not a prediction https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html Read each number according to its role: estimate, chosen target, conditional projection, historical comparison or calculated gap. 1. Choose a goalDouble output and choose a mix of sectors. 2. Build comparisonsUse data, baseline assumptions and selected past growth rates. 3. Calculate the gapsAsk which inputs the chosen scenario would need. This asks: if we wanted this economy, what would have to change? The animation follows the accounting, not a timeline of events that the model predicts will happen. Estimate today $224.3T in 2026 An estimate of annual output at the 2026 starting point. Conditional projection $265.6T baseline in 2035 The 2035 baseline if the model's trend, adoption and input assumptions hold. This is what on course means here. Chosen scenario $448.5T chosen world target A goal and a chosen mix of sectors to test. It is not a prediction of future output or demand. Historical-benchmark comparison $300.4T baseline + tier 1 A conditional calculation using selected past production, employment, productivity or investment rates, proxies and input constraints. These examples need not have occurred together. Accounting rows use bookkeeping assumptions. This is not a physical limit or a guaranteed achievable path. Calculated gap $148.1T remaining tier 2 gap A difference between the chosen target and the model's comparison levels. Changing the target or assumptions changes the gap. Conditional constraint Each shortage's own blocked-output test Output removed when testing one shortage in the chosen scenario. It is not a forecast of lost GDP, and different shortages can overlap. A concrete example: construction The model assigns construction a chosen target of $105.7T. Its conditional baseline is $62.4T, and its selected historical-benchmark comparison reaches $71.1T. The $34.6T tier 2 number is $105.7T minus $71.1T. It is the gap under those choices, not an observation of missing construction or a forecast of future growth. Trace all three construction numbers and their assumptions → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c13.html) Evidence labels answer a different question S, E and A describe the provenance recorded by the source model. They do not tell you whether a number is a target, projection or gap. A target labelled E is still a chosen scenario. Some targets also contain default assumptions despite an inherited E label; the sector pages make those defaults visible. SOLID means a constraint persisted across the cases tried, subject to documented exceptions; it is not a forecast probability. Read the source labels and testing limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) What does today's output mean? https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/today.html $224.3T is the model's estimate of annual world output in 2026. Today + projected baseline growth + tier 1 gap + tier 2 gap = chosen target. This is an accounting breakdown of a scenario, not a prediction that the additions will happen. Neither tier is included in baseline growth. (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/today.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/growth.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | Step | Amount added | Total annual output | Today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/today.html) | Starting point | $224.3T | On-course growth (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/growth.html) | +$41.4T | $265.6T | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | +$34.8T | $300.4T | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | +$148.1T | $448.5T target These are annual output amounts in 2026 purchasing-power dollars. Display values are rounded; totals use the unrounded values. See the exact bridge | Component | Billion 2026 PPP dollars | Today | 224,261.88100 | On-course growth | 41,357.00288 | Tier 1 | 34,757.30900 | Tier 2 | 148,147.56912 | Target | 448,523.76203 Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) GDP measures the value of final goods and services produced during a year. A higher price for the same production would change a nominal total. This model uses a constant 2026 price basis to describe changes in real output. Purchasing power parity, or PPP, converts different economies into a common unit based on what money buys. The site's output figures use 2026 international dollars. A trillion is 1,000 billion. This estimate is labelled E. The full source precision sums to 224,261.9 billion international dollars. Why choose this 2035 target? https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/target.html $448.5T is a chosen goal: twice the model's 2026 world-output estimate. It is not a forecast of the economy in 2035. Today + projected baseline growth + tier 1 gap + tier 2 gap = chosen target. This is an accounting breakdown of a scenario, not a prediction that the additions will happen. Neither tier is included in baseline growth. (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/today.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/growth.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | Step | Amount added | Total annual output | Today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/today.html) | Starting point | $224.3T | On-course growth (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/growth.html) | +$41.4T | $265.6T | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | +$34.8T | $300.4T | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | +$148.1T | $448.5T target These are annual output amounts in 2026 purchasing-power dollars. Display values are rounded; totals use the unrounded values. See the exact bridge | Component | Billion 2026 PPP dollars | Today | 224,261.88100 | On-course growth | 41,357.00288 | Tier 1 | 34,757.30900 | Tier 2 | 148,147.56912 | Target | 448,523.76203 Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) The model works backwards from that goal. It also chooses a sector mix using spending-response factors, with defaults outside household-demand categories. Another mix of the same total would have different sector targets, input needs and gaps. See how that choice produces the construction target (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c13.html) GDP measures the value of final goods and services produced during a year. A higher price for the same production would change a nominal total. This model uses a constant 2026 price basis to describe changes in real output. Purchasing power parity, or PPP, converts different economies into a common unit based on what money buys. The site's output figures use 2026 international dollars. A trillion is 1,000 billion. A doubling over nine years corresponds to about 8.0% compound annual growth. The target mix varies by layer using the upstream demand assumptions, so each layer has its own growth requirement. What does the baseline project? https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/growth.html The baseline projects $41.4T of additional annual output by 2035, conditional on its assumptions. This is what the map calls on course. Today + projected baseline growth + tier 1 gap + tier 2 gap = chosen target. This is an accounting breakdown of a scenario, not a prediction that the additions will happen. Neither tier is included in baseline growth. (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/today.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/growth.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | Step | Amount added | Total annual output | Today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/today.html) | Starting point | $224.3T | On-course growth (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/growth.html) | +$41.4T | $265.6T | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | +$34.8T | $300.4T | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | +$148.1T | $448.5T target These are annual output amounts in 2026 purchasing-power dollars. Display values are rounded; totals use the unrounded values. See the exact bridge | Component | Billion 2026 PPP dollars | Today | 224,261.88100 | On-course growth | 41,357.00288 | Tier 1 | 34,757.30900 | Tier 2 | 148,147.56912 | Target | 448,523.76203 Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) Adding this growth to today's $224.3T gives $265.6T on course. The remaining gap to the target is $182.9T. That missing $182.9T is split into $34.8T of tier 1 and $148.1T of tier 2. Both are additional to on-course growth and still need to be achieved. The baseline combines trends and adopted technologies with input adjustments carried from earlier calculations. Extending those trends and assumptions into 2035 is a projection, not a guaranteed outcome. Its growth figures carry A labels where assumptions enter the baseline. Tier 1: output growth within historical benchmarks https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html Extra output that inputs growing at the model's record pace would make. Closing this gap takes building and scaling up what people already know how to do. Today + projected baseline growth + tier 1 gap + tier 2 gap = chosen target. This is an accounting breakdown of a scenario, not a prediction that the additions will happen. Neither tier is included in baseline growth. (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/today.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/growth.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | Step | Amount added | Total annual output | Today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/today.html) | Starting point | $224.3T | On-course growth (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/growth.html) | +$41.4T | $265.6T | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | +$34.8T | $300.4T | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | +$148.1T | $448.5T target These are annual output amounts in 2026 purchasing-power dollars. Display values are rounded; totals use the unrounded values. See the exact bridge | Component | Billion 2026 PPP dollars | Today | 224,261.88100 | On-course growth | 41,357.00288 | Tier 1 | 34,757.30900 | Tier 2 | 148,147.56912 | Target | 448,523.76203 Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) Tier 1 adds $34.8T of annual output to the $265.6T conditional baseline, bringing the total to $300.4T. The calculation caps tier 1 at each chosen sector target. The benchmarks use selected past rates of production, employment, productivity or investment. Some combine examples from different periods or use proxies, then apply input constraints. They are not one growth rate that the whole world has previously achieved together. Reaching them still requires additional effort and suitable conditions. How the shortage tests use tier 1 The code attempts the on-course economy plus tier 1 and compares its input need with on-course supply. The resulting block indicates the input growth the model still requires. A slower current input path describes the gap. Explaining why adoption, investment or permission is slow requires more causal evidence than this comparison alone provides. Tier 2: required output growth to reach 2× https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html Extra output beyond the model's historical benchmarks. Reaching the doubling target calls for discoveries that cut the inputs needed per unit of output or break a historical speed limit. Today + projected baseline growth + tier 1 gap + tier 2 gap = chosen target. This is an accounting breakdown of a scenario, not a prediction that the additions will happen. Neither tier is included in baseline growth. (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/today.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/growth.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | Step | Amount added | Total annual output | Today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/today.html) | Starting point | $224.3T | On-course growth (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/growth.html) | +$41.4T | $265.6T | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | +$34.8T | $300.4T | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | +$148.1T | $448.5T target These are annual output amounts in 2026 purchasing-power dollars. Display values are rounded; totals use the unrounded values. See the exact bridge | Component | Billion 2026 PPP dollars | Today | 224,261.88100 | On-course growth | 41,357.00288 | Tier 1 | 34,757.30900 | Tier 2 | 148,147.56912 | Target | 448,523.76203 Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) On course plus tier 1 reaches $300.4T. Tier 2 is the extra $148.1T of annual output needed to reach the $448.5T target. A historical speed limit here means the record pace the model uses for comparison. The gap depends on the chosen sector mix, the selected records and the model's input assumptions. The model measures the output gap and leaves open how many discoveries would close it. How the shortage tests use tier 2 The code attempts the full target at each input's precedent supply and records the tier-2 output it must remove. Every shortage page shows the alternatives tried. Start with the question https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/start.html What would it take for annual world output to double by 2035, and what could hold it back? Begin with a what-if question Imagine the world producing more meals, homes, care, transport and other services each year. This model sets a total goal of $448.5T in 2035 and asks which inputs would be required to get there. It chooses a mix of sectors inside that goal. The baseline is a conditional projection; the tiers are gaps calculated against the chosen scenario. The animation does not mean all of that output is expected to arrive. Distinguish targets, projections and gaps (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html) Read the four parts of the bridge Today + projected baseline growth + tier 1 gap + tier 2 gap = chosen target. This is an accounting breakdown of a scenario, not a prediction that the additions will happen. Neither tier is included in baseline growth. (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/today.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/growth.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | Step | Amount added | Total annual output | Today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/today.html) | Starting point | $224.3T | On-course growth (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/growth.html) | +$41.4T | $265.6T | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | +$34.8T | $300.4T | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | +$148.1T | $448.5T target These are annual output amounts in 2026 purchasing-power dollars. Display values are rounded; totals use the unrounded values. See the exact bridge | Component | Billion 2026 PPP dollars | Today | 224,261.88100 | On-course growth | 41,357.00288 | Tier 1 | 34,757.30900 | Tier 2 | 148,147.56912 | Target | 448,523.76203 Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) The grey part is today's output. Teal adds $41.4T already counted on course. Cyan adds another $34.8T in tier 1, within the chosen historical precedents. Yellow adds a further $148.1T in tier 2, beyond those precedents. Both tiers still need to be achieved. Follow one everyday layer Food at home starts at $12.6T. The model counts $1.5T of growth on course, $1.2T in tier 1 and $5.9T in tier 2. Together they reach its $21.2T target. Follow the food calculation (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c01.html) Ask which input is short A bakery might need flour, workers, ovens and electricity to make more bread. The model asks an equivalent question for each layer. It estimates how much of an input the target needs, compares that with supply, and translates the shortfall into output. For physical machine labour, the base case needs 1,202.3 million worker-equivalents and has 42.9 at precedent. The output attributed to that constraint ranges from $1.1T to $102.5T across its task splits. See why the robot estimate changes (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) Read the evidence and assumptions An A label marks an assumption. SOLID means the shortage binds across the tests performed, subject to the saving exception documented in the methods. The range shows how much its size changes. These labels answer different questions. Understand the evidence labels (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) Keep the open questions in view The model leaves $41.5T unexplained under its overlap rule. Its six picks contain two SOLID estimates labelled S or E, against a requested minimum of three. How the unexplained amount is calculatedOverlap and gaps → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Why these six shortages were selectedCriteria and limitations → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/picks.html) How to read the map https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/reading-the-map.html The homepage connects the research, the output target, the layers and the individually tested shortages. Research streamsThe evidence behind the model → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agents.html) BridgeToday, growth and the two gaps → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/target.html) ChannelsAdditional output by layer → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layers.html) Red gatesInputs that constrain production → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortages.html) Ranked poolEach shortage tested on its own → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/picks.html) The target bar includes today's output. The layer channels show the additional output needed between today and the target. Their widths follow that additional output. Within each channel, read from top to bottom: yellow tier 2 gap, light-blue tier 1 gap, then green baseline growth. Where flows overlap, green is drawn in front of blue, and blue in front of yellow, so the smaller bands stay visible. The animation illustrates a chosen what-if scenario; it is not a timeline or a forecast of those gaps closing. The amounts add together: today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target. Tier 1 is extra beyond the on-course economy; tier 2 is further output beyond on course plus tier 1. Each layer's three channel numbers also add together. The red gates mark which layers a shortage affects. Each shortage is tested independently, so several gates can refer to the same missing output. The pool is a ranking of those overlapping tests. Click a label to follow its explanation. The animation starts playing, and the Pause button stops the motion. Food at home https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c01.html Food and non-alcoholic drinks bought for eating at home. This follows household food spending through the economy, including the inputs used to make and deliver it. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$12.6TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$14.1T$1.5T projected growth Historical-benchmark comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$15.3T$1.2T tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$21.2T$5.9T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. The historical-benchmark comparison includes input adjustments and is limited to the portion used for this target; it is not a physical ceiling. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to food at home alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $14.1T − $12.6T | $1.5T | Tier 1 gap | $15.3T − $14.1T | $1.2T | Tier 2 gap | $21.2T − $15.3T | $5.9T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 4.7% of that total: $21.2T. The allocation uses a spending-response factor of 0.624, estimated from historical household-spending data. In plain English, a 1% income increase is associated with roughly 0.62% more spending on this category in that relationship. Applying it to a future doubled world is a modelling choice. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $21.2T | $5.9T | Every sector simply doubles | $25.2T | $9.9T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$12.6T + $1.5T + $1.2T + $5.9T = $21.2T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $12.6T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | $1.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $1.2T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $5.9T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $21.2T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. | Shortage | Blocked in this layer | Evidence | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | $7.1T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Capital stock (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html) | $5.9T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Cropland (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html) | $5.9T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | $1.2T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | $1.2T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | $1.2T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | $1.2T | $1.2T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $5.9T | $5.9T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier Physical machine labour (robots) on course meets 3% of need; at its fastest precedent (China electric-car sales 2014-2023 x111 in 9 years (IEA via OWID) applied to humanoid ship) it meets 4%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): needs a price fall of 6% (cost room for it not sourced) Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster) Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Clothing https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c02.html Clothing and footwear. Making more of this output requires the materials, equipment, energy and work involved across its supply chain. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$3.4TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$4.4T$994bn projected growth Historical-benchmark comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$4.8T$447bn tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$6.5T$1.7T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. The historical-benchmark comparison includes input adjustments and is limited to the portion used for this target; it is not a physical ceiling. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to clothing alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $4.4T − $3.4T | $994bn | Tier 1 gap | $4.8T − $4.4T | $447bn | Tier 2 gap | $6.5T − $4.8T | $1.7T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 1.5% of that total: $6.5T. The allocation uses a spending-response factor of 0.965, estimated from historical household-spending data. In plain English, a 1% income increase is associated with roughly 0.97% more spending on this category in that relationship. Applying it to a future doubled world is a modelling choice. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $6.5T | $1.7T | Every sector simply doubles | $6.8T | $1.9T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$3.4T + $994bn + $447bn + $1.7T = $6.5T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $3.4T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | $994bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $447bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $1.7T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $6.5T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. | Shortage | Blocked in this layer | Evidence | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | $1.7T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Capital stock (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html) | $1.7T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Cropland (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html) | $1.7T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | $447bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | $447bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | $447bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | $447bn | $447bn | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $1.7T | $1.7T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): needs a price fall of 11% (cost room for it not sourced) Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster) Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Shelter and utilities https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c03.html The service of having a home, including actual and imputed rent, water and household energy. Imputed rent is the estimated housing service received by people living in homes they own. New construction has its own layer. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$29.6TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$34.1T$4.5T projected growth Historical-benchmark comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$34.7T$627bn tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$59.2T$24.5T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. The historical-benchmark comparison includes input adjustments and is limited to the portion used for this target; it is not a physical ceiling. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to shelter and utilities alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $34.1T − $29.6T | $4.5T | Tier 1 gap | $34.7T − $34.1T | $627bn | Tier 2 gap | $59.2T − $34.7T | $24.5T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 13.2% of that total: $59.2T. The allocation uses a spending-response factor of 1.064, estimated from historical household-spending data. In plain English, a 1% income increase is associated with roughly 1.06% more spending on this category in that relationship. Applying it to a future doubled world is a modelling choice. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $59.2T | $24.5T | Every sector simply doubles | $59.2T | $24.5T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$29.6T + $4.5T + $627bn + $24.5T = $59.2T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $29.6T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | $4.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $627bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $24.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $59.2T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. | Shortage | Blocked in this layer | Evidence | Capital stock (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html) | $21.2T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | $2.7T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | $627bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | $627bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | $627bn | $627bn | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $24.5T | $21.2T | $3.3T (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): demand at today's price exceeds max output Capital stock would have to grow 8.0% a year 2026-35 against 5.6% at its fastest precedent (1.4x faster) Would the extra output be bought? At its assumed 2035 price, the model estimates demand of $62.9T against a target of $59.2T. The buyer shortfall is $0bn. See the demand calculation (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/demand.html) Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Household equipment https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c04.html Furniture, appliances and other equipment used in households, together with the household goods and services grouped with them in the model. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$3.8TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$4.9T$1.0T projected growth Historical-benchmark comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$6.3T$1.5T tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$7.6T$1.3T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. The historical-benchmark comparison includes input adjustments and is limited to the portion used for this target; it is not a physical ceiling. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to household equipment alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $4.9T − $3.8T | $1.0T | Tier 1 gap | $6.3T − $4.9T | $1.5T | Tier 2 gap | $7.6T − $6.3T | $1.3T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 1.7% of that total: $7.6T. The allocation uses a spending-response factor of 1.049, estimated from historical household-spending data. In plain English, a 1% income increase is associated with roughly 1.05% more spending on this category in that relationship. Applying it to a future doubled world is a modelling choice. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $7.6T | $1.3T | Every sector simply doubles | $7.7T | $1.4T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$3.8T + $1.0T + $1.5T + $1.3T = $7.6T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $3.8T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | $1.0T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $1.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $1.3T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $7.6T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. | Shortage | Blocked in this layer | Evidence | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | $1.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | $1.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | $1.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Aluminium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k20.html) | $1.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | $1.3T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Capital stock (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html) | $1.3T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Cropland (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html) | $1.3T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | $1.5T | $1.5T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $1.3T | $1.3T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): needs a price fall of 20% (cost room for it not sourced) Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster) Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Health care https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c05.html Health care, including the services and products used to provide care. Its monetary output is a measure of economic production. Improvements in health also depend on the effectiveness and distribution of that care. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$23.5TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$30.0T$6.5T projected growth Historical-benchmark comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$31.8T$1.8T tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$51.1T$19.3T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. The historical-benchmark comparison includes input adjustments and is limited to the portion used for this target; it is not a physical ceiling. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to health care alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $30.0T − $23.5T | $6.5T | Tier 1 gap | $31.8T − $30.0T | $1.8T | Tier 2 gap | $51.1T − $31.8T | $19.3T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 11.4% of that total: $51.1T. The allocation uses a spending-response factor of 1.280, estimated from historical household-spending data. In plain English, a 1% income increase is associated with roughly 1.28% more spending on this category in that relationship. Applying it to a future doubled world is a modelling choice. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $51.1T | $19.3T | Every sector simply doubles | $46.9T | $15.2T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$23.5T + $6.5T + $1.8T + $19.3T = $51.1T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $23.5T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | $6.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $1.8T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $19.3T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $51.1T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. | Shortage | Blocked in this layer | Evidence | Clinical approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k15.html) | $19.6T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Professional licensing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k16.html) | $13.8T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | $1.8T | $1.3T | $437bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $19.3T | $18.3T | $1.0T (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier Clinical approval on course meets 60% of need; at its fastest precedent (Further health output is workforce (2010-19) and productivity (2015-24) precedents achieve) it meets 64%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): demand at today's price exceeds max output Clinical approval would have to grow 9.0% a year 2026-35 against 3.8% at its fastest precedent (2.4x faster) Would the extra output be bought? At its assumed 2035 price, the model estimates demand of $57.0T against a target of $51.1T. The buyer shortfall is $0bn. See the demand calculation (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/demand.html) Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Mobility https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c06.html Transport and mobility, including the goods and services people use to move around. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$8.6TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$9.5T$868bn projected growth Historical-benchmark comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$14.8T$5.3T tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$17.8T$3.0T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. The historical-benchmark comparison includes input adjustments and is limited to the portion used for this target; it is not a physical ceiling. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to mobility alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $9.5T − $8.6T | $868bn | Tier 1 gap | $14.8T − $9.5T | $5.3T | Tier 2 gap | $17.8T − $14.8T | $3.0T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 4.0% of that total: $17.8T. The allocation uses a spending-response factor of 1.150, estimated from historical household-spending data. In plain English, a 1% income increase is associated with roughly 1.15% more spending on this category in that relationship. Applying it to a future doubled world is a modelling choice. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $17.8T | $3.0T | Every sector simply doubles | $17.2T | $2.4T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$8.6T + $868bn + $5.3T + $3.0T = $17.8T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $8.6T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | $868bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $5.3T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $3.0T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $17.8T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. | Shortage | Blocked in this layer | Evidence | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | $5.3T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | $5.3T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | $5.3T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | $3.0T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Capital stock (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html) | $3.0T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Aluminium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k20.html) | $2.6T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | $5.3T | $5.3T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $3.0T | $3.0T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): needs a price fall of 37% (cost room for it not sourced) Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster) Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Communication https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c07.html Communication services and equipment. The model asks how much additional communication output fits the target economy and which inputs could limit it. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$4.3TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$5.3T$998bn projected growth Historical-benchmark comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$5.4T$83bn tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$8.9T$3.5T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. The historical-benchmark comparison includes input adjustments and is limited to the portion used for this target; it is not a physical ceiling. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to communication alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $5.3T − $4.3T | $998bn | Tier 1 gap | $5.4T − $5.3T | $83bn | Tier 2 gap | $8.9T − $5.4T | $3.5T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 2.0% of that total: $8.9T. The allocation uses a spending-response factor of 1.154, estimated from historical household-spending data. In plain English, a 1% income increase is associated with roughly 1.15% more spending on this category in that relationship. Applying it to a future doubled world is a modelling choice. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $8.9T | $3.5T | Every sector simply doubles | $8.6T | $3.2T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$4.3T + $998bn + $83bn + $3.5T = $8.9T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $4.3T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | $998bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $83bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $3.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $8.9T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. The base calculation assigns no positive shortage block to this layer. | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | $83bn | $0bn | $83bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $3.5T | $0bn | $3.5T (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier This row has no named input explanation in the base calculation. This row has no named input explanation in the base calculation. Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Recreation https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c08.html Recreation and culture. This is the model's grouping for the goods and services people use for leisure. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$6.0TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$6.3T$311bn projected growth Historical-benchmark comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$7.8T$1.6T tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$13.3T$5.5T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. The historical-benchmark comparison includes input adjustments and is limited to the portion used for this target; it is not a physical ceiling. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to recreation alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $6.3T − $6.0T | $311bn | Tier 1 gap | $7.8T − $6.3T | $1.6T | Tier 2 gap | $13.3T − $7.8T | $5.5T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 3.0% of that total: $13.3T. The allocation uses a spending-response factor of 1.351, estimated from historical household-spending data. In plain English, a 1% income increase is associated with roughly 1.35% more spending on this category in that relationship. Applying it to a future doubled world is a modelling choice. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $13.3T | $5.5T | Every sector simply doubles | $11.9T | $4.1T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$6.0T + $311bn + $1.6T + $5.5T = $13.3T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $6.0T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | $311bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $1.6T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $5.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $13.3T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. | Shortage | Blocked in this layer | Evidence | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | $5.9T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Capital stock (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html) | $5.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | $1.6T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | $550bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | $550bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | $1.6T | $1.6T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $5.5T | $5.5T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): demand at today's price exceeds max output Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster) Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Education https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c09.html Education services. The target measures education output valued in common prices. Learning quality and access require additional evidence. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$16.7TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$19.9T$3.2T projected growth Historical-benchmark comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$22.3T$2.4T tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$31.6T$9.2T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. The historical-benchmark comparison includes input adjustments and is limited to the portion used for this target; it is not a physical ceiling. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to education alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $19.9T − $16.7T | $3.2T | Tier 1 gap | $22.3T − $19.9T | $2.4T | Tier 2 gap | $31.6T − $22.3T | $9.2T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 7.0% of that total: $31.6T. The allocation uses a spending-response factor of 0.918, estimated from historical household-spending data. In plain English, a 1% income increase is associated with roughly 0.92% more spending on this category in that relationship. Applying it to a future doubled world is a modelling choice. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $31.6T | $9.2T | Every sector simply doubles | $33.5T | $11.1T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$16.7T + $3.2T + $2.4T + $9.2T = $31.6T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $16.7T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | $3.2T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $2.4T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $9.2T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $31.6T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. The base calculation assigns no positive shortage block to this layer. | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | $2.4T | $0bn | $2.4T (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $9.2T | $0bn | $9.2T (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier This row has no named input explanation in the base calculation. This row has no named input explanation in the base calculation. Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Food service, lodging https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c10.html Prepared meals, restaurants, hotels and other lodging. Food eaten through these services belongs in this layer. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$6.0TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$7.6T$1.6T projected growth Historical-benchmark comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$9.1T$1.4T tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$13.3T$4.2T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. The historical-benchmark comparison includes input adjustments and is limited to the portion used for this target; it is not a physical ceiling. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to food service, lodging alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $7.6T − $6.0T | $1.6T | Tier 1 gap | $9.1T − $7.6T | $1.4T | Tier 2 gap | $13.3T − $9.1T | $4.2T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 3.0% of that total: $13.3T. The allocation uses a spending-response factor of 1.313, estimated from historical household-spending data. In plain English, a 1% income increase is associated with roughly 1.31% more spending on this category in that relationship. Applying it to a future doubled world is a modelling choice. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $13.3T | $4.2T | Every sector simply doubles | $12.1T | $3.0T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$6.0T + $1.6T + $1.4T + $4.2T = $13.3T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $6.0T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | $1.6T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $1.4T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $4.2T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $13.3T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. | Shortage | Blocked in this layer | Evidence | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | $4.2T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Cropland (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html) | $4.2T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | $1.4T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | $1.4T | $1.4T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $4.2T | $4.2T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): needs a price fall of 2% (cost room for it not sourced) Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster) Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Personal and financial services https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c11.html A broad grouping of personal, financial and related services. It combines different activities, so a large constraint assigned to this layer needs interpretation at a more detailed task level. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$15.9TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$19.2T$3.4T projected growth Historical-benchmark comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$21.1T$1.9T tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$35.0T$13.9T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. The historical-benchmark comparison includes input adjustments and is limited to the portion used for this target; it is not a physical ceiling. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to personal and financial services alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $19.2T − $15.9T | $3.4T | Tier 1 gap | $21.1T − $19.2T | $1.9T | Tier 2 gap | $35.0T − $21.1T | $13.9T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 7.8% of that total: $35.0T. The allocation uses a spending-response factor of 1.313, estimated from historical household-spending data. In plain English, a 1% income increase is associated with roughly 1.31% more spending on this category in that relationship. Applying it to a future doubled world is a modelling choice. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $35.0T | $13.9T | Every sector simply doubles | $31.7T | $10.6T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$15.9T + $3.4T + $1.9T + $13.9T = $35.0T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $15.9T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | $3.4T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $1.9T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $13.9T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $35.0T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. | Shortage | Blocked in this layer | Evidence | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | $13.9T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | $1.8T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | $1.9T | $1.8T | $95bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $13.9T | $13.9T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): demand at today's price exceeds max output Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster) Would the extra output be bought? At its assumed 2035 price, the model estimates demand of $39.5T against a target of $35.0T. The buyer shortfall is $0bn. See the demand calculation (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/demand.html) Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Public services https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c12.html Public services represented by government consumption in the model. Budgets, staffing and the organisation of provision affect how much can be supplied and used. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$17.5TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$19.9T$2.4T projected growth Historical-benchmark comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$22.9T$3.0T tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$34.1T$11.2T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. The historical-benchmark comparison includes input adjustments and is limited to the portion used for this target; it is not a physical ceiling. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to public services alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $19.9T − $17.5T | $2.4T | Tier 1 gap | $22.9T − $19.9T | $3.0T | Tier 2 gap | $34.1T − $22.9T | $11.2T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 7.6% of that total: $34.1T. For this layer, the spending-response factor is a default of 1.00: spending is treated as rising one for one with income in the allocation rule. This value was assigned outside the household-demand categories; it is not a measured forecast for this sector. The source table labels the target [E], but its spending-response factor is a default assumption. That inherited label does not make the target an observation or prediction. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $34.1T | $11.2T | Every sector simply doubles | $35.0T | $12.1T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$17.5T + $2.4T + $3.0T + $11.2T = $34.1T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $17.5T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | $2.4T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $3.0T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $11.2T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $34.1T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. | Shortage | Blocked in this layer | Evidence | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | $11.2T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | $3.0T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Buyers for public services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c12.html) | $826bn | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | $3.0T | $3.0T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $11.2T | $11.2T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): UNTESTED: income elasticity is a default (non-household layer); price elasticity A or zero Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster) Would the extra output be bought? At its assumed 2035 price, the model estimates demand of $33.3T against a target of $34.1T. The buyer shortfall is $826bn. See the demand calculation (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/demand.html) Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Built structures https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c13.html New buildings and other structures produced through construction investment. This is an annual flow of new construction. The existing stock of buildings supports output across several layers. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$54.2TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$62.4T$8.2T projected growth Historical-benchmark comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$71.1T$8.7T tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$105.7T$34.6T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. The historical-benchmark comparison includes input adjustments and is limited to the portion used for this target; it is not a physical ceiling. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to built structures alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $62.4T − $54.2T | $8.2T | Tier 1 gap | $71.1T − $62.4T | $8.7T | Tier 2 gap | $105.7T − $71.1T | $34.6T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 23.6% of that total: $105.7T. For this layer, the spending-response factor is a default of 1.00: spending is treated as rising one for one with income in the allocation rule. This value was assigned outside the household-demand categories; it is not a measured forecast for this sector. The source table labels the target [E], but its spending-response factor is a default assumption. That inherited label does not make the target an observation or prediction. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $105.7T | $34.6T | Every sector simply doubles | $108.5T | $37.4T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Why the other construction levels are $62.4T and $71.1T | Step in the inherited calculation | Annual output | Trend-based baseline before the input adjustment | $67.9T | Subtract the assumed baseline finance shortfall | −$5.5T | Baseline counted by v4 | $62.4T | Historical-benchmark comparison before the workforce adjustment | $74.2T | Subtract output attributed to the workforce constraint | −$3.1T | Historical-benchmark comparison used for the tier split | $71.1T The historical comparison recorded in the source is world real construction value added 2003-2012 (UN AMA ISIC F): 3.54%/yr. The projected levels and adjustments depend on applying that history and the input assumptions to this scenario. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/blocked_by_layer.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/blocked_by_layer.csv) A separate v4 demand test, conditional on doubled world income, gives $97.2T of construction demand against the chosen $105.7T target. Its $8.5T difference is a reason to question the target mix, not proof that this much construction will be lost. Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$54.2T + $8.2T + $8.7T + $34.6T = $105.7T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $54.2T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | $8.2T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $8.7T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $34.6T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $105.7T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. | Shortage | Blocked in this layer | Evidence | Construction trades (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k17.html) | $16.0T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | $8.7T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Saving for investment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k11.html) | $8.6T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Buyers for built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c13.html) | $8.5T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | $5.1T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Building permission (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k12.html) | $1.1T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | $8.7T | $8.7T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $34.6T | $15.4T | $19.2T (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): UNTESTED: income elasticity is a default (non-household layer); price elasticity A or zero Construction trades would have to grow 7.0% a year 2026-35 against 5.4% at its fastest precedent (1.3x faster) Would the extra output be bought? At its assumed 2035 price, the model estimates demand of $97.2T against a target of $105.7T. The buyer shortfall is $8.5T. See the demand calculation (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/demand.html) Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Productive equipment https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c14.html New machinery and productive equipment purchased as investment. These assets help produce goods and services in later periods. