Shortages
Clinical approval
Clinical approval is the health output that the model assumes can be provided under the relevant approval constraints.
What-if model · Chosen targets, conditional projections and calculated gaps.
Conditional constraint- Calculated output blocked
- $19.6Tin this scenario, one constraint
- Range across tested cases
- $4.9T – $19.6T3 cases; not a probability interval
This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result.
What is being compared?
The base case uses the value of health output allowed as a proxy for approval throughput. Two alternatives use a study's share of health-spending growth attributed to technology to estimate how much growth needs newly approved products. Applying that spending relationship to approval capacity is part of the model's interpretation.
| Quantity | 2035 amount |
|---|---|
| Needed for the full target | 51,080.9 |
| Supply on course | 30,435.4 |
| Supply at precedent | 32,810.9 |
All three use the same input unit — bn 2026 int$ of health output (C05) that must be allowed in 2035.
Show the shortage calculation
Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement.
| Supply path | Input shortfall | Full-target need met |
|---|---|---|
| On course | 20,645.5 | 59.6% |
| At precedent | 18,270.0 | 64.2% |
The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below.
Source files · shortages_v4.csv
How this becomes blocked output
The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage.
$18.3T tier 2 + $1.3T tier 1 = $19.6T blocked
The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed.
Understand the allocation and its limitsSee the affected layers
| Layer | Base output blocked |
|---|---|
| Health care | $19.6T |
Other shortages can block these same amounts. Removing a single constraint leaves the other constraints to be tested.
Source files · own_blocks_v4.csv
What changes the answer?
Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows.
| Case | What changes | Output blocked |
|---|---|---|
| base | v3 ratio: identity | $19.6T |
| techshare_low | only 27% of health output growth beyond the current-rule path comes from new technology needing approval; the rest is more of approved care | $4.9T |
| techshare_high | only 48% of health output growth beyond the current-rule path comes from new technology needing approval; the rest is more of approved care | $8.8T |
See its reported rank in each scenario
| Scenario | Rank | Output blocked |
|---|---|---|
| base | 5 | $19.6T |
| AI takes cognitive tasks first | 9 | $19.6T |
| humans keep cognitive tasks | 5 | $19.6T |
| labour productivity on trend | 5 | $19.6T |
| v3 second sourced ratios | 4 | $19.6T |
| 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | 10 | $19.6T |
| land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | 11 | $4.9T |
The published ranking takes the first matching variant for each scenario. Clinical approval and cropland each have a second S6 variant that appears in the range above and is omitted from those ranking columns.
Read every scenarioGrowth and the historical comparison
Further health output is workforce (2010-19) and productivity (2015-24) precedents achieved under current approval rules (BL C05-F1, C05-F2); new products not needed
| Rate | Annual growth |
|---|---|
| Needed to reach the target input | 9.0% |
| Implied by precedent supply | 3.8% |
The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035.
Sources and exact values
Source files · shortages_v4.csv · variants_v4.csv · own_blocks_v4.csv
base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)
techshare_low · searches_v4.csv W2 (Smith, Newhouse, Freeland 2009)
techshare_high · searches_v4.csv W2 (Smith, Newhouse, Freeland 2009)
Open the input files and source registries