Shortages

Rare earths

Magnet rare earths are material inputs used in some motors, generators and other equipment.

What-if model · Chosen targets, conditional projections and calculated gaps.

Conditional constraint
Calculated output blocked
$0bnin this scenario, one constraint
Range across tested cases
$0bn – $0bn3 cases; not a probability interval

This is a conditional test of the chosen target economy. It does not predict how much GDP will be lost. Changing the target mix, supply assumptions or production method can change the result.

[A] Assumednot tested (blocks 1T or less)UNTESTED

What is being compared?

The requirement is measured in rare-earth-element content. The model uses the inherited substitution approximation when translating the material shortfall into output.

Quantity2035 amount
Needed for the full target213.0
Supply on course136.4
Supply at precedent709.6

All three use the same input unit — kt magnet rare earth elements per year.

Show the shortage calculation

Input shortage = maximum of zero and requirement minus supply. Coverage = supply ÷ requirement.

Supply pathInput shortfallFull-target need met
On course76.764.0%
At precedent0.0333.1%

The physical shortfall and the blocked-output amount use different units. The model converts between them using each layer's input requirements and the allocation described below.

Source files · shortages_v4.csv

How this becomes blocked output

The model asks two questions. With the whole target attempted, how much tier-2 output must be removed at precedent input supply? With only on-course output and tier 1 attempted, how much tier-1 output must be removed at on-course supply? It adds the resulting tier-2 and tier-1 blocks for this shortage.

$0bn tier 2 + $0bn tier 1 = $0bn blocked

The allocation drops eligible output from the model's most input-intensive layers first and protects the on-course baseline. The ordering is fixed within a test. Labour-dependent requirements are recalculated as output is removed.

Understand the allocation and its limits

What changes the answer?

Each row recomputes the constraint under a different production or demand assumption. The displayed range takes the smallest and largest output blocks across all these rows.

CaseWhat changesOutput blocked
basev3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)$0bn
v3altv3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)$0bn
today2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.84 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)$0bn
Assumption behind the verdict

v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion); v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion); 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.84 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)

What evidence would improve this?

IEA Critical Minerals Data Explorer magnet rare-earth end-use split; non-China separation capacity under construction

Growth and the historical comparison

World rare-earth mine output 1960-1969 x7.97 in 9 years (USGS via OWID)

RateAnnual growth
Needed to reach the target input10.2%
Implied by precedent supply25.9%

The growth comparison uses a nine-year interval from 2026 to 2035.

Sources and exact values

Source files · shortages_v4.csv · variants_v4.csv · own_blocks_v4.csv

base · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035); input_layer_v3.csv (missing, output_depending_ppp_bn)

v3alt · stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)

today · stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K08 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)

Open the input files and source registries

Copy this prompt

Copy the selected text using your keyboard or touch menu, then paste it into your assistant.