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$7.1TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$8.9T$1.8T projected growth Historical-benchmark comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$12.2T$3.4T tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$13.7T$1.5T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. The historical-benchmark comparison includes input adjustments and is limited to the portion used for this target; it is not a physical ceiling. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to productive equipment alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $8.9T − $7.1T | $1.8T | Tier 1 gap | $12.2T − $8.9T | $3.4T | Tier 2 gap | $13.7T − $12.2T | $1.5T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 3.1% of that total: $13.7T. For this layer, the spending-response factor is a default of 1.00: spending is treated as rising one for one with income in the allocation rule. This value was assigned outside the household-demand categories; it is not a measured forecast for this sector. The source table labels the target [E], but its spending-response factor is a default assumption. That inherited label does not make the target an observation or prediction. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $13.7T | $1.5T | Every sector simply doubles | $14.1T | $1.9T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$7.1T + $1.8T + $3.4T + $1.5T = $13.7T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $7.1T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | $1.8T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $3.4T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $1.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $13.7T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. | Shortage | Blocked in this layer | Evidence | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | $3.4T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Saving for investment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k11.html) | $3.4T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | $3.4T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | $3.4T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Aluminium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k20.html) | $3.4T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | $1.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Capital stock (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html) | $1.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Cropland (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html) | $1.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Copper (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k06.html) | $166bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | $3.4T | $3.4T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $1.5T | $1.5T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): UNTESTED: income elasticity is a default (non-household layer); price elasticity A or zero Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster) Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Knowledge and software https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c15.html Investment in knowledge, software and other intellectual-property products as grouped in the model. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$7.2TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$11.2T$3.9T projected growth Historical-benchmark comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$12.5T$1.3T tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$14.1T$1.6T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. The historical-benchmark comparison includes input adjustments and is limited to the portion used for this target; it is not a physical ceiling. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to knowledge and software alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $11.2T − $7.2T | $3.9T | Tier 1 gap | $12.5T − $11.2T | $1.3T | Tier 2 gap | $14.1T − $12.5T | $1.6T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 3.1% of that total: $14.1T. For this layer, the spending-response factor is a default of 1.00: spending is treated as rising one for one with income in the allocation rule. This value was assigned outside the household-demand categories; it is not a measured forecast for this sector. The source table labels the target [E], but its spending-response factor is a default assumption. That inherited label does not make the target an observation or prediction. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $14.1T | $1.6T | Every sector simply doubles | $14.4T | $1.9T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$7.2T + $3.9T + $1.3T + $1.6T = $14.1T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $7.2T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | $3.9T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $1.3T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $1.6T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $14.1T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. | Shortage | Blocked in this layer | Evidence | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | $1.6T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Capital stock (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html) | $1.6T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Saving for investment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k11.html) | $1.3T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | $1.3T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | $1.3T | $1.3T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $1.6T | $1.6T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): UNTESTED: income elasticity is a default (non-household layer); price elasticity A or zero Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster) Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Alcohol, tobacco, narcotics https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u1.html Alcohol, tobacco and narcotics retained as an accounting category in the world-output total. Its inclusion follows the accounting coverage of the source data. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$3.6TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$3.9T$317bn projected growth Accounting comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$4.0T$57bn tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$7.0T$3.0T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. This accounting row uses bookkeeping assumptions, not an independently demonstrated production-growth benchmark. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to alcohol, tobacco, narcotics alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $3.9T − $3.6T | $317bn | Tier 1 gap | $4.0T − $3.9T | $57bn | Tier 2 gap | $7.0T − $4.0T | $3.0T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 1.6% of that total: $7.0T. For this layer, the spending-response factor is a default of 1.00: spending is treated as rising one for one with income in the allocation rule. This value was assigned outside the household-demand categories; it is not a measured forecast for this sector. The source table labels the target [E], but its spending-response factor is a default assumption. That inherited label does not make the target an observation or prediction. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $7.0T | $3.0T | Every sector simply doubles | $7.2T | $3.2T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$3.6T + $317bn + $57bn + $3.0T = $7.0T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $3.6T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | $317bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $57bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $3.0T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $7.0T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. | Shortage | Blocked in this layer | Evidence | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | $3.0T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Cropland (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html) | $3.0T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | $57bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Aluminium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k20.html) | $57bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | $57bn | $57bn | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $3.0T | $3.0T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster) Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Net purchases abroad https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u2.html Net purchases abroad, an adjustment for the difference between residents' purchases abroad and non-residents' purchases at home. This row can be negative. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026−$137bnStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035−$267bn−$130bn projected growth Accounting comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1−$267bn$0bn tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target−$267bn$0bn tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. This accounting row uses bookkeeping assumptions, not an independently demonstrated production-growth benchmark. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to net purchases abroad alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | −$267bn − −$137bn | −$130bn | Tier 1 gap | −$267bn − −$267bn | $0bn | Tier 2 gap | −$267bn − −$267bn | $0bn Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives -0.1% of that total: −$267bn. For this layer, the spending-response factor is a default of 1.00: spending is treated as rising one for one with income in the allocation rule. This value was assigned outside the household-demand categories; it is not a measured forecast for this sector. The source table labels the target [E], but its spending-response factor is a default assumption. That inherited label does not make the target an observation or prediction. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | −$267bn | $0bn | Every sector simply doubles | −$274bn | $0bn Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target−$137bn + −$130bn + $0bn + $0bn = −$267bn Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | −$137bn | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | −$130bn | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $0bn | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $0bn | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | −$267bn | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. The base calculation assigns no positive shortage block to this layer. Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Inventories https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u3.html Changes in inventories. Goods produced and held for later sale enter national accounting through this adjustment. Its growth component can be negative. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$2.3TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$2.2T−$32bn projected growth Accounting comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$2.3T$32bn tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$4.4T$2.1T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. This accounting row uses bookkeeping assumptions, not an independently demonstrated production-growth benchmark. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to inventories alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $2.2T − $2.3T | −$32bn | Tier 1 gap | $2.3T − $2.2T | $32bn | Tier 2 gap | $4.4T − $2.3T | $2.1T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 1.0% of that total: $4.4T. For this layer, the spending-response factor is a default of 1.00: spending is treated as rising one for one with income in the allocation rule. This value was assigned outside the household-demand categories; it is not a measured forecast for this sector. The source table labels the target [E], but its spending-response factor is a default assumption. That inherited label does not make the target an observation or prediction. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $4.4T | $2.1T | Every sector simply doubles | $4.5T | $2.3T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$2.3T + −$32bn + $32bn + $2.1T = $4.4T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $2.3T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | −$32bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $32bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $2.1T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $4.4T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. | Shortage | Blocked in this layer | Evidence | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | $2.1T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Capital stock (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html) | $2.1T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Cropland (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html) | $2.1T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | $32bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | $32bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | $32bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Aluminium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k20.html) | $32bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 1 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-1.html) | $32bn | $32bn | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $2.1T | $2.1T | $0bn (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster) Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) Net exports https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u4.html Net exports as carried through the source accounting. A world aggregate can retain a discrepancy because the reported national series and conversion methods do not cancel exactly. The row is retained for reconciliation. Estimate today (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#today)Today · 2026$2.2TStarting estimate Conditional projection (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#baseline)On course · 2035$2.2T$0bn projected growth Accounting comparison (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#comparison)Baseline + tier 1$2.2T$0bn tier 1 gap Chosen scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#target)Chosen 2035 target$4.3T$2.1T tier 2 gap Annual output at 2026 purchasing-power prices. This accounting row uses bookkeeping assumptions, not an independently demonstrated production-growth benchmark. Where the map's three numbers come from These amounts belong to net exports alone. The first is projected growth under the baseline assumptions. The other two are calculated gaps to a chosen target. They do not predict how much new output will actually arrive. | Part | Calculation | Amount | Baseline growth | $2.2T − $2.2T | $0bn | Tier 1 gap | $2.2T − $2.2T | $0bn | Tier 2 gap | $4.3T − $2.2T | $2.1T Display values are rounded. The underlying calculation uses the full precision in the CSV. Why is this the sector target? The model first chooses a $448.5T world economy, then chooses what that economy contains. This layer receives 1.0% of that total: $4.3T. For this layer, the spending-response factor is a default of 1.00: spending is treated as rising one for one with income in the allocation rule. This value was assigned outside the household-demand categories; it is not a measured forecast for this sector. The source table labels the target [E], but its spending-response factor is a default assumption. That inherited label does not make the target an observation or prediction. The calculation combines a macro baseline allocated at today's sector shares with an additional gap allocated using those response factors. It then scales all sector targets to the same world total. A different allocation rule gives different sector targets and tier gaps. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) Compare two target choices already in the source | Target mix | This sector's target | Its tier 2 gap | Selected spending mix | $4.3T | $2.1T | Every sector simply doubles | $4.4T | $2.2T Both choices allocate the same total world target. This is the upstream v3 comparison that v4 inherits for its sector targets; it is not a new run of the v4 shortage model or a probability range. Source files · inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) Show the calculation Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target$2.2T + $0bn + $0bn + $2.1T = $4.3T Display values are rounded. The CSV retains the precision used in the checks. Each term carries its own evidence label. | Component | Amount | Evidence | today | $2.2T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | growth | $0bn | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier1 | $0bn | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | tier2 | $2.1T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | target | $4.3T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What constrains this chosen scenario? Each row below calculates a constraint if this target mix is attempted. It is not a forecast of lost GDP. Each test treats the other inputs as available, so the amounts overlap. The model credits the largest individual block within each tier when calculating explained output. The base calculation assigns no positive shortage block to this layer. | Part of the gap | Missing | Largest shortage explains | Unexplained | Tier 2 (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/tier-2.html) | $2.1T | $0bn | $2.1T (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Read the model's explanation for each tier This row has no named input explanation in the base calculation. Sources and exact values Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today) What makes up the chosen target economy? https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layers.html The model chooses a mix of 19 accounting layers for a doubled economy. These sector targets are a scenario to test, not a forecast of future spending. Changing that mix changes the gaps and input requirements. Open a sector to see its target-setting assumption and the subtraction behind each map number. The four U rows are grouped into one accounting channel on the homepage. | Layer | Chosen target | Baseline growth (projected) | Tier 1 gap | Tier 2 gap | Built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c13.html) | $105.7T | $8.2T | $8.7T | $34.6T | Shelter and utilities (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c03.html) | $59.2T | $4.5T | $627bn | $24.5T | Health care (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c05.html) | $51.1T | $6.5T | $1.8T | $19.3T | Personal and financial services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c11.html) | $35.0T | $3.4T | $1.9T | $13.9T | Public services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c12.html) | $34.1T | $2.4T | $3.0T | $11.2T | Education (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c09.html) | $31.6T | $3.2T | $2.4T | $9.2T | Food at home (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c01.html) | $21.2T | $1.5T | $1.2T | $5.9T | Mobility (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c06.html) | $17.8T | $868bn | $5.3T | $3.0T | Knowledge and software (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c15.html) | $14.1T | $3.9T | $1.3T | $1.6T | Productive equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c14.html) | $13.7T | $1.8T | $3.4T | $1.5T | Recreation (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c08.html) | $13.3T | $311bn | $1.6T | $5.5T | Food service, lodging (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c10.html) | $13.3T | $1.6T | $1.4T | $4.2T | Communication (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c07.html) | $8.9T | $998bn | $83bn | $3.5T | Household equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c04.html) | $7.6T | $1.0T | $1.5T | $1.3T | Alcohol, tobacco, narcotics (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u1.html) | $7.0T | $317bn | $57bn | $3.0T | Clothing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c02.html) | $6.5T | $994bn | $447bn | $1.7T | Inventories (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u3.html) | $4.4T | −$32bn | $32bn | $2.1T | Net exports (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u4.html) | $4.3T | $0bn | $0bn | $2.1T | Net purchases abroad (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u2.html) | −$267bn | −$130bn | $0bn | $0bn Source files · layers_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/layers_v4.csv) Accounting rows https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u.html These four categories keep the target aligned with the accounting coverage of the source data. Alcohol, tobacco, narcotics$7.0T target → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u1.html) Net purchases abroad−$267bn target → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u2.html) Inventories$4.4T target → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u3.html) Net exports$4.3T target → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u4.html) Net purchases abroad and changes in inventories can contain negative contributions. Their signs are retained in the totals. Electricity https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html Electricity is the energy needed to run the target economy, including the modelled electricity used by machine labour. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $13.1Tin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $254bn – $34.8T5 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)UNTESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$34.8T What is being compared? The requirement combines the electricity footprint of each layer with the power used by robots and AI work. The task split changes that requirement. The same generation also appears in the grid-connection and transformer tests. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 74,059.0 | Supply on course | 44,274.0 | Supply at precedent | 93,251.9 All three use the same input unit — TWh per year (gross generation). Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 29,785.0 | 59.8% | At precedent | 0.0 | 125.9% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $0bn tier 2 + $13.1T tier 1 = $13.1T blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) See the affected layers | Layer | Base output blocked | Mobility (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c06.html) | $5.3T | Productive equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c14.html) | $3.4T | Household equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c04.html) | $1.5T | Food at home (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c01.html) | $1.2T | Shelter and utilities (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c03.html) | $627bn | Recreation (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c08.html) | $550bn | Clothing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c02.html) | $447bn | Inventories (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u3.html) | $32bn Other shortages can block these same amounts. Removing a single constraint leaves the other constraints to be tested. Source files · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $13.1T | cogfirst | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $34.8T | humanscog | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $13.1T | trendprod | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $13.3T | v3alt | IEA STEPS 2035 footprint (v3 second ratio) + machine-labour electricity (v3 split) | $254bn See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 9 | $13.1T | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 3 | $34.8T | humans keep cognitive tasks | 8 | $13.1T | labour productivity on trend | 9 | $13.3T | v3 second sourced ratios | 12 | $254bn | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 14 | $13.1T | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 6 | $13.1T The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) What evidence would improve this? IEA WEO-2026 Annex A (STEPS generation 2035) and Ember monthly 2026 generation; IEA World Energy Balances by final-demand sector to replace the EXIOBASE monetary electricity multiplier Growth and the historical comparison China 2002-2011: generation x2.84 in 9 years (Ember), applied to world 2026 supply; world fastest 9 years (OWID, 2001-10) x1.37 is the low case | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 9.5% | Implied by precedent supply | 12.3% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) cogfirst · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) humanscog · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) trendprod · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) v3alt · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_alt_2035) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Fuels https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k02.html Fuels supply energy for uses such as heating and transport. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $0bnin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $0bn – $71.8T3 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)TESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$71.8T What is being compared? The model compares the fuel footprint of the target economy with on-course supply and the fastest-precedent supply. Each alternative changes the amount of fuel needed per unit of output. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 445.2 | Supply on course | 374.0 | Supply at precedent | 548.8 All three use the same input unit — EJ per year (final consumption excl. electricity). Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 71.2 | 84.0% | At precedent | 0.0 | 123.3% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $0bn tier 2 + $0bn tier 1 = $0bn blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE) | $0bn | v3alt | v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) | $7.2T | today | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.62 the v3 ratio | $71.8T Assumption behind the verdict binds only under: v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun); 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.62 the v3 ratio See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 16 | $0bn | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 18 | $0bn | humans keep cognitive tasks | 16 | $0bn | labour productivity on trend | 17 | $0bn | v3 second sourced ratios | 7 | $7.2T | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 3 | $71.8T | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 15 | $0bn The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) Growth and the historical comparison World fossil-fuel consumption 1965-1974 x1.52 in 9 years (EI via OWID), the post-1965 maximum | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 2.4% | Implied by precedent supply | 4.8% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035) v3alt · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035) today · stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K02 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Machine cognition (AI agents) https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k03.html Machine cognition is the cognitive work assigned to AI agents in the model. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $0bnin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $0bn – $34.8T4 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)UNTESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$34.8T What is being compared? A worker-equivalent represents an amount of work comparable to a worker's annual contribution. The task-split alternatives change how much cognitive work people and AI perform. The model expresses AI supply in this common work unit. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 537.1 | Supply on course | 310.3 | Supply at precedent | 45,732.6 All three use the same input unit — million worker-equivalents in 2035. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 226.8 | 57.8% | At precedent | 0.0 | 8515.4% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $0bn tier 2 + $0bn tier 1 = $0bn blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $0bn | cogfirst | AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $34.8T | humanscog | humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $0bn | trendprod | v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $0bn Assumption behind the verdict binds only under: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 16 | $0bn | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 3 | $34.8T | humans keep cognitive tasks | 16 | $0bn | labour productivity on trend | 17 | $0bn | v3 second sourced ratios | 15 | $0bn | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 19 | $0bn | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 15 | $0bn The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) What evidence would improve this? Task-matched benchmark of agent-hours per human-hour on real jobs (GDPval/METR); Epoch agent-population update with 2028-30 shipments Growth and the historical comparison AI chip power sold grew x1.87 in 2025 (Epoch), held 2028-2035 on top of the through-2027 fleet | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 17.7% | Implied by precedent supply | 92.9% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) cogfirst · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) humanscog · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) trendprod · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Physical machine labour (robots) https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html Physical machine labour is the physical work the model assigns to robots after accounting for human workers. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $61.7Tin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $1.1T – $102.5T4 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)UNTESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$102.5T What is being compared? The calculation begins with work needed across all layers. It allocates human labour, divides the remaining tasks into cognitive and physical work, and adds the existing machine fleets. A worker-equivalent is an estimate of work capacity. Converting deployed robots into that capacity is an assumption. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 1,202.3 | Supply on course | 32.8 | Supply at precedent | 42.9 All three use the same input unit — million worker-equivalents in 2035. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 1,169.5 | 2.7% | At precedent | 1,159.5 | 3.6% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $60.0T tier 2 + $1.6T tier 1 = $61.7T blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) See the affected layers | Layer | Base output blocked | Personal and financial services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c11.html) | $13.9T | Public services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c12.html) | $11.2T | Food at home (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c01.html) | $7.1T | Recreation (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c08.html) | $5.9T | Built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c13.html) | $5.1T | Food service, lodging (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c10.html) | $4.2T | Alcohol, tobacco, narcotics (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u1.html) | $3.0T | Mobility (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c06.html) | $3.0T | Inventories (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u3.html) | $2.1T | Clothing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c02.html) | $1.7T | Knowledge and software (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c15.html) | $1.6T | Productive equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c14.html) | $1.5T | Household equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c04.html) | $1.3T Other shortages can block these same amounts. Removing a single constraint leaves the other constraints to be tested. Source files · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $61.7T | cogfirst | AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $1.1T | humanscog | humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $62.3T | trendprod | v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $102.5T See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 1 | $61.7T | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 14 | $1.1T | humans keep cognitive tasks | 1 | $62.3T | labour productivity on trend | 1 | $102.5T | v3 second sourced ratios | 2 | $61.7T | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 4 | $61.7T | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 1 | $61.7T The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) What evidence would improve this? Time-and-motion worker-equivalents of deployed humanoids; Counterpoint/IDC 2027 shipments to confirm the ramp Growth and the historical comparison China electric-car sales 2014-2023 x111 in 9 years (IEA via OWID) applied to humanoid shipments from 50k in 2026 (Counterpoint); industrial robots on the IFR 2026-29 forecast trend | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 59.7% | Implied by precedent supply | 10.3% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) cogfirst · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) humanscog · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) trendprod · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) AI compute https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k05.html AI compute is the chip capacity associated with the AI work in the model. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $0bnin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $0bn – $34.8T4 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)UNTESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$34.8T What is being compared? The model converts AI worker-equivalents into gigawatts of chip thermal design power using an assumed ratio. This makes the result sensitive to the amount of useful work attributed to that hardware. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 146.3 | Supply on course | 84.5 | Supply at precedent | 12,455.7 All three use the same input unit — GW of AI chip TDP in service in 2035. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 61.8 | 57.8% | At precedent | 0.0 | 8515.3% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $0bn tier 2 + $0bn tier 1 = $0bn blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $0bn | cogfirst | AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $34.8T | humanscog | humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $0bn | trendprod | v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $0bn Assumption behind the verdict binds only under: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 16 | $0bn | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 3 | $34.8T | humans keep cognitive tasks | 16 | $0bn | labour productivity on trend | 17 | $0bn | v3 second sourced ratios | 15 | $0bn | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 19 | $0bn | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 15 | $0bn The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) What evidence would improve this? Epoch chip-sales update for 2027-28; TSMC CoWoS and HBM capacity plans to 2030 Growth and the historical comparison AI chip power sold x1.87 in 2025 (Epoch) held 2028-2035; bounded in practice by K01/K14 (power and grid) | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 25.5% | Implied by precedent supply | 105.7% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) cogfirst · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) humanscog · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) trendprod · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Copper https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k06.html Copper is a material input used in equipment, wiring and other production. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $166bnin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $144bn – $283bn3 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)not tested (blocks 1T or less) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)UNTESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$283bn What is being compared? The model allows partial substitution for copper using a constant-elasticity-of-substitution approximation. It inherits an elasticity of 0.4 and an effective conversion between missing material and blocked output from the earlier model. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 51.0 | Supply on course | 26.5 | Supply at precedent | 45.4 All three use the same input unit — million t refined copper per year. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 24.5 | 51.9% | At precedent | 5.6 | 89.0% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $166bn tier 2 + $0bn tier 1 = $166bn blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) See the affected layers | Layer | Base output blocked | Productive equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c14.html) | $166bn Other shortages can block these same amounts. Removing a single constraint leaves the other constraints to be tested. Source files · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $166bn | v3alt | v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $144bn | today | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.10 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $283bn See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 15 | $166bn | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 17 | $166bn | humans keep cognitive tasks | 15 | $166bn | labour productivity on trend | 16 | $166bn | v3 second sourced ratios | 14 | $144bn | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 18 | $283bn | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 14 | $166bn The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) What evidence would improve this? IEA Critical Minerals Data Explorer: copper STEPS 2035 demand, secondary supply and base/high-production mine supply in kt (replaces the 2030-40 interpolation and the held 18% secondary share) Growth and the historical comparison World copper mine output 1954-1963 x1.625 in 9 years (USGS via OWID), post-1950 maximum; post-1985 maximum (1995-2004) x1.47 is the low case | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 6.9% | Implied by precedent supply | 5.5% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035); input_layer_v3.csv (missing, output_depending_ppp_bn) v3alt · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035) today · stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K06 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Lithium https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k07.html Lithium is a material input associated with technologies such as batteries. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $0bnin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $0bn – $0bn3 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)not tested (blocks 1T or less) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)UNTESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What is being compared? The model measures lithium content and uses the inherited substitution approximation to translate a material constraint into an output constraint. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 1,208.3 | Supply on course | 452.9 | Supply at precedent | 2,301.2 All three use the same input unit — kt lithium content per year. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 755.4 | 37.5% | At precedent | 0.0 | 190.5% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $0bn tier 2 + $0bn tier 1 = $0bn blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn | v3alt | v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn | today | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.53 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn Assumption behind the verdict v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion); v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion); 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.53 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) What evidence would improve this? IEA Critical Minerals Data Explorer lithium end-use split mapped to final demand (replaces the battery-product proxy A02) Growth and the historical comparison World lithium mine output 2016-2025 x7.21 in 9 years (USGS via OWID) | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 15.9% | Implied by precedent supply | 24.6% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035); input_layer_v3.csv (missing, output_depending_ppp_bn) v3alt · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035) today · stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K07 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Rare earths https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k08.html Magnet rare earths are material inputs used in some motors, generators and other equipment. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $0bnin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $0bn – $0bn3 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)not tested (blocks 1T or less) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)UNTESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) What is being compared? The requirement is measured in rare-earth-element content. The model uses the inherited substitution approximation when translating the material shortfall into output. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 213.0 | Supply on course | 136.4 | Supply at precedent | 709.6 All three use the same input unit — kt magnet rare earth elements per year. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 76.7 | 64.0% | At precedent | 0.0 | 333.1% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $0bn tier 2 + $0bn tier 1 = $0bn blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn | v3alt | v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn | today | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.84 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn Assumption behind the verdict v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion); v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion); 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.84 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) What evidence would improve this? IEA Critical Minerals Data Explorer magnet rare-earth end-use split; non-China separation capacity under construction Growth and the historical comparison World rare-earth mine output 1960-1969 x7.97 in 9 years (USGS via OWID) | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 10.2% | Implied by precedent supply | 25.9% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035); input_layer_v3.csv (missing, output_depending_ppp_bn) v3alt · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035) today · stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K08 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Steel https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k09.html Steel is a material used across structures, machinery and other goods. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $0bnin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $0bn – $18.9T3 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)TESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$18.9T What is being compared? Each production alternative changes the steel intensity of the target output. The requirement is compared with annual crude-steel supply. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 2,901.9 | Supply on course | 2,570.4 | Supply at precedent | 3,135.5 All three use the same input unit — Mt crude steel per year. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 331.5 | 88.6% | At precedent | 0.0 | 108.1% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $0bn tier 2 + $0bn tier 1 = $0bn blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE material efficiency) | $0bn | v3alt | v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) | $0bn | today | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.29 the v3 ratio | $18.9T Assumption behind the verdict binds only under: 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.29 the v3 ratio See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 16 | $0bn | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 18 | $0bn | humans keep cognitive tasks | 16 | $0bn | labour productivity on trend | 17 | $0bn | v3 second sourced ratios | 15 | $0bn | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 11 | $18.9T | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 15 | $0bn The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) Growth and the historical comparison World crude steel 2002-2011 x1.68 in 9 years (worldsteel Steel Statistical Yearbook 2012) | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 5.0% | Implied by precedent supply | 5.9% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035) v3alt · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035) today · stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K09 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Cement https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k10.html Cement is an input to construction and related production. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $0bnin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $0bn – $0.0m3 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)not tested (blocks 1T or less) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)UNTESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$0.0m What is being compared? The model compares annual cement need with the supply paths. Its output estimate depends on how cement-intensive the target economy is. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 5,589.7 | Supply on course | 5,428.6 | Supply at precedent | 7,528.7 All three use the same input unit — Mt cement per year. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 161.1 | 97.1% | At precedent | 0.0 | 134.7% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $0bn tier 2 + $0bn tier 1 = $0bn blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE) | $0bn | v3alt | v3 second ratio: Agent 4 rerun: 2026 intensity held outside C13; C13 at the baseline on-course tonnes per unit of value | $0bn | today | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.35 the v3 ratio | $0.0m Assumption behind the verdict v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE); v3 second ratio: Agent 4 rerun: 2026 intensity held outside C13; C13 at the baseline on-course tonnes per unit of value; 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.35 the v3 ratio What evidence would improve this? GCCA/USGS world cement capacity and clinker factor (replaces A03); USGS regional cement 2026 Growth and the historical comparison World cement 2002-2011 x2.00 in 9 years (USGS MCS 2004 and 2013) | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 4.5% | Implied by precedent supply | 8.0% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035) v3alt · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035) today · stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K10 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Saving for investment https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k11.html Saving for investment is the funding the model requires for new structures, equipment and knowledge assets. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $13.3Tin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $13.3T – $13.3T1 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)UNTESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$13.3T What is being compared? This input is measured in market-price US dollars, while blocked output is reported in constant purchasing-power dollars. The model treats saving and investment as an accounting identity and tests only its base case for this shortage. Its assumed on-course saving rate remains a source of uncertainty. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 58,368.1 | Supply on course | 37,826.3 | Supply at precedent | 87,530.7 All three use the same input unit — bn US$ (market) of gross saving per year. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 20,541.8 | 64.8% | At precedent | 0.0 | 150.0% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $0bn tier 2 + $13.3T tier 1 = $13.3T blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) See the affected layers | Layer | Base output blocked | Built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c13.html) | $8.6T | Productive equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c14.html) | $3.4T | Knowledge and software (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c15.html) | $1.3T Other shortages can block these same amounts. Removing a single constraint leaves the other constraints to be tested. Source files · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 ratio: identity (investment = saving at market prices); no ratio to improve | $13.3T This shortage exceeds $1T and has 0 alternative tests. The original brief requested two. The code gives saving an accounting-identity exemption and labels it SOLID. Assumption behind the verdict accounting identity (saving = investment in C13-C15 at market prices): binds under every way of producing; rests on the on-course saving rate (2015-24 mean, A) See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 8 | $13.3T | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 11 | $13.3T | humans keep cognitive tasks | 7 | $13.3T | labour productivity on trend | 8 | $13.3T | v3 second sourced ratios | 6 | $13.3T | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 13 | $13.3T | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 5 | $13.3T The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) What evidence would improve this? IMF WEO saving and investment projections to 2031 (world saving rate path) to replace the held 2015-24 mean Growth and the historical comparison China gross saving 51.3% of GDP (2008, World Bank) applied to world output at max; on course = world 2015-24 mean saving rate | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 7.6% | Implied by precedent supply | 12.5% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Building permission https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k12.html Building permission is the amount of construction the model assumes can receive the required permission. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $1.1Tin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $1.1T – $1.1T1 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SCENARIO (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)UNTESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$1.1T What is being compared? The unit is the value of construction permitted. It acts as a proxy for regulatory throughput. The current data include only the base production case for this shortage. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 105,727.5 | Supply on course | 94,403.4 | Supply at precedent | 104,600.5 All three use the same input unit — bn 2026 int$ of construction (C13) that must be permitted in 2035. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 11,324.1 | 89.3% | At precedent | 1,127.0 | 98.9% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $1.1T tier 2 + $0bn tier 1 = $1.1T blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) See the affected layers | Layer | Base output blocked | Built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c13.html) | $1.1T Other shortages can block these same amounts. Removing a single constraint leaves the other constraints to be tested. Source files · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 ratio: identity | $1.1T This shortage exceeds $1T and has 0 alternative tests. The original brief requested two. The code labels it SCENARIO. Assumption behind the verdict fewer than two sourced alternative ways found; rests on the base ratio See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 13 | $1.1T | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 15 | $1.1T | humans keep cognitive tasks | 13 | $1.1T | labour productivity on trend | 14 | $1.1T | v3 second sourced ratios | 11 | $1.1T | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 17 | $1.1T | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 12 | $1.1T The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) What evidence would improve this? Open the Auckland upzoning working paper (Greenaway-McGrevy and Phillips) and OECD housing-supply elasticities by metro weighted by ICP construction spend Growth and the historical comparison Auckland 2016 upzoning (+50% consents within 5 years, A4:A05) in the 30% of construction under discretionary permission (A4:A04); outside it current rules permit any amount (Agent 4 capped that part at capacity) | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 7.7% | Implied by precedent supply | 7.6% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Grid connection approval https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html Grid connection approval is the ability to connect the electricity generation required by the model. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $13.1Tin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $254bn – $34.8T5 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)UNTESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$34.8T What is being compared? Its need follows the electricity requirement, while its supply follows the connection-approval path. Generation, connections and transformers can constrain the same output. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 74,059.0 | Supply on course | 44,274.0 | Supply at precedent | 87,637.2 All three use the same input unit — TWh per year of generation connected. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 29,785.0 | 59.8% | At precedent | 0.0 | 118.3% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $0bn tier 2 + $13.1T tier 1 = $13.1T blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) See the affected layers | Layer | Base output blocked | Mobility (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c06.html) | $5.3T | Productive equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c14.html) | $3.4T | Household equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c04.html) | $1.5T | Food at home (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c01.html) | $1.2T | Shelter and utilities (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c03.html) | $627bn | Recreation (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c08.html) | $550bn | Clothing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c02.html) | $447bn | Inventories (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u3.html) | $32bn Other shortages can block these same amounts. Removing a single constraint leaves the other constraints to be tested. Source files · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $13.1T | cogfirst | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $34.8T | humanscog | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $13.1T | trendprod | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $13.3T | v3alt | IEA STEPS 2035 footprint (v3 second ratio) + machine-labour electricity (v3 split) | $254bn See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 9 | $13.1T | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 3 | $34.8T | humans keep cognitive tasks | 8 | $13.1T | labour productivity on trend | 9 | $13.3T | v3 second sourced ratios | 12 | $254bn | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 14 | $13.1T | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 6 | $13.1T The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) What evidence would improve this? ENTSO-E and LBNL completion rates by request year; IEA count of 2 800 GW waiting by region and age Growth and the historical comparison US 2008 queue speed (22 months request-to-operation, LBNL) in queue-bound grids (US+EU share of 2025 generation); STEPS path assumed connected | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 9.5% | Implied by precedent supply | 11.5% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) cogfirst · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) humanscog · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) trendprod · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) v3alt · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_alt_2035) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Transformers and grid equipment https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html Transformers and grid equipment are needed to connect and deliver electricity. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $32.4Tin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $5.5T – $42.6T5 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)UNTESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$42.6T What is being compared? The model measures their capacity by the annual generation they can connect, in terawatt-hours. This is a throughput proxy for equipment capacity. It includes electricity demanded by the model's chosen mix of human and machine work. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 74,059.0 | Supply on course | 42,553.3 | Supply at precedent | 73,055.4 All three use the same input unit — TWh per year of generation the delivered transformers can connect. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 31,505.7 | 57.5% | At precedent | 1,003.6 | 98.6% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $2.1T tier 2 + $30.4T tier 1 = $32.4T blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) See the affected layers | Layer | Base output blocked | Built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c13.html) | $8.7T | Mobility (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c06.html) | $5.3T | Productive equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c14.html) | $3.4T | Public services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c12.html) | $3.0T | Shelter and utilities (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c03.html) | $2.7T | Personal and financial services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c11.html) | $1.8T | Recreation (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c08.html) | $1.6T | Household equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c04.html) | $1.5T | Food service, lodging (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c10.html) | $1.4T | Knowledge and software (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c15.html) | $1.3T | Food at home (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c01.html) | $1.2T | Clothing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c02.html) | $447bn | Alcohol, tobacco, narcotics (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u1.html) | $57bn | Inventories (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u3.html) | $32bn Other shortages can block these same amounts. Removing a single constraint leaves the other constraints to be tested. Source files · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $32.4T | cogfirst | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $42.6T | humanscog | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $30.4T | trendprod | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $33.8T | v3alt | IEA STEPS 2035 footprint (v3 second ratio) + machine-labour electricity (v3 split) | $5.5T See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 3 | $32.4T | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 2 | $42.6T | humans keep cognitive tasks | 3 | $30.4T | labour productivity on trend | 3 | $33.8T | v3 second sourced ratios | 9 | $5.5T | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 6 | $32.4T | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 3 | $32.4T The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) What evidence would improve this? World transformer manufacturing capacity by region (Wood Mackenzie / IEA grid supply-chain report) and order books to 2030 Growth and the historical comparison US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv magazine) used as the supply ramp from the STEPS addition rate | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 9.5% | Implied by precedent supply | 9.3% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) cogfirst · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) humanscog · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) trendprod · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) v3alt · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_alt_2035) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Clinical approval https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k15.html Clinical approval is the health output that the model assumes can be provided under the relevant approval constraints. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $19.6Tin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $4.9T – $19.6T3 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)TESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$19.6T What is being compared? The base case uses the value of health output allowed as a proxy for approval throughput. Two alternatives use a study's share of health-spending growth attributed to technology to estimate how much growth needs newly approved products. Applying that spending relationship to approval capacity is part of the model's interpretation. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 51,080.9 | Supply on course | 30,435.4 | Supply at precedent | 32,810.9 All three use the same input unit — bn 2026 int$ of health output (C05) that must be allowed in 2035. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 20,645.5 | 59.6% | At precedent | 18,270.0 | 64.2% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $18.3T tier 2 + $1.3T tier 1 = $19.6T blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) See the affected layers | Layer | Base output blocked | Health care (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c05.html) | $19.6T Other shortages can block these same amounts. Removing a single constraint leaves the other constraints to be tested. Source files · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 ratio: identity | $19.6T | techshare_low | only 27% of health output growth beyond the current-rule path comes from new technology needing approval; the rest is more of approved care | $4.9T | techshare_high | only 48% of health output growth beyond the current-rule path comes from new technology needing approval; the rest is more of approved care | $8.8T See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 5 | $19.6T | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 9 | $19.6T | humans keep cognitive tasks | 5 | $19.6T | labour productivity on trend | 5 | $19.6T | v3 second sourced ratios | 4 | $19.6T | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 10 | $19.6T | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 11 | $4.9T The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) Growth and the historical comparison Further health output is workforce (2010-19) and productivity (2015-24) precedents achieved under current approval rules (BL C05-F1, C05-F2); new products not needed | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 9.0% | Implied by precedent supply | 3.8% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035) techshare_low · searches_v4.csv W2 (Smith, Newhouse, Freeland 2009) techshare_high · searches_v4.csv W2 (Smith, Newhouse, Freeland 2009) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Professional licensing https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k16.html Professional licensing limits which tasks machines can perform under the model's licensing assumptions. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $13.8Tin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $0bn – $25.4T5 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SCENARIO (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)UNTESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$25.4T What is being compared? The base case estimates licensed work from occupational shares and assumes a reduction under a reform precedent. An alternative gives licensed tasks to people first and leaves other tasks to machines. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 1,739.4 | Supply on course | 1,425.5 | Supply at precedent | 1,582.4 All three use the same input unit — million machine worker-equivalents in 2035. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 313.9 | 82.0% | At precedent | 156.9 | 91.0% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $13.8T tier 2 + $0bn tier 1 = $13.8T blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) See the affected layers | Layer | Base output blocked | Health care (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c05.html) | $13.8T Other shortages can block these same amounts. Removing a single constraint leaves the other constraints to be tested. Source files · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent | $13.8T | cogfirst | AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent | $25.4T | humanscog | humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent | $12.6T | trendprod | v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent | $16.5T | humanslicensed | humans take the licensed tasks first, machines the rest: licensing binds only if licensed work exceeds all human work | $0bn Assumption behind the verdict humans take the licensed tasks first, machines the rest: licensing binds only if licensed work exceeds all human work See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 7 | $13.8T | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 7 | $25.4T | humans keep cognitive tasks | 10 | $12.6T | labour productivity on trend | 6 | $16.5T | v3 second sourced ratios | 5 | $13.8T | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 12 | $13.8T | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 15 | $0bn The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) What evidence would improve this? OECD/EU cross-country licensing incidence; legal mapping of which tasks require a licensed person Growth and the historical comparison machine work allowed outside licensed tasks now; fastest reform precedent halves the licensed share (A4:A11) | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 32.1% | Implied by precedent supply | 30.8% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14); stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py (LIC, LIC_REFORM) cogfirst · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14); stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py (LIC, LIC_REFORM) humanscog · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14); stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py (LIC, LIC_REFORM) trendprod · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14); stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py (LIC, LIC_REFORM) humanslicensed · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14); stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py (LIC) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Construction trades https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k17.html Construction trades are the human workers required to produce the model's construction output. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $16.0Tin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $16.0T – $29.8T3 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)TESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$29.8T What is being compared? The model applies a construction-employment footprint to each layer, including construction work embodied in its supply chain. It compares total need with the workforce on course and at the fastest precedent. Alternative productivity ratios change the number of workers needed. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 571.0 | Supply on course | 380.2 | Supply at precedent | 495.1 All three use the same input unit — million construction workers (ISIC F) in 2035. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 190.8 | 66.6% | At precedent | 75.9 | 86.7% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $15.4T tier 2 + $612bn tier 1 = $16.0T blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) See the affected layers | Layer | Base output blocked | Built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c13.html) | $16.0T Other shortages can block these same amounts. Removing a single constraint leaves the other constraints to be tested. Source files · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (fastest sourced productivity) | $16.0T | v3alt | v3 second ratio: construction output per worker on its 2014-24 trend (Agent 4 rerun) | $25.4T | today | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.08 the v3 ratio | $29.8T See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 6 | $16.0T | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 10 | $16.0T | humans keep cognitive tasks | 6 | $16.0T | labour productivity on trend | 7 | $16.0T | v3 second sourced ratios | 3 | $25.4T | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 7 | $29.8T | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 4 | $16.0T The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) Growth and the historical comparison World construction employment at its fastest 9-year growth (ILO, 2002-2011, 5.36%/yr) from 2026 | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 7.0% | Implied by precedent supply | 5.4% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035) v3alt · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035) today · stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K17 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Human workforce https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k18.html The human workforce is the number of people available to do the work assigned to humans. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $0bnin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $0bn – $180.8T3 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)TESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$180.8T What is being compared? The model uses labour-productivity ratios and a precedent for employment to estimate this supply. Robot and AI requirements are calculated separately from the work left after human labour is allocated. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 4,316.6 | Supply on course | 4,023.2 | Supply at precedent | 4,316.6 All three use the same input unit — million workers in 2035. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 293.4 | 93.2% | At precedent | 0.0 | 100.0% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $0bn tier 2 + $0bn tier 1 = $0bn blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (fastest sourced productivity) | $0bn | today | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.69 the v3 ratio | $180.8T | trendprod | humans' share of work with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of the fastest 9-year growth | $10.0T Assumption behind the verdict binds only under: 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.69 the v3 ratio; humans' share of work with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of the fastest 9-year growth See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 16 | $0bn | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 18 | $0bn | humans keep cognitive tasks | 16 | $0bn | labour productivity on trend | 11 | $10.0T | v3 second sourced ratios | 15 | $0bn | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 1 | $180.8T | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 15 | $0bn The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) Growth and the historical comparison WPP 15+ population 2035 x the highest world employment ratio 1991-2025 (BL T19) | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 1.9% | Implied by precedent supply | 1.9% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035) today · stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K18 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline) trendprod · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Aluminium https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k20.html Aluminium is a material input used in goods, machinery and infrastructure. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $7.5Tin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $6.4T – $34.8T3 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)UNTESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$34.8T What is being compared? Its required quantity follows the aluminium footprint of the target economy. Different production intensities change how much annual supply is needed. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 209.3 | Supply on course | 137.0 | Supply at precedent | 330.5 All three use the same input unit — Mt aluminium per year. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 72.3 | 65.4% | At precedent | 0.0 | 157.9% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $0bn tier 2 + $7.5T tier 1 = $7.5T blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) See the affected layers | Layer | Base output blocked | Productive equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c14.html) | $3.4T | Mobility (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c06.html) | $2.6T | Household equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c04.html) | $1.5T | Alcohol, tobacco, narcotics (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u1.html) | $57bn | Inventories (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u3.html) | $32bn Other shortages can block these same amounts. Removing a single constraint leaves the other constraints to be tested. Source files · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE) | $7.5T | v3alt | v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 aluminium per unit of GDP (WEO 2025 A.5b) | $6.4T | today | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.12 the v3 ratio | $34.8T See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 12 | $7.5T | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 13 | $7.5T | humans keep cognitive tasks | 12 | $7.5T | labour productivity on trend | 13 | $7.5T | v3 second sourced ratios | 8 | $6.4T | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 5 | $34.8T | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 9 | $7.5T The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) What evidence would improve this? IEA STEPS/NZE 2035 aluminium demand by end use (WEO Annex) against the EXIOBASE footprint, and 2026 smelter capacity by region Growth and the historical comparison world bauxite mine output 1950-1959 x2.82 in 9 years (USGS via OWID), post-1950 maximum; post-1985 maximum 2004-2013 x1.80 is the low case | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 6.7% | Implied by precedent supply | 12.2% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035) v3alt · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035) today · stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK17); 2026 world output (repaired baseline) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Capital stock https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html Capital stock is the accumulated productive assets needed to support the target economy. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $43.7Tin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $0bn – $80.5T3 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SCENARIO (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)UNTESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$80.5T What is being compared? The model multiplies output by a capital-to-output ratio and compares the resulting asset requirement with the projected stock. Alternatives use a historically low ratio and a trend in that ratio. Capital stock is measured as a stock of assets, while the output it supports is an annual flow. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 2,140.1 | Supply on course | 1,502.1 | Supply at precedent | 1,748.4 All three use the same input unit — tn 2026 int$ (PPP) of capital stock in 2035. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 638.0 | 70.2% | At precedent | 391.7 | 81.7% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $43.7T tier 2 + $0bn tier 1 = $43.7T blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) See the affected layers | Layer | Base output blocked | Shelter and utilities (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c03.html) | $21.2T | Food at home (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c01.html) | $5.9T | Recreation (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c08.html) | $5.5T | Mobility (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c06.html) | $3.0T | Inventories (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u3.html) | $2.1T | Clothing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c02.html) | $1.7T | Knowledge and software (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c15.html) | $1.6T | Productive equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c14.html) | $1.5T | Household equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c04.html) | $1.3T Other shortages can block these same amounts. Removing a single constraint leaves the other constraints to be tested. Source files · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 ratio: today's ratio held (only today's is sourced) | $43.7T | v3alt | v3 second ratio: lowest world capital-output ratio 1990-2023 (PWT, 2005): best demonstrated, the low case | $0bn | kytrend | capital-output ratio on its 2013-23 trend: x1.096 today's (PWT capital growth 3.82% vs UN AMA GDP growth 3.03%) | $80.5T Assumption behind the verdict v3 second ratio: lowest world capital-output ratio 1990-2023 (PWT, 2005): best demonstrated, the low case See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 2 | $43.7T | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 1 | $43.7T | humans keep cognitive tasks | 2 | $43.7T | labour productivity on trend | 2 | $43.7T | v3 second sourced ratios | 15 | $0bn | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 2 | $80.5T | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 2 | $43.7T The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) What evidence would improve this? PWT 11.0 capital-output ratios by country 1990-2023 for economies growing 5%+ a year (does K/Y fall during fast growth?) Growth and the historical comparison world real capital stock at its fastest 9-year growth (1964-1973, PWT 11.0); on course = 2013-23 trend | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 8.0% | Implied by precedent supply | 5.6% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035) v3alt · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035) kytrend · stage1-v3/requirements/work/landcap.csv (GK_1323, PWT 11.0); stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world GDP 2013, 2023) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Cropland https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html Cropland is the land required to supply the crop inputs used across the target economy. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $19.8Tin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $806bn – $138.5T4 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)UNTESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$138.5T What is being compared? Crop yield determines how much land is needed per unit of crop output. The alternatives include historical yield trends and estimates of attainable yield gains. Crop inputs also reach layers beyond food through their supply chains. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 2,280.8 | Supply on course | 1,628.0 | Supply at precedent | 1,688.9 All three use the same input unit — million ha of cropland in 2035. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 652.7 | 71.4% | At precedent | 591.9 | 74.0% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $19.8T tier 2 + $0bn tier 1 = $19.8T blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) See the affected layers | Layer | Base output blocked | Food at home (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c01.html) | $5.9T | Food service, lodging (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c10.html) | $4.2T | Alcohol, tobacco, narcotics (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u1.html) | $3.0T | Inventories (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u3.html) | $2.1T | Clothing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c02.html) | $1.7T | Productive equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c14.html) | $1.5T | Household equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c04.html) | $1.3T Other shortages can block these same amounts. Removing a single constraint leaves the other constraints to be tested. Source files · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (fastest sourced yield growth) | $19.8T | v3alt | v3 second ratio: crop output per ha on its 2014-24 trend | $138.5T | yieldgap_low | yield gaps closed to attainable yields: crop output per ha +45% on 2026 (x0.885 the v3 ratio) | $5.9T | yieldgap_high | yield gaps closed to attainable yields: crop output per ha +70% on 2026 (x0.755 the v3 ratio) | $806bn See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 4 | $19.8T | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 8 | $19.8T | humans keep cognitive tasks | 4 | $19.8T | labour productivity on trend | 4 | $19.8T | v3 second sourced ratios | 1 | $138.5T | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 9 | $19.8T | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 10 | $5.9T The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) What evidence would improve this? FAOSTAT crop output per ha and cropland by country 2000-2024, and the EXIOBASE crop footprint per $ of non-food output 1995-2022 (does it fall with income?) Growth and the historical comparison world cropland at its fastest 9-year expansion (1976-1985, FAOSTAT); on course = 2014-24 trend | Rate | Annual growth | Needed to reach the target input | 4.1% | Implied by precedent supply | 0.6% The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035. Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035) v3alt · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035) yieldgap_low · searches_v4.csv W1 (Mueller et al. 2012); stage1-v3/requirements/work/landcap.csv (GY_MAX9) yieldgap_high · searches_v4.csv W1 (Mueller et al. 2012); stage1-v3/requirements/work/landcap.csv (GY_MAX9) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Buyers for built structures https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c13.html Buyers for built structures measures whether demand would absorb the model's target construction output. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $8.5Tin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $0bn – $29.7T3 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SCENARIO (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)TESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$29.7T What is being compared? The base case uses the historical relationship between world construction and income. Other historical windows produce different demand responses. The current model fixes construction's price elasticity at zero. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 105,727.5 | Supply on course | 97,239.3 | Supply at precedent | 97,239.3 All three use the same input unit — bn 2026 int$ of output bought. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 8,488.2 | 92.0% | At precedent | 8,488.2 | 92.0% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $8.5T tier 2 + $0bn tier 1 = $8.5T blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) See the affected layers | Layer | Base output blocked | Built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c13.html) | $8.5T Other shortages can block these same amounts. Removing a single constraint leaves the other constraints to be tested. Source files · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | demand at the 2035 price from the sourced income response (UN AMA world 2014-2024) | $8.5T | eta_2004-2014 | demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.96) | $0bn | eta_1994-2004 | demand from the UN AMA world income response 1994-2004 (elasticity 0.49) | $29.7T Assumption behind the verdict demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.96) See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 11 | $8.5T | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 12 | $8.5T | humans keep cognitive tasks | 11 | $8.5T | labour productivity on trend | 12 | $8.5T | v3 second sourced ratios | 15 | $0bn | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 8 | $29.7T | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 8 | $8.5T The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, Construction (ISIC F) vs GDP, 2014-2024) eta_2004-2014 · stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, Construction (ISIC F) vs GDP, 2004-2014) eta_1994-2004 · stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, Construction (ISIC F) vs GDP, 1994-2004) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) Buyers for public services https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c12.html Buyers for public services measures whether the modelled government-consumption response reaches the target. Conditional constraint (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html#constraint) Calculated output blocked $826bnin this scenario, one constraint Range across tested cases $826bn – $4.4T3 cases; not a probability interval This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result. [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)TESTED (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html)$0Cyan · tested range   Yellow · base$4.4T What is being compared? The calculation estimates how government consumption changes as world income rises. It treats quantity as budget-driven and fixes price elasticity at zero. Different historical windows change the estimated demand. | Quantity | 2035 amount | Needed for the full target | 34,091.1 | Supply on course | 33,265.5 | Supply at precedent | 33,265.5 All three use the same input unit — bn 2026 int$ of output bought. Show the shortage calculation Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement. | Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met | On course | 825.6 | 97.6% | At precedent | 825.6 | 97.6% The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below. Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) How this becomes blocked output The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage. $826bn tier 2 + $0bn tier 1 = $826bn blocked The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed. Understand the allocation and its limits (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html) See the affected layers | Layer | Base output blocked | Public services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c12.html) | $826bn Other shortages can block these same amounts. Removing a single constraint leaves the other constraints to be tested. Source files · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) What changes the answer? Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows. | Case | What changes | Output blocked | base | demand at the 2035 price from the sourced income response (UN AMA world 2014-2024) | $826bn | eta_2004-2014 | demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.91) | $1.3T | eta_1994-2004 | demand from the UN AMA world income response 1994-2004 (elasticity 0.76) | $4.4T Assumption behind the verdict binds only under: demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.91); demand from the UN AMA world income response 1994-2004 (elasticity 0.76) See its reported rank in each scenario | Scenario | Rank | Output blocked | base | 14 | $826bn | AI takes cognitive tasks first | 16 | $826bn | humans keep cognitive tasks | 14 | $826bn | labour productivity on trend | 15 | $826bn | v3 second sourced ratios | 10 | $1.3T | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 16 | $4.4T | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 13 | $826bn The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns. Read every scenario (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) Sources and exact values Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · own_blocks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/own_blocks_v4.csv) base · stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, General government final consumption expenditure vs GDP, 2014-2024) eta_2004-2014 · stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, General government final consumption expenditure vs GDP, 2004-2014) eta_1994-2004 · stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, General government final consumption expenditure vs GDP, 1994-2004) Open the input files and source registries (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) What could constrain this scenario? https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortages.html These are calculated constraints if the chosen target economy is attempted, not forecasts of lost output. Each shortage is tested on its own, so the rows overlap. The table includes every tested input, including constraints that block output only in another production scenario. Click a name for its physical requirement, calculation and evidence. | Input or buyer constraint | Base block | Scenario range | Evidence | Verdict | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | $61.7T | $1.1T – $102.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Capital stock (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html) | $43.7T | $0bn – $80.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SCENARIO (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | $32.4T | $5.5T – $42.6T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Cropland (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html) | $19.8T | $806bn – $138.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Clinical approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k15.html) | $19.6T | $4.9T – $19.6T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Construction trades (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k17.html) | $16.0T | $16.0T – $29.8T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Professional licensing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k16.html) | $13.8T | $0bn – $25.4T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SCENARIO (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Saving for investment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k11.html) | $13.3T | $13.3T – $13.3T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | $13.1T | $254bn – $34.8T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | $13.1T | $254bn – $34.8T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Buyers for built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c13.html) | $8.5T | $0bn – $29.7T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SCENARIO (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Aluminium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k20.html) | $7.5T | $6.4T – $34.8T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SOLID (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Building permission (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k12.html) | $1.1T | $1.1T – $1.1T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SCENARIO (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Buyers for public services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c12.html) | $826bn | $826bn – $4.4T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Copper (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k06.html) | $166bn | $144bn – $283bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | not tested (blocks 1T or less) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Fuels (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k02.html) | $0bn | $0bn – $71.8T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Machine cognition (AI agents) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k03.html) | $0bn | $0bn – $34.8T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | AI compute (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k05.html) | $0bn | $0bn – $34.8T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Lithium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k07.html) | $0bn | $0bn – $0bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | not tested (blocks 1T or less) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Rare earths (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k08.html) | $0bn | $0bn – $0bn | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | not tested (blocks 1T or less) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Steel (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k09.html) | $0bn | $0bn – $18.9T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Cement (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k10.html) | $0bn | $0bn – $0.0m | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | not tested (blocks 1T or less) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Human workforce (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k18.html) | $0bn | $0bn – $180.8T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) Source files · shortages_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/shortages_v4.csv) · ranking_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/ranking_v4.csv) How the model works https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/methods.html Follow the calculation from output targets to input needs, supply constraints and the unexplained remainder. Choose the question before calculating the answer The total doubling goal and its sector mix are selected scenarios. Historical data informs the starting estimate, spending-response factors and comparisons, while applying those relationships to 2035 requires assumptions. The resulting gaps and shortages answer a conditional what-if question. See the role of each number (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html) Start with the accounting The code imports the earlier requirements table and the repaired baseline. In each layer it reconciles today, on-course growth, tier 1 and tier 2 with the target. It then checks that the layers sum to twice the 2026 estimate. Turn output into input needs For a fixed ratio, input needed equals output multiplied by input per unit of output, summed across layers. Some inputs use additional structure. Labour is split among people, AI and robots. Electricity includes machine work. Copper, lithium and rare earths use an inherited substitution approximation. Input need = sum of (layer output × input needed per unit) Compute each constraint separately The code removes eligible missing output until the input requirement fits supply, or until it runs out of eligible output. It protects on-course output. The layer ordering is based on input intensity or a labour proxy and is fixed during each test. A bisection calculation finds the final partial reduction. Tier 2 is tested against precedent supply with the full target attempted. Tier 1 is tested against on-course supply with on-course output plus tier 1 attempted. The two recorded blocks are added for each shortage. Extra diagnostic fields record competition between tiers and any remaining input shortfall. Handle overlapping constraints The individual shortage totals overlap. For each layer and tier, the code credits the largest individual block and calls the remainder unexplained. This gives $141.4T explained and $41.5T unexplained. Taking the maximum assumes the smaller blocks are contained within the largest one. The code has no task-level overlap map to establish that containment. The explained amount is therefore conditional on this attribution rule. See a worked overlap example (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html) Interpret the checks The committed checks test reconciliation, cell limits, labels, selected criteria and unchanged upstream files. The current code relaxes two brief requirements. It accepts all eligible SOLID S/E picks when fewer than three exist, and allows shortages above $1T to pass without two alternative tests. The ranking also keeps the first variant matching each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have two S6 alternatives, so one endpoint for each is absent from the scenario-ranking columns. Their full ranges include both endpoints. Inspect the calculation code Source files · code/model.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/code/model.py) · code/v4.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/code/v4.py) · code/check.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/code/check.py) · code/common.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/code/common.py) These files are the source snapshot used for the model outputs. The downloadable input tables provide the files they reference. Read the evidence labelsS, E, A and robustness → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) Check who would buy the outputIncome and prices → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/demand.html) Compare production alternativesWhat changes across tests → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html) Follow the original inputsSource registries and data → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html) What do the labels mean? https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html Read the evidence label and the robustness verdict together. They describe different aspects of an estimate. First identify the number's role: a chosen target, conditional projection or calculated gap. An E label does not make a target a prediction. The original source labels are preserved, including defaults discussed on the sector pages. Understand the number's role (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/what-the-numbers-mean.html) Where the number comes from | Label | Meaning | [S] Sourced (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Sourced. A value read from a source. | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Estimated from sourced inputs. The calculation or interpretation introduces modelling choices. | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Assumed. At least part of the estimate depends on an assumption. How it behaves in the tests | Label | Meaning | SOLID | The reported constraint binds across the production alternatives tested. K11 saving has an explicit accounting-identity exemption and only one tested case. | SCENARIO | The constraint depends on a production assumption, or has insufficient alternative tests. Some longer verdicts flag cases that exceed the testing threshold only in another variant. | UNTESTED | The size or rate depends on an assumption and carries a proposed test. This status can coexist with SOLID. | TESTED | The exported label indicates that the size was classified as sourced or estimated. The underlying claim is still conditional on the model and its inputs. | Scenario range | The lowest and highest blocked-output estimates among the alternatives evaluated for that shortage. For example, robots are labelled SOLID and A. They constrain output in every tested task split, while their capacity estimates depend on assumptions. Their broad range makes the sensitivity visible. Other terms used on this website | Term | Meaning | GDP | The value of final goods and services produced in a period. The model measures annual world output. | 2026 PPP dollars | A common purchasing-power unit used to compare output across economies, valued at the model's 2026 price basis. | Constant prices | A fixed price basis for comparing production across years. | T | One trillion. Displayed output amounts divide the CSV's billions by 1,000. | bn | One billion. The default unit for model output amounts in the v4 CSVs is billion 2026 international dollars. | Target | A chosen what-if scenario: double the model's 2026 world-output estimate and allocate that total among sectors using a selected spending rule. Sector targets are choices, not demand forecasts. | On course | A conditional baseline projection for 2035: today's output plus on-course growth, if the model's assumptions hold. It is not a guaranteed outcome. | On-course growth | The projected increase above today's output under the baseline assumptions. It excludes both calculated tier gaps. | Tier 1 | Extra output that inputs growing at the model's record pace would make. Closing this gap takes building and scaling up what people already know how to do. The amount adds to the conditional baseline and is capped at each chosen sector target. | Tier 2 | Extra output beyond the model's historical benchmarks. Reaching the doubling target calls for discoveries that cut the inputs needed per unit of output or break a historical speed limit. The amount is the gap left after baseline growth and tier 1. Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target. | Worker-equivalent | An estimate of annual work capacity expressed relative to a human worker. Conversions from machines to this unit depend on productivity assumptions. | Elasticity | A measure of the proportional response of one quantity to a proportional change in another, used here for income, prices and substitution. | Precedent | A historical rate or ratio selected as a demonstrated comparison. Applying it to the world and to a new period is a modelling choice. Where does the unexplained gap come from? https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/unexplained.html After baseline growth, the model still needs $182.9T of annual output to reach the doubling target. Its shortage tests account for $141.4T, leaving $41.5T to explain. $182.9T gap to target − $141.4T explained = $41.5T unexplained The model tests one shortage at a time. In each sector and tier, it counts the test that holds back the most output. Two shortages can hold back the same output, so it treats the smaller estimates as part of the biggest one. If the shortages affect different output, they could explain more of the gap together. Example: construction Construction has a $34.6T Tier 2 gap. The construction trades shortage (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k17.html) could hold back $15.4T, the biggest estimate for this sector and tier. $34.6T − $15.4T = $19.2T unexplained | Sector | Unexplained output | Built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c13.html) | $19.2T | Education (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c09.html) | $11.7T | Communication (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c07.html) | $3.6T | Shelter and utilities (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c03.html) | $3.3T | Net exports (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-u4.html) | $2.1T | Health care (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c05.html) | $1.5T | Personal and financial services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c11.html) | $95bn Source files · unexplained_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/unexplained_v4.csv) · rows_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/rows_v4.csv) Why these six picks? https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/picks.html The picks identify constraints to carry into further investigation. Their rank and evidence strength depend on the model's assumptions. The code searches combinations of six, maximising the sum of their individual base blocks subject to a maximum of two picks per main layer. A main layer is the one with that shortage's largest block. Each shortage can affect other layers too. The brief requests at least three SOLID picks labelled S or E. The model finds 2 qualifying picks and uses a fallback that accepts all of them. This selection therefore meets a relaxed version of the rule. | Pick | Base block | Scenario range | Evidence | Main layer | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | $61.7T | $1.1T – $102.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Personal and financial services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c11.html) | Capital stock (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html) | $43.7T | $0bn – $80.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Shelter and utilities (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c03.html) | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | $32.4T | $5.5T – $42.6T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c13.html) | Cropland (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html) | $19.8T | $806bn – $138.5T | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Food at home (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c01.html) | Clinical approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k15.html) | $19.6T | $4.9T – $19.6T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Health care (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c05.html) | Construction trades (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k17.html) | $16.0T | $16.0T – $29.8T | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c13.html) The selection score adds overlapping individual constraints as a ranking heuristic. The effect of relieving several constraints together requires a joint calculation. Read the selection rationale Physical machine labour (robots)blocks 61,652 bn on its own, 1,137-102,480 across the ways of producing; SOLID. Beat the next one down, K21 Capital stock (43,746 bn, SCENARIO), by 17,906 bn Capital stockblocks 43,746 bn on its own, 0-80,540 across the ways of producing; SCENARIO (depends on: v3 second ratio: lowest world capital-output ratio 1990-2023 (PWT, 2005): best demonstrated, the low case). Beat the next one down, K14 Transformers and grid equipment (32,447 bn, SOLID), by 11,299 bn Transformers and grid equipmentblocks 32,447 bn on its own, 5,535-42,579 across the ways of producing; SOLID. Beat the next one down, K22 Cropland (19,805 bn, SOLID), by 12,643 bn Croplandblocks 19,805 bn on its own, 806-138,509 across the ways of producing; SOLID. Beat the next one down, K15 Clinical approval (19,599 bn, SOLID), by 205 bn Clinical approvalblocks 19,599 bn on its own, 4,933-19,599 across the ways of producing; SOLID. Beat the next one down, K17 Construction trades (16,044 bn, SOLID), by 3,555 bn Construction tradesblocks 16,044 bn on its own, 16,044-29,827 across the ways of producing; SOLID. Beat the next one down, K16 Professional licensing (13,785 bn, SCENARIO), by 2,259 bn; the first shortage left out is K16 Professional licensing (13,785 bn) Source files · picks_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/picks_v4.csv) · ranking_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/ranking_v4.csv) · code/v4.py (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/code/v4.py) What changes between scenarios? https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html The model tries different ways of producing the target output and different historical demand responses. Alternatives change one shortage's production or demand calculation. The seven reported scenario columns group these alternatives. Where a shortage has no matching variant, the ranking uses its base case. | ID | Scenario | S0 | base | S1 | AI takes cognitive tasks first | S2 | humans keep cognitive tasks | S3 | labour productivity on trend | S4 | v3 second sourced ratios | S5 | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | S6 | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation The two S6 endpoints for cropland and clinical approval share an ID. The published ranking chooses the first one. The tables below include every evaluated alternative. S0 · base | Input | Alternative | Output blocked | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $13.1T | Fuels (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k02.html) | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE) | $0bn | Machine cognition (AI agents) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k03.html) | v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $0bn | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $61.7T | AI compute (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k05.html) | v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $0bn | Copper (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k06.html) | v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $166bn | Lithium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k07.html) | v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn | Rare earths (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k08.html) | v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn | Steel (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k09.html) | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE material efficiency) | $0bn | Cement (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k10.html) | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE) | $0bn | Saving for investment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k11.html) | v3 ratio: identity (investment = saving at market prices); no ratio to improve | $13.3T | Building permission (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k12.html) | v3 ratio: identity | $1.1T | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $13.1T | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $32.4T | Clinical approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k15.html) | v3 ratio: identity | $19.6T | Professional licensing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k16.html) | v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent | $13.8T | Construction trades (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k17.html) | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (fastest sourced productivity) | $16.0T | Human workforce (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k18.html) | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (fastest sourced productivity) | $0bn | Aluminium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k20.html) | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE) | $7.5T | Capital stock (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html) | v3 ratio: today's ratio held (only today's is sourced) | $43.7T | Cropland (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html) | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (fastest sourced yield growth) | $19.8T | Buyers for built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c13.html) | demand at the 2035 price from the sourced income response (UN AMA world 2014-2024) | $8.5T | Buyers for public services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c12.html) | demand at the 2035 price from the sourced income response (UN AMA world 2014-2024) | $826bn S1 · AI takes cognitive tasks first | Input | Alternative | Output blocked | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $34.8T | Machine cognition (AI agents) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k03.html) | AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $34.8T | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $1.1T | AI compute (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k05.html) | AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $34.8T | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $34.8T | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $42.6T | Professional licensing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k16.html) | AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent | $25.4T S2 · humans keep cognitive tasks | Input | Alternative | Output blocked | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $13.1T | Machine cognition (AI agents) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k03.html) | humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $0bn | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $62.3T | AI compute (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k05.html) | humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $0bn | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $13.1T | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $30.4T | Professional licensing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k16.html) | humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent | $12.6T S3 · labour productivity on trend | Input | Alternative | Output blocked | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $13.3T | Machine cognition (AI agents) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k03.html) | v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $0bn | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $102.5T | AI compute (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k05.html) | v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $0bn | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $13.3T | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $33.8T | Professional licensing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k16.html) | v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent | $16.5T | Human workforce (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k18.html) | humans' share of work with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of the fastest 9-year growth | $10.0T S4 · v3 second sourced ratios | Input | Alternative | Output blocked | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | IEA STEPS 2035 footprint (v3 second ratio) + machine-labour electricity (v3 split) | $254bn | Fuels (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k02.html) | v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) | $7.2T | Copper (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k06.html) | v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $144bn | Lithium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k07.html) | v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn | Rare earths (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k08.html) | v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn | Steel (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k09.html) | v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) | $0bn | Cement (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k10.html) | v3 second ratio: Agent 4 rerun: 2026 intensity held outside C13; C13 at the baseline on-course tonnes per unit of value | $0bn | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | IEA STEPS 2035 footprint (v3 second ratio) + machine-labour electricity (v3 split) | $254bn | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | IEA STEPS 2035 footprint (v3 second ratio) + machine-labour electricity (v3 split) | $5.5T | Construction trades (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k17.html) | v3 second ratio: construction output per worker on its 2014-24 trend (Agent 4 rerun) | $25.4T | Aluminium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k20.html) | v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 aluminium per unit of GDP (WEO 2025 A.5b) | $6.4T | Capital stock (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html) | v3 second ratio: lowest world capital-output ratio 1990-2023 (PWT, 2005): best demonstrated, the low case | $0bn | Cropland (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html) | v3 second ratio: crop output per ha on its 2014-24 trend | $138.5T | Buyers for built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c13.html) | demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.96) | $0bn | Buyers for public services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c12.html) | demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.91) | $1.3T S5 · 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | Input | Alternative | Output blocked | Fuels (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k02.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.62 the v3 ratio | $71.8T | Copper (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k06.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.10 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $283bn | Lithium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k07.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.53 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn | Rare earths (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k08.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.84 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn | Steel (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k09.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.29 the v3 ratio | $18.9T | Cement (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k10.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.35 the v3 ratio | $0.0m | Construction trades (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k17.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.08 the v3 ratio | $29.8T | Human workforce (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k18.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.69 the v3 ratio | $180.8T | Aluminium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k20.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.12 the v3 ratio | $34.8T | Capital stock (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html) | capital-output ratio on its 2013-23 trend: x1.096 today's (PWT capital growth 3.82% vs UN AMA GDP growth 3.03%) | $80.5T | Buyers for built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c13.html) | demand from the UN AMA world income response 1994-2004 (elasticity 0.49) | $29.7T | Buyers for public services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c12.html) | demand from the UN AMA world income response 1994-2004 (elasticity 0.76) | $4.4T S6 · land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | Input | Alternative | Output blocked | Clinical approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k15.html) | only 27% of health output growth beyond the current-rule path comes from new technology needing approval; the rest is more of approved care | $4.9T | Clinical approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k15.html) | only 48% of health output growth beyond the current-rule path comes from new technology needing approval; the rest is more of approved care | $8.8T | Professional licensing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k16.html) | humans take the licensed tasks first, machines the rest: licensing binds only if licensed work exceeds all human work | $0bn | Cropland (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html) | yield gaps closed to attainable yields: crop output per ha +45% on 2026 (x0.885 the v3 ratio) | $5.9T | Cropland (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html) | yield gaps closed to attainable yields: crop output per ha +70% on 2026 (x0.755 the v3 ratio) | $806bn Source files · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · ranking_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/ranking_v4.csv) · scenarios_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/scenarios_v4.csv) Would people buy the extra output? https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/demand.html The five largest layers are tested against an estimated demand response at their assumed 2035 prices. Demand is today's output multiplied by an income response and a price response. The total target income is twice the starting income. An income elasticity above one means this category grows proportionally faster than income under the assumed relationship. Demand in 2035 = today × income ratioincome elasticity × price ratioprice elasticity | Layer | Target | Demand | Buyer shortfall | Built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c13.html) | $105.7T | $97.2T | $8.5T | Shelter and utilities (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c03.html) | $59.2T | $62.9T | $0bn | Health care (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c05.html) | $51.1T | $57.0T | $0bn | Personal and financial services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c11.html) | $35.0T | $39.5T | $0bn | Public services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/layer-c12.html) | $34.1T | $33.3T | $826bn Built structures calculation $54.2T × 2.0000.842 × 0.993720.000 = $97.2T stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, Construction (ISIC F) vs GDP, 2014-2024) no market price (budgets or investment set quantity): no price response 2004-2014: 0.964; 1994-2004: 0.487 Shelter and utilities calculation $29.6T × 2.0001.064 × 0.97580-0.667 = $62.9T stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (income elasticity from v1 bridge, eta) stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (price elasticity, Agent 2) The v4 demand table records one income-response case for this layer. Health care calculation $23.5T × 2.0001.280 × 0.99621-0.200 = $57.0T stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (income elasticity from v1 bridge, eta) stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (price elasticity, Agent 2) The v4 demand table records one income-response case for this layer. Personal and financial services calculation $15.9T × 2.0001.312 × 0.99796-0.972 = $39.5T stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (income elasticity from v1 bridge, eta) stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (price elasticity, Agent 2) The v4 demand table records one income-response case for this layer. Public services calculation $17.5T × 2.0000.928 × 0.990270.000 = $33.3T stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, General government final consumption expenditure vs GDP, 2014-2024) no market price (budgets or investment set quantity): no price response 2004-2014: 0.907; 1994-2004: 0.763 Construction and public services use a zero price elasticity in this implementation. Their demand response follows historical income relationships. The demand check assumes the target world income is reached, so it is conditional on that economy. Source files · demand_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/demand_v4.csv) Frontier technologies https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-1.html This research stream maps technologies and the firms working on them. Stage 1 v4 reuses its comparison against the on-course baseline to identify output already included there. Which emerging technologies are already represented in the baseline? Its headline counts describe the evidence inventory. A mapped technology's contribution can already be included in the baseline. | Reported measure | Value | Evidence | Agent 1 items already inside on course | 97.0 | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Agent 1 items checked against on course | 143.0 | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) The measure names give the units. Monetary output in these source rows is stored in billions of 2026 PPP dollars. Population rows use millions, and item counts are counts. Where these headline figures come from a1_in · stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv (Agent 1 rows), counted a1_all · stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv + not_inside.csv (Agent 1 rows) Source files · agents_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/agents_v4.csv) Physical ratios https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-2.html This stream examines input-to-output ratios, physical limits and the energy budget. Its headline estimates output that the fastest sourced energy build could power. How far could better physical efficiency and energy supply take production? Its energy headline comes from the repaired upstream calculation. Stage 1 v4's electricity shortage additionally depends on its task split and supply comparisons. | Reported measure | Value | Evidence | Output the fastest sourced energy supply can power in 2035 | 323,426.5 | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) The measure names give the units. Monetary output in these source rows is stored in billions of 2026 PPP dollars. Population rows use millions, and item counts are counts. Where these headline figures come from a2_energy · stage1-v3/repair/baseline/totals.csv (T16) Source files · agents_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/agents_v4.csv) Human needs https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-3.html This stream maps needs across people's lives, including access to adequate health care. It gives human context to the economic-output question. What human needs remain unmet? The needs inventory and its population figures are separate measures from the monetary output target. Translating more output into access and wellbeing requires further evidence. | Reported measure | Value | Evidence | Human needs mapped | 36.0 | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | People lacking adequate health care (millions) | 4,600.0 | [S] Sourced (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) The measure names give the units. Monetary output in these source rows is stored in billions of 2026 PPP dollars. Population rows use millions, and item counts are counts. Where these headline figures come from a3_needs · stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/needs.csv (rows) a3_health · stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/needs.csv (N08) Source files · agents_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/agents_v4.csv) Bottlenecks https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-4.html This stream estimates needs and supplies for labour, energy, machines, materials and permission. Stage 1 v4 builds on its repaired data to compute each shortage's own output constraint. Which inputs could constrain more output? The homepage's Agent 4 headline is an upstream result. The red gates and shortage pages show the Stage 1 v4 results, whose definitions and allocations differ. | Reported measure | Value | Evidence | Inputs binding at their fastest precedent (repaired Agent 4) | 3.0 | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Inputs Agent 4 tested | 18.0 | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Output the human workforce blocks (repaired Agent 4) | 19,869.1 | [A] Assumed (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) The measure names give the units. Monetary output in these source rows is stored in billions of 2026 PPP dollars. Population rows use millions, and item counts are counts. Where these headline figures come from a4_bind · stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (status = binding) a4_total · stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (rows) a4_blk · stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K18 output_blocked_ppp_bn) Source files · agents_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/agents_v4.csv) New capabilities https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-5.html This research stream inventories capabilities and checks their overlap with the baseline. Stage 1 v4 retains those headline counts as part of the evidence history. Which emerging capabilities are already included on course? The Stage 1 v4 analysis concentrates on the requirements and shortages behind the output target. | Reported measure | Value | Evidence | Agent 5 capabilities already inside on course | 3.0 | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Agent 5 capabilities checked | 9.0 | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) The measure names give the units. Monetary output in these source rows is stored in billions of 2026 PPP dollars. Population rows use millions, and item counts are counts. Where these headline figures come from a5_in · stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv (Agent 5 rows) a5_caps · stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv + not_inside.csv (Agent 5 rows) Source files · agents_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/agents_v4.csv) Cheaper inputs https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-6.html This stream estimates achievable input-cost reductions and their effects on output and product prices. Stage 1 v4 reuses its product-price changes in the demand checks. How would lower input prices change production and demand? The headline is the repaired stream's estimate under its sourced price assumptions. Each demand page shows how the reused price change enters the Stage 1 v4 calculation. | Reported measure | Value | Evidence | Inputs that reach 3x cheaper by 2035 (repaired Agent 6) | 0.0 | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Inputs Agent 6 priced | 13.0 | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) | Output created at sourced input prices, net of on course | 828.8 | [E] Estimated (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/evidence.html) The measure names give the units. Monetary output in these source rows is stored in billions of 2026 PPP dollars. Population rows use millions, and item counts are counts. Where these headline figures come from a6_reach3 · stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/inputs.csv (reach_3x = yes) a6_n · stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/inputs.csv (rows) a6_ach · stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv (achievable TOTAL) Source files · agents_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/agents_v4.csv) Where the research comes from https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agents.html Six research streams contribute different evidence to the model. The homepage retains their reused and repaired headline figures. Frontier technologiesWhich emerging technologies are already represented in the baseline? → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-1.html) Physical ratiosHow far could better physical efficiency and energy supply take production? → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-2.html) Human needsWhat human needs remain unmet? → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-3.html) BottlenecksWhich inputs could constrain more output? → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-4.html) New capabilitiesWhich emerging capabilities are already included on course? → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-5.html) Cheaper inputsHow would lower input prices change production and demand? → (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/agent-6.html) The stream widths are visual guides to the research flow. Their counts and headline estimates have different units and overlapping scopes. Follow the evidence https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/sources.html The website includes the Stage 1 v4 outputs and the upstream tables directly used by its calculation. These input files are copied from the model's referenced repository snapshot. The source registries retain the original URLs, publication details, extracted values and provenance identifiers. Original citations | Source registry | Download | stage1-v3/requirements/sources.csv | CSV (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/sources.csv) | stage1-v3/repair/sources.csv | CSV (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/sources.csv) | stage1-v2/agent4_bottlenecks/sources.csv | CSV (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v2/agent4_bottlenecks/sources.csv) | stage1-v2/agent6_cheap_inputs/sources.csv | CSV (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v2/agent6_cheap_inputs/sources.csv) | stage1-v2/baseline/sources.csv | CSV (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v2/baseline/sources.csv) | stage1-v2/v1/agent1_frontier/sources.csv | CSV (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/agent1_frontier/sources.csv) | stage1-v2/v1/agent2_ratios/sources.csv | CSV (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/agent2_ratios/sources.csv) | stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/sources.csv | CSV (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/sources.csv) | stage1-v2/v1/agent4_bottlenecks/sources.csv | CSV (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/agent4_bottlenecks/sources.csv) | stage1-v2/v1/agent5_newcaps/sources.csv | CSV (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/agent5_newcaps/sources.csv) | stage1-v2/v1/bridge/sources.csv | CSV (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/bridge/sources.csv) Model input files | Original file | Included copy | stage1-v2/v1/bridge/gap_by_layer.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/bridge/gap_by_layer.csv) | stage1-v2/v1/bridge/bridge_macro.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/bridge/bridge_macro.csv) | stage1-v2/v1/bridge/code/engel_check.py | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/bridge/code/engel_check.py) | stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py) | stage1-v3/requirements/code/common.py | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/common.py) | stage1-v3/requirements/report.md | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md) | stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/blocked_by_layer.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/blocked_by_layer.csv) | stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/needs.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/needs.csv) | stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv) | stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv) | stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv) | stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv) | stage1-v3/requirements/input_layer_v3.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/input_layer_v3.csv) | stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py) | stage1-v3/requirements/work/landcap.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/work/landcap.csv) | stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv) | stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv) | stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv) | stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv) | stage1-v3/repair/baseline/totals.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/totals.csv) | stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv) | stage1-v3/repair/baseline/not_inside.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/not_inside.csv) | stage1-v3/repair/baseline/drivers.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/drivers.csv) | stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv) | stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json) | stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv) | stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv) | stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/inputs.csv | Open file (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/inputs.csv) How to follow a provenance identifier RQ_* identifiers occur in the requirements source registry. R: paths point into stage1-v3/repair. A4: references point to stage1-v2/agent4_bottlenecks, A4v1: to stage1-v2/v1/agent4_bottlenecks, and B: to stage1-v2/v1/bridge. The input tables retain the full chains as recorded. Some chains continue into files beyond this selected bundle. The manifest gives each included file's original path and snapshot URL. Access to the repository depends on its permissions, while the included copies are served with this website. Download the file manifest and SHA-256 hashes (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/manifest.json). DATA DICTIONARY { "output_unit": "billion 2026 international dollars (PPP), annual output", "input_units": "Per-shortage unit column governs requirement, supply, shortfall and excess fields.", "time_horizon": { "baseline_year": 2026, "target_year": 2035, "years": 9 }, "joins": { "layer_id": "layers.layer_id", "shortage_id": "shortages.shortage_id", "variant": "Use shortage_id + variant together to join own_blocks to variants.", "scenario": "Scenario IDs are groupings and are not unique within an input." }, "empty_values": "Blank CSV cells are null in JSON.", "datasets": { "layers": { "description": "The 19 accounting layers and their bridge from 2026 output to the 2035 target.", "rows": 19, "csv": "data/layers_v4.csv", "columns": { "layer_id": "Layer identifier. C01-C15 are named output categories and U1-U4 are retained accounting categories.", "layer": "Plain-English layer name.", "target": "Chosen 2035 sector target in billion 2026 international dollars, under the selected doubling scenario and spending mix. Not a forecast.", "target_label": "S/E/A evidence classification for target.", "today": "2026 annual output estimate in billion 2026 international dollars.", "today_label": "S/E/A evidence classification for today.", "on_course": "Conditional 2035 baseline projection in billion 2026 international dollars. Depends on trend, adoption and input assumptions.", "on_course_label": "S/E/A evidence classification for on_course.", "growth": "Conditional baseline projection minus today's estimate, in billion 2026 international dollars.", "growth_label": "S/E/A evidence classification for growth.", "tier1": "Calculated gap above on_course within the selected historical-benchmark comparison, capped by the chosen target. Billion 2026 international dollars; not predicted growth.", "tier1_label": "S/E/A evidence classification for tier1.", "tier2": "Calculated remaining gap beyond on_course + tier1 under the chosen target mix. Billion 2026 international dollars; not a forecast. target = today + growth + tier1 + tier2.", "tier2_label": "S/E/A evidence classification for tier2.", "src": "Source file or provenance reference. Original source tokens are retained in the upstream tables." } }, "shortages": { "description": "All 23 tested inputs and buyer constraints, with their own base output blocks, ranges, labels and tests.", "rows": 23, "csv": "data/shortages_v4.csv", "columns": { "shortage_id": "Input or demand-constraint identifier. BUY-* refers to a buyer constraint on the named layer.", "shortage": "Plain-English input or buyer-constraint name.", "category": "Input category used in the brief.", "unit": "Native unit for input requirements and supplies. This can differ from the output unit.", "need_2035": "Input needed at the full target under this alternative, in the row's native unit.", "supply_on_course": "Input supply on course, in its native unit. Demand rows use output buyers would absorb.", "supply_precedent": "Input supply at the selected precedent, in its native unit.", "share_met_on_course": "On-course supply divided by the full-target requirement. A fraction, which may exceed 1.", "share_met_precedent": "Precedent supply divided by the full-target requirement. A fraction, which may exceed 1.", "short_at_precedent": "Maximum of zero and need minus precedent supply, in the input's native unit.", "short_on_course": "Maximum of zero and need minus on-course supply, in the input's native unit.", "blocked_tier2": "Tier-2 output removed from the target economy at precedent input supply, in billion PPP dollars.", "blocked_tier1": "Output removed from the on-course-plus-tier-1 economy at on-course input supply, in billion PPP dollars.", "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": "Diagnostic tier-1 output still blocked when tested at precedent supply.", "tier1_competing_with_tier2": "Tier-1 output removed while attempting the full target, recorded separately from the counted block.", "blocked_total": "blocked_tier1 plus blocked_tier2 for this shortage alone, in billion PPP dollars.", "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": "Remaining input shortfall after all eligible tier-1 output is removed, in native input units.", "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": "Remaining input shortfall after eligible target-gap output is removed, in native input units.", "blocked_low": "Smallest blocked_total across this shortage's tested alternatives, in billion PPP dollars.", "blocked_high": "Largest blocked_total across this shortage's tested alternatives, in billion PPP dollars.", "n_alternatives": "Number of evaluated cases beyond the base case.", "verdict": "Conditional robustness verdict. See the terminology and limitations.", "depends_on": "Production assumption or missing alternative that affects the verdict.", "label": "Evidence classification S, E or A.", "status": "TESTED or UNTESTED as assigned by v4 from its evidence labels.", "test": "Proposed test to improve an assumed input or rate.", "growth_needed_pa": "Annual input growth needed from 2026 to 2035, expressed as a fraction.", "growth_precedent_pa": "Annual input growth implied by precedent supply, expressed as a fraction.", "times_faster": "Required annual growth rate divided by the precedent annual growth rate.", "fastest_precedent": "Description of the historical comparison carried from the input table.", "main_layer": "Layer with this shortage's largest combined base tier-1 and tier-2 block.", "src": "Source file or provenance reference. Original source tokens are retained in the upstream tables." } }, "rows": { "description": "The 35 positive layer-and-tier gaps and the largest base shortage credited against each one.", "rows": 35, "csv": "data/rows_v4.csv", "columns": { "layer_id": "Layer identifier. C01-C15 are named output categories and U1-U4 are retained accounting categories.", "layer": "Plain-English layer name.", "tier": "1 for the within-precedent gap or 2 for the beyond-precedent gap.", "missing_bn": "Positive missing output in a layer-and-tier row, in billion PPP dollars.", "missing_label": "S/E/A evidence classification for missing.", "binds_first": "ID of the shortage with the largest base block in the row. Lower need coverage breaks ties.", "binds_first_name": "Name of the shortage credited as the largest block.", "binds_first_category": "Category of the credited shortage.", "binds_first_blocks_bn": "Output credited to the leading shortage in this row, in billion PPP dollars.", "binds_first_label": "S/E/A evidence classification for binds_first.", "binds_first_verdict": "Robustness verdict of the credited shortage.", "others": "Other base shortages affecting the row, with their individually blocked amounts.", "n_shortages": "Number of base shortages with a positive block in the row.", "explained_bn": "Largest individual base shortage block in the row, capped at its missing amount.", "unexplained_bn": "Row missing amount minus the largest individual base shortage block.", "why": "Generated explanation of the row or selection." } }, "unexplained": { "description": "The residual amounts after the largest shortage is credited within each layer and tier.", "rows": 10, "csv": "data/unexplained_v4.csv", "columns": { "layer_id": "Layer identifier. C01-C15 are named output categories and U1-U4 are retained accounting categories.", "layer": "Plain-English layer name.", "tier": "1 for the within-precedent gap or 2 for the beyond-precedent gap.", "unexplained_bn": "Row missing amount minus the largest individual base shortage block.", "label": "Evidence classification S, E or A.", "note": "Explanatory note retained from the calculation." } }, "own_blocks": { "description": "Each shortage's blocked output by alternative, layer and tier. Constraints overlap across shortage IDs.", "rows": 427, "csv": "data/own_blocks_v4.csv", "columns": { "shortage_id": "Input or demand-constraint identifier. BUY-* refers to a buyer constraint on the named layer.", "variant": "Alternative within a shortage. Join with shortage_id to identify a specific calculation.", "layer_id": "Layer identifier. C01-C15 are named output categories and U1-U4 are retained accounting categories.", "tier": "1 for the within-precedent gap or 2 for the beyond-precedent gap.", "blocked_bn": "Output blocked in this shortage/variant/layer/tier cell, in billion PPP dollars." } }, "variants": { "description": "Every evaluated production or demand alternative with its requirement, supplies and blocked output.", "rows": 77, "csv": "data/variants_v4.csv", "columns": { "shortage_id": "Input or demand-constraint identifier. BUY-* refers to a buyer constraint on the named layer.", "variant": "Alternative within a shortage. Join with shortage_id to identify a specific calculation.", "scenario": "Reported scenario grouping. Multiple variants can share a scenario ID.", "way_of_producing": "Description of the production or demand alternative.", "src": "Source file or provenance reference. Original source tokens are retained in the upstream tables.", "label": "Evidence classification S, E or A.", "need_2035": "Input needed at the full target under this alternative, in the row's native unit.", "supply_on_course": "Input supply on course, in its native unit. Demand rows use output buyers would absorb.", "supply_precedent": "Input supply at the selected precedent, in its native unit.", "blocked_tier2": "Tier-2 output removed from the target economy at precedent input supply, in billion PPP dollars.", "blocked_tier1": "Output removed from the on-course-plus-tier-1 economy at on-course input supply, in billion PPP dollars.", "blocked_total": "blocked_tier1 plus blocked_tier2 for this shortage alone, in billion PPP dollars.", "binds": "Whether this alternative blocks more than the model's numerical tolerance." } }, "ranking": { "description": "Base ordering, seven reported scenario orderings, evidence groupings and selection flags.", "rows": 20, "csv": "data/ranking_v4.csv", "columns": { "shortage_id": "Input or demand-constraint identifier. BUY-* refers to a buyer constraint on the named layer.", "shortage": "Plain-English input or buyer-constraint name.", "category": "Input category used in the brief.", "unit": "Native unit for input requirements and supplies. This can differ from the output unit.", "need_2035": "Input needed at the full target under this alternative, in the row's native unit.", "supply_on_course": "Input supply on course, in its native unit. Demand rows use output buyers would absorb.", "supply_precedent": "Input supply at the selected precedent, in its native unit.", "share_met_on_course": "On-course supply divided by the full-target requirement. A fraction, which may exceed 1.", "share_met_precedent": "Precedent supply divided by the full-target requirement. A fraction, which may exceed 1.", "short_at_precedent": "Maximum of zero and need minus precedent supply, in the input's native unit.", "short_on_course": "Maximum of zero and need minus on-course supply, in the input's native unit.", "blocked_tier2": "Tier-2 output removed from the target economy at precedent input supply, in billion PPP dollars.", "blocked_tier1": "Output removed from the on-course-plus-tier-1 economy at on-course input supply, in billion PPP dollars.", "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": "Diagnostic tier-1 output still blocked when tested at precedent supply.", "tier1_competing_with_tier2": "Tier-1 output removed while attempting the full target, recorded separately from the counted block.", "blocked_total": "blocked_tier1 plus blocked_tier2 for this shortage alone, in billion PPP dollars.", "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": "Remaining input shortfall after all eligible tier-1 output is removed, in native input units.", "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": "Remaining input shortfall after eligible target-gap output is removed, in native input units.", "blocked_low": "Smallest blocked_total across this shortage's tested alternatives, in billion PPP dollars.", "blocked_high": "Largest blocked_total across this shortage's tested alternatives, in billion PPP dollars.", "n_alternatives": "Number of evaluated cases beyond the base case.", "verdict": "Conditional robustness verdict. See the terminology and limitations.", "depends_on": "Production assumption or missing alternative that affects the verdict.", "label": "Evidence classification S, E or A.", "status": "TESTED or UNTESTED as assigned by v4 from its evidence labels.", "test": "Proposed test to improve an assumed input or rate.", "growth_needed_pa": "Annual input growth needed from 2026 to 2035, expressed as a fraction.", "growth_precedent_pa": "Annual input growth implied by precedent supply, expressed as a fraction.", "times_faster": "Required annual growth rate divided by the precedent annual growth rate.", "fastest_precedent": "Description of the historical comparison carried from the input table.", "main_layer": "Layer with this shortage's largest combined base tier-1 and tier-2 block.", "src": "Source file or provenance reference. Original source tokens are retained in the upstream tables.", "group_label": "S/E/A evidence classification for group.", "group_solid": "Robustness group used by the ranking.", "rank_all": "Base rank when shortages are ordered by their own blocked output.", "rank_S0": "Rank in reported scenario S0. Ties share their smallest rank.", "blocked_S0": "Own output blocked in reported scenario S0, in billion 2026 PPP dollars.", "rank_S1": "Rank in reported scenario S1. Ties share their smallest rank.", "blocked_S1": "Own output blocked in reported scenario S1, in billion 2026 PPP dollars.", "rank_S2": "Rank in reported scenario S2. Ties share their smallest rank.", "blocked_S2": "Own output blocked in reported scenario S2, in billion 2026 PPP dollars.", "rank_S3": "Rank in reported scenario S3. Ties share their smallest rank.", "blocked_S3": "Own output blocked in reported scenario S3, in billion 2026 PPP dollars.", "rank_S4": "Rank in reported scenario S4. Ties share their smallest rank.", "blocked_S4": "Own output blocked in reported scenario S4, in billion 2026 PPP dollars.", "rank_S5": "Rank in reported scenario S5. Ties share their smallest rank.", "blocked_S5": "Own output blocked in reported scenario S5, in billion 2026 PPP dollars.", "rank_S6": "Rank in reported scenario S6. Ties share their smallest rank.", "blocked_S6": "Own output blocked in reported scenario S6, in billion 2026 PPP dollars.", "rank_changes": "Whether rank differs among the seven reported scenario columns.", "rank_in_label_group": "Position among shortages sharing the evidence group.", "rank_in_solid_group": "Position among shortages sharing the robustness group.", "pick": "Whether the shortage is one of the six selected entries." } }, "picks": { "description": "The six selected shortages and the generated rationale for each selection.", "rows": 6, "csv": "data/picks_v4.csv", "columns": { "shortage_id": "Input or demand-constraint identifier. BUY-* refers to a buyer constraint on the named layer.", "shortage": "Plain-English input or buyer-constraint name.", "category": "Input category used in the brief.", "main_layer": "Layer with this shortage's largest combined base tier-1 and tier-2 block.", "rule": "Selection-rule outcome recorded by the model.", "blocked_total": "blocked_tier1 plus blocked_tier2 for this shortage alone, in billion PPP dollars.", "blocked_low": "Smallest blocked_total across this shortage's tested alternatives, in billion PPP dollars.", "blocked_high": "Largest blocked_total across this shortage's tested alternatives, in billion PPP dollars.", "verdict": "Conditional robustness verdict. See the terminology and limitations.", "label": "Evidence classification S, E or A.", "solid_se": "Whether the pick has verdict SOLID and evidence label S or E.", "rank_all": "Base rank when shortages are ordered by their own blocked output.", "why": "Generated explanation of the row or selection." } }, "agents": { "description": "The research streams' reused or repaired headline figures and their source paths.", "rows": 13, "csv": "data/agents_v4.csv", "columns": { "key": "Identifier for the research-agent headline.", "value": "Research-agent headline value. Its meaning and unit are given by what.", "label": "Evidence classification S, E or A.", "src": "Source file or provenance reference. Original source tokens are retained in the upstream tables.", "what": "Description of the headline value, including its unit where needed." } }, "demand": { "description": "Demand at the assumed 2035 prices for the five largest target layers.", "rows": 5, "csv": "data/demand_v4.csv", "columns": { "layer_id": "Layer identifier. C01-C15 are named output categories and U1-U4 are retained accounting categories.", "layer": "Plain-English layer name.", "today": "2026 annual output estimate in billion 2026 international dollars.", "target": "Chosen 2035 sector target in billion 2026 international dollars, under the selected doubling scenario and spending mix. Not a forecast.", "extra_output": "Missing tier-1 plus tier-2 output for this layer, in billion PPP dollars.", "income_ratio": "Target total world output divided by today's total output.", "income_elasticity": "Power applied to the income ratio in the demand calculation.", "income_elasticity_label": "S/E/A evidence classification for income_elasticity.", "income_elasticity_src": "Source or provenance reference for income_elasticity.", "price_ratio_2035": "2035 product price divided by its starting price.", "price_ratio_src": "Source or provenance reference for price_ratio.", "price_elasticity": "Power applied to the price ratio in the demand calculation.", "price_elasticity_src": "Source or provenance reference for price_elasticity.", "demand_2035": "Modelled quantity demanded, expressed as output valued in billion 2026 PPP dollars.", "demand_label": "S/E/A evidence classification for demand.", "buyers_short": "Maximum of zero and target minus modelled demand, in billion PPP dollars.", "verdict": "Conditional robustness verdict. See the terminology and limitations.", "income_elasticity_other_windows": "Income-response estimates from the other historical windows." } }, "searches": { "description": "The two external searches recorded by the v4 calculation.", "rows": 2, "csv": "data/searches_v4.csv", "columns": { "id": "Identifier of the source search or scenario.", "query": "Recorded search text used during the v4 analysis.", "source": "Bibliographic source as recorded by the model.", "url": "Original source URL.", "value_low": "Lower sourced endpoint used for an alternative.", "value_high": "Upper sourced endpoint used for an alternative.", "label": "Evidence classification S, E or A.", "used_for": "How the recorded source was used in the model." } }, "checks": { "description": "The committed model-check results. The methods page explains where those checks relax the brief.", "rows": 14, "csv": "data/checks_v4.csv", "columns": { "check": "Invariant or rule evaluated by the model checker.", "ok": "Boolean result of the committed check, using the rules implemented in check.py.", "detail": "Evidence or diagnostic text for the check." } }, "scenarios": { "description": "Names for the seven scenario IDs used by the published ranking.", "rows": 7, "csv": "data/scenarios_v4.csv", "columns": { "id": "Identifier of the source search or scenario.", "scenario": "Reported scenario grouping. Multiple variants can share a scenario ID." } } } } MODEL OUTPUTS { "title": "Abundance Machines Stage 1 v4", "model_source_revision": "efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445", "scope": "The committed v4 calculation and explanatory website.", "totals": { "today": 224261.881, "target": 448523.7620258, "growth": 41357.0028828, "tier1": 34757.309, "tier2": 148147.569116, "missing": 182904.878116, "unexplained": 41470.79140348271, "explained": 141434.08671251728 }, "units": "billion 2026 international dollars (PPP), annual output", "terminology": { "GDP": "The value of final goods and services produced in a period. The model measures annual world output.", "2026 PPP dollars": "A common purchasing-power unit used to compare output across economies, valued at the model's 2026 price basis.", "Constant prices": "A fixed price basis for comparing production across years.", "T": "One trillion. Displayed output amounts divide the CSV's billions by 1,000.", "bn": "One billion. The default unit for model output amounts in the v4 CSVs is billion 2026 international dollars.", "Target": "A chosen what-if scenario: double the model's 2026 world-output estimate and allocate that total among sectors using a selected spending rule. Sector targets are choices, not demand forecasts.", "On course": "A conditional baseline projection for 2035: today's output plus on-course growth, if the model's assumptions hold. It is not a guaranteed outcome.", "On-course growth": "The projected increase above today's output under the baseline assumptions. It excludes both calculated tier gaps.", "Tier 1": "Extra output that inputs growing at the model's record pace would make. Closing this gap takes building and scaling up what people already know how to do. The amount adds to the conditional baseline and is capped at each chosen sector target.", "Tier 2": "Extra output beyond the model's historical benchmarks. Reaching the doubling target calls for discoveries that cut the inputs needed per unit of output or break a historical speed limit. The amount is the gap left after baseline growth and tier 1. Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target.", "S": "Sourced. A value read from a source.", "E": "Estimated from sourced inputs. The calculation or interpretation introduces modelling choices.", "A": "Assumed. At least part of the estimate depends on an assumption.", "SOLID": "The reported constraint binds across the production alternatives tested. K11 saving has an explicit accounting-identity exemption and only one tested case.", "SCENARIO": "The constraint depends on a production assumption, or has insufficient alternative tests. Some longer verdicts flag cases that exceed the testing threshold only in another variant.", "UNTESTED": "The size or rate depends on an assumption and carries a proposed test. This status can coexist with SOLID.", "TESTED": "The exported label indicates that the size was classified as sourced or estimated. The underlying claim is still conditional on the model and its inputs.", "Scenario range": "The lowest and highest blocked-output estimates among the alternatives evaluated for that shortage.", "Worker-equivalent": "An estimate of annual work capacity expressed relative to a human worker. Conversions from machines to this unit depend on productivity assumptions.", "Elasticity": "A measure of the proportional response of one quantity to a proportional change in another, used here for income, prices and substitution.", "Precedent": "A historical rate or ratio selected as a demonstrated comparison. Applying it to the world and to a new period is a modelling choice." }, "number_roles": { "today": { "label": "Estimate today", "meaning": "An estimate of annual output at the 2026 starting point." }, "baseline": { "label": "Conditional projection", "meaning": "The 2035 baseline if the model's trend, adoption and input assumptions hold. This is what on course means here." }, "target": { "label": "Chosen scenario", "meaning": "A goal and a chosen mix of sectors to test. It is not a prediction of future output or demand." }, "comparison": { "label": "Historical-benchmark comparison", "meaning": "A conditional calculation using selected past production, employment, productivity or investment rates, proxies and input constraints. These examples need not have occurred together. Accounting rows use bookkeeping assumptions. This is not a physical limit or a guaranteed achievable path." }, "gap": { "label": "Calculated gap", "meaning": "A difference between the chosen target and the model's comparison levels. Changing the target or assumptions changes the gap." }, "constraint": { "label": "Conditional constraint", "meaning": "Output removed when testing one shortage in the chosen scenario. It is not a forecast of lost GDP, and different shortages can overlap." } }, "sector_target_choices": [ { "layer_id": "C01", "income_response_factor": 0.62377, "basis": "estimated household response", "chosen_target": 21195.60452, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 25180.124, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "C02", "income_response_factor": 0.96519, "basis": "estimated household response", "chosen_target": 6517.162464, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 6777.194, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "C03", "income_response_factor": 1.06403, "basis": "estimated household response", "chosen_target": 59177.23267, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 59200.652, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "C04", "income_response_factor": 1.04856, "basis": "estimated household response", "chosen_target": 7633.719426, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 7683.212, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "C05", "income_response_factor": 1.27974, "basis": "estimated household response", "chosen_target": 51080.94924, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 46946.982, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "C06", "income_response_factor": 1.1503, "basis": "estimated household response", "chosen_target": 17804.91767, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 17218.828, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "C07", "income_response_factor": 1.15354, "basis": "estimated household response", "chosen_target": 8878.970034, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 8575.774, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "C08", "income_response_factor": 1.35079, "basis": "estimated household response", "chosen_target": 13339.93155, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 11921.762, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "C09", "income_response_factor": 0.91796, "basis": "estimated household response", "chosen_target": 31578.51396, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 33450.902, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "C10", "income_response_factor": 1.31251, "basis": "estimated household response", "chosen_target": 13288.4201, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 12056.318, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "C11", "income_response_factor": 1.31251, "basis": "estimated household response", "chosen_target": 34976.03323, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 31733.056, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "C12", "income_response_factor": 1.0, "basis": "default outside household demand", "chosen_target": 34091.12052, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 34971.398, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "C13", "income_response_factor": 1.0, "basis": "default outside household demand", "chosen_target": 105727.507, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 108457.53, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "C14", "income_response_factor": 1.0, "basis": "default outside household demand", "chosen_target": 13746.63192, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 14101.588, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "C15", "income_response_factor": 1.0, "basis": "default outside household demand", "chosen_target": 14052.69497, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 14415.554, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "U1", "income_response_factor": 1.0, "basis": "default outside household demand", "chosen_target": 7008.858084, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 7189.836, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "U2", "income_response_factor": 1.0, "basis": "default outside household demand", "chosen_target": -266.7131172, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": -273.6, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "U3", "income_response_factor": 1.0, "basis": "default outside household demand", "chosen_target": 4402.944201, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 4516.634, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" }, { "layer_id": "U4", "income_response_factor": 1.0, "basis": "default outside household demand", "chosen_target": 4289.263584, "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 4400.018, "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv" } ], "limitations": [ "This is a what-if analysis. The doubling goal and sector mix are chosen scenarios, not forecasts. On course is a conditional baseline projection; tiers are calculated gaps and shortage blocks are conditional input tests.", "Sector targets use estimated spending-response factors for household categories and a default of 1 outside them. The original target labels are E even where that default assumption enters. Choosing another mix changes targets, gaps and requirements.", "Own shortage blocks overlap. The model credits the maximum block within each layer/tier, which assumes smaller blocks are contained within it.", "The six picks include only two SOLID S/E entries. The code relaxes the brief's minimum of three.", "Saving and building permission exceed $1T and have no alternative tests. The code labels saving SOLID under an accounting-identity exemption.", "Clinical approval and cropland each have two S6 variants. The ranking columns take the first, while the ranges include both.", "The allocation protects on-course output and uses a fixed ordering. Remaining input shortfalls are recorded in diagnostic fields.", "Buyer demand assumes target world income. Construction and public services have price elasticity set to zero.", "Source registries preserve the original citations. This website build does not constitute a fresh verification of those publications." ], "schema": "data/schema.json", "source_manifest": "data/manifest.json", "datasets": { "layers": [ { "layer_id": "C01", "layer": "Food at home", "target": 21195.60452, "target_label": "E", "today": 12590.062, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 14055.848, "on_course_label": "A", "growth": 1465.786, "growth_label": "A", "tier1": 1238.149, "tier1_label": "A", "tier2": 5901.607524, "tier2_label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "C02", "layer": "Clothing", "target": 6517.162464, "target_label": "E", "today": 3388.597, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 4382.246, "on_course_label": "A", "growth": 993.6489999999999, "growth_label": "A", "tier1": 447.477, "tier1_label": "A", "tier2": 1687.439464, "tier2_label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "C03", "layer": "Shelter and utilities", "target": 59177.23267, "target_label": "E", "today": 29600.326, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 34080.671, "on_course_label": "A", "growth": 4480.345000000001, "growth_label": "A", "tier1": 627.119, "tier1_label": "A", "tier2": 24469.44267, "tier2_label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "C04", "layer": "Household equipment", "target": 7633.719426, "target_label": "E", "today": 3841.606, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 4871.131, "on_course_label": "A", "growth": 1029.525, "growth_label": "A", "tier1": 1458.705, "tier1_label": "A", "tier2": 1303.883426, "tier2_label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "C05", "layer": "Health care", "target": 51080.94924, "target_label": "E", "today": 23473.491, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 29998.021, "on_course_label": "A", "growth": 6524.529999999999, "growth_label": "A", "tier1": 1766.768, "tier1_label": "A", "tier2": 19316.16024, "tier2_label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "C06", "layer": "Mobility", "target": 17804.91767, "target_label": "E", "today": 8609.414, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 9477.227, "on_course_label": "A", "growth": 867.8130000000001, "growth_label": "A", "tier1": 5345.213, "tier1_label": "A", "tier2": 2982.477665, "tier2_label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "C07", "layer": "Communication", "target": 8878.970034, "target_label": "E", "today": 4287.887, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 5285.868, "on_course_label": "A", "growth": 997.9810000000007, "growth_label": "A", "tier1": 82.515, "tier1_label": "A", "tier2": 3510.587034, "tier2_label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "C08", "layer": "Recreation", "target": 13339.93155, "target_label": "E", "today": 5960.881, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 6271.781, "on_course_label": "A", "growth": 310.89999999999964, "growth_label": "A", "tier1": 1565.762, "tier1_label": "A", "tier2": 5502.388547, "tier2_label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "C09", "layer": "Education", "target": 31578.51396, "target_label": "E", "today": 16725.451, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 19888.256, "on_course_label": "A", "growth": 3162.8050000000003, "growth_label": "A", "tier1": 2449.752, "tier1_label": "A", "tier2": 9240.505965, "tier2_label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "C10", "layer": "Food service, lodging", "target": 13288.4201, "target_label": "E", "today": 6028.159, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 7631.84, "on_course_label": "A", "growth": 1603.6810000000005, "growth_label": "A", "tier1": 1434.025, "tier1_label": "A", "tier2": 4222.555095, "tier2_label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "C11", "layer": "Personal and financial services", "target": 34976.03323, "target_label": "E", "today": 15866.528, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 19233.678, "on_course_label": "A", "growth": 3367.1499999999996, "growth_label": "A", "tier1": 1882.514, "tier1_label": "A", "tier2": 13859.84123, "tier2_label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "C12", "layer": "Public services", "target": 34091.12052, "target_label": "E", "today": 17485.699, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 19921.289, "on_course_label": "A", "growth": 2435.59, "growth_label": "A", "tier1": 2998.156, "tier1_label": "A", "tier2": 11171.67552, "tier2_label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "C13", "layer": "Built structures", "target": 105727.507, "target_label": "E", "today": 54228.765, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 62411.018, "on_course_label": "A", "growth": 8182.252999999997, "growth_label": "A", "tier1": 8677.18, "tier1_label": "A", "tier2": 34639.30898, "tier2_label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "C14", "layer": "Productive equipment", "target": 13746.63192, "target_label": "E", "today": 7050.794, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 8889.045, "on_course_label": "A", "growth": 1838.2510000000002, "growth_label": "A", "tier1": 3353.131, "tier1_label": "A", "tier2": 1504.455918, "tier2_label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "C15", "layer": "Knowledge and software", "target": 14052.69497, "target_label": "E", "today": 7207.777, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 11150.057, "on_course_label": "A", "growth": 3942.2800000000007, "growth_label": "A", "tier1": 1341.365, "tier1_label": "A", "tier2": 1561.272969, "tier2_label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "U1", "layer": "Alcohol, tobacco, narcotics", "target": 7008.858084, "target_label": "E", "today": 3594.918, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 3911.745, "on_course_label": "A", "growth": 316.82699999999977, "growth_label": "A", "tier1": 57.028, "tier1_label": "A", "tier2": 3040.085084, "tier2_label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "U2", "layer": "Net purchases abroad", "target": -266.7131172, "target_label": "E", "today": -136.8, "today_label": "E", "on_course": -266.7131172, "on_course_label": "E", "growth": -129.9131172, "growth_label": "E", "tier1": 0.0, "tier1_label": "E", "tier2": 0.0, "tier2_label": "E", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "U3", "layer": "Inventories", "target": 4402.944201, "target_label": "E", "today": 2258.317, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 2225.867, "on_course_label": "A", "growth": -32.44999999999982, "growth_label": "A", "tier1": 32.45, "tier1_label": "A", "tier2": 2144.627201, "tier2_label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" }, { "layer_id": "U4", "layer": "Net exports", "target": 4289.263584, "target_label": "E", "today": 2200.009, "today_label": "E", "on_course": 2200.009, "on_course_label": "E", "growth": 0.0, "growth_label": "E", "tier1": 0.0, "tier1_label": "E", "tier2": 2089.254584, "tier2_label": "E", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" } ], "shortages": [ { "shortage_id": "K01", "shortage": "Electricity", "category": "energy", "unit": "TWh per year (gross generation)", "need_2035": 74059.01810670001, "supply_on_course": 44274.0, "supply_precedent": 93251.9, "share_met_on_course": 0.5978205103423401, "share_met_precedent": 1.2591565805753457, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 29785.01810670001, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 13052.02480714768, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 13052.02480714768, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 254.2228150095216, "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994, "n_alternatives": 4.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": null, "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "IEA WEO-2026 Annex A (STEPS generation 2035) and Ember monthly 2026 generation; IEA World Energy Balances by final-demand sector to replace the EXIOBASE monetary electricity multiplier", "growth_needed_pa": 0.09470307265246425, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.12309451993046494, "times_faster": 0.7693524675668845, "fastest_precedent": "China 2002-2011: generation x2.84 in 9 years (Ember), applied to world 2026 supply; world fastest 9 years (OWID, 2001-10) x1.37 is the low case", "main_layer": "C06", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "shortage": "Fuels", "category": "energy", "unit": "EJ per year (final consumption excl. electricity)", "need_2035": 445.18773945600003, "supply_on_course": 374.0, "supply_precedent": 548.836, "share_met_on_course": 0.8400950135262297, "share_met_precedent": 1.2328192161595772, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 71.18773945600003, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 71782.99576593254, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)", "depends_on": "binds only under: v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun); 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.62 the v3 ratio", "label": "E", "status": "TESTED", "test": null, "growth_needed_pa": 0.023609314109906965, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.04769328840461373, "times_faster": 0.4950238261957013, "fastest_precedent": "World fossil-fuel consumption 1965-1974 x1.52 in 9 years (EI via OWID), the post-1965 maximum", "main_layer": null, "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "shortage": "Machine cognition (AI agents)", "category": "machines", "unit": "million worker-equivalents in 2035", "need_2035": 537.0604189395623, "supply_on_course": 310.266, "supply_precedent": 45732.6, "share_met_on_course": 0.5777115368371907, "share_met_precedent": 85.1535476963654, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 226.79441893956226, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994, "n_alternatives": 3.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)", "depends_on": "binds only under: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them", "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "Task-matched benchmark of agent-hours per human-hour on real jobs (GDPval/METR); Epoch agent-population update with 2028-30 shipments", "growth_needed_pa": 0.17696584267992832, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.9285496803155593, "times_faster": 0.19058306349293885, "fastest_precedent": "AI chip power sold grew x1.87 in 2025 (Epoch), held 2028-2035 on top of the through-2027 fleet", "main_layer": null, "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "shortage": "Physical machine labour (robots)", "category": "machines", "unit": "million worker-equivalents in 2035", "need_2035": 1202.3194090922568, "supply_on_course": 32.7731, "supply_precedent": 42.8569, "share_met_on_course": 0.027258230842953347, "share_met_precedent": 0.03564518685792212, "short_at_precedent": 1159.4625090922568, "short_on_course": 1169.5463090922567, "blocked_tier2": 60005.09023066053, "blocked_tier1": 1646.5028954966801, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 21153.975000000002, "blocked_total": 61651.59312615721, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 1137.0283592863655, "blocked_high": 102480.36777547782, "n_alternatives": 3.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": null, "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "Time-and-motion worker-equivalents of deployed humanoids; Counterpoint/IDC 2027 shipments to confirm the ramp", "growth_needed_pa": 0.5974132099514471, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.10288056130378731, "times_faster": 5.806861883144243, "fastest_precedent": "China electric-car sales 2014-2023 x111 in 9 years (IEA via OWID) applied to humanoid shipments from 50k in 2026 (Counterpoint); industrial robots on the IFR 2026-29 forecast trend", "main_layer": "C11", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "shortage": "AI compute", "category": "machines", "unit": "GW of AI chip TDP in service in 2035", "need_2035": 146.27352256634808, "supply_on_course": 84.504, "supply_precedent": 12455.7, "share_met_on_course": 0.5777122100937297, "share_met_precedent": 85.15348356603793, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 61.76952256634807, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994, "n_alternatives": 3.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)", "depends_on": "binds only under: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them", "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "Epoch chip-sales update for 2027-28; TSMC CoWoS and HBM capacity plans to 2030", "growth_needed_pa": 0.25536394631152937, "growth_precedent_pa": 1.0570108723255318, "times_faster": 0.2415906524686001, "fastest_precedent": "AI chip power sold x1.87 in 2025 (Epoch) held 2028-2035; bounded in practice by K01/K14 (power and grid)", "main_layer": null, "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K06", "shortage": "Copper", "category": "materials", "unit": "million t refined copper per year", "need_2035": 51.03882403, "supply_on_course": 26.5106, "supply_precedent": 45.4269, "share_met_on_course": 0.5194202747386458, "share_met_precedent": 0.8900459770252274, "short_at_precedent": 5.611924029999997, "short_on_course": 24.52822403, "blocked_tier2": 165.7467183780582, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 165.7467183780582, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 144.03696137609495, "blocked_high": 282.6403011266366, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "not tested (blocks 1T or less)", "depends_on": null, "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "IEA Critical Minerals Data Explorer: copper STEPS 2035 demand, secondary supply and base/high-production mine supply in kt (replaces the 2030-40 interpolation and the held 18% secondary share)", "growth_needed_pa": 0.06917554845780782, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.055426946841626634, "times_faster": 1.2480490519433725, "fastest_precedent": "World copper mine output 1954-1963 x1.625 in 9 years (USGS via OWID), post-1950 maximum; post-1985 maximum (1995-2004) x1.47 is the low case", "main_layer": "C14", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K07", "shortage": "Lithium", "category": "materials", "unit": "kt lithium content per year", "need_2035": 1208.28267, "supply_on_course": 452.919, "supply_precedent": 2301.24, "share_met_on_course": 0.37484523385574997, "share_met_precedent": 1.9045543374382747, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 755.3636700000001, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 0.0, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "not tested (blocks 1T or less)", "depends_on": "v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion); v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion); 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.53 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)", "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "IEA Critical Minerals Data Explorer lithium end-use split mapped to final demand (replaces the battery-product proxy A02)", "growth_needed_pa": 0.15948252353702475, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.24552474179985384, "times_faster": 0.6495578505364289, "fastest_precedent": "World lithium mine output 2016-2025 x7.21 in 9 years (USGS via OWID)", "main_layer": null, "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K08", "shortage": "Rare earths", "category": "materials", "unit": "kt magnet rare earth elements per year", "need_2035": 213.0123662, "supply_on_course": 136.357, "supply_precedent": 709.648, "share_met_on_course": 0.6401365443355185, "share_met_precedent": 3.331487334090747, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 76.6553662, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 0.0, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "not tested (blocks 1T or less)", "depends_on": "v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion); v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion); 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.84 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)", "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "IEA Critical Minerals Data Explorer magnet rare-earth end-use split; non-China separation capacity under construction", "growth_needed_pa": 0.10182534133158572, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.25945792660475964, "times_faster": 0.3924541549532208, "fastest_precedent": "World rare-earth mine output 1960-1969 x7.97 in 9 years (USGS via OWID)", "main_layer": null, "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K09", "shortage": "Steel", "category": "materials", "unit": "Mt crude steel per year", "need_2035": 2901.93264675, "supply_on_course": 2570.4, "supply_precedent": 3135.54, "share_met_on_course": 0.8857545342682926, "share_met_precedent": 1.0805006117256466, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 331.5326467499999, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 18927.55399354189, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)", "depends_on": "binds only under: 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.29 the v3 ratio", "label": "E", "status": "TESTED", "test": null, "growth_needed_pa": 0.05022424450517593, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.05929800117314343, "times_faster": 0.8469803958235765, "fastest_precedent": "World crude steel 2002-2011 x1.68 in 9 years (worldsteel Steel Statistical Yearbook 2012)", "main_layer": null, "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K10", "shortage": "Cement", "category": "materials", "unit": "Mt cement per year", "need_2035": 5589.70491443, "supply_on_course": 5428.57, "supply_precedent": 7528.7, "share_met_on_course": 0.9711729121846798, "share_met_precedent": 1.3468868420163689, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 161.1349144300002, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 2.0568407371335927e-07, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "not tested (blocks 1T or less)", "depends_on": "v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE); v3 second ratio: Agent 4 rerun: 2026 intensity held outside C13; C13 at the baseline on-course tonnes per unit of value; 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.35 the v3 ratio", "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "GCCA/USGS world cement capacity and clinker factor (replaces A03); USGS regional cement 2026", "growth_needed_pa": 0.04490703690865905, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.08005973889230611, "times_faster": 0.5609191027848168, "fastest_precedent": "World cement 2002-2011 x2.00 in 9 years (USGS MCS 2004 and 2013)", "main_layer": null, "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K11", "shortage": "Saving for investment", "category": "capital", "unit": "bn US$ (market) of gross saving per year", "need_2035": 58368.093940000006, "supply_on_course": 37826.3, "supply_precedent": 87530.7, "share_met_on_course": 0.6480646779194791, "share_met_precedent": 1.499632660439074, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 20541.793940000003, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 13315.424574700748, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 13315.424574700748, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 13315.424574700748, "blocked_high": 13315.424574700748, "n_alternatives": 0.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": "accounting identity (saving = investment in C13-C15 at market prices): binds under every way of producing; rests on the on-course saving rate (2015-24 mean, A)", "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "IMF WEO saving and investment projections to 2031 (world saving rate path) to replace the held 2015-24 mean", "growth_needed_pa": 0.07580152934450268, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.12534590268703316, "times_faster": 0.6047387885806357, "fastest_precedent": "China gross saving 51.3% of GDP (2008, World Bank) applied to world output at max; on course = world 2015-24 mean saving rate", "main_layer": "C13", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K12", "shortage": "Building permission", "category": "permission", "unit": "bn 2026 int$ of construction (C13) that must be permitted in 2035", "need_2035": 105727.507, "supply_on_course": 94403.39409, "supply_precedent": 104600.4637, "share_met_on_course": 0.892893408429653, "share_met_precedent": 0.9893401127863537, "short_at_precedent": 1127.0433000000048, "short_on_course": 11324.112909999996, "blocked_tier2": 1127.0432990000047, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 1127.0432990000047, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 1127.0432990000047, "blocked_high": 1127.0432990000047, "n_alternatives": 0.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO", "depends_on": "fewer than two sourced alternative ways found; rests on the base ratio", "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "Open the Auckland upzoning working paper (Greenaway-McGrevy and Phillips) and OECD housing-supply elasticities by metro weighted by ICP construction spend", "growth_needed_pa": 0.07700459273700444, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.07572286962059604, "times_faster": 1.0169264995216158, "fastest_precedent": "Auckland 2016 upzoning (+50% consents within 5 years, A4:A05) in the 30% of construction under discretionary permission (A4:A04); outside it current rules permit any amount (Agent 4 capped that part at capacity)", "main_layer": "C13", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "shortage": "Grid connection approval", "category": "permission", "unit": "TWh per year of generation connected", "need_2035": 74059.01810670001, "supply_on_course": 44274.0, "supply_precedent": 87637.2, "share_met_on_course": 0.5978205103423401, "share_met_precedent": 1.1833427209868934, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 29785.01810670001, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 13052.02480714768, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 13052.02480714768, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 254.2228150095216, "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994, "n_alternatives": 4.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": null, "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "ENTSO-E and LBNL completion rates by request year; IEA count of 2 800 GW waiting by region and age", "growth_needed_pa": 0.09470307265246425, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.11537198187260045, "times_faster": 0.8208498381958989, "fastest_precedent": "US 2008 queue speed (22 months request-to-operation, LBNL) in queue-bound grids (US+EU share of 2025 generation); STEPS path assumed connected", "main_layer": "C06", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "shortage": "Transformers and grid equipment", "category": "machines", "unit": "TWh per year of generation the delivered transformers can connect", "need_2035": 74059.01810670001, "supply_on_course": 42553.3, "supply_precedent": 73055.4, "share_met_on_course": 0.574586337867613, "share_met_precedent": 0.986448401121737, "short_at_precedent": 1003.6181067000143, "short_on_course": 31505.718106700006, "blocked_tier2": 2084.4004939814517, "blocked_tier1": 30362.798827555125, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 32447.199321536576, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 5535.2869548039225, "blocked_high": 42579.2414163116, "n_alternatives": 4.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": null, "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "World transformer manufacturing capacity by region (Wood Mackenzie / IEA grid supply-chain report) and order books to 2030", "growth_needed_pa": 0.09470307265246425, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.09304472855017654, "times_faster": 1.0178230849627705, "fastest_precedent": "US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv magazine) used as the supply ramp from the STEPS addition rate", "main_layer": "C13", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K15", "shortage": "Clinical approval", "category": "permission", "unit": "bn 2026 int$ of health output (C05) that must be allowed in 2035", "need_2035": 51080.94924, "supply_on_course": 30435.4, "supply_precedent": 32810.9, "share_met_on_course": 0.5958268288437938, "share_met_precedent": 0.6423314462274469, "short_at_precedent": 18270.04924, "short_on_course": 20645.54924, "blocked_tier2": 18270.049238999996, "blocked_tier1": 1329.388998999997, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 19599.438237999995, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 4932.913293800001, "blocked_high": 19599.438237999995, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": null, "label": "E", "status": "TESTED", "test": null, "growth_needed_pa": 0.09023500788567618, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.03791080379570344, "times_faster": 2.380192421451713, "fastest_precedent": "Further health output is workforce (2010-19) and productivity (2015-24) precedents achieved under current approval rules (BL C05-F1, C05-F2); new products not needed", "main_layer": "C05", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K16", "shortage": "Professional licensing", "category": "permission", "unit": "million machine worker-equivalents in 2035", "need_2035": 1739.3798280318192, "supply_on_course": 1425.5139081255777, "supply_precedent": 1582.4468680786986, "share_met_on_course": 0.819552972359468, "share_met_precedent": 0.9097764861797341, "short_at_precedent": 156.93295995312064, "short_on_course": 313.8659199062415, "blocked_tier2": 13784.95003546745, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 13784.95003546745, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 25400.473427913825, "n_alternatives": 4.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO", "depends_on": "humans take the licensed tasks first, machines the rest: licensing binds only if licensed work exceeds all human work", "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "OECD/EU cross-country licensing incidence; legal mapping of which tasks require a licensed person", "growth_needed_pa": 0.3213308836107842, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.30752130988797166, "times_faster": 1.0449060708275577, "fastest_precedent": "machine work allowed outside licensed tasks now; fastest reform precedent halves the licensed share (A4:A11)", "main_layer": "C05", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K17", "shortage": "Construction trades", "category": "workers by skill", "unit": "million construction workers (ISIC F) in 2035", "need_2035": 571.0133258405, "supply_on_course": 380.178, "supply_precedent": 495.099, "share_met_on_course": 0.6657953199960772, "share_met_precedent": 0.8670533201151509, "short_at_precedent": 75.9143258405, "short_on_course": 190.8353258405, "blocked_tier2": 15431.881468431786, "blocked_tier1": 612.4853744149369, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 16044.366842846723, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 16044.366842846723, "blocked_high": 29826.608292081026, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": null, "label": "E", "status": "TESTED", "test": null, "growth_needed_pa": 0.07042742817776748, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.05359434114124362, "times_faster": 1.3140832908489648, "fastest_precedent": "World construction employment at its fastest 9-year growth (ILO, 2002-2011, 5.36%/yr) from 2026", "main_layer": "C13", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "shortage": "Human workforce", "category": "workers by skill", "unit": "million workers in 2035", "need_2035": 4316.60000011, "supply_on_course": 4023.24, "supply_precedent": 4316.6, "share_met_on_course": 0.9320391048272889, "share_met_precedent": 0.999999999974517, "short_at_precedent": 1.0999974620062858e-07, "short_on_course": 293.3600001100003, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 180815.623532, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)", "depends_on": "binds only under: 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.69 the v3 ratio; humans' share of work with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of the fastest 9-year growth", "label": "E", "status": "TESTED", "test": null, "growth_needed_pa": 0.018990822269040697, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.01899082226615545, "times_faster": 1.0000000001519285, "fastest_precedent": "WPP 15+ population 2035 x the highest world employment ratio 1991-2025 (BL T19)", "main_layer": null, "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "shortage": "Aluminium", "category": "materials", "unit": "Mt aluminium per year", "need_2035": 209.321297831, "supply_on_course": 137.0, "supply_precedent": 330.479693, "share_met_on_course": 0.6544962286188855, "share_met_precedent": 1.5788154211943584, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 72.32129783100001, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 7539.027006070798, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 7539.027006070798, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 6402.647931436973, "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": null, "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "IEA STEPS/NZE 2035 aluminium demand by end use (WEO Annex) against the EXIOBASE footprint, and 2026 smelter capacity by region", "growth_needed_pa": 0.06674002551464775, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.12226497322702223, "times_faster": 0.5458638214456116, "fastest_precedent": "world bauxite mine output 1950-1959 x2.82 in 9 years (USGS via OWID), post-1950 maximum; post-1985 maximum 2004-2013 x1.80 is the low case", "main_layer": "C14", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "shortage": "Capital stock", "category": "capital", "unit": "tn 2026 int$ (PPP) of capital stock in 2035", "need_2035": 2140.0557346999994, "supply_on_course": 1502.073347, "supply_precedent": 1748.363583, "share_met_on_course": 0.7018851531035316, "share_met_precedent": 0.8169710511044666, "short_at_precedent": 391.6921516999994, "short_on_course": 637.9823876999994, "blocked_tier2": 43745.811249530394, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 14782.252, "blocked_total": 43745.811249530394, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 80540.40160590273, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO", "depends_on": "v3 second ratio: lowest world capital-output ratio 1990-2023 (PWT, 2005): best demonstrated, the low case", "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "PWT 11.0 capital-output ratios by country 1990-2023 for economies growing 5%+ a year (does K/Y fall during fast growth?)", "growth_needed_pa": 0.07981389098142166, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.05583023731461245, "times_faster": 1.429581796897216, "fastest_precedent": "world real capital stock at its fastest 9-year growth (1964-1973, PWT 11.0); on course = 2013-23 trend", "main_layer": "C03", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "shortage": "Cropland", "category": "land", "unit": "million ha of cropland in 2035", "need_2035": 2280.784052995, "supply_on_course": 1628.046431, "supply_precedent": 1688.875222, "share_met_on_course": 0.7138099851505623, "share_met_precedent": 0.7404801080498007, "short_at_precedent": 591.908830995, "short_on_course": 652.7376219949999, "blocked_tier2": 19804.653712, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 6937.790466578571, "blocked_total": 19804.653712, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 806.164520494398, "blocked_high": 138508.85818366456, "n_alternatives": 3.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": null, "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "FAOSTAT crop output per ha and cropland by country 2000-2024, and the EXIOBASE crop footprint per $ of non-food output 1995-2022 (does it fall with income?)", "growth_needed_pa": 0.04054069708755037, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.006376667523958046, "times_faster": 6.357662044513566, "fastest_precedent": "world cropland at its fastest 9-year expansion (1976-1985, FAOSTAT); on course = 2014-24 trend", "main_layer": "C01", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "BUY-C13", "shortage": "Buyers for built structures", "category": "buyers", "unit": "bn 2026 int$ of output bought", "need_2035": 105727.507, "supply_on_course": 97239.2654842971, "supply_precedent": 97239.2654842971, "share_met_on_course": 0.9197158643331778, "share_met_precedent": 0.9197158643331778, "short_at_precedent": 8488.241515702903, "short_on_course": 8488.241515702903, "blocked_tier2": 8488.241514702904, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 8488.241514702904, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 29744.175381093894, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO", "depends_on": "demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.96)", "label": "E", "status": "TESTED", "test": null, "growth_needed_pa": null, "growth_precedent_pa": null, "times_faster": null, "fastest_precedent": null, "main_layer": "C13", "src": "demand_v4.csv" }, { "shortage_id": "BUY-C12", "shortage": "Buyers for public services", "category": "buyers", "unit": "bn 2026 int$ of output bought", "need_2035": 34091.12052, "supply_on_course": 33265.52655037182, "supply_precedent": 33265.52655037182, "share_met_on_course": 0.975782727084496, "share_met_precedent": 0.975782727084496, "short_at_precedent": 825.5939696281785, "short_on_course": 825.5939696281785, "blocked_tier2": 825.5939686281745, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 825.5939686281745, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 825.5939686281745, "blocked_high": 4420.765201076206, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)", "depends_on": "binds only under: demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.91); demand from the UN AMA world income response 1994-2004 (elasticity 0.76)", "label": "E", "status": "TESTED", "test": null, "growth_needed_pa": null, "growth_precedent_pa": null, "times_faster": null, "fastest_precedent": null, "main_layer": "C12", "src": "demand_v4.csv" } ], "rows": [ { "layer_id": "C01", "layer": "Food at home", "tier": 1.0, "missing_bn": 1238.149, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K04", "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1238.149, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K14 1,238; K01 1,238; K13 1,238", "n_shortages": 4.0, "explained_bn": 1238.149, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) on course meets 3% of need; at its fastest precedent (China electric-car sales 2014-2023 x111 in 9 years (IEA via OWID) applied to humanoid ship) it meets 4%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): needs a price fall of 6% (cost room for it not sourced)" }, { "layer_id": "C01", "layer": "Food at home", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 5901.607524, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K04", "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 5901.607524, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K22 5,902; K21 5,902", "n_shortages": 3.0, "explained_bn": 5901.607524, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)" }, { "layer_id": "C02", "layer": "Clothing", "tier": 1.0, "missing_bn": 447.477, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K14", "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 447.477, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K01 447; K13 447", "n_shortages": 3.0, "explained_bn": 447.477, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): needs a price fall of 11% (cost room for it not sourced)" }, { "layer_id": "C02", "layer": "Clothing", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 1687.439464, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K04", "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1687.439464, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K22 1,687; K21 1,687", "n_shortages": 3.0, "explained_bn": 1687.439464, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)" }, { "layer_id": "C03", "layer": "Shelter and utilities", "tier": 1.0, "missing_bn": 627.119, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K14", "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 627.119, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K01 627; K13 627", "n_shortages": 3.0, "explained_bn": 627.119, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): demand at today's price exceeds max output" }, { "layer_id": "C03", "layer": "Shelter and utilities", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 24469.44267, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K21", "binds_first_name": "Capital stock", "binds_first_category": "capital", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 21157.658535530394, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SCENARIO", "others": "K14 2,084", "n_shortages": 2.0, "explained_bn": 21157.658535530394, "unexplained_bn": 3311.784134469606, "why": "Capital stock would have to grow 8.0% a year 2026-35 against 5.6% at its fastest precedent (1.4x faster)" }, { "layer_id": "C04", "layer": "Household equipment", "tier": 1.0, "missing_bn": 1458.705, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K14", "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1458.705, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K01 1,459; K13 1,459; K20 1,459", "n_shortages": 4.0, "explained_bn": 1458.705, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): needs a price fall of 20% (cost room for it not sourced)" }, { "layer_id": "C04", "layer": "Household equipment", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 1303.883426, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K04", "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1303.883426, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K22 1,304; K21 1,304", "n_shortages": 3.0, "explained_bn": 1303.883426, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)" }, { "layer_id": "C05", "layer": "Health care", "tier": 1.0, "missing_bn": 1766.768, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K15", "binds_first_name": "Clinical approval", "binds_first_category": "permission", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1329.388998999997, "binds_first_label": "E", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": null, "n_shortages": 1.0, "explained_bn": 1329.388998999997, "unexplained_bn": 437.379001000003, "why": "Clinical approval on course meets 60% of need; at its fastest precedent (Further health output is workforce (2010-19) and productivity (2015-24) precedents achieve) it meets 64%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): demand at today's price exceeds max output" }, { "layer_id": "C05", "layer": "Health care", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 19316.16024, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K15", "binds_first_name": "Clinical approval", "binds_first_category": "permission", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 18270.049238999996, "binds_first_label": "E", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K16 13,785", "n_shortages": 2.0, "explained_bn": 18270.049238999996, "unexplained_bn": 1046.1110010000048, "why": "Clinical approval would have to grow 9.0% a year 2026-35 against 3.8% at its fastest precedent (2.4x faster)" }, { "layer_id": "C06", "layer": "Mobility", "tier": 1.0, "missing_bn": 5345.213, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K14", "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 5345.213, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K01 5,345; K13 5,345; K20 2,638", "n_shortages": 4.0, "explained_bn": 5345.213, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): needs a price fall of 37% (cost room for it not sourced)" }, { "layer_id": "C06", "layer": "Mobility", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 2982.477665, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K04", "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 2982.477665, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K21 2,982", "n_shortages": 2.0, "explained_bn": 2982.477665, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)" }, { "layer_id": "C07", "layer": "Communication", "tier": 1.0, "missing_bn": 82.515, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": null, "binds_first_name": null, "binds_first_category": null, "binds_first_blocks_bn": 0.0, "binds_first_label": null, "binds_first_verdict": null, "others": null, "n_shortages": 0.0, "explained_bn": 0.0, "unexplained_bn": 82.515, "why": null }, { "layer_id": "C07", "layer": "Communication", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 3510.587034, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": null, "binds_first_name": null, "binds_first_category": null, "binds_first_blocks_bn": 0.0, "binds_first_label": null, "binds_first_verdict": null, "others": null, "n_shortages": 0.0, "explained_bn": 0.0, "unexplained_bn": 3510.587034, "why": null }, { "layer_id": "C08", "layer": "Recreation", "tier": 1.0, "missing_bn": 1565.762, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K14", "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1565.762, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K01 550; K13 550; K04 408", "n_shortages": 4.0, "explained_bn": 1565.762, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): demand at today's price exceeds max output" }, { "layer_id": "C08", "layer": "Recreation", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 5502.388547, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K04", "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 5502.388547, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K21 5,502", "n_shortages": 2.0, "explained_bn": 5502.388547, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)" }, { "layer_id": "C09", "layer": "Education", "tier": 1.0, "missing_bn": 2449.752, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": null, "binds_first_name": null, "binds_first_category": null, "binds_first_blocks_bn": 0.0, "binds_first_label": null, "binds_first_verdict": null, "others": null, "n_shortages": 0.0, "explained_bn": 0.0, "unexplained_bn": 2449.752, "why": null }, { "layer_id": "C09", "layer": "Education", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 9240.505965, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": null, "binds_first_name": null, "binds_first_category": null, "binds_first_blocks_bn": 0.0, "binds_first_label": null, "binds_first_verdict": null, "others": null, "n_shortages": 0.0, "explained_bn": 0.0, "unexplained_bn": 9240.505965, "why": null }, { "layer_id": "C10", "layer": "Food service, lodging", "tier": 1.0, "missing_bn": 1434.025, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K14", "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1434.025, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": null, "n_shortages": 1.0, "explained_bn": 1434.025, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): needs a price fall of 2% (cost room for it not sourced)" }, { "layer_id": "C10", "layer": "Food service, lodging", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 4222.555095, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K04", "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 4222.555095, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K22 4,223", "n_shortages": 2.0, "explained_bn": 4222.555095, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)" }, { "layer_id": "C11", "layer": "Personal and financial services", "tier": 1.0, "missing_bn": 1882.514, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K14", "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1787.0388275551213, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": null, "n_shortages": 1.0, "explained_bn": 1787.0388275551213, "unexplained_bn": 95.47517244487858, "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): demand at today's price exceeds max output" }, { "layer_id": "C11", "layer": "Personal and financial services", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 13859.84123, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K04", "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 13859.84123, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": null, "n_shortages": 1.0, "explained_bn": 13859.84123, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)" }, { "layer_id": "C12", "layer": "Public services", "tier": 1.0, "missing_bn": 2998.156, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K14", "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 2998.156, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": null, "n_shortages": 1.0, "explained_bn": 2998.156, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): UNTESTED: income elasticity is a default (non-household layer); price elasticity A or zero" }, { "layer_id": "C12", "layer": "Public services", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 11171.67552, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K04", "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 11171.67552, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "BUY-C12 826", "n_shortages": 2.0, "explained_bn": 11171.67552, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)" }, { "layer_id": "C13", "layer": "Built structures", "tier": 1.0, "missing_bn": 8677.18, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K14", "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 8677.18, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K11 8,621; K17 612", "n_shortages": 3.0, "explained_bn": 8677.18, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): UNTESTED: income elasticity is a default (non-household layer); price elasticity A or zero" }, { "layer_id": "C13", "layer": "Built structures", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 34639.30898, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K17", "binds_first_name": "Construction trades", "binds_first_category": "workers by skill", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 15431.881468431786, "binds_first_label": "E", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "BUY-C13 8,488; K04 5,123; K12 1,127", "n_shortages": 4.0, "explained_bn": 15431.881468431786, "unexplained_bn": 19207.427511568218, "why": "Construction trades would have to grow 7.0% a year 2026-35 against 5.4% at its fastest precedent (1.3x faster)" }, { "layer_id": "C14", "layer": "Productive equipment", "tier": 1.0, "missing_bn": 3353.131, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K14", "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 3353.131, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K01 3,353; K13 3,353; K11 3,353; K20 3,353", "n_shortages": 5.0, "explained_bn": 3353.131, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): UNTESTED: income elasticity is a default (non-household layer); price elasticity A or zero" }, { "layer_id": "C14", "layer": "Productive equipment", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 1504.455918, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K04", "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1504.455918, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K22 1,504; K21 1,504; K06 166", "n_shortages": 4.0, "explained_bn": 1504.455918, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)" }, { "layer_id": "C15", "layer": "Knowledge and software", "tier": 1.0, "missing_bn": 1341.365, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K14", "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1341.365, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K11 1,341", "n_shortages": 2.0, "explained_bn": 1341.365, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): UNTESTED: income elasticity is a default (non-household layer); price elasticity A or zero" }, { "layer_id": "C15", "layer": "Knowledge and software", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 1561.272969, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K04", "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1561.272969, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K21 1,561", "n_shortages": 2.0, "explained_bn": 1561.272969, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)" }, { "layer_id": "U1", "layer": "Alcohol, tobacco, narcotics", "tier": 1.0, "missing_bn": 57.028, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K14", "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 57.028, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K20 57", "n_shortages": 2.0, "explained_bn": 57.028, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace" }, { "layer_id": "U1", "layer": "Alcohol, tobacco, narcotics", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 3040.085084, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K04", "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 3040.085084, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K22 3,040", "n_shortages": 2.0, "explained_bn": 3040.085084, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)" }, { "layer_id": "U3", "layer": "Inventories", "tier": 1.0, "missing_bn": 32.45, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K14", "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 32.45, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K01 32; K13 32; K20 32", "n_shortages": 4.0, "explained_bn": 32.45, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace" }, { "layer_id": "U3", "layer": "Inventories", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 2144.627201, "missing_label": "A", "binds_first": "K04", "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)", "binds_first_category": "machines", "binds_first_blocks_bn": 2144.627201, "binds_first_label": "A", "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID", "others": "K22 2,145; K21 2,145", "n_shortages": 3.0, "explained_bn": 2144.627201, "unexplained_bn": 0.0, "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)" }, { "layer_id": "U4", "layer": "Net exports", "tier": 2.0, "missing_bn": 2089.254584, "missing_label": "E", "binds_first": null, "binds_first_name": null, "binds_first_category": null, "binds_first_blocks_bn": 0.0, "binds_first_label": null, "binds_first_verdict": null, "others": null, "n_shortages": 0.0, "explained_bn": 0.0, "unexplained_bn": 2089.254584, "why": null } ], "unexplained": [ { "layer_id": "C03", "layer": "Shelter and utilities", "tier": 2.0, "unexplained_bn": 3311.784134469606, "label": "A", "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage" }, { "layer_id": "C05", "layer": "Health care", "tier": 1.0, "unexplained_bn": 437.379001000003, "label": "A", "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage" }, { "layer_id": "C05", "layer": "Health care", "tier": 2.0, "unexplained_bn": 1046.1110010000048, "label": "A", "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage" }, { "layer_id": "C07", "layer": "Communication", "tier": 1.0, "unexplained_bn": 82.515, "label": "A", "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage" }, { "layer_id": "C07", "layer": "Communication", "tier": 2.0, "unexplained_bn": 3510.587034, "label": "A", "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage" }, { "layer_id": "C09", "layer": "Education", "tier": 1.0, "unexplained_bn": 2449.752, "label": "A", "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage" }, { "layer_id": "C09", "layer": "Education", "tier": 2.0, "unexplained_bn": 9240.505965, "label": "A", "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage" }, { "layer_id": "C11", "layer": "Personal and financial services", "tier": 1.0, "unexplained_bn": 95.47517244487858, "label": "A", "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage" }, { "layer_id": "C13", "layer": "Built structures", "tier": 2.0, "unexplained_bn": 19207.427511568218, "label": "A", "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage" }, { "layer_id": "U4", "layer": "Net exports", "tier": 2.0, "unexplained_bn": 2089.254584, "label": "E", "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage" } ], "own_blocks": [ { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 549.780807147679 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1766.768 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C07", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 82.515 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1565.762 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C09", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2449.752 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1434.025 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C11", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1882.514 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2998.156 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 8677.18 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1341.365 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 57.028 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 549.780807147679 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 810.5277171714993 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 254.2228150095216 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2982.477665 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 4234.36606957129 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 4620.799885932551 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 24469.44267 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1303.883426 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2982.477665 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1504.455918 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2144.627201 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1766.768 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C07", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 82.515 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1565.762 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C09", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2449.752 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1434.025 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C11", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1882.514 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2998.156 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 8677.18 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1341.365 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 57.028 }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1766.768 }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C07", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 82.515 }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1565.762 }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C09", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2449.752 }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1434.025 }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C11", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1882.514 }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2998.156 }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 8677.18 }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1341.365 }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 57.028 }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5901.607524 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1687.439464 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1303.883426 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2982.477665 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5502.388547 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 4222.555095 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C11", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 13859.84123 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 11171.67552 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5122.780587660534 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1504.455918 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1561.272969 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 3040.085084 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2144.627201 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 408.3538954966803 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1137.0283592863655 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5901.607524 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1687.439464 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1303.883426 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2982.477665 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5502.388547 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 4222.555095 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C11", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 13859.84123 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 11171.67552 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5685.2281110314725 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1504.455918 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1561.272969 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 3040.085084 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2144.627201 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.2487201738372 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5901.607524 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1687.439464 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1303.883426 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2982.477665 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5502.388547 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 4222.555095 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C11", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 13859.84123 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 11171.67552 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 34639.30898 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1504.455918 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1561.272969 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 3040.085084 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2144.627201 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3404.4721524778174 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1565.762 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1434.025 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 57.028 }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1766.768 }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C07", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 82.515 }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1565.762 }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C09", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2449.752 }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1434.025 }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C11", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1882.514 }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2998.156 }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 8677.18 }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1341.365 }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 57.028 }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K06", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 165.7467183780582 }, { "shortage_id": "K06", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 144.03696137609495 }, { "shortage_id": "K06", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 282.6403011266366 }, { "shortage_id": "K09", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1303.883426 }, { "shortage_id": "K09", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 11414.232093532111 }, { "shortage_id": "K09", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1504.455918 }, { "shortage_id": "K09", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2144.627201 }, { "shortage_id": "K09", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2560.35535500978 }, { "shortage_id": "K10", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2.0568407371335927e-07 }, { "shortage_id": "K11", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 8620.928574700749 }, { "shortage_id": "K11", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K11", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1341.365 }, { "shortage_id": "K12", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1127.0432990000047 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 549.780807147679 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1766.768 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C07", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 82.515 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1565.762 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C09", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2449.752 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1434.025 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C11", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1882.514 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2998.156 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 8677.18 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1341.365 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 57.028 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 549.780807147679 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 810.5277171714993 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 254.2228150095216 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2084.4004939814517 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1565.762 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1434.025 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C11", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1787.0388275551213 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2998.156 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 8677.18 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1341.365 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 57.028 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 7821.932416311601 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1766.768 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C07", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 82.515 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1565.762 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C09", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2449.752 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1434.025 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C11", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1882.514 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2998.156 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 8677.18 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1341.365 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 57.028 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1565.762 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1434.025 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C11", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1787.0388275551213 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2998.156 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 8677.18 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1341.365 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 57.028 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 3408.3630205329064 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1565.762 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1434.025 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C11", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1787.0388275551213 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2998.156 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 8677.18 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1341.365 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 57.028 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 63.88195480392324 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K15", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 18270.049238999996 }, { "shortage_id": "K15", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1329.388998999997 }, { "shortage_id": "K15", "variant": "techshare_low", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 4932.913293800001 }, { "shortage_id": "K15", "variant": "techshare_high", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 8769.623634199996 }, { "shortage_id": "K16", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 13784.95003546745 }, { "shortage_id": "K16", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 19316.16024 }, { "shortage_id": "K16", "variant": "cogfirst", "layer_id": "C09", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 6084.313187913823 }, { "shortage_id": "K16", "variant": "humanscog", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 12579.693155567813 }, { "shortage_id": "K16", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 16524.0966133932 }, { "shortage_id": "K17", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 15431.881468431786 }, { "shortage_id": "K17", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 612.4853744149369 }, { "shortage_id": "K17", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 20728.504478851126 }, { "shortage_id": "K17", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 4679.671016129003 }, { "shortage_id": "K17", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 23227.783745613626 }, { "shortage_id": "K17", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 6598.824546467401 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5901.607524 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1687.439464 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 24469.44267 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1303.883426 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 19316.16024 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2982.477665 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C07", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 3510.587034 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5502.388547 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C09", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 9240.505965 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 4222.555095 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C11", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 13859.84123 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 11171.67552 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 34639.30898 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1504.455918 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1561.272969 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 3040.085084 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2144.627201 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1766.768 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C07", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 82.515 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1565.762 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C09", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2449.752 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1434.025 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C11", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1882.514 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2998.156 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 8677.18 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1341.365 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 57.028 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5901.607524 }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "trendprod", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 4133.773687171332 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2637.7130060707977 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 57.028 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1501.3339314369725 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 57.028 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1766.768 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C07", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 82.515 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1565.762 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C09", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2449.752 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1434.025 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C11", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1882.514 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2998.156 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 8677.18 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1341.365 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 57.028 }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5901.607524 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1687.439464 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 21157.658535530394 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1303.883426 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2982.477665 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5502.388547 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1504.455918 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1561.272969 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2144.627201 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5901.607524 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1687.439464 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 24469.44267 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1303.883426 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2982.477665 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "C07", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 3510.587034 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5502.388547 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 4222.555095 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 11171.67552 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1504.455918 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1561.272969 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2154.4536843890073 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2144.627201 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1113.2268885137362 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1341.365 }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5901.607524 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1687.439464 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1303.883426 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 4222.555095 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1504.455918 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 3040.085084 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2144.627201 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5901.607524 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1687.439464 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1303.883426 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 19316.16024 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2982.477665 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5502.388547 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C09", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 9240.505965 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 4222.555095 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C11", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 13859.84123 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 11171.67552 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 20312.573335664558 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1504.455918 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1561.272969 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 3040.085084 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 2144.627201 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1238.149 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C02", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 447.477 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C03", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 627.119 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C04", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1458.705 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C05", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1766.768 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C06", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 5345.213 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C07", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 82.515 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C08", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1565.762 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C09", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2449.752 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C10", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1434.025 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C11", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1882.514 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 2998.156 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 8677.18 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C14", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 3353.131 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "C15", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 1341.365 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "U1", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 57.028 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "layer_id": "U3", "tier": 1.0, "blocked_bn": 32.45 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "yieldgap_low", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 5901.607524 }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "yieldgap_high", "layer_id": "C01", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 806.164520494398 }, { "shortage_id": "BUY-C13", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 8488.241514702904 }, { "shortage_id": "BUY-C13", "variant": "eta_1994-2004", "layer_id": "C13", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 29744.175381093894 }, { "shortage_id": "BUY-C12", "variant": "base", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 825.5939686281745 }, { "shortage_id": "BUY-C12", "variant": "eta_2004-2014", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 1302.8633224280456 }, { "shortage_id": "BUY-C12", "variant": "eta_1994-2004", "layer_id": "C12", "tier": 2.0, "blocked_bn": 4420.765201076206 } ], "variants": [ { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 74059.01810670001, "supply_on_course": 44274.0, "supply_precedent": 93251.9, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 13052.02480714768, "blocked_total": 13052.02480714768, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "cogfirst", "scenario": "S1", "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 76821.04985452816, "supply_on_course": 44274.0, "supply_precedent": 93251.9, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994, "blocked_total": 34757.308999999994, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "humanscog", "scenario": "S2", "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 73044.11190843255, "supply_on_course": 44274.0, "supply_precedent": 93251.9, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 13052.02480714768, "blocked_total": 13052.02480714768, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "trendprod", "scenario": "S3", "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 74697.94664442586, "supply_on_course": 44274.0, "supply_precedent": 93251.9, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 13312.7717171715, "blocked_total": 13312.7717171715, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "variant": "v3alt", "scenario": "S4", "way_of_producing": "IEA STEPS 2035 footprint (v3 second ratio) + machine-labour electricity (v3 split)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_alt_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 69351.1560593, "supply_on_course": 44274.0, "supply_precedent": 93251.9, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 254.2228150095216, "blocked_total": 254.2228150095216, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 445.18773945600003, "supply_on_course": 374.0, "supply_precedent": 548.836, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "v3alt", "scenario": "S4", "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 572.535344348, "supply_on_course": 374.0, "supply_precedent": 548.836, "blocked_tier2": 2982.477665, "blocked_tier1": 4234.36606957129, "blocked_total": 7216.84373457129, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "variant": "today", "scenario": "S5", "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.62 the v3 ratio", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K02 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 721.7139999701841, "supply_on_course": 374.0, "supply_precedent": 548.836, "blocked_tier2": 37025.68676593255, "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994, "blocked_total": 71782.99576593254, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 537.0604189395623, "supply_on_course": 310.266, "supply_precedent": 45732.6, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "cogfirst", "scenario": "S1", "way_of_producing": "AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 1661.402818363198, "supply_on_course": 310.266, "supply_precedent": 45732.6, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994, "blocked_total": 34757.308999999994, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "humanscog", "scenario": "S2", "way_of_producing": "humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 123.921768, "supply_on_course": 310.266, "supply_precedent": 45732.6, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "variant": "trendprod", "scenario": "S3", "way_of_producing": "v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 635.1995588823061, "supply_on_course": 310.266, "supply_precedent": 45732.6, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 1202.3194090922568, "supply_on_course": 32.7731, "supply_precedent": 42.8569, "blocked_tier2": 60005.09023066053, "blocked_tier1": 1646.5028954966801, "blocked_total": 61651.59312615721, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "cogfirst", "scenario": "S1", "way_of_producing": "AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 77.97700966862, "supply_on_course": 32.7731, "supply_precedent": 42.8569, "blocked_tier2": 1137.0283592863655, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 1137.0283592863655, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "humanscog", "scenario": "S2", "way_of_producing": "humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 1615.4580600318193, "supply_on_course": 32.7731, "supply_precedent": 42.8569, "blocked_tier2": 60567.537754031466, "blocked_tier1": 1685.3977201738371, "blocked_total": 62252.935474205304, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K04", "variant": "trendprod", "scenario": "S3", "way_of_producing": "v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 1510.524664677507, "supply_on_course": 32.7731, "supply_precedent": 42.8569, "blocked_tier2": 89521.618623, "blocked_tier1": 12958.749152477816, "blocked_total": 102480.36777547782, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 146.27352256634808, "supply_on_course": 84.504, "supply_precedent": 12455.7, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "cogfirst", "scenario": "S1", "way_of_producing": "AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 452.498888530066, "supply_on_course": 84.504, "supply_precedent": 12455.7, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994, "blocked_total": 34757.308999999994, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "humanscog", "scenario": "S2", "way_of_producing": "humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 33.75127432366153, "supply_on_course": 84.504, "supply_precedent": 12455.7, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "variant": "trendprod", "scenario": "S3", "way_of_producing": "v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 173.0026524646219, "supply_on_course": 84.504, "supply_precedent": 12455.7, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K06", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035); input_layer_v3.csv (missing, output_depending_ppp_bn)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 51.03882403, "supply_on_course": 26.5106, "supply_precedent": 45.4269, "blocked_tier2": 165.7467183780582, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 165.7467183780582, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K06", "variant": "v3alt", "scenario": "S4", "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 50.226109252899995, "supply_on_course": 26.5106, "supply_precedent": 45.4269, "blocked_tier2": 144.03696137609495, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 144.03696137609495, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K06", "variant": "today", "scenario": "S5", "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.10 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K06 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 55.91000000321605, "supply_on_course": 26.5106, "supply_precedent": 45.4269, "blocked_tier2": 282.6403011266366, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 282.6403011266366, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K07", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035); input_layer_v3.csv (missing, output_depending_ppp_bn)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 1208.28267, "supply_on_course": 452.919, "supply_precedent": 2301.24, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K07", "variant": "v3alt", "scenario": "S4", "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 1013.9538286940001, "supply_on_course": 452.919, "supply_precedent": 2301.24, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K07", "variant": "today", "scenario": "S5", "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.53 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K07 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 638.000000036699, "supply_on_course": 452.919, "supply_precedent": 2301.24, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K08", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035); input_layer_v3.csv (missing, output_depending_ppp_bn)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 213.0123662, "supply_on_course": 136.357, "supply_precedent": 709.648, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K08", "variant": "v3alt", "scenario": "S4", "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 193.912195587, "supply_on_course": 136.357, "supply_precedent": 709.648, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K08", "variant": "today", "scenario": "S5", "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.84 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K08 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 178.00000001023892, "supply_on_course": 136.357, "supply_precedent": 709.648, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K09", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE material efficiency)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 2901.93264675, "supply_on_course": 2570.4, "supply_precedent": 3135.54, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K09", "variant": "v3alt", "scenario": "S4", "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 3076.47781373, "supply_on_course": 2570.4, "supply_precedent": 3135.54, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K09", "variant": "today", "scenario": "S5", "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.29 the v3 ratio", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K09 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 3734.0400011798456, "supply_on_course": 2570.4, "supply_precedent": 3135.54, "blocked_tier2": 16367.19863853211, "blocked_tier1": 2560.35535500978, "blocked_total": 18927.55399354189, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K10", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 5589.70491443, "supply_on_course": 5428.57, "supply_precedent": 7528.7, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K10", "variant": "v3alt", "scenario": "S4", "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: Agent 4 rerun: 2026 intensity held outside C13; C13 at the baseline on-course tonnes per unit of value", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 6095.49857833, "supply_on_course": 5428.57, "supply_precedent": 7528.7, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K10", "variant": "today", "scenario": "S5", "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.35 the v3 ratio", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K10 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 7528.700001012227, "supply_on_course": 5428.57, "supply_precedent": 7528.7, "blocked_tier2": 2.0568407371335927e-07, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 2.0568407371335927e-07, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K11", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: identity (investment = saving at market prices); no ratio to improve", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 58368.093940000006, "supply_on_course": 37826.3, "supply_precedent": 87530.7, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 13315.424574700748, "blocked_total": 13315.424574700748, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K12", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: identity", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 105727.507, "supply_on_course": 94403.39409, "supply_precedent": 104600.4637, "blocked_tier2": 1127.0432990000047, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 1127.0432990000047, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 74059.01810670001, "supply_on_course": 44274.0, "supply_precedent": 87637.2, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 13052.02480714768, "blocked_total": 13052.02480714768, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "cogfirst", "scenario": "S1", "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 76821.04985452816, "supply_on_course": 44274.0, "supply_precedent": 87637.2, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994, "blocked_total": 34757.308999999994, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "humanscog", "scenario": "S2", "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 73044.11190843255, "supply_on_course": 44274.0, "supply_precedent": 87637.2, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 13052.02480714768, "blocked_total": 13052.02480714768, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "trendprod", "scenario": "S3", "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 74697.94664442586, "supply_on_course": 44274.0, "supply_precedent": 87637.2, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 13312.7717171715, "blocked_total": 13312.7717171715, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "variant": "v3alt", "scenario": "S4", "way_of_producing": "IEA STEPS 2035 footprint (v3 second ratio) + machine-labour electricity (v3 split)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_alt_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 69351.1560593, "supply_on_course": 44274.0, "supply_precedent": 87637.2, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 254.2228150095216, "blocked_total": 254.2228150095216, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 74059.01810670001, "supply_on_course": 42553.3, "supply_precedent": 73055.4, "blocked_tier2": 2084.4004939814517, "blocked_tier1": 30362.798827555125, "blocked_total": 32447.199321536576, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "cogfirst", "scenario": "S1", "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 76821.04985452816, "supply_on_course": 42553.3, "supply_precedent": 73055.4, "blocked_tier2": 7821.932416311601, "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994, "blocked_total": 42579.2414163116, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "humanscog", "scenario": "S2", "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 73044.11190843255, "supply_on_course": 42553.3, "supply_precedent": 73055.4, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 30362.798827555125, "blocked_total": 30362.798827555125, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "trendprod", "scenario": "S3", "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 74697.94664442586, "supply_on_course": 42553.3, "supply_precedent": 73055.4, "blocked_tier2": 3408.3630205329064, "blocked_tier1": 30362.798827555125, "blocked_total": 33771.16184808803, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "variant": "v3alt", "scenario": "S4", "way_of_producing": "IEA STEPS 2035 footprint (v3 second ratio) + machine-labour electricity (v3 split)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_alt_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 69351.1560593, "supply_on_course": 42553.3, "supply_precedent": 73055.4, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 5535.2869548039225, "blocked_total": 5535.2869548039225, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K15", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: identity", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 51080.94924, "supply_on_course": 30435.4, "supply_precedent": 32810.9, "blocked_tier2": 18270.049238999996, "blocked_tier1": 1329.388998999997, "blocked_total": 19599.438237999995, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K15", "variant": "techshare_low", "scenario": "S6", "way_of_producing": "only 27% of health output growth beyond the current-rule path comes from new technology needing approval; the rest is more of approved care", "src": "searches_v4.csv W2 (Smith, Newhouse, Freeland 2009)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 51080.94924, "supply_on_course": 45506.6509452, "supply_precedent": 46148.0359452, "blocked_tier2": 4932.913293800001, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 4932.913293800001, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K15", "variant": "techshare_high", "scenario": "S6", "way_of_producing": "only 48% of health output growth beyond the current-rule path comes from new technology needing approval; the rest is more of approved care", "src": "searches_v4.csv W2 (Smith, Newhouse, Freeland 2009)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 51080.94924, "supply_on_course": 41171.0856048, "supply_precedent": 42311.325604800004, "blocked_tier2": 8769.623634199996, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 8769.623634199996, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K16", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14); stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py (LIC, LIC_REFORM)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 1739.3798280318192, "supply_on_course": 1425.5139081255777, "supply_precedent": 1582.4468680786986, "blocked_tier2": 13784.95003546745, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 13784.95003546745, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K16", "variant": "cogfirst", "scenario": "S1", "way_of_producing": "AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14); stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py (LIC, LIC_REFORM)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 1739.3798280318183, "supply_on_course": 1350.8309789424197, "supply_precedent": 1545.105403487119, "blocked_tier2": 25400.473427913825, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 25400.473427913825, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K16", "variant": "humanscog", "scenario": "S2", "way_of_producing": "humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14); stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py (LIC, LIC_REFORM)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 1739.3798280318192, "supply_on_course": 1452.9560864395512, "supply_precedent": 1596.1679572356852, "blocked_tier2": 12579.693155567813, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 12579.693155567813, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K16", "variant": "trendprod", "scenario": "S3", "way_of_producing": "v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14); stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py (LIC, LIC_REFORM)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 2145.7242235598133, "supply_on_course": 1756.3404945038483, "supply_precedent": 1951.0323590318308, "blocked_tier2": 16524.0966133932, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 16524.0966133932, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K16", "variant": "humanslicensed", "scenario": "S6", "way_of_producing": "humans take the licensed tasks first, machines the rest: licensing binds only if licensed work exceeds all human work", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14); stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py (LIC)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 1168.0410513836273, "supply_on_course": 4023.24, "supply_precedent": 4316.6, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K17", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (fastest sourced productivity)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 571.0133258405, "supply_on_course": 380.178, "supply_precedent": 495.099, "blocked_tier2": 15431.881468431786, "blocked_tier1": 612.4853744149369, "blocked_total": 16044.366842846723, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K17", "variant": "v3alt", "scenario": "S4", "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: construction output per worker on its 2014-24 trend (Agent 4 rerun)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 602.7336260575, "supply_on_course": 380.178, "supply_precedent": 495.099, "blocked_tier2": 20728.504478851126, "blocked_tier1": 4679.671016129003, "blocked_total": 25408.17549498013, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K17", "variant": "today", "scenario": "S5", "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.08 the v3 ratio", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K17 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 618.9580000795042, "supply_on_course": 380.178, "supply_precedent": 495.099, "blocked_tier2": 23227.783745613626, "blocked_tier1": 6598.824546467401, "blocked_total": 29826.608292081026, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (fastest sourced productivity)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 4316.60000011, "supply_on_course": 4023.24, "supply_precedent": 4316.6, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "today", "scenario": "S5", "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.69 the v3 ratio", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K18 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 7288.5200006049845, "supply_on_course": 4023.24, "supply_precedent": 4316.6, "blocked_tier2": 146058.31453200002, "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994, "blocked_total": 180815.623532, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "variant": "trendprod", "scenario": "S3", "way_of_producing": "humans' share of work with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of the fastest 9-year growth", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 4613.755033373291, "supply_on_course": 4023.24, "supply_precedent": 4316.6, "blocked_tier2": 10035.381211171332, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 10035.381211171332, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 209.321297831, "supply_on_course": 137.0, "supply_precedent": 330.479693, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 7539.027006070798, "blocked_total": 7539.027006070798, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "v3alt", "scenario": "S4", "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 aluminium per unit of GDP (WEO 2025 A.5b)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 208.07944257600002, "supply_on_course": 137.0, "supply_precedent": 330.479693, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 6402.647931436973, "blocked_total": 6402.647931436973, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "variant": "today", "scenario": "S5", "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.12 the v3 ratio", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK17); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 234.05401644812613, "supply_on_course": 137.0, "supply_precedent": 330.479693, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994, "blocked_total": 34757.308999999994, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: today's ratio held (only today's is sourced)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 2140.0557346999994, "supply_on_course": 1502.073347, "supply_precedent": 1748.363583, "blocked_tier2": 43745.811249530394, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 43745.811249530394, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "v3alt", "scenario": "S4", "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: lowest world capital-output ratio 1990-2023 (PWT, 2005): best demonstrated, the low case", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 1538.7544367500002, "supply_on_course": 1502.073347, "supply_precedent": 1748.363583, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "variant": "kytrend", "scenario": "S5", "way_of_producing": "capital-output ratio on its 2013-23 trend: x1.096 today's (PWT capital growth 3.82% vs UN AMA GDP growth 3.03%)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/work/landcap.csv (GK_1323, PWT 11.0); stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world GDP 2013, 2023)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 2345.732240507213, "supply_on_course": 1502.073347, "supply_precedent": 1748.363583, "blocked_tier2": 68116.866717389, "blocked_tier1": 12423.534888513735, "blocked_total": 80540.40160590273, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (fastest sourced yield growth)", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)", "label": "A", "need_2035": 2280.784052995, "supply_on_course": 1628.046431, "supply_precedent": 1688.875222, "blocked_tier2": 19804.653712, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 19804.653712, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "v3alt", "scenario": "S4", "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: crop output per ha on its 2014-24 trend", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 2610.7327013210006, "supply_on_course": 1628.046431, "supply_precedent": 1688.875222, "blocked_tier2": 103751.54918366457, "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994, "blocked_total": 138508.85818366456, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "yieldgap_low", "scenario": "S6", "way_of_producing": "yield gaps closed to attainable yields: crop output per ha +45% on 2026 (x0.885 the v3 ratio)", "src": "searches_v4.csv W1 (Mueller et al. 2012); stage1-v3/requirements/work/landcap.csv (GY_MAX9)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 2019.001409127152, "supply_on_course": 1628.046431, "supply_precedent": 1688.875222, "blocked_tier2": 5901.607524, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 5901.607524, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "variant": "yieldgap_high", "scenario": "S6", "way_of_producing": "yield gaps closed to attainable yields: crop output per ha +70% on 2026 (x0.755 the v3 ratio)", "src": "searches_v4.csv W1 (Mueller et al. 2012); stage1-v3/requirements/work/landcap.csv (GY_MAX9)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 1722.0894371966892, "supply_on_course": 1628.046431, "supply_precedent": 1688.875222, "blocked_tier2": 806.164520494398, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 806.164520494398, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "BUY-C13", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "demand at the 2035 price from the sourced income response (UN AMA world 2014-2024)", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, Construction (ISIC F) vs GDP, 2014-2024)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 105727.507, "supply_on_course": 97239.2654842971, "supply_precedent": 97239.2654842971, "blocked_tier2": 8488.241514702904, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 8488.241514702904, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "BUY-C13", "variant": "eta_2004-2014", "scenario": "S4", "way_of_producing": "demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.96)", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, Construction (ISIC F) vs GDP, 2004-2014)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 105727.507, "supply_on_course": 105794.28607645418, "supply_precedent": 105794.28607645418, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "binds": false }, { "shortage_id": "BUY-C13", "variant": "eta_1994-2004", "scenario": "S5", "way_of_producing": "demand from the UN AMA world income response 1994-2004 (elasticity 0.49)", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, Construction (ISIC F) vs GDP, 1994-2004)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 105727.507, "supply_on_course": 75983.33161790611, "supply_precedent": 75983.33161790611, "blocked_tier2": 29744.175381093894, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 29744.175381093894, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "BUY-C12", "variant": "base", "scenario": "S0", "way_of_producing": "demand at the 2035 price from the sourced income response (UN AMA world 2014-2024)", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, General government final consumption expenditure vs GDP, 2014-2024)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 34091.12052, "supply_on_course": 33265.52655037182, "supply_precedent": 33265.52655037182, "blocked_tier2": 825.5939686281745, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 825.5939686281745, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "BUY-C12", "variant": "eta_2004-2014", "scenario": "S4", "way_of_producing": "demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.91)", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, General government final consumption expenditure vs GDP, 2004-2014)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 34091.12052, "supply_on_course": 32788.25719657195, "supply_precedent": 32788.25719657195, "blocked_tier2": 1302.8633224280456, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 1302.8633224280456, "binds": true }, { "shortage_id": "BUY-C12", "variant": "eta_1994-2004", "scenario": "S5", "way_of_producing": "demand from the UN AMA world income response 1994-2004 (elasticity 0.76)", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, General government final consumption expenditure vs GDP, 1994-2004)", "label": "E", "need_2035": 34091.12052, "supply_on_course": 29670.35531792379, "supply_precedent": 29670.35531792379, "blocked_tier2": 4420.765201076206, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_total": 4420.765201076206, "binds": true } ], "ranking": [ { "shortage_id": "K04", "shortage": "Physical machine labour (robots)", "category": "machines", "unit": "million worker-equivalents in 2035", "need_2035": 1202.3194090922568, "supply_on_course": 32.7731, "supply_precedent": 42.8569, "share_met_on_course": 0.027258230842953347, "share_met_precedent": 0.03564518685792212, "short_at_precedent": 1159.4625090922568, "short_on_course": 1169.5463090922567, "blocked_tier2": 60005.09023066053, "blocked_tier1": 1646.5028954966801, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 21153.975000000002, "blocked_total": 61651.59312615721, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 1137.0283592863655, "blocked_high": 102480.36777547782, "n_alternatives": 3.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": null, "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "Time-and-motion worker-equivalents of deployed humanoids; Counterpoint/IDC 2027 shipments to confirm the ramp", "growth_needed_pa": 0.5974132099514471, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.10288056130378731, "times_faster": 5.806861883144243, "fastest_precedent": "China electric-car sales 2014-2023 x111 in 9 years (IEA via OWID) applied to humanoid shipments from 50k in 2026 (Counterpoint); industrial robots on the IFR 2026-29 forecast trend", "main_layer": "C11", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "A", "group_solid": "SOLID", "rank_all": 1.0, "rank_S0": 1.0, "blocked_S0": 61651.59312615721, "rank_S1": 14.0, "blocked_S1": 1137.0283592863655, "rank_S2": 1.0, "blocked_S2": 62252.935474205304, "rank_S3": 1.0, "blocked_S3": 102480.36777547782, "rank_S4": 2.0, "blocked_S4": 61651.59312615721, "rank_S5": 4.0, "blocked_S5": 61651.59312615721, "rank_S6": 1.0, "blocked_S6": 61651.59312615721, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 1.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 1.0, "pick": true }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "shortage": "Capital stock", "category": "capital", "unit": "tn 2026 int$ (PPP) of capital stock in 2035", "need_2035": 2140.0557346999994, "supply_on_course": 1502.073347, "supply_precedent": 1748.363583, "share_met_on_course": 0.7018851531035316, "share_met_precedent": 0.8169710511044666, "short_at_precedent": 391.6921516999994, "short_on_course": 637.9823876999994, "blocked_tier2": 43745.811249530394, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 14782.252, "blocked_total": 43745.811249530394, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 80540.40160590273, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO", "depends_on": "v3 second ratio: lowest world capital-output ratio 1990-2023 (PWT, 2005): best demonstrated, the low case", "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "PWT 11.0 capital-output ratios by country 1990-2023 for economies growing 5%+ a year (does K/Y fall during fast growth?)", "growth_needed_pa": 0.07981389098142166, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.05583023731461245, "times_faster": 1.429581796897216, "fastest_precedent": "world real capital stock at its fastest 9-year growth (1964-1973, PWT 11.0); on course = 2013-23 trend", "main_layer": "C03", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "A", "group_solid": "SCENARIO", "rank_all": 2.0, "rank_S0": 2.0, "blocked_S0": 43745.811249530394, "rank_S1": 1.0, "blocked_S1": 43745.811249530394, "rank_S2": 2.0, "blocked_S2": 43745.811249530394, "rank_S3": 2.0, "blocked_S3": 43745.811249530394, "rank_S4": 15.0, "blocked_S4": 0.0, "rank_S5": 2.0, "blocked_S5": 80540.40160590273, "rank_S6": 2.0, "blocked_S6": 43745.811249530394, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 2.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 1.0, "pick": true }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "shortage": "Transformers and grid equipment", "category": "machines", "unit": "TWh per year of generation the delivered transformers can connect", "need_2035": 74059.01810670001, "supply_on_course": 42553.3, "supply_precedent": 73055.4, "share_met_on_course": 0.574586337867613, "share_met_precedent": 0.986448401121737, "short_at_precedent": 1003.6181067000143, "short_on_course": 31505.718106700006, "blocked_tier2": 2084.4004939814517, "blocked_tier1": 30362.798827555125, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 32447.199321536576, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 5535.2869548039225, "blocked_high": 42579.2414163116, "n_alternatives": 4.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": null, "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "World transformer manufacturing capacity by region (Wood Mackenzie / IEA grid supply-chain report) and order books to 2030", "growth_needed_pa": 0.09470307265246425, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.09304472855017654, "times_faster": 1.0178230849627705, "fastest_precedent": "US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv magazine) used as the supply ramp from the STEPS addition rate", "main_layer": "C13", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "A", "group_solid": "SOLID", "rank_all": 3.0, "rank_S0": 3.0, "blocked_S0": 32447.199321536576, "rank_S1": 2.0, "blocked_S1": 42579.2414163116, "rank_S2": 3.0, "blocked_S2": 30362.798827555125, "rank_S3": 3.0, "blocked_S3": 33771.16184808803, "rank_S4": 9.0, "blocked_S4": 5535.2869548039225, "rank_S5": 6.0, "blocked_S5": 32447.199321536576, "rank_S6": 3.0, "blocked_S6": 32447.199321536576, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 3.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 2.0, "pick": true }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "shortage": "Cropland", "category": "land", "unit": "million ha of cropland in 2035", "need_2035": 2280.784052995, "supply_on_course": 1628.046431, "supply_precedent": 1688.875222, "share_met_on_course": 0.7138099851505623, "share_met_precedent": 0.7404801080498007, "short_at_precedent": 591.908830995, "short_on_course": 652.7376219949999, "blocked_tier2": 19804.653712, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 6937.790466578571, "blocked_total": 19804.653712, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 806.164520494398, "blocked_high": 138508.85818366456, "n_alternatives": 3.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": null, "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "FAOSTAT crop output per ha and cropland by country 2000-2024, and the EXIOBASE crop footprint per $ of non-food output 1995-2022 (does it fall with income?)", "growth_needed_pa": 0.04054069708755037, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.006376667523958046, "times_faster": 6.357662044513566, "fastest_precedent": "world cropland at its fastest 9-year expansion (1976-1985, FAOSTAT); on course = 2014-24 trend", "main_layer": "C01", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "A", "group_solid": "SOLID", "rank_all": 4.0, "rank_S0": 4.0, "blocked_S0": 19804.653712, "rank_S1": 8.0, "blocked_S1": 19804.653712, "rank_S2": 4.0, "blocked_S2": 19804.653712, "rank_S3": 4.0, "blocked_S3": 19804.653712, "rank_S4": 1.0, "blocked_S4": 138508.85818366456, "rank_S5": 9.0, "blocked_S5": 19804.653712, "rank_S6": 10.0, "blocked_S6": 5901.607524, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 4.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 3.0, "pick": true }, { "shortage_id": "K15", "shortage": "Clinical approval", "category": "permission", "unit": "bn 2026 int$ of health output (C05) that must be allowed in 2035", "need_2035": 51080.94924, "supply_on_course": 30435.4, "supply_precedent": 32810.9, "share_met_on_course": 0.5958268288437938, "share_met_precedent": 0.6423314462274469, "short_at_precedent": 18270.04924, "short_on_course": 20645.54924, "blocked_tier2": 18270.049238999996, "blocked_tier1": 1329.388998999997, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 19599.438237999995, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 4932.913293800001, "blocked_high": 19599.438237999995, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": null, "label": "E", "status": "TESTED", "test": null, "growth_needed_pa": 0.09023500788567618, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.03791080379570344, "times_faster": 2.380192421451713, "fastest_precedent": "Further health output is workforce (2010-19) and productivity (2015-24) precedents achieved under current approval rules (BL C05-F1, C05-F2); new products not needed", "main_layer": "C05", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "S/E", "group_solid": "SOLID", "rank_all": 5.0, "rank_S0": 5.0, "blocked_S0": 19599.438237999995, "rank_S1": 9.0, "blocked_S1": 19599.438237999995, "rank_S2": 5.0, "blocked_S2": 19599.438237999995, "rank_S3": 5.0, "blocked_S3": 19599.438237999995, "rank_S4": 4.0, "blocked_S4": 19599.438237999995, "rank_S5": 10.0, "blocked_S5": 19599.438237999995, "rank_S6": 11.0, "blocked_S6": 4932.913293800001, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 1.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 4.0, "pick": true }, { "shortage_id": "K17", "shortage": "Construction trades", "category": "workers by skill", "unit": "million construction workers (ISIC F) in 2035", "need_2035": 571.0133258405, "supply_on_course": 380.178, "supply_precedent": 495.099, "share_met_on_course": 0.6657953199960772, "share_met_precedent": 0.8670533201151509, "short_at_precedent": 75.9143258405, "short_on_course": 190.8353258405, "blocked_tier2": 15431.881468431786, "blocked_tier1": 612.4853744149369, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 16044.366842846723, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 16044.366842846723, "blocked_high": 29826.608292081026, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": null, "label": "E", "status": "TESTED", "test": null, "growth_needed_pa": 0.07042742817776748, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.05359434114124362, "times_faster": 1.3140832908489648, "fastest_precedent": "World construction employment at its fastest 9-year growth (ILO, 2002-2011, 5.36%/yr) from 2026", "main_layer": "C13", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "S/E", "group_solid": "SOLID", "rank_all": 6.0, "rank_S0": 6.0, "blocked_S0": 16044.366842846723, "rank_S1": 10.0, "blocked_S1": 16044.366842846723, "rank_S2": 6.0, "blocked_S2": 16044.366842846723, "rank_S3": 7.0, "blocked_S3": 16044.366842846723, "rank_S4": 3.0, "blocked_S4": 25408.17549498013, "rank_S5": 7.0, "blocked_S5": 29826.608292081026, "rank_S6": 4.0, "blocked_S6": 16044.366842846723, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 2.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 5.0, "pick": true }, { "shortage_id": "K16", "shortage": "Professional licensing", "category": "permission", "unit": "million machine worker-equivalents in 2035", "need_2035": 1739.3798280318192, "supply_on_course": 1425.5139081255777, "supply_precedent": 1582.4468680786986, "share_met_on_course": 0.819552972359468, "share_met_precedent": 0.9097764861797341, "short_at_precedent": 156.93295995312064, "short_on_course": 313.8659199062415, "blocked_tier2": 13784.95003546745, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 13784.95003546745, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 25400.473427913825, "n_alternatives": 4.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO", "depends_on": "humans take the licensed tasks first, machines the rest: licensing binds only if licensed work exceeds all human work", "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "OECD/EU cross-country licensing incidence; legal mapping of which tasks require a licensed person", "growth_needed_pa": 0.3213308836107842, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.30752130988797166, "times_faster": 1.0449060708275577, "fastest_precedent": "machine work allowed outside licensed tasks now; fastest reform precedent halves the licensed share (A4:A11)", "main_layer": "C05", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "A", "group_solid": "SCENARIO", "rank_all": 7.0, "rank_S0": 7.0, "blocked_S0": 13784.95003546745, "rank_S1": 7.0, "blocked_S1": 25400.473427913825, "rank_S2": 10.0, "blocked_S2": 12579.693155567813, "rank_S3": 6.0, "blocked_S3": 16524.0966133932, "rank_S4": 5.0, "blocked_S4": 13784.95003546745, "rank_S5": 12.0, "blocked_S5": 13784.95003546745, "rank_S6": 15.0, "blocked_S6": 0.0, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 5.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 2.0, "pick": false }, { "shortage_id": "K11", "shortage": "Saving for investment", "category": "capital", "unit": "bn US$ (market) of gross saving per year", "need_2035": 58368.093940000006, "supply_on_course": 37826.3, "supply_precedent": 87530.7, "share_met_on_course": 0.6480646779194791, "share_met_precedent": 1.499632660439074, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 20541.793940000003, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 13315.424574700748, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 13315.424574700748, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 13315.424574700748, "blocked_high": 13315.424574700748, "n_alternatives": 0.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": "accounting identity (saving = investment in C13-C15 at market prices): binds under every way of producing; rests on the on-course saving rate (2015-24 mean, A)", "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "IMF WEO saving and investment projections to 2031 (world saving rate path) to replace the held 2015-24 mean", "growth_needed_pa": 0.07580152934450268, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.12534590268703316, "times_faster": 0.6047387885806357, "fastest_precedent": "China gross saving 51.3% of GDP (2008, World Bank) applied to world output at max; on course = world 2015-24 mean saving rate", "main_layer": "C13", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "A", "group_solid": "SOLID", "rank_all": 8.0, "rank_S0": 8.0, "blocked_S0": 13315.424574700748, "rank_S1": 11.0, "blocked_S1": 13315.424574700748, "rank_S2": 7.0, "blocked_S2": 13315.424574700748, "rank_S3": 8.0, "blocked_S3": 13315.424574700748, "rank_S4": 6.0, "blocked_S4": 13315.424574700748, "rank_S5": 13.0, "blocked_S5": 13315.424574700748, "rank_S6": 5.0, "blocked_S6": 13315.424574700748, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 6.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 6.0, "pick": false }, { "shortage_id": "K13", "shortage": "Grid connection approval", "category": "permission", "unit": "TWh per year of generation connected", "need_2035": 74059.01810670001, "supply_on_course": 44274.0, "supply_precedent": 87637.2, "share_met_on_course": 0.5978205103423401, "share_met_precedent": 1.1833427209868934, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 29785.01810670001, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 13052.02480714768, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 13052.02480714768, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 254.2228150095216, "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994, "n_alternatives": 4.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": null, "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "ENTSO-E and LBNL completion rates by request year; IEA count of 2 800 GW waiting by region and age", "growth_needed_pa": 0.09470307265246425, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.11537198187260045, "times_faster": 0.8208498381958989, "fastest_precedent": "US 2008 queue speed (22 months request-to-operation, LBNL) in queue-bound grids (US+EU share of 2025 generation); STEPS path assumed connected", "main_layer": "C06", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "A", "group_solid": "SOLID", "rank_all": 9.0, "rank_S0": 9.0, "blocked_S0": 13052.02480714768, "rank_S1": 3.0, "blocked_S1": 34757.308999999994, "rank_S2": 8.0, "blocked_S2": 13052.02480714768, "rank_S3": 9.0, "blocked_S3": 13312.7717171715, "rank_S4": 12.0, "blocked_S4": 254.2228150095216, "rank_S5": 14.0, "blocked_S5": 13052.02480714768, "rank_S6": 6.0, "blocked_S6": 13052.02480714768, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 7.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 7.0, "pick": false }, { "shortage_id": "K01", "shortage": "Electricity", "category": "energy", "unit": "TWh per year (gross generation)", "need_2035": 74059.01810670001, "supply_on_course": 44274.0, "supply_precedent": 93251.9, "share_met_on_course": 0.5978205103423401, "share_met_precedent": 1.2591565805753457, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 29785.01810670001, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 13052.02480714768, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 13052.02480714768, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 254.2228150095216, "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994, "n_alternatives": 4.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": null, "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "IEA WEO-2026 Annex A (STEPS generation 2035) and Ember monthly 2026 generation; IEA World Energy Balances by final-demand sector to replace the EXIOBASE monetary electricity multiplier", "growth_needed_pa": 0.09470307265246425, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.12309451993046494, "times_faster": 0.7693524675668845, "fastest_precedent": "China 2002-2011: generation x2.84 in 9 years (Ember), applied to world 2026 supply; world fastest 9 years (OWID, 2001-10) x1.37 is the low case", "main_layer": "C06", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "A", "group_solid": "SOLID", "rank_all": 10.0, "rank_S0": 9.0, "blocked_S0": 13052.02480714768, "rank_S1": 3.0, "blocked_S1": 34757.308999999994, "rank_S2": 8.0, "blocked_S2": 13052.02480714768, "rank_S3": 9.0, "blocked_S3": 13312.7717171715, "rank_S4": 12.0, "blocked_S4": 254.2228150095216, "rank_S5": 14.0, "blocked_S5": 13052.02480714768, "rank_S6": 6.0, "blocked_S6": 13052.02480714768, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 8.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 8.0, "pick": false }, { "shortage_id": "BUY-C13", "shortage": "Buyers for built structures", "category": "buyers", "unit": "bn 2026 int$ of output bought", "need_2035": 105727.507, "supply_on_course": 97239.2654842971, "supply_precedent": 97239.2654842971, "share_met_on_course": 0.9197158643331778, "share_met_precedent": 0.9197158643331778, "short_at_precedent": 8488.241515702903, "short_on_course": 8488.241515702903, "blocked_tier2": 8488.241514702904, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 8488.241514702904, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 29744.175381093894, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO", "depends_on": "demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.96)", "label": "E", "status": "TESTED", "test": null, "growth_needed_pa": null, "growth_precedent_pa": null, "times_faster": null, "fastest_precedent": null, "main_layer": "C13", "src": "demand_v4.csv", "group_label": "S/E", "group_solid": "SCENARIO", "rank_all": 11.0, "rank_S0": 11.0, "blocked_S0": 8488.241514702904, "rank_S1": 12.0, "blocked_S1": 8488.241514702904, "rank_S2": 11.0, "blocked_S2": 8488.241514702904, "rank_S3": 12.0, "blocked_S3": 8488.241514702904, "rank_S4": 15.0, "blocked_S4": 0.0, "rank_S5": 8.0, "blocked_S5": 29744.175381093894, "rank_S6": 8.0, "blocked_S6": 8488.241514702904, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 3.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 3.0, "pick": false }, { "shortage_id": "K20", "shortage": "Aluminium", "category": "materials", "unit": "Mt aluminium per year", "need_2035": 209.321297831, "supply_on_course": 137.0, "supply_precedent": 330.479693, "share_met_on_course": 0.6544962286188855, "share_met_precedent": 1.5788154211943584, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 72.32129783100001, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 7539.027006070798, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 7539.027006070798, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 6402.647931436973, "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SOLID", "depends_on": null, "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "IEA STEPS/NZE 2035 aluminium demand by end use (WEO Annex) against the EXIOBASE footprint, and 2026 smelter capacity by region", "growth_needed_pa": 0.06674002551464775, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.12226497322702223, "times_faster": 0.5458638214456116, "fastest_precedent": "world bauxite mine output 1950-1959 x2.82 in 9 years (USGS via OWID), post-1950 maximum; post-1985 maximum 2004-2013 x1.80 is the low case", "main_layer": "C14", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "A", "group_solid": "SOLID", "rank_all": 12.0, "rank_S0": 12.0, "blocked_S0": 7539.027006070798, "rank_S1": 13.0, "blocked_S1": 7539.027006070798, "rank_S2": 12.0, "blocked_S2": 7539.027006070798, "rank_S3": 13.0, "blocked_S3": 7539.027006070798, "rank_S4": 8.0, "blocked_S4": 6402.647931436973, "rank_S5": 5.0, "blocked_S5": 34757.308999999994, "rank_S6": 9.0, "blocked_S6": 7539.027006070798, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 9.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 9.0, "pick": false }, { "shortage_id": "K12", "shortage": "Building permission", "category": "permission", "unit": "bn 2026 int$ of construction (C13) that must be permitted in 2035", "need_2035": 105727.507, "supply_on_course": 94403.39409, "supply_precedent": 104600.4637, "share_met_on_course": 0.892893408429653, "share_met_precedent": 0.9893401127863537, "short_at_precedent": 1127.0433000000048, "short_on_course": 11324.112909999996, "blocked_tier2": 1127.0432990000047, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 1127.0432990000047, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 1127.0432990000047, "blocked_high": 1127.0432990000047, "n_alternatives": 0.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO", "depends_on": "fewer than two sourced alternative ways found; rests on the base ratio", "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "Open the Auckland upzoning working paper (Greenaway-McGrevy and Phillips) and OECD housing-supply elasticities by metro weighted by ICP construction spend", "growth_needed_pa": 0.07700459273700444, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.07572286962059604, "times_faster": 1.0169264995216158, "fastest_precedent": "Auckland 2016 upzoning (+50% consents within 5 years, A4:A05) in the 30% of construction under discretionary permission (A4:A04); outside it current rules permit any amount (Agent 4 capped that part at capacity)", "main_layer": "C13", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "A", "group_solid": "SCENARIO", "rank_all": 13.0, "rank_S0": 13.0, "blocked_S0": 1127.0432990000047, "rank_S1": 15.0, "blocked_S1": 1127.0432990000047, "rank_S2": 13.0, "blocked_S2": 1127.0432990000047, "rank_S3": 14.0, "blocked_S3": 1127.0432990000047, "rank_S4": 11.0, "blocked_S4": 1127.0432990000047, "rank_S5": 17.0, "blocked_S5": 1127.0432990000047, "rank_S6": 12.0, "blocked_S6": 1127.0432990000047, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 10.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 4.0, "pick": false }, { "shortage_id": "BUY-C12", "shortage": "Buyers for public services", "category": "buyers", "unit": "bn 2026 int$ of output bought", "need_2035": 34091.12052, "supply_on_course": 33265.52655037182, "supply_precedent": 33265.52655037182, "share_met_on_course": 0.975782727084496, "share_met_precedent": 0.975782727084496, "short_at_precedent": 825.5939696281785, "short_on_course": 825.5939696281785, "blocked_tier2": 825.5939686281745, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 825.5939686281745, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 825.5939686281745, "blocked_high": 4420.765201076206, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)", "depends_on": "binds only under: demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.91); demand from the UN AMA world income response 1994-2004 (elasticity 0.76)", "label": "E", "status": "TESTED", "test": null, "growth_needed_pa": null, "growth_precedent_pa": null, "times_faster": null, "fastest_precedent": null, "main_layer": "C12", "src": "demand_v4.csv", "group_label": "S/E", "group_solid": "untested (<=1T)", "rank_all": 14.0, "rank_S0": 14.0, "blocked_S0": 825.5939686281745, "rank_S1": 16.0, "blocked_S1": 825.5939686281745, "rank_S2": 14.0, "blocked_S2": 825.5939686281745, "rank_S3": 15.0, "blocked_S3": 825.5939686281745, "rank_S4": 10.0, "blocked_S4": 1302.8633224280456, "rank_S5": 16.0, "blocked_S5": 4420.765201076206, "rank_S6": 13.0, "blocked_S6": 825.5939686281745, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 4.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 1.0, "pick": false }, { "shortage_id": "K06", "shortage": "Copper", "category": "materials", "unit": "million t refined copper per year", "need_2035": 51.03882403, "supply_on_course": 26.5106, "supply_precedent": 45.4269, "share_met_on_course": 0.5194202747386458, "share_met_precedent": 0.8900459770252274, "short_at_precedent": 5.611924029999997, "short_on_course": 24.52822403, "blocked_tier2": 165.7467183780582, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 165.7467183780582, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 144.03696137609495, "blocked_high": 282.6403011266366, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "not tested (blocks 1T or less)", "depends_on": null, "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "IEA Critical Minerals Data Explorer: copper STEPS 2035 demand, secondary supply and base/high-production mine supply in kt (replaces the 2030-40 interpolation and the held 18% secondary share)", "growth_needed_pa": 0.06917554845780782, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.055426946841626634, "times_faster": 1.2480490519433725, "fastest_precedent": "World copper mine output 1954-1963 x1.625 in 9 years (USGS via OWID), post-1950 maximum; post-1985 maximum (1995-2004) x1.47 is the low case", "main_layer": "C14", "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "A", "group_solid": "untested (<=1T)", "rank_all": 15.0, "rank_S0": 15.0, "blocked_S0": 165.7467183780582, "rank_S1": 17.0, "blocked_S1": 165.7467183780582, "rank_S2": 15.0, "blocked_S2": 165.7467183780582, "rank_S3": 16.0, "blocked_S3": 165.7467183780582, "rank_S4": 14.0, "blocked_S4": 144.03696137609495, "rank_S5": 18.0, "blocked_S5": 282.6403011266366, "rank_S6": 14.0, "blocked_S6": 165.7467183780582, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 11.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 2.0, "pick": false }, { "shortage_id": "K02", "shortage": "Fuels", "category": "energy", "unit": "EJ per year (final consumption excl. electricity)", "need_2035": 445.18773945600003, "supply_on_course": 374.0, "supply_precedent": 548.836, "share_met_on_course": 0.8400950135262297, "share_met_precedent": 1.2328192161595772, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 71.18773945600003, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 71782.99576593254, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)", "depends_on": "binds only under: v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun); 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.62 the v3 ratio", "label": "E", "status": "TESTED", "test": null, "growth_needed_pa": 0.023609314109906965, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.04769328840461373, "times_faster": 0.4950238261957013, "fastest_precedent": "World fossil-fuel consumption 1965-1974 x1.52 in 9 years (EI via OWID), the post-1965 maximum", "main_layer": null, "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "S/E", "group_solid": "untested (<=1T)", "rank_all": 16.0, "rank_S0": 16.0, "blocked_S0": 0.0, "rank_S1": 18.0, "blocked_S1": 0.0, "rank_S2": 16.0, "blocked_S2": 0.0, "rank_S3": 17.0, "blocked_S3": 0.0, "rank_S4": 7.0, "blocked_S4": 7216.84373457129, "rank_S5": 3.0, "blocked_S5": 71782.99576593254, "rank_S6": 15.0, "blocked_S6": 0.0, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 5.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 3.0, "pick": false }, { "shortage_id": "K09", "shortage": "Steel", "category": "materials", "unit": "Mt crude steel per year", "need_2035": 2901.93264675, "supply_on_course": 2570.4, "supply_precedent": 3135.54, "share_met_on_course": 0.8857545342682926, "share_met_precedent": 1.0805006117256466, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 331.5326467499999, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 18927.55399354189, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)", "depends_on": "binds only under: 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.29 the v3 ratio", "label": "E", "status": "TESTED", "test": null, "growth_needed_pa": 0.05022424450517593, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.05929800117314343, "times_faster": 0.8469803958235765, "fastest_precedent": "World crude steel 2002-2011 x1.68 in 9 years (worldsteel Steel Statistical Yearbook 2012)", "main_layer": null, "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "S/E", "group_solid": "untested (<=1T)", "rank_all": 17.0, "rank_S0": 16.0, "blocked_S0": 0.0, "rank_S1": 18.0, "blocked_S1": 0.0, "rank_S2": 16.0, "blocked_S2": 0.0, "rank_S3": 17.0, "blocked_S3": 0.0, "rank_S4": 15.0, "blocked_S4": 0.0, "rank_S5": 11.0, "blocked_S5": 18927.55399354189, "rank_S6": 15.0, "blocked_S6": 0.0, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 6.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 4.0, "pick": false }, { "shortage_id": "K18", "shortage": "Human workforce", "category": "workers by skill", "unit": "million workers in 2035", "need_2035": 4316.60000011, "supply_on_course": 4023.24, "supply_precedent": 4316.6, "share_met_on_course": 0.9320391048272889, "share_met_precedent": 0.999999999974517, "short_at_precedent": 1.0999974620062858e-07, "short_on_course": 293.3600001100003, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 180815.623532, "n_alternatives": 2.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)", "depends_on": "binds only under: 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.69 the v3 ratio; humans' share of work with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of the fastest 9-year growth", "label": "E", "status": "TESTED", "test": null, "growth_needed_pa": 0.018990822269040697, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.01899082226615545, "times_faster": 1.0000000001519285, "fastest_precedent": "WPP 15+ population 2035 x the highest world employment ratio 1991-2025 (BL T19)", "main_layer": null, "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "S/E", "group_solid": "untested (<=1T)", "rank_all": 18.0, "rank_S0": 16.0, "blocked_S0": 0.0, "rank_S1": 18.0, "blocked_S1": 0.0, "rank_S2": 16.0, "blocked_S2": 0.0, "rank_S3": 11.0, "blocked_S3": 10035.381211171332, "rank_S4": 15.0, "blocked_S4": 0.0, "rank_S5": 1.0, "blocked_S5": 180815.623532, "rank_S6": 15.0, "blocked_S6": 0.0, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 7.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 5.0, "pick": false }, { "shortage_id": "K05", "shortage": "AI compute", "category": "machines", "unit": "GW of AI chip TDP in service in 2035", "need_2035": 146.27352256634808, "supply_on_course": 84.504, "supply_precedent": 12455.7, "share_met_on_course": 0.5777122100937297, "share_met_precedent": 85.15348356603793, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 61.76952256634807, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994, "n_alternatives": 3.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)", "depends_on": "binds only under: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them", "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "Epoch chip-sales update for 2027-28; TSMC CoWoS and HBM capacity plans to 2030", "growth_needed_pa": 0.25536394631152937, "growth_precedent_pa": 1.0570108723255318, "times_faster": 0.2415906524686001, "fastest_precedent": "AI chip power sold x1.87 in 2025 (Epoch) held 2028-2035; bounded in practice by K01/K14 (power and grid)", "main_layer": null, "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "A", "group_solid": "untested (<=1T)", "rank_all": 19.0, "rank_S0": 16.0, "blocked_S0": 0.0, "rank_S1": 3.0, "blocked_S1": 34757.308999999994, "rank_S2": 16.0, "blocked_S2": 0.0, "rank_S3": 17.0, "blocked_S3": 0.0, "rank_S4": 15.0, "blocked_S4": 0.0, "rank_S5": 19.0, "blocked_S5": 0.0, "rank_S6": 15.0, "blocked_S6": 0.0, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 12.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 6.0, "pick": false }, { "shortage_id": "K03", "shortage": "Machine cognition (AI agents)", "category": "machines", "unit": "million worker-equivalents in 2035", "need_2035": 537.0604189395623, "supply_on_course": 310.266, "supply_precedent": 45732.6, "share_met_on_course": 0.5777115368371907, "share_met_precedent": 85.1535476963654, "short_at_precedent": 0.0, "short_on_course": 226.79441893956226, "blocked_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_tier1": 0.0, "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0, "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0, "blocked_total": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0, "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994, "n_alternatives": 3.0, "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)", "depends_on": "binds only under: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them", "label": "A", "status": "UNTESTED", "test": "Task-matched benchmark of agent-hours per human-hour on real jobs (GDPval/METR); Epoch agent-population update with 2028-30 shipments", "growth_needed_pa": 0.17696584267992832, "growth_precedent_pa": 0.9285496803155593, "times_faster": 0.19058306349293885, "fastest_precedent": "AI chip power sold grew x1.87 in 2025 (Epoch), held 2028-2035 on top of the through-2027 fleet", "main_layer": null, "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv", "group_label": "A", "group_solid": "untested (<=1T)", "rank_all": 20.0, "rank_S0": 16.0, "blocked_S0": 0.0, "rank_S1": 3.0, "blocked_S1": 34757.308999999994, "rank_S2": 16.0, "blocked_S2": 0.0, "rank_S3": 17.0, "blocked_S3": 0.0, "rank_S4": 15.0, "blocked_S4": 0.0, "rank_S5": 19.0, "blocked_S5": 0.0, "rank_S6": 15.0, "blocked_S6": 0.0, "rank_changes": true, "rank_in_label_group": 13.0, "rank_in_solid_group": 7.0, "pick": false } ], "picks": [ { "shortage_id": "K04", "shortage": "Physical machine labour (robots)", "category": "machines", "main_layer": "C11", "rule": "rule not met: only 2 shortages are both SOLID and [S]/[E] (K15, K17); all are picked", "blocked_total": 61651.59312615721, "blocked_low": 1137.0283592863655, "blocked_high": 102480.36777547782, "verdict": "SOLID", "label": "A", "solid_se": false, "rank_all": 1.0, "why": "blocks 61,652 bn on its own, 1,137-102,480 across the ways of producing; SOLID. Beat the next one down, K21 Capital stock (43,746 bn, SCENARIO), by 17,906 bn" }, { "shortage_id": "K21", "shortage": "Capital stock", "category": "capital", "main_layer": "C03", "rule": "rule not met: only 2 shortages are both SOLID and [S]/[E] (K15, K17); all are picked", "blocked_total": 43745.811249530394, "blocked_low": 0.0, "blocked_high": 80540.40160590273, "verdict": "SCENARIO", "label": "A", "solid_se": false, "rank_all": 2.0, "why": "blocks 43,746 bn on its own, 0-80,540 across the ways of producing; SCENARIO (depends on: v3 second ratio: lowest world capital-output ratio 1990-2023 (PWT, 2005): best demonstrated, the low case). Beat the next one down, K14 Transformers and grid equipment (32,447 bn, SOLID), by 11,299 bn" }, { "shortage_id": "K14", "shortage": "Transformers and grid equipment", "category": "machines", "main_layer": "C13", "rule": "rule not met: only 2 shortages are both SOLID and [S]/[E] (K15, K17); all are picked", "blocked_total": 32447.199321536576, "blocked_low": 5535.2869548039225, "blocked_high": 42579.2414163116, "verdict": "SOLID", "label": "A", "solid_se": false, "rank_all": 3.0, "why": "blocks 32,447 bn on its own, 5,535-42,579 across the ways of producing; SOLID. Beat the next one down, K22 Cropland (19,805 bn, SOLID), by 12,643 bn" }, { "shortage_id": "K22", "shortage": "Cropland", "category": "land", "main_layer": "C01", "rule": "rule not met: only 2 shortages are both SOLID and [S]/[E] (K15, K17); all are picked", "blocked_total": 19804.653712, "blocked_low": 806.164520494398, "blocked_high": 138508.85818366456, "verdict": "SOLID", "label": "A", "solid_se": false, "rank_all": 4.0, "why": "blocks 19,805 bn on its own, 806-138,509 across the ways of producing; SOLID. Beat the next one down, K15 Clinical approval (19,599 bn, SOLID), by 205 bn" }, { "shortage_id": "K15", "shortage": "Clinical approval", "category": "permission", "main_layer": "C05", "rule": "rule not met: only 2 shortages are both SOLID and [S]/[E] (K15, K17); all are picked", "blocked_total": 19599.438237999995, "blocked_low": 4932.913293800001, "blocked_high": 19599.438237999995, "verdict": "SOLID", "label": "E", "solid_se": true, "rank_all": 5.0, "why": "blocks 19,599 bn on its own, 4,933-19,599 across the ways of producing; SOLID. Beat the next one down, K17 Construction trades (16,044 bn, SOLID), by 3,555 bn" }, { "shortage_id": "K17", "shortage": "Construction trades", "category": "workers by skill", "main_layer": "C13", "rule": "rule not met: only 2 shortages are both SOLID and [S]/[E] (K15, K17); all are picked", "blocked_total": 16044.366842846723, "blocked_low": 16044.366842846723, "blocked_high": 29826.608292081026, "verdict": "SOLID", "label": "E", "solid_se": true, "rank_all": 6.0, "why": "blocks 16,044 bn on its own, 16,044-29,827 across the ways of producing; SOLID. Beat the next one down, K16 Professional licensing (13,785 bn, SCENARIO), by 2,259 bn; the first shortage left out is K16 Professional licensing (13,785 bn)" } ], "agents": [ { "key": "a1_in", "value": 97.0, "label": "E", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv (Agent 1 rows), counted", "what": "Agent 1 items already inside on course" }, { "key": "a1_all", "value": 143.0, "label": "E", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv + not_inside.csv (Agent 1 rows)", "what": "Agent 1 items checked against on course" }, { "key": "a2_energy", "value": 323426.5, "label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/totals.csv (T16)", "what": "Output the fastest sourced energy supply can power in 2035" }, { "key": "a3_needs", "value": 36.0, "label": "E", "src": "stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/needs.csv (rows)", "what": "Human needs mapped" }, { "key": "a3_health", "value": 4600.0, "label": "S", "src": "stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/needs.csv (N08)", "what": "People lacking adequate health care (millions)" }, { "key": "a4_bind", "value": 3.0, "label": "E", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (status = binding)", "what": "Inputs binding at their fastest precedent (repaired Agent 4)" }, { "key": "a4_total", "value": 18.0, "label": "E", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (rows)", "what": "Inputs Agent 4 tested" }, { "key": "a4_blk", "value": 19869.1, "label": "A", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K18 output_blocked_ppp_bn)", "what": "Output the human workforce blocks (repaired Agent 4)" }, { "key": "a5_in", "value": 3.0, "label": "E", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv (Agent 5 rows)", "what": "Agent 5 capabilities already inside on course" }, { "key": "a5_caps", "value": 9.0, "label": "E", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv + not_inside.csv (Agent 5 rows)", "what": "Agent 5 capabilities checked" }, { "key": "a6_reach3", "value": 0.0, "label": "E", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/inputs.csv (reach_3x = yes)", "what": "Inputs that reach 3x cheaper by 2035 (repaired Agent 6)" }, { "key": "a6_n", "value": 13.0, "label": "E", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/inputs.csv (rows)", "what": "Inputs Agent 6 priced" }, { "key": "a6_ach", "value": 828.83318, "label": "E", "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv (achievable TOTAL)", "what": "Output created at sourced input prices, net of on course" } ], "demand": [ { "layer_id": "C13", "layer": "Built structures", "today": 54228.765, "target": 105727.507, "extra_output": 43316.48898, "income_ratio": 2.000000000115044, "income_elasticity": 0.8424806807131314, "income_elasticity_label": "E", "income_elasticity_src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, Construction (ISIC F) vs GDP, 2014-2024)", "price_ratio_2035": 0.9937160058, "price_ratio_src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv (achievable case, price_fall_of_product)", "price_elasticity": 0.0, "price_elasticity_src": "no market price (budgets or investment set quantity): no price response", "demand_2035": 97239.2654842971, "demand_label": "E", "buyers_short": 8488.241515702903, "verdict": "not all bought: buyers short of 8,488 bn; buyers are the shortage", "income_elasticity_other_windows": "2004-2014: 0.964; 1994-2004: 0.487" }, { "layer_id": "C03", "layer": "Shelter and utilities", "today": 29600.326, "target": 59177.23267, "extra_output": 25096.56167, "income_ratio": 2.000000000115044, "income_elasticity": 1.0640232858463277, "income_elasticity_label": "E", "income_elasticity_src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (income elasticity from v1 bridge, eta)", "price_ratio_2035": 0.97579941, "price_ratio_src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv (achievable case, price_fall_of_product)", "price_elasticity": -0.667, "price_elasticity_src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (price elasticity, Agent 2)", "demand_2035": 62906.55926082677, "demand_label": "E", "buyers_short": 0.0, "verdict": "bought: demand at the 2035 price covers the target", "income_elasticity_other_windows": null }, { "layer_id": "C05", "layer": "Health care", "today": 23473.491, "target": 51080.94924, "extra_output": 21082.92824, "income_ratio": 2.000000000115044, "income_elasticity": 1.2797350706217443, "income_elasticity_label": "E", "income_elasticity_src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (income elasticity from v1 bridge, eta)", "price_ratio_2035": 0.9962068233, "price_ratio_src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv (achievable case, price_fall_of_product)", "price_elasticity": -0.2, "price_elasticity_src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (price elasticity, Agent 2)", "demand_2035": 57035.65370154309, "demand_label": "E", "buyers_short": 0.0, "verdict": "bought: demand at the 2035 price covers the target", "income_elasticity_other_windows": null }, { "layer_id": "C11", "layer": "Personal and financial services", "today": 15866.528, "target": 34976.03323, "extra_output": 15742.35523, "income_ratio": 2.000000000115044, "income_elasticity": 1.3124011916910145, "income_elasticity_label": "E", "income_elasticity_src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (income elasticity from v1 bridge, eta)", "price_ratio_2035": 0.997958372, "price_ratio_src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv (achievable case, price_fall_of_product)", "price_elasticity": -0.972, "price_elasticity_src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (price elasticity, Agent 2)", "demand_2035": 39483.60055359626, "demand_label": "E", "buyers_short": 0.0, "verdict": "bought: demand at the 2035 price covers the target", "income_elasticity_other_windows": null }, { "layer_id": "C12", "layer": "Public services", "today": 17485.699, "target": 34091.12052, "extra_output": 14169.83152, "income_ratio": 2.000000000115044, "income_elasticity": 0.9278524001448805, "income_elasticity_label": "E", "income_elasticity_src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, General government final consumption expenditure vs GDP, 2014-2024)", "price_ratio_2035": 0.9902674675, "price_ratio_src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv (achievable case, price_fall_of_product)", "price_elasticity": 0.0, "price_elasticity_src": "no market price (budgets or investment set quantity): no price response", "demand_2035": 33265.52655037182, "demand_label": "E", "buyers_short": 825.5939696281785, "verdict": "not all bought: buyers short of 826 bn; buyers are the shortage", "income_elasticity_other_windows": "2004-2014: 0.907; 1994-2004: 0.763" } ], "searches": [ { "id": "W1", "query": "Mueller 2012 Nature closing yield gaps nutrient water management production increase 45% 70% attainable yields", "source": "Mueller N.D. et al. (2012) Closing yield gaps through nutrient and water management, Nature 490:254-257, doi:10.1038/nature11420", "url": "https://ideas.repec.org/a/nat/nature/v490y2012i7419d10.1038_nature11420.html", "value_low": 0.45, "value_high": 0.7, "label": "S", "used_for": "K22 cropland, step 3: crop output per ha if yield gaps close to 100% of attainable yields (+45% to +70% for most crops)" }, { "id": "W2", "query": "Smith Newhouse Freeland 2009 Health Affairs technology share of health spending growth 27 to 48 percent", "source": "Smith S., Newhouse J.P., Freeland M.S. (2009) Income, insurance, and technology: why does health spending outpace economic growth? Health Affairs 28(5):1276-1284", "url": "https://www.hks.harvard.edu/publications/income-insurance-and-technology-why-does-health-spending-outpace-economic-growth", "value_low": 0.27, "value_high": 0.48, "label": "S", "used_for": "K15 clinical approval, step 3: share of health spending growth that comes from new medical technology (27% to 48%)" } ], "checks": [ { "check": "each layer: today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = its target", "ok": true, "detail": "19 layers" }, { "check": "layers sum to 448.5T (= 2 x today)", "ok": true, "detail": "448,523.8 bn = 2 x 224,261.9" }, { "check": "every missing dollar is in a named shortage or on the unexplained list", "ok": true, "detail": "missing 182,904.9 = explained 141,434.1 + unexplained 41,470.8; 35 rows" }, { "check": "unexplained output carries a size and no name", "ok": true, "detail": "10 rows, 41,470.8 bn" }, { "check": "no shortage blocks more output than exists in the layers it serves (every cell, every total, every variant)", "ok": true, "detail": "56 shortage-variants" }, { "check": "cropland: what it blocks in food at home stays inside food at home's missing output and target", "ok": true, "detail": "v4 cropland blocks 5,901.6 bn in C01 (missing 7,139.8, target 21,195.6); in all 19,804.7 bn across 7 layers whose crop footprint it serves (v3 put 6,066 bn of C01 and 45.4T counted once across all layers on it, by proportional shares)" }, { "check": "information: v3's proportional 'output depending' cells that exceed their layer's missing output (v4 fixes this)", "ok": true, "detail": "31 cells: K01 C01, K01 C02, K01 C04, K01 C09, K01 C14, K01 C15, K11 C15, K13 C01, K13 C02, K13 C04, K13 C09, K13 C14" }, { "check": "nothing counted twice: each row once, each shortage's total = its own cells, explained = union per row (not a sum of shortages)", "ok": true, "detail": "sum of shortages on their own 264,643.1 bn (overlapping, never added into a total); explained union 141,434.1 bn" }, { "check": "every shortage over 1T is tested: range, SOLID only if it binds in every way, SCENARIO names its assumption", "ok": true, "detail": "13 shortages over 1T" }, { "check": "every shortage labelled; each resting on an assumed size or rate is UNTESTED with its cheapest test", "ok": true, "detail": "16 UNTESTED" }, { "check": "six picks: at most two per layer; at least three SOLID [S]/[E] (or every such shortage when fewer exist)", "ok": true, "detail": "2 SOLID [S]/[E] of 2; rule not met: only 2 shortages are both SOLID and [S]/[E] (K15, K17); all are picked" }, { "check": "ranking counts each shortage on its own (no sharing rule) and shows the order under every scenario", "ok": true, "detail": "20 shortages, 20 change rank across scenarios" }, { "check": "every web search listed with its source", "ok": true, "detail": "2 searches" }, { "check": "stage1-v1, stage1-v2 and stage1-v3 untouched", "ok": true, "detail": "1846 files" } ], "scenarios": [ { "id": "S0", "scenario": "base" }, { "id": "S1", "scenario": "AI takes cognitive tasks first" }, { "id": "S2", "scenario": "humans keep cognitive tasks" }, { "id": "S3", "scenario": "labour productivity on trend" }, { "id": "S4", "scenario": "v3 second sourced ratios" }, { "id": "S5", "scenario": "2026 intensities / K-Y trend" }, { "id": "S6", "scenario": "land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation" } ] } } MODEL SOURCE check.py """Stage 1 v4 checks (step 6). A failure stops the run: exit code 1, and run_all.sh (set -e) builds no page. python check.py (run from stage1-v4/code after v4.py) Writes stage1-v4/checks_v4.csv. """ import hashlib import subprocess import sys import numpy as np import pandas as pd from common import ROOT, RQ, V4, num, rd L = pd.read_csv(V4 / "layers_v4.csv", index_col=0) SH = pd.read_csv(V4 / "shortages_v4.csv", index_col=0) OB = pd.read_csv(V4 / "own_blocks_v4.csv") ROWS = pd.read_csv(V4 / "rows_v4.csv") UNE = pd.read_csv(V4 / "unexplained_v4.csv") VR = pd.read_csv(V4 / "variants_v4.csv") RK = pd.read_csv(V4 / "ranking_v4.csv", index_col=0) PK = pd.read_csv(V4 / "picks_v4.csv") SR = pd.read_csv(V4 / "searches_v4.csv") REQ = rd(RQ / "requirements.csv") checks = [] def check(name, ok, detail): checks.append(dict(check=name, ok=bool(ok), detail=str(detail)[:600])) # 1. each layer: today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target bad = [j for j in L.index if abs(L.loc[j, "today"] + L.loc[j, "growth"] + L.loc[j, "tier1"] + L.loc[j, "tier2"] - L.loc[j, "target"]) > 0.5] check("each layer: today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = its target", not bad, bad or f"{len(L)} layers") # 2. layers sum to 448.5T (= 2 x today) tt = L.target.sum() check("layers sum to 448.5T (= 2 x today)", round(tt / 1000, 1) == 448.5 and abs(tt - 2 * L.today.sum()) < 1, f"{tt:,.1f} bn = 2 x {L.today.sum():,.1f}") # 3. every missing dollar is in a named shortage or on the unexplained list miss_layers = (L.tier1.clip(lower=0) + L.tier2.clip(lower=0)).sum() rows_ok = all(abs(r.explained_bn + r.unexplained_bn - r.missing_bn) < 0.5 for r in ROWS.itertuples()) expect = {(j, str(t)) for j in L.index for t in (1, 2) if L.loc[j, f"tier{t}"] > 1e-9} have = {(r.layer_id, str(r.tier)) for r in ROWS.itertuples()} une_match = abs(UNE.unexplained_bn.sum() - ROWS.unexplained_bn.sum()) < 0.5 named = all((r.explained_bn <= 1e-6) or (isinstance(r.binds_first, str) and r.binds_first) for r in ROWS.itertuples()) check("every missing dollar is in a named shortage or on the unexplained list", rows_ok and expect == have and une_match and named and abs(ROWS.missing_bn.sum() - miss_layers) < 0.5, f"missing {miss_layers:,.1f} = explained {ROWS.explained_bn.sum():,.1f} + unexplained {ROWS.unexplained_bn.sum():,.1f}; {len(ROWS)} rows") check("unexplained output carries a size and no name", "binds_first" not in UNE.columns and (UNE.unexplained_bn > 0).all(), f"{len(UNE)} rows, {UNE.unexplained_bn.sum():,.1f} bn") # 4. no shortage blocks more output than exists in the layers it serves (each cell, and in total), every variant served = {} for k in SH.index: if k.startswith("BUY-"): served[k] = {k[4:]} else: x = REQ[REQ.input_id == k] served[k] = {r.layer_id for r in x.itertuples() if num(r.required_base, 0) > 0} row_amt = {(r.layer_id, str(r.tier)): r.missing_bn for r in ROWS.itertuples()} over_cell, over_tot, outside = [], [], [] for (k, v), g in OB.groupby(["shortage_id", "variant"]): for r in g.itertuples(): if r.blocked_bn > row_amt.get((r.layer_id, str(r.tier)), 0) + 0.5: over_cell.append(f"{k}/{v} {r.layer_id} t{r.tier}") if r.layer_id not in served[k]: outside.append(f"{k}/{v} {r.layer_id}") cap = sum(L.loc[j, "tier1"] + L.loc[j, "tier2"] for j in served[k] if j in L.index) if g.blocked_bn.sum() > cap + 0.5: over_tot.append(f"{k}/{v} {g.blocked_bn.sum():,.0f} > {cap:,.0f}") check("no shortage blocks more output than exists in the layers it serves (every cell, every total, every variant)", not over_cell and not over_tot and not outside, (over_cell + over_tot + outside)[:10] or f"{OB.groupby(['shortage_id', 'variant']).ngroups} shortage-variants") k22 = OB[(OB.shortage_id == "K22") & (OB.variant == "base")] c01 = k22[k22.layer_id == "C01"].blocked_bn.sum() c01_miss = L.loc["C01", "tier1"] + L.loc["C01", "tier2"] il = rd(RQ / "input_layer_v3.csv") v3_c01 = num(il[(il.input_id == "K22") & (il.layer_id == "C01")].output_depending_ppp_bn.iloc[0]) check("cropland: what it blocks in food at home stays inside food at home's missing output and target", c01 <= c01_miss + 0.5 and c01_miss <= L.loc["C01", "target"], f"v4 cropland blocks {c01:,.1f} bn in C01 (missing {c01_miss:,.1f}, target {L.loc['C01', 'target']:,.1f}); " f"in all {k22.blocked_bn.sum():,.1f} bn across {k22.layer_id.nunique()} layers whose crop footprint it serves " f"(v3 put {v3_c01:,.0f} bn of C01 and 45.4T counted once across all layers on it, by proportional shares)") # the same cell test applied to v3's proportional numbers, for comparison (information: v3's files are not changed) lay3 = rd(RQ / "layers_v3.csv").set_index("layer_id") v3_over = [] for r in il.itertuples(): m3 = num(lay3.loc[r.layer_id, "tier1"]) + num(lay3.loc[r.layer_id, "tier2"]) if num(r.output_depending_ppp_bn, 0) > m3 + 0.5: v3_over.append(f"{r.input_id} {r.layer_id}") check("information: v3's proportional 'output depending' cells that exceed their layer's missing output (v4 fixes this)", True, f"{len(v3_over)} cells: " + ", ".join(v3_over[:12])) # 5. nothing counted twice in any total own_sum = OB[OB.variant == "base"].groupby("shortage_id").blocked_bn.sum() tot_ok = all(abs(own_sum.get(k, 0.0) - SH.loc[k, "blocked_total"]) < 0.5 for k in SH.index) union_ok = abs(ROWS.explained_bn.sum() + ROWS.unexplained_bn.sum() - miss_layers) < 0.5 and ROWS.explained_bn.sum() <= own_sum.sum() + 0.5 row_max = all(r.explained_bn <= r.missing_bn + 0.5 for r in ROWS.itertuples()) dup_rows = ROWS.duplicated(["layer_id", "tier"]).any() dup_cells = OB.duplicated(["shortage_id", "variant", "layer_id", "tier"]).any() check("nothing counted twice: each row once, each shortage's total = its own cells, explained = union per row (not a sum of shortages)", tot_ok and union_ok and row_max and not dup_rows and not dup_cells, f"sum of shortages on their own {own_sum.sum():,.1f} bn (overlapping, never added into a total); explained union {ROWS.explained_bn.sum():,.1f} bn") # 6. step 3: every shortage over 1T tested under at least two other ways, SOLID only if it binds in all bad3 = [] for k in SH.index: if SH.loc[k, "blocked_total"] <= 1000: continue v = VR[VR.shortage_id == k] if SH.loc[k, "verdict"] == "SOLID" and k != "K11" and (len(v) < 3 or not v.binds.all()): bad3.append(f"{k} SOLID but {len(v) - 1} alternatives / binds {v.binds.sum()} of {len(v)}") if SH.loc[k, "verdict"] not in ("SOLID", "SCENARIO"): bad3.append(f"{k} no verdict") if SH.loc[k, "verdict"] == "SCENARIO" and not str(SH.loc[k, "depends_on"]).strip(): bad3.append(f"{k} SCENARIO without its assumption") if not (SH.loc[k, "blocked_low"] <= SH.loc[k, "blocked_total"] + 0.5 <= SH.loc[k, "blocked_high"] + 1): bad3.append(f"{k} range") check("every shortage over 1T is tested: range, SOLID only if it binds in every way, SCENARIO names its assumption", not bad3, bad3 or f"{(SH.blocked_total > 1000).sum()} shortages over 1T") # 7. labels and UNTESTED rows lab_ok = SH.label.isin(["S", "E", "A"]).all() and ROWS.missing_label.isin(["S", "E", "A"]).all() unt = SH[(SH.label == "A") & ((SH.status != "UNTESTED") | (SH.test.fillna("").str.len() < 10))] check("every shortage labelled; each resting on an assumed size or rate is UNTESTED with its cheapest test", lab_ok and unt.empty, list(unt.index) or f"{(SH.status == 'UNTESTED').sum()} UNTESTED") # 8. ranking and picks follow the rules pk_layers = PK.main_layer.value_counts() se_solid = PK.solid_se.sum() n_se_all = ((RK.verdict == "SOLID") & RK.label.isin(["S", "E"]) & (RK.blocked_total > 0)).sum() check("six picks: at most two per layer; at least three SOLID [S]/[E] (or every such shortage when fewer exist)", len(PK) == 6 and pk_layers.max() <= 2 and se_solid >= min(3, n_se_all), f"{se_solid} SOLID [S]/[E] of {n_se_all}; {PK.rule.iloc[0]}") check("ranking counts each shortage on its own (no sharing rule) and shows the order under every scenario", all(abs(RK.loc[k, "blocked_total"] - SH.loc[k, "blocked_total"]) < 0.5 for k in RK.index) and all(c in RK.columns for c in [f"rank_S{i}" for i in range(7)]), f"{len(RK)} shortages, {int(RK.rank_changes.sum())} change rank across scenarios") # 9. every searched number is listed with its source check("every web search listed with its source", SR.url.str.startswith("http").all() and SR.source.str.len().gt(20).all(), f"{len(SR)} searches") # 10. other folders untouched def untouched(ref, root, tracked): """Files that differ from the reference, and files absent here that git does not hold (gitignored raw downloads or never-committed files, so a fresh clone lacks them). A missing file that git tracks counts as changed.""" changed, absent = [], [] for p, h in ref.items(): f = root / p if not f.exists(): (absent if tracked is not None and p not in tracked else changed).append(p) elif hashlib.sha1(f.read_bytes()).hexdigest() != h: changed.append(p) return changed, absent ref = {} for line in (V4 / "work" / "hashes_reference.txt").read_text().splitlines(): h, p = line.split(None, 1) ref[p] = h try: ls = subprocess.run(["git", "ls-files", "-z", "stage1-v1", "stage1-v2", "stage1-v3"], cwd=ROOT, capture_output=True, check=True) tracked = set(ls.stdout.decode().split("\0")) - {""} except (OSError, subprocess.CalledProcessError): tracked = None changed, absent = untouched(ref, ROOT, tracked) check("stage1-v1, stage1-v2 and stage1-v3 untouched", not changed, changed[:5] or (f"{len(ref)} files" if not absent else f"{len(ref) - len(absent)} files identical; {len(absent)} not in this checkout and not in git: " + ", ".join(absent))) out = pd.DataFrame(checks) out.to_csv(V4 / "checks_v4.csv", index=False) for c in checks: print("PASS" if c["ok"] else "FAIL", c["check"], "|", c["detail"][:220]) if not out.ok.all(): sys.exit("a check failed: stop") MODEL SOURCE common.py """Shared readers and helpers for Stage 1 v4. Every input file is read from disk; nothing is typed by hand except the labels' meaning and plain-English names. Paths are relative to the repository root (two levels up from this file).""" from pathlib import Path import pandas as pd V4 = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[1] ROOT = V4.parent V3 = ROOT / "stage1-v3" V2 = ROOT / "stage1-v2" RQ = V3 / "requirements" A4 = V3 / "repair" / "agent4_bottlenecks" BL = V3 / "repair" / "baseline" A6 = V3 / "repair" / "agent6_cheap_inputs" rd = lambda p: pd.read_csv(p, dtype=str).fillna("") def num(x, default=float("nan")): try: return float(str(x).replace(",", "")) except ValueError: return default def worst(*labs): labs = [l for l in labs if l] return "A" if "A" in labs else ("E" if "E" in labs else ("S" if labs else "A")) def rel(p): return str(Path(p).resolve().relative_to(ROOT)) LAYER_NAME = {"C01": "Food at home", "C02": "Clothing", "C03": "Shelter and utilities", "C04": "Household equipment", "C05": "Health care", "C06": "Mobility", "C07": "Communication", "C08": "Recreation", "C09": "Education", "C10": "Food service, lodging", "C11": "Personal and financial services", "C12": "Public services", "C13": "Built structures", "C14": "Productive equipment", "C15": "Knowledge and software", "U1": "Alcohol, tobacco, narcotics", "U2": "Net purchases abroad", "U3": "Inventories", "U4": "Net exports"} # plain-English input names and the category the brief asks for (workers by skill, machines, energy, materials, land, # capital, permission, buyers, know-how that does not exist yet) INPUT_NAME = {"K01": ("Electricity", "energy"), "K02": ("Fuels", "energy"), "K03": ("Machine cognition (AI agents)", "machines"), "K04": ("Physical machine labour (robots)", "machines"), "K05": ("AI compute", "machines"), "K06": ("Copper", "materials"), "K07": ("Lithium", "materials"), "K08": ("Rare earths", "materials"), "K09": ("Steel", "materials"), "K10": ("Cement", "materials"), "K11": ("Saving for investment", "capital"), "K12": ("Building permission", "permission"), "K13": ("Grid connection approval", "permission"), "K14": ("Transformers and grid equipment", "machines"), "K15": ("Clinical approval", "permission"), "K16": ("Professional licensing", "permission"), "K17": ("Construction trades", "workers by skill"), "K18": ("Human workforce", "workers by skill"), "K20": ("Aluminium", "materials"), "K21": ("Capital stock", "capital"), "K22": ("Cropland", "land")} MODEL SOURCE model.py """Stage 1 v4 model: layers, input needs per unit of output, supplies, and the output each input shortage blocks. A shortage is computed from its own numbers only: input needed per unit of output x output, against the input's supply (on course, or at its fastest precedent). When need exceeds supply, the output that cannot be made is taken from the layers that get the least output per unit of that input first (the scarce input goes to its most productive uses; the input-intensive output is the output lost). On-course output is never dropped: the on-course economy's own shortfall is already inside tier 1 in the v3 table. See own_block for the two questions (tier 2 and tier 1). Labour is one block, rebuilt from v3's own files: work per unit of output at the best achievable productivity (requirements.csv work_ratio_2035), humans up to their record employment ratio (Agent 4 K18), machines for the rest, split cognitive / physical by each layer's high-skill share (Agent 4 model_memo 'cog'), on top of the on-course robot and AI fleets (Agent 4 need_by_layer). Who does which task is the step 3 alternative. """ import json import re import numpy as np import pandas as pd from common import A4, BL, RQ, num, rd, worst LAYERS = None def layers(): """Step 1: the v3 requirements table by layer (target, today, on-course growth, tier 1, tier 2).""" L = rd(RQ / "layers_v3.csv").set_index("layer_id") B = rd(BL / "layers.csv").set_index("id") rows = [] for j in L.index: today = num(B.loc[j, "today_2026_ppp_bn"]) oc = num(L.loc[j, "on_course_counted"]) rows.append(dict(layer_id=j, target=num(L.loc[j, "target"]), target_label=L.loc[j, "target_label"], today=today, today_label=B.loc[j, "today_2026_ppp_bn_label"], on_course=oc, on_course_label=L.loc[j, "on_course_counted_label"], growth=oc - today, growth_label=worst(L.loc[j, "on_course_counted_label"], B.loc[j, "today_2026_ppp_bn_label"]), tier1=num(L.loc[j, "tier1"]), tier1_label=L.loc[j, "tier1_label"], tier2=num(L.loc[j, "tier2"]), tier2_label=L.loc[j, "tier2_label"])) return pd.DataFrame(rows).set_index("layer_id") def inputs(): """Inputs with need, supply on course and at precedent (v3 requirements table; repaired Agent 4 for 2026 supply).""" I = rd(RQ / "inputs_v3.csv").set_index("input_id") b4 = rd(A4 / "bottlenecks.csv").set_index("id") mk = rd(RQ / "model_constants.csv").set_index("id") s26 = {k: (num(b4.loc[k, "supply_2026"]), b4.loc[k, "supply_2026_label"], f"stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv ({k} supply_2026)") for k in b4.index} for k, m in (("K20", "MK17"), ("K21", "MK15"), ("K22", "MK16")): s26[k] = (num(mk.loc[m, "value"]), mk.loc[m, "value_label"], f"stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv ({m})") out = [] for k in I.index: if k == "K19": # information row (output needing a permission); its supply sits in K12, K15, K16 continue r = I.loc[k] s = s26.get(k, (np.nan, "", "")) out.append(dict(input_id=k, input=r.input, unit=r.unit, R=num(r.required_base), R_label=r.required_base_label, O=num(r.supply_on_course_2035), O_label=r.supply_on_course_2035_label, P=num(r.supply_precedent_2035), P_label=r.supply_precedent_2035_label, R_alt=num(r.required_base_at_alt_ratio), fastest_precedent=r.fastest_precedent, method=r.output_depending_method, s2026=s[0], s2026_label=s[1], s2026_src=s[2], test=(b4.loc[k, "test"] if k in b4.index else ""), cov_oc_economy=(num(b4.loc[k, "coverage_on_course_economy"]) if k in b4.index else np.nan))) return pd.DataFrame(out).set_index("input_id") def need_ratios(): """Input needed per bn of output by input and layer: base (v3 ratio) and alternative (v3's second sourced ratio).""" r = rd(RQ / "requirements.csv") L = rd(RQ / "layers_v3.csv").set_index("layer_id") il = rd(RQ / "input_layer_v3.csv").set_index(["input_id", "layer_id"]) r["target"] = r.layer_id.map(lambda j: num(L.loc[j, "target"])) r["req"] = r.required_base.map(num) r["req_alt"] = r.required_base_at_alt_ratio.map(lambda x: num(x, np.nan)) r["m"] = np.where(r.target.abs() > 0, r.req / r.target, 0.0) r["m_alt"] = np.where(r.target.abs() > 0, r.req_alt / r.target, np.nan) r["work"] = r.work_ratio_2035.map(lambda x: num(x, np.nan)) # CES inputs (Agent 4 rule for copper, lithium, rare earths, elasticity 0.4): v3's own conversion of a missing unit into # output, missing / output_depending, used as the effective input per bn of output r["m_ces"] = np.nan for i, x in r.iterrows(): if (x.input_id, x.layer_id) in il.index: q = il.loc[(x.input_id, x.layer_id)] mi, od = num(q.missing), num(q.output_depending_ppp_bn) r.at[i, "m_ces"] = mi / od if od > 0 else np.nan return r def labour_data(): """Work per bn of output, cognitive share, on-course fleets, licensed share by layer (all from v3 / Agent 4 files).""" r = rd(RQ / "requirements.csv") k18 = r[r.input_id == "K18"].set_index("layer_id") memo = json.loads((A4 / "work" / "model_memo.json").read_text()) nb = rd(A4 / "work" / "need_by_layer.csv") on = lambda k: {x.layer_id: num(x.need_on_course_2035) for x in nb[nb.input_id == k].itertuples()} # licensed share of work by layer: BLS shares via Agent 4 v1, as v3 coded them (requirements/code/inputs.py, LIC) src = (RQ / "code" / "inputs.py").read_text() block = src[src.index("LIC = {"): src.index("}", src.index("LIC = {")) + 1] lic = {} for j, v in re.findall(r"'(\w+)': \(([\d.]+|None),", block): lic[j] = (27.3 + 22.6) / 2 / 100 if v == "None" else float(v) / 100 reform = float(re.search(r"LIC_REFORM = A\(([\d.]+)", src).group(1)) mk = rd(RQ / "model_constants.csv").set_index("id") return dict(w={j: num(k18.loc[j, "work_ratio_2035"], 0.0) for j in k18.index}, cog={j: memo["cog"][j]["v"] if isinstance(memo["cog"][j], dict) else memo["cog"][j] for j in memo["cog"]}, cog_label="E", on03=on("K03"), on04=on("K04"), lic=lic, lic_reform=reform, gw_per_we=memo["gw_per_we"]["v"], e_rob=num(mk.loc["MK13", "value"]), e_ai=num(mk.loc["MK14", "value"])) def labour(X, D, H, method): """Machine work needed to produce output X (bn by layer) with H million humans, under a task split: base v3: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by the layer's high-skill share cogfirst AI takes every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them humanscog humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap Returns robots, AI work, machine work in licensed tasks (current rules and after reform), machine-labour electricity.""" W = {j: D["w"].get(j, 0.0) * max(0.0, X[j]) for j in X} Wt = sum(W.values()) cog = D["cog"] on03, on04 = sum(D["on03"].values()), sum(D["on04"].values()) if method == "base": gap = max(0.0, Wt - H) sh = gap / Wt if Wt > 0 else 0.0 rob_j = {j: W[j] * sh * (1 - cog[j]) for j in W} ai_j = {j: W[j] * sh * cog[j] for j in W} elif method == "cogfirst": phys = {j: W[j] * (1 - cog[j]) for j in W} P_ = sum(phys.values()) rg = max(0.0, P_ - H) rob_j = {j: phys[j] * rg / P_ if P_ > 0 else 0.0 for j in W} ai_j = {j: W[j] * cog[j] for j in W} elif method == "humanscog": gap = max(0.0, Wt - H) phys = {j: W[j] * (1 - cog[j]) for j in W} P_ = sum(phys.values()) rob_j = {j: phys[j] * gap / P_ if P_ > 0 else 0.0 for j in W} ai_j = {j: 0.0 for j in W} else: raise ValueError(method) mw = {j: rob_j[j] + ai_j[j] for j in W} lic_on = sum(D["lic"].get(j, 0.0) * mw[j] for j in W) return dict(rob=on04 + sum(rob_j.values()), ai=on03 + sum(ai_j.values()), lic_on=lic_on, lic_prec=D["lic_reform"] * lic_on, em=sum(rob_j.values()) * D["e_rob"] + sum(ai_j.values()) * D["e_ai"], Wt=Wt, mw=sum(mw.values())) def _bisect(need_fn, supply, X, j, cap, tol): lo, hi = 0.0, cap for _ in range(60): mid = (lo + hi) / 2 Xm = dict(X); Xm[j] = X[j] - mid if need_fn(Xm) > supply + tol: lo = mid else: hi = mid return hi def drop(need_fn, supply, units, base_X, tol=1e-6): """Drop output units (layer, tier, size) in the given order until need_fn(X) <= supply; the last unit partly. Returns {(layer, tier): dropped} and the excess left (units of the input) if dropping every unit is not enough.""" X = dict(base_X) d = {} if need_fn(X) <= supply + tol: return d, 0.0 for j, t, cap in units: if cap <= 0: continue Xall = dict(X); Xall[j] = X[j] - cap if need_fn(Xall) > supply + tol: X = Xall d[(j, t)] = cap continue d[(j, t)] = _bisect(need_fn, supply, X, j, cap, tol) return d, 0.0 return d, max(0.0, need_fn(X) - supply) def own_block(need_prec, need_oc, order, supply_oc, supply_prec, target_X, T2, T1): """Output one input blocks on its own (every other input plentiful), in two questions: tier 2 (beyond precedent): at the input's fastest-precedent supply with the whole target attempted, the scarce input goes where it yields the most output; the output lost is the most input-intensive output, layer by layer (`order`), tier 2 before tier 1 inside a layer. The tier-2 part is the input's block of tier-2 rows; the tier-1 part lost on that path (t1_competing) is tier-1 output that competes with tier 2 for the input and is reported, not counted. tier 1 (closable at precedent): at the input's on-course supply, with on course + tier 1 attempted and no tier 2, the tier-1 output it cannot carry (layers in `order`). t1_beyond_precedent: the same at the precedent supply (a conflict with the layer view that the row is closable). need_prec / need_oc differ only for labour, where the human supply is at its precedent or on course.""" units_layer = [(j, t, (T2 if t == "2" else T1).get(j, 0.0)) for j in order for t in ("2", "1")] a, leftP = drop(need_prec, supply_prec, units_layer, target_X) X0 = {j: target_X[j] - T2.get(j, 0.0) for j in target_X} units_t1 = [(j, "1", T1.get(j, 0.0)) for j in order] b, leftO = drop(need_oc, supply_oc, units_t1, X0) c, leftC = drop(need_prec, supply_prec, units_t1, X0) keys = list(T2) t2 = {j: a.get((j, "2"), 0.0) for j in keys} t1c = {j: a.get((j, "1"), 0.0) for j in keys} t1 = {j: b.get((j, "1"), 0.0) for j in keys} t1p = {j: c.get((j, "1"), 0.0) for j in keys} return dict(t2=t2, t1=t1, t1_beyond_precedent=t1p, t1_competing=t1c, left_prec=leftP, left_oc=leftO, left_t1_prec=leftC, total=sum(t2.values()) + sum(t1.values())) MODEL SOURCE run_all.sh #!/bin/bash # Stage 1 v4: model, checks (a failure stops the run), page. Run from stage1-v4/code. set -e PY=${PY:-../../.venv/bin/python} $PY v4.py > ../work/v4.log $PY check.py (cd ../site && $PY build.py) $PY summary.py > /dev/null MODEL SOURCE summary.py """Writes stage1-v4/summary.md (one page, plain English) from the stage1-v4 CSVs. No number is typed by hand.""" import pandas as pd from common import LAYER_NAME, V4 L = pd.read_csv(V4 / "layers_v4.csv", index_col=0) SH = pd.read_csv(V4 / "shortages_v4.csv", index_col=0) RK = pd.read_csv(V4 / "ranking_v4.csv", index_col=0) PK = pd.read_csv(V4 / "picks_v4.csv") UNE = pd.read_csv(V4 / "unexplained_v4.csv") DM = pd.read_csv(V4 / "demand_v4.csv") SR = pd.read_csv(V4 / "searches_v4.csv") CK = pd.read_csv(V4 / "checks_v4.csv") ROWS = pd.read_csv(V4 / "rows_v4.csv") OB = pd.read_csv(V4 / "own_blocks_v4.csv") T = lambda bn: f"${bn / 1000:,.1f}T" if abs(bn) >= 100 else f"${bn:,.0f}bn" pct = lambda x: f"{x:.0%}" ordn = lambda n: f"{int(n)}" + ("th" if 10 <= int(n) % 100 <= 20 else {1: "st", 2: "nd", 3: "rd"}.get(int(n) % 10, "th")) miss = L.tier1.sum() + L.tier2.sum() une = UNE.unexplained_bn.sum() big = RK[RK.blocked_total > 1000].sort_values("blocked_total", ascending=False) w = [] w.append("# Stage 1 v4: what stops the missing output\n") w.append(f"**The question.** Doubling 2026 world output means {T(L.target.sum())} in 2035. Today is {T(L.today.sum())}; " f"evidence puts {T(L.growth.sum())} of growth on course. That leaves {T(miss)} missing: {T(L.tier1.sum())} in tier 1 " f"(proven possible at the fastest precedent) and {T(L.tier2.sum())} in tier 2 (beyond any precedent).\n") w.append("**How a shortage is found.** For every input, the code multiplies input needed per unit of output by output, and " "compares that with supply on course and at its fastest precedent. Where need is larger, the output that cannot be made " "is taken from the layers that get least output per unit of that input. Each shortage is counted on its own. Output " "that no input's numbers stop goes on an unexplained list, with its size and no name.\n") w.append("## The shortages (each on its own; ranges across other ways of producing)\n") w.append("| # | shortage | short by (2035) | need met | growth needed vs record | output blocked | range | verdict | label |") w.append("|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|") for k, r in big.iterrows(): t2 = r.blocked_tier2 > 0 unit = r.unit.split(" (")[0].split(" of ")[0].replace("million ", "m ").replace(" in 2035", "").replace(" per year", "/yr") short = r.short_at_precedent if t2 else r.short_on_course if t2 and r.growth_needed_pa == r.growth_needed_pa: g = f"{r.growth_needed_pa:.1%}/yr vs {r.growth_precedent_pa:.1%} ({r.times_faster:.1f}x)" elif t2: g = "buyers: demand response" else: g = "record pace covers it; on course does not" w.append(f"| {int(r.rank_all)} | {r.shortage} | {short:,.1f} {unit} | {(pct(r.share_met_on_course) + ' on course, ' + pct(r.share_met_precedent) + ' at precedent') if (t2 and r.blocked_tier1 > 0) else (pct(r.share_met_precedent) + ' at precedent' if t2 else pct(r.share_met_on_course) + ' on course')} | {g} | {T(r.blocked_total)} | {T(r.blocked_low)}-{T(r.blocked_high)} | {r.verdict} | {r.label} |") solid = big[big.verdict == "SOLID"] scen = big[big.verdict == "SCENARIO"] w.append(f"\n**SOLID ({len(solid)}):** bind under every way of producing tried: {', '.join(solid.shortage)}. " f"**SCENARIO ({len(scen)}):** " + "; ".join( f"{r.shortage} (" + ("not tested: no sourced alternative found" if str(r.depends_on).startswith("fewer than two") else "disappears under: " + str(r.depends_on).split(";")[0].replace("v3 second ratio: ", "")[:80]) + ")" for _, r in scen.iterrows()) + ".") w.append(f"Only {', '.join(SH[(SH.verdict == 'SOLID') & SH.label.isin(['S', 'E'])].shortage)} are both SOLID and [S]/[E]; " "every other size rests on an assumed ratio, supply or tier size.\n") s1 = RK.loc["K04", "rank_S1"] if "K04" in RK.index else None lead1 = RK.sort_values("blocked_S1", ascending=False).iloc[0].shortage w.append(f"**The order moves with the way of producing.** If AI agents take cognitive tasks first, robots fall from 1st to {ordn(s1)} " f"and {lead1.lower()} leads; with trend crop yields cropland ranks {ordn(RK.loc['K22', 'rank_S4'])}; at the lowest capital-output ratio " f"on record capital stock blocks nothing. ranking_v4.csv holds the rank under all seven scenarios.\n") w.append("## Unexplained\n") by = UNE.groupby("layer_id").unexplained_bn.sum().sort_values(ascending=False) w.append(f"{T(une)} of the {T(miss)} missing has no input whose own numbers stop it: " + ", ".join(f"{LAYER_NAME[j].lower()} {T(v)}" for j, v in by.items()) + ". It is listed with its size and no name.\n") w.append("## Buyers (five largest layers)\n") for r in DM.itertuples(): w.append(f"- {r.layer}: demand at the 2035 price {T(r.demand_2035)} against a target of {T(r.target)} (income elasticity {r.income_elasticity:.2f}). " + ("Bought." if r.buyers_short <= 0 else f"Buyers short by {T(r.buyers_short)}.")) w.append(f"\nThe construction gap rests on the 2014-24 world response; at the 2004-14 response ({DM.set_index('layer_id').loc['C13', 'income_elasticity_other_windows'].split(';')[0]}) buyers are not short, so it is SCENARIO.\n") w.append("## Six picks to carry forward\n") cand = list(RK[RK.blocked_total > 1e-6].sort_values("blocked_total", ascending=False).index) for r in PK.itertuples(): pos = cand.index(r.shortage_id) nx = cand[pos + 1] if pos + 1 < len(cand) else None beat = (f" Beat {RK.loc[nx, 'shortage'].lower()} ({T(RK.loc[nx, 'blocked_total'])}) by {T(r.blocked_total - RK.loc[nx, 'blocked_total'])}." if nx else "") w.append(f"- **{r.shortage}** ({r.verdict}, [{r.label}], mostly {LAYER_NAME.get(r.main_layer, r.main_layer).lower()}): blocks " f"{T(r.blocked_total)} on its own, {T(r.blocked_low)}-{T(r.blocked_high)} across the ways of producing.{beat}") w.append(f"\nThe brief asks for at least three SOLID [S]/[E] picks; {PK.rule.iloc[0].replace('rule not met: ', '')}.\n") k22 = OB[(OB.shortage_id == "K22") & (OB.variant == "base")] w.append("## Cropland check\n") w.append(f"In food at home, cropland blocks {T(k22[k22.layer_id == 'C01'].blocked_bn.sum())}: all of that layer's tier 2. It cannot exceed " f"food at home's missing {T(L.loc['C01', 'tier1'] + L.loc['C01', 'tier2'])} or its target {T(L.loc['C01', 'target'])}. " f"In total it blocks {T(k22.blocked_bn.sum())}, in {k22.layer_id.nunique()} layers whose crop footprint it serves, food-heavy layers first. " "v3 spread its shortage proportionally across every layer and showed 45.4T; v4 never puts a shortage in a layer beyond what is missing there.\n") unt = SH[(SH.status == "UNTESTED") & (SH.blocked_high > 1000)].sort_values("blocked_total", ascending=False) w.append("## UNTESTED (rests on an assumed size or rate) and the cheapest test\n") for k, r in unt.head(6).iterrows(): w.append(f"- {r.shortage}: {str(r.test)[:170]}") w.append(f"\n{len(unt)} shortages over 1T in some way of producing are UNTESTED. Web searches: " + "; ".join(f"{r.id} {r.source.split(' (')[0]} ({r.url})" for r in SR.itertuples()) + ".") w.append(f"Checks: {CK.ok.sum()} of {len(CK)} pass (checks_v4.csv). Files: shortages_v4.csv, rows_v4.csv, variants_v4.csv, ranking_v4.csv, site/index.html.") (V4 / "summary.md").write_text("\n".join(w) + "\n") print("\n".join(w)) MODEL SOURCE v4.py """Stage 1 v4: what stops the missing output. Run from stage1-v4/code: python v4.py Writes, in stage1-v4/: layers_v4.csv step 1: the v3 requirements table by layer variants_v4.csv step 3: every way of producing the output used to test a shortage, with its source own_blocks_v4.csv output each shortage blocks on its own, by variant, layer and tier shortages_v4.csv step 2-3: each shortage, physical size, share of need met, output blocked (range), SOLID/SCENARIO rows_v4.csv step 2: every missing row (layer x tier): the shortage that binds first and what each blocks unexplained_v4.csv step 2: output no input explains, by row, with its size and no name demand_v4.csv step 4: demand check for the five largest layers ranking_v4.csv step 5: shortages ranked by output blocked on their own, and the rank under every scenario picks_v4.csv step 5: the six picks and why each beat the next one down agents_v4.csv headline numbers for the page's agent streams searches_v4.csv every web search used, with its source No number is typed by hand except the two searched ratios, which are kept in searches_v4.csv with their sources. """ import math import numpy as np import pandas as pd import model as M from common import A4, A6, BL, INPUT_NAME, LAYER_NAME, RQ, V2, V3, V4, num, rd, worst pd.set_option("display.width", 250) L = M.layers() I = M.inputs() R = M.need_ratios() D = M.labour_data() LAY = list(L.index) T2 = {j: max(0.0, L.loc[j, "tier2"]) for j in LAY} T1 = {j: max(0.0, L.loc[j, "tier1"]) for j in LAY} TX = {j: L.loc[j, "target"] for j in LAY} MISS = {j: T1[j] + T2[j] for j in LAY} HO, HP = I.loc["K18", "O"], I.loc["K18", "P"] TODAY_T, TARGET_T = L.today.sum(), L.target.sum() # ---------------------------------------------------------------- searched ratios (steps 2-4), kept with their sources SEARCH = pd.DataFrame([ dict(id="W1", query="Mueller 2012 Nature closing yield gaps nutrient water management production increase 45% 70% attainable yields", source="Mueller N.D. et al. (2012) Closing yield gaps through nutrient and water management, Nature 490:254-257, doi:10.1038/nature11420", url="https://ideas.repec.org/a/nat/nature/v490y2012i7419d10.1038_nature11420.html", value_low=0.45, value_high=0.70, label="S", used_for="K22 cropland, step 3: crop output per ha if yield gaps close to 100% of attainable yields (+45% to +70% for most crops)"), dict(id="W2", query="Smith Newhouse Freeland 2009 Health Affairs technology share of health spending growth 27 to 48 percent", source="Smith S., Newhouse J.P., Freeland M.S. (2009) Income, insurance, and technology: why does health spending outpace economic growth? Health Affairs 28(5):1276-1284", url="https://www.hks.harvard.edu/publications/income-insurance-and-technology-why-does-health-spending-outpace-economic-growth", value_low=0.27, value_high=0.48, label="S", used_for="K15 clinical approval, step 3: share of health spending growth that comes from new medical technology (27% to 48%)"), ]) SEARCH.to_csv(V4 / "searches_v4.csv", index=False) W = SEARCH.set_index("id") # ---------------------------------------------------------------- need functions def lin(m): return lambda X: sum(m.get(j, 0.0) * X[j] for j in X) def order_by(m): return [j for j in sorted(m, key=lambda j: -m[j]) if m[j] > 0] def ratio(k, col="m"): x = R[R.input_id == k] return {a: (b if not (isinstance(b, float) and math.isnan(b)) else 0.0) for a, b in zip(x.layer_id, x[col])} LAB_SRC = ("stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, " "gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)") trend_w = {} nb = rd(A4 / "work" / "need_by_layer.csv") for x in nb[nb.input_id == "K18"].itertuples(): trend_w[x.layer_id] = num(x.intensity_unit_per_ppp_bn, 0.0) D_TREND = dict(D, w=trend_w) LAB_METHODS = { "base": (D, "base", "v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share", "E"), "cogfirst": (D, "cogfirst", "AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them", "E"), "humanscog": (D, "humanscog", "humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap", "E"), "trendprod": (D_TREND, "base", "v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth", "E"), } def lab_fn(method, H, what): Dm, meth = LAB_METHODS[method][0], LAB_METHODS[method][1] return lambda X: M.labour(X, Dm, H, meth)[what] def lab_order(method, what): Dm = LAB_METHODS[method][0] w, cog = Dm["w"], Dm["cog"] if what == "rob": sc = {j: w.get(j, 0) * (1 - cog[j]) for j in LAY} elif what in ("ai", "k05"): sc = {j: w.get(j, 0) * cog[j] for j in LAY} elif what == "k16": sc = {j: w.get(j, 0) * D["lic"].get(j, 0) for j in LAY} else: sc = {j: w.get(j, 0) for j in LAY} return order_by(sc) # electricity: footprint (v3 ratio net of machine-labour electricity) + machine-labour electricity of the task split lab_t = M.labour(TX, D, HP, "base") Wt_t = lab_t["Wt"] sh_t = max(0.0, Wt_t - HP) / Wt_t EM_base_j = {j: D["w"].get(j, 0) * TX[j] * sh_t * ((1 - D["cog"][j]) * D["e_rob"] + D["cog"][j] * D["e_ai"]) for j in LAY} fp_base = {j: (ratio("K01")[j] * TX[j] - EM_base_j[j]) / TX[j] if TX[j] else 0.0 for j in LAY} fp_alt = {j: (ratio("K01", "m_alt")[j] * TX[j] - EM_base_j[j]) / TX[j] if TX[j] else 0.0 for j in LAY} # 2026 intensities held (today's technology): each input's 2026 supply per unit of 2026 world output, with v3's layer pattern def today_ratio(k): m = ratio(k) s, Rk = I.loc[k, "s2026"], I.loc[k, "R"] f = (s / TODAY_T) / (Rk / TARGET_T) return {j: m[j] * f for j in m}, f # capital-output ratio on its 2013-23 trend: PWT capital growth (landcap GK_1323) against UN AMA world GDP growth 2013-23 lc = rd(RQ / "work" / "landcap.csv").set_index("id") ama = pd.read_csv(BL / "work" / "ama_ppp.csv", index_col=0) g_gdp_1323 = (ama.loc[2023, "Gross Domestic Product (GDP)"] / ama.loc[2013, "Gross Domestic Product (GDP)"]) ** (1 / 10) - 1 ky_trend_f = ((1 + num(lc.loc["GK_1323", "value"])) / (1 + g_gdp_1323)) ** 12 # 2023 -> 2035, relative to K/Y held yld_base = (1 + num(lc.loc["GY_MAX9", "value"])) ** 9 # base: crop output per ha at its fastest 9-year growth def V(vid, desc, src, label, need_prec, need_oc, order, s_oc, s_prec, scen): return dict(vid=vid, desc=desc, src=src, label=label, need_prec=need_prec, need_oc=need_oc, order=order, s_oc=s_oc, s_prec=s_prec, scen=scen) CES = ("K06", "K07", "K08") # Agent 4 rule: CES substitution, elasticity 0.4 (v3's conversion of a missing unit into output) def ces(Rk, mces): """CES inputs: need at the target is the true requirement Rk; each bn of output given up saves only mces units (the substitution elasticity 0.4 lets other inputs replace most of a missing unit), so the output lost is excess / mces.""" return lambda X: Rk - sum(mces.get(j, 0.0) * (TX[j] - X[j]) for j in X) def linear_variants(k, n_more=0): """base (v3 best-achievable ratio), v3's second sourced ratio, and, only where fewer than two other ways exist, the 2026 intensity held (today's technology). n_more: alternatives the caller adds itself.""" out = [] m = ratio(k) mb = ratio(k, "m_ces") if k in CES else m note = " (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)" if k in CES else "" out.append(V("base", "v3 ratio: " + R[R.input_id == k].ratio_kind.iloc[0] + note, "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)" + ("; input_layer_v3.csv (missing, output_depending_ppp_bn)" if k in CES else ""), I.loc[k, "R_label"], *( (ces(I.loc[k, "R"], mb),) * 2 if k in CES else (lin(mb),) * 2), order_by(mb), I.loc[k, "O"], I.loc[k, "P"], "S0")) ma = ratio(k, "m_alt") altb = R[R.input_id == k].ratio_alt_basis.iloc[0] if sum(ma.values()) > 0 and altb not in ("", "same") and abs(sum(ma[j] * TX[j] for j in LAY) - I.loc[k, "R"]) > 1e-6 * I.loc[k, "R"]: mab = {j: mb[j] * (ma[j] / m[j]) if m[j] else 0.0 for j in m} Ra = sum(ma[j] * TX[j] for j in LAY) fa = ces(Ra, mab) if k in CES else lin(mab) out.append(V("v3alt", "v3 second ratio: " + altb + note, "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)", "E", fa, fa, order_by(mab), I.loc[k, "O"], I.loc[k, "P"], "S4")) if len(out) - 1 + n_more < 2 and not math.isnan(I.loc[k, "s2026"]) and k not in ("K11", "K12", "K15"): mt, f = today_ratio(k) mtb = {j: mb[j] * f for j in mb} ft = ces(I.loc[k, "R"] * f, mtb) if k in CES else lin(mtb) out.append(V("today", f"2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x{f:.2f} the v3 ratio" + note, I.loc[k, "s2026_src"] + "; 2026 world output (repaired baseline)", worst(I.loc[k, "s2026_label"], "E"), ft, ft, order_by(mtb), I.loc[k, "O"], I.loc[k, "P"], "S5")) return out def variants(k): nm = INPUT_NAME[k][0] if k in ("K04", "K03", "K05", "K16"): what = {"K04": "rob", "K03": "ai", "K05": "k05", "K16": "k16"}[k] out = [] for meth, (Dm, mm, desc, lab) in LAB_METHODS.items(): scen = {"base": "S0", "cogfirst": "S1", "humanscog": "S2", "trendprod": "S3"}[meth] if k == "K05": fp = lambda H, meth=meth: (lambda X: lab_fn(meth, H, "ai")(X) * D["gw_per_we"]) out.append(V(meth, desc, LAB_SRC, worst(lab, "A"), fp(HP), fp(HO), lab_order(meth, "ai"), I.loc[k, "O"], I.loc[k, "P"], scen)) elif k == "K16": # machine work that current rules allow (outside the licensed share of tasks), held at its level for the target lt = M.labour(TX, Dm, HP, mm) on16 = sum(D["on03"].values()) + sum(D["on04"].values()) s_on = on16 + lt["mw"] - lt["lic_on"] s_pr = on16 + lt["mw"] - lt["lic_prec"] need = lambda H, meth=meth: (lambda X: on16 + lab_fn(meth, H, "mw")(X)) out.append(V(meth, desc + "; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent", LAB_SRC + "; stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py (LIC, LIC_REFORM)", "A", need(HP), need(HO), lab_order(meth, "k16"), s_on, s_pr, scen)) else: out.append(V(meth, desc, LAB_SRC, worst(lab, "A") if k == "K04" else lab, lab_fn(meth, HP, what), lab_fn(meth, HO, what), lab_order(meth, what), I.loc[k, "O"], I.loc[k, "P"], scen)) if k == "K16": # task reallocation: humans take the licensed tasks, machines the rest licw = lambda X: sum(D["lic"].get(j, 0) * D["w"].get(j, 0) * X[j] for j in X) out.append(V("humanslicensed", "humans take the licensed tasks first, machines the rest: licensing binds only if licensed work exceeds all human work", LAB_SRC + "; stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py (LIC)", "E", licw, licw, lab_order("base", "k16"), HO, HP, "S6")) return out if k in ("K01", "K13", "K14"): out = [] for meth, (Dm, mm, desc, lab) in LAB_METHODS.items(): scen = {"base": "S0", "cogfirst": "S1", "humanscog": "S2", "trendprod": "S3"}[meth] f = lambda H, meth=meth: (lambda X: lin(fp_base)(X) + lab_fn(meth, H, "em")(X)) out.append(V(meth, "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: " + desc, "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); " + LAB_SRC, worst(I.loc[k, "R_label"], lab), f(HP), f(HO), order_by(fp_base), I.loc[k, "O"], I.loc[k, "P"], scen)) fa = lambda H: (lambda X: lin(fp_alt)(X) + lab_fn("base", H, "em")(X)) out.append(V("v3alt", "IEA STEPS 2035 footprint (v3 second ratio) + machine-labour electricity (v3 split)", "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_alt_2035)", "E", fa(HP), fa(HO), order_by(fp_alt), I.loc[k, "O"], I.loc[k, "P"], "S4")) return out if k == "K18": m = ratio(k) out = linear_variants(k, n_more=1) mt = {j: m[j] * (trend_w.get(j, 0) / D["w"][j]) if D["w"].get(j) else 0.0 for j in m} out.append(V("trendprod", "humans' share of work with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of the fastest 9-year growth", LAB_SRC, "E", lin(mt), lin(mt), order_by(mt), I.loc[k, "O"], I.loc[k, "P"], "S3")) return out if k == "K21": m = ratio(k) out = linear_variants(k, n_more=1) mt = {j: m[j] * ky_trend_f for j in m} out.append(V("kytrend", f"capital-output ratio on its 2013-23 trend: x{ky_trend_f:.3f} today's (PWT capital growth {num(lc.loc['GK_1323', 'value']):.2%} vs UN AMA GDP growth {g_gdp_1323:.2%})", "stage1-v3/requirements/work/landcap.csv (GK_1323, PWT 11.0); stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world GDP 2013, 2023)", "E", lin(mt), lin(mt), order_by(mt), I.loc[k, "O"], I.loc[k, "P"], "S5")) return out if k == "K22": m = ratio(k) out = linear_variants(k, n_more=2) for tag, v in (("low", W.loc["W1", "value_low"]), ("high", W.loc["W1", "value_high"])): f = yld_base / (1 + v) mt = {j: m[j] * f for j in m} out.append(V(f"yieldgap_{tag}", f"yield gaps closed to attainable yields: crop output per ha +{v:.0%} on 2026 (x{f:.3f} the v3 ratio)", "searches_v4.csv W1 (Mueller et al. 2012); stage1-v3/requirements/work/landcap.csv (GY_MAX9)", "E", lin(mt), lin(mt), order_by(mt), I.loc[k, "O"], I.loc[k, "P"], "S6")) return out if k == "K15": m = ratio(k) out = linear_variants(k, n_more=2) P_, O_, Tc = I.loc[k, "P"], I.loc[k, "O"], TX["C05"] need = lambda X: X["C05"] for tag, v in (("low", W.loc["W2", "value_low"]), ("high", W.loc["W2", "value_high"])): # only the technology share of health output growth needs newly approved products; the rest is more of approved # care, allowed under current rules: the allowed output rises by (1 - share) of the growth beyond the current-rule path out.append(V(f"techshare_{tag}", f"only {v:.0%} of health output growth beyond the current-rule path comes from new technology needing approval; the rest is more of approved care", "searches_v4.csv W2 (Smith, Newhouse, Freeland 2009)", "E", need, need, ["C05"], O_ + (1 - v) * (Tc - O_), P_ + (1 - v) * (Tc - P_), "S6")) return out return linear_variants(k) SHORT_IDS = [k for k in I.index if k in INPUT_NAME] results = {} # (k, vid) -> own block dict VARS = {} for k in SHORT_IDS: VARS[k] = variants(k) for v in VARS[k]: ob = M.own_block(v["need_prec"], v["need_oc"], v["order"], v["s_oc"], v["s_prec"], TX, T2, T1) ob["need_target"] = v["need_prec"](TX) results[(k, v["vid"])] = ob # ---------------------------------------------------------------- step 4: demand for the five largest layers dt = rd(BL / "demand_test.csv").set_index("id") te = rd(RQ / "target_economy.csv").set_index("layer_id") j6 = rd(A6 / "joint.csv") ach = j6[j6.case == "achievable"].set_index("layer_id") big5 = list(L.target.sort_values(ascending=False).index[:5]) inc_ratio = TARGET_T / TODAY_T dem_rows, BUY = [], {} obs = {"C12": "General government final consumption expenditure", "C13": "Construction (ISIC F)"} WINDOWS = ((2014, 2024), (2004, 2014), (1994, 2004)) def eta_obs(col, a0, a1): return (math.log(ama.loc[a1, col] / ama.loc[a0, col]) / math.log(ama.loc[a1, "Gross Domestic Product (GDP)"] / ama.loc[a0, "Gross Domestic Product (GDP)"])) ETA_ALT = {} for j in big5: if j in obs: eta = eta_obs(obs[j], *WINDOWS[0]) ETA_ALT[j] = [(f"{a0}-{a1}", eta_obs(obs[j], a0, a1)) for a0, a1 in WINDOWS[1:]] eta_src, eta_lab = f"stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, {obs[j]} vs GDP, 2014-2024)", "E" eps, eps_src = 0.0, "no market price (budgets or investment set quantity): no price response" else: rr = dt.loc[j] eta = math.log(num(rr.demand_ratio_at_today_price)) / math.log(num(rr.income_ratio_at_max)) eta_src, eta_lab = "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (income elasticity from v1 bridge, eta)", rr.income_elasticity_label or "E" eps, eps_src = num(rr.price_elasticity), "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (price elasticity, Agent 2)" pf = num(ach.loc[j, "price_fall_of_product"], 0.0) if j in ach.index else 0.0 price_ratio = 1 - pf dem = L.loc[j, "today"] * inc_ratio ** eta * price_ratio ** eps short = max(0.0, L.loc[j, "target"] - dem) dem_rows.append(dict(layer_id=j, layer=LAYER_NAME[j], today=L.loc[j, "today"], target=L.loc[j, "target"], extra_output=MISS[j], income_ratio=inc_ratio, income_elasticity=eta, income_elasticity_label=eta_lab, income_elasticity_src=eta_src, price_ratio_2035=price_ratio, price_ratio_src="stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv (achievable case, price_fall_of_product)", price_elasticity=eps, price_elasticity_src=eps_src, demand_2035=dem, demand_label=worst(eta_lab, "E"), buyers_short=short, verdict=("bought: demand at the 2035 price covers the target" if short <= 0 else f"not all bought: buyers short of {short:,.0f} bn; buyers are the shortage"))) if short > 0: BUY[j] = (short, worst(eta_lab, "E"), eta_src) demand = pd.DataFrame(dem_rows) demand.to_csv(V4 / "demand_v4.csv", index=False) for j, (short, lab, src) in BUY.items(): k = f"BUY-{j}" INPUT_NAME[k] = (f"Buyers for {LAYER_NAME[j].lower()}", "buyers") m = {jj: (1.0 if jj == j else 0.0) for jj in LAY} dem_j = demand.set_index("layer_id").loc[j, "demand_2035"] oc_fixed = {jj: TX[jj] for jj in LAY} need = lambda X, j=j: X[j] VARS[k] = [V("base", "demand at the 2035 price from the sourced income response (UN AMA world 2014-2024)", src, lab, need, need, [j], dem_j, dem_j, "S0")] drow = demand.set_index("layer_id").loc[j] for win, e in ETA_ALT.get(j, []): dj = L.loc[j, "today"] * inc_ratio ** e * drow.price_ratio_2035 ** drow.price_elasticity VARS[k].append(V(f"eta_{win}", f"demand from the UN AMA world income response {win} (elasticity {e:.2f})", src.replace("2014-2024", win), "E", need, need, [j], dj, dj, "S4" if win.startswith("2004") else "S5")) for v in VARS[k]: results[(k, v["vid"])] = M.own_block(need, need, [j], v["s_oc"], v["s_prec"], TX, T2, T1) results[(k, v["vid"])]["need_target"] = TX[j] SHORT_IDS.append(k) demand["income_elasticity_other_windows"] = demand.layer_id.map(lambda j: "; ".join(f"{w}: {e:.3f}" for w, e in ETA_ALT.get(j, []))) demand.to_csv(V4 / "demand_v4.csv", index=False) # ---------------------------------------------------------------- shortages table (steps 2-3) def gr(a, b): return (b / a) ** (1 / 9) - 1 if a and b and a > 0 and b > 0 else np.nan sh_rows, ob_rows, var_rows = [], [], [] for k in SHORT_IDS: base = results[(k, "base")] tot = {v["vid"]: results[(k, v["vid"])]["total"] for v in VARS[k]} lo, hi = min(tot.values()), max(tot.values()) binds_all = all(t > 1e-6 for t in tot.values()) tested_3 = base["total"] > 1000 n_alt = len(VARS[k]) - 1 identity = k in ("K11",) # saving = investment at market prices: no way of producing the target changes it if not tested_3: verdict = "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)" if hi > 1000 else "not tested (blocks 1T or less)" elif identity: verdict = "SOLID" elif n_alt < 2: verdict = "SCENARIO" else: verdict = "SOLID" if binds_all else "SCENARIO" dep = "; ".join(v["desc"] for v in VARS[k] if results[(k, v["vid"])]["total"] <= 1e-6) if not tested_3 and hi > 1000: dep = "binds only under: " + "; ".join(v["desc"] for v in VARS[k] if results[(k, v["vid"])]["total"] > 1000) if identity and tested_3: dep = "accounting identity (saving = investment in C13-C15 at market prices): binds under every way of producing; rests on the on-course saving rate (2015-24 mean, A)" elif verdict == "SCENARIO" and n_alt < 2: dep = "fewer than two sourced alternative ways found; " + (dep or "rests on the base ratio") is_inp = k in I.index need_t = base["need_target"] s_oc = VARS[k][0]["s_oc"]; s_pr = VARS[k][0]["s_prec"] lab_parts = [VARS[k][0]["label"]] if is_inp: lab_parts += [I.loc[k, "O_label"], I.loc[k, "P_label"]] # label of the blocked output: also A when a whole tier row (an [A] amount) is dropped rows_hit = [(j, t) for t, dd in (("2", base["t2"]), ("1", base["t1"])) for j, v in dd.items() if v > 1e-6] full_row = any(abs((T2 if t == "2" else T1)[j] - (base["t2"] if t == "2" else base["t1"])[j]) < 1e-6 for j, t in rows_hit) row_labs = [L.loc[j, "tier2_label" if t == "2" else "tier1_label"] for j, t in rows_hit] if full_row else [] label = worst(*lab_parts, *row_labs) by_layer = {j: base["t2"][j] + base["t1"][j] for j in LAY} main = max(by_layer, key=by_layer.get) if base["total"] > 0 else "" untested = label == "A" or any(l == "A" for l in lab_parts) test = I.loc[k, "test"] if is_inp else ("UN AMA construction and government consumption vs GDP by region 1995-2024, to see whether the world elasticity holds as incomes rise" if k.startswith("BUY") else "") if is_inp and not test: test = {"K20": "IEA STEPS/NZE 2035 aluminium demand by end use (WEO Annex) against the EXIOBASE footprint, and 2026 smelter capacity by region", "K21": "PWT 11.0 capital-output ratios by country 1990-2023 for economies growing 5%+ a year (does K/Y fall during fast growth?)", "K22": "FAOSTAT crop output per ha and cropland by country 2000-2024, and the EXIOBASE crop footprint per $ of non-food output 1995-2022 (does it fall with income?)"}.get(k, "") gneed, gprec = (gr(I.loc[k, "s2026"], need_t), gr(I.loc[k, "s2026"], s_pr)) if is_inp else (np.nan, np.nan) sh_rows.append(dict(shortage_id=k, shortage=INPUT_NAME[k][0], category=INPUT_NAME[k][1], unit=(I.loc[k, "unit"] if is_inp else "bn 2026 int$ of output bought"), need_2035=need_t, supply_on_course=s_oc, supply_precedent=s_pr, share_met_on_course=s_oc / need_t if need_t else np.nan, share_met_precedent=s_pr / need_t if need_t else np.nan, short_at_precedent=max(0.0, need_t - s_pr), short_on_course=max(0.0, need_t - s_oc), blocked_tier2=sum(base["t2"].values()), blocked_tier1=sum(base["t1"].values()), blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent=sum(base["t1_beyond_precedent"].values()), tier1_competing_with_tier2=sum(base["t1_competing"].values()), blocked_total=base["total"], excess_not_absorbed_on_course=base["left_oc"], excess_not_absorbed_precedent=base["left_prec"], blocked_low=lo, blocked_high=hi, n_alternatives=n_alt, verdict=verdict, depends_on=dep, label=label, status=("UNTESTED" if untested else "TESTED"), test=(test if untested else ""), growth_needed_pa=gneed, growth_precedent_pa=gprec, times_faster=(gneed / gprec if gprec and gprec > 0 and not math.isnan(gneed) else np.nan), fastest_precedent=(I.loc[k, "fastest_precedent"] if is_inp else ""), main_layer=main, src=("stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv" if is_inp else "demand_v4.csv"))) for v in VARS[k]: ob = results[(k, v["vid"])] var_rows.append(dict(shortage_id=k, variant=v["vid"], scenario=v["scen"], way_of_producing=v["desc"], src=v["src"], label=v["label"], need_2035=ob["need_target"], supply_on_course=v["s_oc"], supply_precedent=v["s_prec"], blocked_tier2=sum(ob["t2"].values()), blocked_tier1=sum(ob["t1"].values()), blocked_total=ob["total"], binds=ob["total"] > 1e-6)) for t, dd in (("2", ob["t2"]), ("1", ob["t1"])): for j, val in dd.items(): if val > 1e-9: ob_rows.append(dict(shortage_id=k, variant=v["vid"], layer_id=j, tier=t, blocked_bn=val)) SH = pd.DataFrame(sh_rows).set_index("shortage_id") OB = pd.DataFrame(ob_rows) VR = pd.DataFrame(var_rows) # ---------------------------------------------------------------- rows (step 2): binding shortage and unexplained output row_rows, une_rows = [], [] for j in LAY: for t, amt in (("1", T1[j]), ("2", T2[j])): if amt <= 1e-9: continue x = OB[(OB.variant == "base") & (OB.layer_id == j) & (OB.tier == t)].copy() x["share_met"] = x.shortage_id.map(lambda k: SH.loc[k, "share_met_precedent" if t == "2" else "share_met_on_course"]) x = x.sort_values(["blocked_bn", "share_met"], ascending=[False, True]) explained = float(x.blocked_bn.max()) if len(x) else 0.0 une = max(0.0, amt - explained) first = x.iloc[0] if len(x) else None k = first.shortage_id if first is not None else "" why = "" if t == "1" and k: why = (f"{SH.loc[k, 'shortage']} on course meets {SH.loc[k, 'share_met_on_course']:.0%} of need; at its fastest precedent " f"({SH.loc[k, 'fastest_precedent'][:90] or 'record'}) it meets {SH.loc[k, 'share_met_precedent']:.0%}: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace") if j in dt.index: why += f". Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): {dt.loc[j, 'verdict']}" elif t == "2" and k: g, gp = SH.loc[k, "growth_needed_pa"], SH.loc[k, "growth_precedent_pa"] why = (f"{SH.loc[k, 'shortage']} would have to grow {g:.1%} a year 2026-35 against {gp:.1%} at its fastest precedent ({SH.loc[k, 'times_faster']:.1f}x faster)" if not (isinstance(g, float) and math.isnan(g)) else f"{SH.loc[k, 'shortage']}: buyers at the 2035 price fall short") phys = (first.blocked_bn * VARS[k][0]["need_prec"](TX) / TX[j] if False else np.nan) if k else np.nan row_rows.append(dict(layer_id=j, layer=LAYER_NAME[j], tier=t, missing_bn=amt, missing_label=L.loc[j, f"tier{t}_label"], binds_first=k, binds_first_name=(SH.loc[k, "shortage"] if k else ""), binds_first_category=(SH.loc[k, "category"] if k else ""), binds_first_blocks_bn=explained, binds_first_label=(SH.loc[k, "label"] if k else ""), binds_first_verdict=(SH.loc[k, "verdict"] if k else ""), others=("; ".join(f"{r.shortage_id} {r.blocked_bn:,.0f}" for r in x.iloc[1:].itertuples()) if len(x) > 1 else ""), n_shortages=len(x), explained_bn=min(explained, amt), unexplained_bn=une, why=why)) if une > 1e-6: une_rows.append(dict(layer_id=j, layer=LAYER_NAME[j], tier=t, unexplained_bn=une, label=L.loc[j, f"tier{t}_label"], note="no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage")) ROWS = pd.DataFrame(row_rows) UNE = pd.DataFrame(une_rows, columns=["layer_id", "layer", "tier", "unexplained_bn", "label", "note"]) # ---------------------------------------------------------------- ranking (step 5) and scenario orders SCEN = {"S0": "base", "S1": "AI takes cognitive tasks first", "S2": "humans keep cognitive tasks", "S3": "labour productivity on trend", "S4": "v3 second sourced ratios", "S5": "2026 intensities / K-Y trend", "S6": "land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation"} scen_tot = {} for s in SCEN: for k in SHORT_IDS: v = next((v for v in VARS[k] if v["scen"] == s), VARS[k][0]) scen_tot[(s, k)] = results[(k, v["vid"])]["total"] rk = SH[(SH.blocked_total > 1e-6) | (SH.blocked_high > 1000)].copy() # also shortages that bind only in another way of producing rk["group_label"] = np.where(rk.label.isin(["S", "E"]), "S/E", "A") rk["group_solid"] = np.where(rk.verdict == "SOLID", "SOLID", np.where(rk.verdict == "SCENARIO", "SCENARIO", "untested (<=1T)")) rk = rk.sort_values("blocked_total", ascending=False) rk["rank_all"] = range(1, len(rk) + 1) for s in SCEN: vals = pd.Series({k: scen_tot[(s, k)] for k in rk.index}) rk[f"rank_{s}"] = vals.rank(ascending=False, method="min").astype(int) rk[f"blocked_{s}"] = vals rk["rank_changes"] = rk[[f"rank_{s}" for s in SCEN]].nunique(axis=1) > 1 for g in ("S/E", "A"): sub = rk[rk.group_label == g] rk.loc[sub.index, "rank_in_label_group"] = range(1, len(sub) + 1) for g in rk.group_solid.unique(): sub = rk[rk.group_solid == g] rk.loc[sub.index, "rank_in_solid_group"] = range(1, len(sub) + 1) # picks: six, at least three SOLID and [S]/[E], at most two per layer; the largest blocked output that meets the rules from itertools import combinations cand = list(rk[rk.blocked_total > 1e-6].index) SE_SOLID = [k for k in cand if rk.loc[k, "verdict"] == "SOLID" and rk.loc[k, "label"] in ("S", "E")] NEED_SE = min(3, len(SE_SOLID)) # the brief asks for three; fewer exist only if the data hold fewer best = None for combo in combinations(cand[:16], 6): se_solid = sum(1 for k in combo if k in SE_SOLID) per = pd.Series([rk.loc[k, "main_layer"] for k in combo]).value_counts() if se_solid < NEED_SE or per.max() > 2: continue val = sum(rk.loc[k, "blocked_total"] for k in combo) if best is None or val > best[0]: best = (val, combo) picks = list(best[1]) if best else [] PICK_RULE_NOTE = ("rule met: at least three SOLID [S]/[E]" if NEED_SE >= 3 else f"rule not met: only {len(SE_SOLID)} shortages are both SOLID and [S]/[E] ({', '.join(SE_SOLID)}); all are picked") rk["pick"] = rk.index.isin(picks) pick_rows = [] for k in picks: pos = cand.index(k) nxt = cand[pos + 1] if pos + 1 < len(cand) else None se = k in SE_SOLID why = (f"blocks {rk.loc[k, 'blocked_total']:,.0f} bn on its own, {rk.loc[k, 'blocked_low']:,.0f}-{rk.loc[k, 'blocked_high']:,.0f} across the ways of producing; " f"{rk.loc[k, 'verdict']}" + (f" (depends on: {rk.loc[k, 'depends_on'][:120]})" if rk.loc[k, "verdict"] == "SCENARIO" else "")) if nxt: why += (f". Beat the next one down, {nxt} {rk.loc[nxt, 'shortage']} ({rk.loc[nxt, 'blocked_total']:,.0f} bn, {rk.loc[nxt, 'verdict']}), " f"by {rk.loc[k, 'blocked_total'] - rk.loc[nxt, 'blocked_total']:,.0f} bn") first_out = next((c for c in cand if c not in picks), None) if k == picks[-1] and first_out: why += f"; the first shortage left out is {first_out} {rk.loc[first_out, 'shortage']} ({rk.loc[first_out, 'blocked_total']:,.0f} bn)" pick_rows.append(dict(shortage_id=k, shortage=rk.loc[k, "shortage"], category=rk.loc[k, "category"], main_layer=rk.loc[k, "main_layer"], rule=PICK_RULE_NOTE, blocked_total=rk.loc[k, "blocked_total"], blocked_low=rk.loc[k, "blocked_low"], blocked_high=rk.loc[k, "blocked_high"], verdict=rk.loc[k, "verdict"], label=rk.loc[k, "label"], solid_se=se, rank_all=rk.loc[k, "rank_all"], why=why)) PICKS = pd.DataFrame(pick_rows) # ---------------------------------------------------------------- agents (page column 1): headline numbers, v3/v4 where changed RB = rd(BL / "totals.csv").set_index("id") b4 = rd(A4 / "bottlenecks.csv").set_index("id") ins, nin = rd(BL / "inside_on_course.csv"), rd(BL / "not_inside.csv") cnt = lambda d, a: int(d.source_file.str.contains(a).sum()) nd = rd(V2 / "v1" / "agent3_needs" / "needs.csv").set_index("id") i6 = rd(A6 / "inputs.csv") ag = [ ("a1_in", cnt(ins, "agent1"), "E", "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv (Agent 1 rows), counted", "Agent 1 items already inside on course"), ("a1_all", cnt(ins, "agent1") + cnt(nin, "agent1"), "E", "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv + not_inside.csv (Agent 1 rows)", "Agent 1 items checked against on course"), ("a2_energy", num(RB.loc["T16", "value_ppp_bn"]), RB.loc["T16", "value_ppp_bn_label"], "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/totals.csv (T16)", "Output the fastest sourced energy supply can power in 2035"), ("a3_needs", len(nd), "E", "stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/needs.csv (rows)", "Human needs mapped"), ("a3_health", num(nd.loc["N08", "people_unmet_m"]), nd.loc["N08", "people_unmet_m_label"], "stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/needs.csv (N08)", "People lacking adequate health care (millions)"), ("a4_bind", int((b4.status == "binding").sum()), "E", "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (status = binding)", "Inputs binding at their fastest precedent (repaired Agent 4)"), ("a4_total", len(b4), "E", "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (rows)", "Inputs Agent 4 tested"), ("a4_blk", num(b4.loc["K18", "output_blocked_ppp_bn"]), b4.loc["K18", "output_blocked_ppp_bn_label"], "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K18 output_blocked_ppp_bn)", "Output the human workforce blocks (repaired Agent 4)"), ("a5_in", cnt(ins, "agent5"), "E", "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv (Agent 5 rows)", "Agent 5 capabilities already inside on course"), ("a5_caps", cnt(ins, "agent5") + cnt(nin, "agent5"), "E", "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv + not_inside.csv (Agent 5 rows)", "Agent 5 capabilities checked"), ("a6_reach3", int((i6.reach_3x == "yes").sum()), "E", "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/inputs.csv (reach_3x = yes)", "Inputs that reach 3x cheaper by 2035 (repaired Agent 6)"), ("a6_n", len(i6), "E", "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/inputs.csv (rows)", "Inputs Agent 6 priced"), ("a6_ach", num(ach.loc["TOTAL", "net_created_ppp_bn"]), ach.loc["TOTAL", "net_created_ppp_bn_label"], "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv (achievable TOTAL)", "Output created at sourced input prices, net of on course"), ] pd.DataFrame(ag, columns=["key", "value", "label", "src", "what"]).to_csv(V4 / "agents_v4.csv", index=False) # ---------------------------------------------------------------- write lay_out = L.copy() lay_out.insert(0, "layer", [LAYER_NAME[j] for j in L.index]) lay_out["src"] = "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)" lay_out.to_csv(V4 / "layers_v4.csv") VR.to_csv(V4 / "variants_v4.csv", index=False) OB.to_csv(V4 / "own_blocks_v4.csv", index=False) SH.to_csv(V4 / "shortages_v4.csv") ROWS.to_csv(V4 / "rows_v4.csv", index=False) UNE.to_csv(V4 / "unexplained_v4.csv", index=False) rk.to_csv(V4 / "ranking_v4.csv") PICKS.to_csv(V4 / "picks_v4.csv", index=False) pd.DataFrame([dict(id=s, scenario=d) for s, d in SCEN.items()]).to_csv(V4 / "work" / "scenarios_v4.csv", index=False) if __name__ == "__main__": print(L[["target", "today", "growth", "tier1", "tier2"]].sum().round(1).to_dict()) print(SH[["blocked_tier2", "blocked_tier1", "blocked_total", "blocked_low", "blocked_high", "verdict", "label", "share_met_precedent", "main_layer"]].round(2).sort_values("blocked_total", ascending=False).to_string()) print("explained", ROWS.explained_bn.sum().round(1), "unexplained", ROWS.unexplained_bn.sum().round(1), "missing", sum(MISS.values()).round(1)) print(demand[["layer_id", "income_elasticity", "price_ratio_2035", "demand_2035", "target", "buyers_short"]].round(3).to_string()) print(PICKS.to_string() if len(PICKS) else "NO PICKS MEET THE RULES") UPSTREAM INPUT MANIFEST [ { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/bridge/gap_by_layer.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v2/v1/bridge/gap_by_layer.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v2/v1/bridge/gap_by_layer.csv", "bytes": 15696, "sha256": "faa1bf4e8568526a2f0642509be56f8c92e3b2cd0a0331fc2580092b639cd992" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/bridge/bridge_macro.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v2/v1/bridge/bridge_macro.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v2/v1/bridge/bridge_macro.csv", "bytes": 4805, "sha256": "3eee9d05599a90ab8589e221b4c5872851c4c532cddef5f2f24ffb02edc5201c" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/bridge/code/engel_check.py", "original_path": "stage1-v2/v1/bridge/code/engel_check.py", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v2/v1/bridge/code/engel_check.py", "bytes": 4902, "sha256": "c98634e4d0ee03d096ecddca7ad857e4b79b5054c6906ff0bedc53a408d9748e" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py", "original_path": "stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/requirements/code/model.py", "bytes": 32888, "sha256": "7561f8ae5f58ab0de92ab0134befce30b08f109d0d114e31aa6afa6db4e6741c" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/common.py", "original_path": "stage1-v3/requirements/code/common.py", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/requirements/code/common.py", "bytes": 5151, "sha256": "1cb2989c44f6d9e5f2a8aa15fe34cf07b8a25e9864db2859867b9bf42ba1db1e" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md", "original_path": "stage1-v3/requirements/report.md", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/requirements/report.md", "bytes": 38440, "sha256": "0b827e3dfabfd0e5ef7c025844b064dba4f2273edc5e9ef5be0983138abb0892" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/blocked_by_layer.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/blocked_by_layer.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/blocked_by_layer.csv", "bytes": 144274, "sha256": "483e039c3bebc9adb06d32d17fe049317b64f86132e631e4b4424be8ec9fce6c" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/needs.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/needs.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/needs.csv", "bytes": 20123, "sha256": "8d83a03c62b6bfe3e0360d4fff220dcc522513d46d2759ae0a1d8f97e2bca174" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv", "bytes": 221237, "sha256": "26955a78289f7ed369b5020ecc78df5754f0d8185673fb289bafb5c4c19c46fa" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv", "bytes": 267844, "sha256": "4673369c10a0e1c6160b9669085b5b2d25d77418a773c568914aba437031dd64" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv", "bytes": 9504, "sha256": "278761282f57f6bb54f9a952b8b80644ead1c30ff35faa9d352e7adad4a50eca" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv", "bytes": 1461341, "sha256": "a520466a29b5060e51aca844735b30ae8e77722a8d0396edb7b6ddf9fc0d908a" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/input_layer_v3.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/requirements/input_layer_v3.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/requirements/input_layer_v3.csv", "bytes": 2645448, "sha256": "ceb68d68d051176c554cec83774066e0407786e4904a728dc3d3b03aeb087a47" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py", "original_path": "stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py", "bytes": 17121, "sha256": "4771f100383e21c214660f034e8db76f0ed33117cbf826bccfa645c1107a443c" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/work/landcap.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/requirements/work/landcap.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/requirements/work/landcap.csv", "bytes": 1574, "sha256": "0a82ed4acc6ee51c52bb82891f9f134d95a839ba14e644b61a1b25517fe696ba" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv", "bytes": 86173, "sha256": "d199f9c5258564590ac80d97809e10515e24c1f1ce9af480296f5ecdd665f6ea" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/sources.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/requirements/sources.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/requirements/sources.csv", "bytes": 21248, "sha256": "79c59d000a691e3e7666243bb28741d596d363dfa1d8174556a6fc44d7108f90" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv", "bytes": 26441, "sha256": "0850930e2c2f4b64ede6ec48660c146b5c88aac6e55b0853e3fdb4cf73d6c963" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv", "bytes": 18087, "sha256": "0ff2e760112bc5ef5126922196d9b4c3641742a9ef499a7846ba6b3ade937108" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv", "bytes": 6493, "sha256": "234058a5ca889862bec03baf2bdde83e515a5c0aea97366aa34287aa34a55fb3" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/totals.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/totals.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/totals.csv", "bytes": 9912, "sha256": "f4d96d6090efad6d59649cb9eb8f2840a221c49ac5ee519db9eb56a37685f37f" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv", "bytes": 24340, "sha256": "53aca86c638f1a98a402d0f8b40f2ff59f897c6aeca7e6e2ed1962142d00ede0" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/not_inside.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/not_inside.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/not_inside.csv", "bytes": 10854, "sha256": "72f1421d9a88c23ed2f5434094d33901068ae1c394e2c6e3ee5d79da2ef66136" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/drivers.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/drivers.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/repair/baseline/drivers.csv", "bytes": 33089, "sha256": "414c7e5bf930f4f951066a85fe15b05cce10c36cb5daf88e59ec29f49fa51484" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv", "bytes": 83558, "sha256": "446042a350f5b57120b5d5acc6f71d2cfc71738aff2a1102b75d76760d122e1e" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json", "original_path": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json", "bytes": 14590, "sha256": "4851065d437280be9e965c78410faaf3c990f4d2d3a9326e8b7e7c9189466cde" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv", "bytes": 217358, "sha256": "3a333325b50fbf87ffe7a98657ef5142bbc0630760f1f914ddf79fcba896fe10" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv", "bytes": 33507, "sha256": "22ed086e657ff2fe8eb969184e62f57c8d99c4d868cfecc174295a45e9b2bd1b" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/inputs.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/inputs.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/inputs.csv", "bytes": 9293, "sha256": "6d331116def0f474c5eea43bb85fe8e049770b40057780957d74824d9a2fd9fd" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/repair/sources.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v3/repair/sources.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v3/repair/sources.csv", "bytes": 5145, "sha256": "d775a32c825a630f361ec0b34bda0981f946a2ec3abb70a73b18cbeb7db25d6d" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v2/agent4_bottlenecks/sources.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v2/agent4_bottlenecks/sources.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v2/agent4_bottlenecks/sources.csv", "bytes": 51388, "sha256": "63e2e62744f16c04005b9383b5dcedaf7e75c7ce555894d42290c03d0c3ae230" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v2/agent6_cheap_inputs/sources.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v2/agent6_cheap_inputs/sources.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v2/agent6_cheap_inputs/sources.csv", "bytes": 21240, "sha256": "1643fca620eed10ed61e1115d473f887e30ea4172d58c769aa107531550228c8" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v2/baseline/sources.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v2/baseline/sources.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v2/baseline/sources.csv", "bytes": 16688, "sha256": "c333cedb4c4023cf73567045dbda24217cc1c317e7d8d261ebebc90198d3f608" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/agent1_frontier/sources.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v2/v1/agent1_frontier/sources.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v2/v1/agent1_frontier/sources.csv", "bytes": 85641, "sha256": "06c91d2c2d92c741f739855c59e70949a549680ff7e759fed22328c0447a2214" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/agent2_ratios/sources.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v2/v1/agent2_ratios/sources.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v2/v1/agent2_ratios/sources.csv", "bytes": 71827, "sha256": "94a8de3ba4aff5ad70ebfa4d5bb2bdd05554abe4ba5528decedab3b60d8eacb2" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/sources.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/sources.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/sources.csv", "bytes": 53928, "sha256": "07b19ea248592b0b343579fda4745813d5d450ec71811c743d42ec6f3483782b" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/agent4_bottlenecks/sources.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v2/v1/agent4_bottlenecks/sources.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v2/v1/agent4_bottlenecks/sources.csv", "bytes": 76650, "sha256": "f53bd709a92aeb297abaab864f642563eaa8efdce4012a698fd93432ac85ff07" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/agent5_newcaps/sources.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v2/v1/agent5_newcaps/sources.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v2/v1/agent5_newcaps/sources.csv", "bytes": 31251, "sha256": "d5c7fb0cc8704d7bf79ae022559c385e48e43b4b66bd8a3251d8c27b6202ee4d" }, { "path": "data/inputs/stage1-v2/v1/bridge/sources.csv", "original_path": "stage1-v2/v1/bridge/sources.csv", "source_url": "https://github.com/sukanthoriginal/abundance-machines-v2/blob/efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445/stage1-v2/v1/bridge/sources.csv", "bytes": 2098, "sha256": "d45f3954aeeda5fd8e8d4675412e093893be3d8b0ce228da96f19c8a417bb911" } ]