What changes between scenarios? https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/scenarios.html The model tries different ways of producing the target output and different historical demand responses. Alternatives change one shortage's production or demand calculation. The seven reported scenario columns group these alternatives. Where a shortage has no matching variant, the ranking uses its base case. | ID | Scenario | S0 | base | S1 | AI takes cognitive tasks first | S2 | humans keep cognitive tasks | S3 | labour productivity on trend | S4 | v3 second sourced ratios | S5 | 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | S6 | land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation The two S6 endpoints for cropland and clinical approval share an ID. The published ranking chooses the first one. The tables below include every evaluated alternative. S0 · base | Input | Alternative | Output blocked | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $13.1T | Fuels (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k02.html) | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE) | $0bn | Machine cognition (AI agents) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k03.html) | v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $0bn | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $61.7T | AI compute (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k05.html) | v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $0bn | Copper (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k06.html) | v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $166bn | Lithium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k07.html) | v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn | Rare earths (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k08.html) | v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn | Steel (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k09.html) | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE material efficiency) | $0bn | Cement (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k10.html) | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE) | $0bn | Saving for investment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k11.html) | v3 ratio: identity (investment = saving at market prices); no ratio to improve | $13.3T | Building permission (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k12.html) | v3 ratio: identity | $1.1T | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $13.1T | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share | $32.4T | Clinical approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k15.html) | v3 ratio: identity | $19.6T | Professional licensing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k16.html) | v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent | $13.8T | Construction trades (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k17.html) | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (fastest sourced productivity) | $16.0T | Human workforce (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k18.html) | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (fastest sourced productivity) | $0bn | Aluminium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k20.html) | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE) | $7.5T | Capital stock (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html) | v3 ratio: today's ratio held (only today's is sourced) | $43.7T | Cropland (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html) | v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (fastest sourced yield growth) | $19.8T | Buyers for built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c13.html) | demand at the 2035 price from the sourced income response (UN AMA world 2014-2024) | $8.5T | Buyers for public services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c12.html) | demand at the 2035 price from the sourced income response (UN AMA world 2014-2024) | $826bn S1 · AI takes cognitive tasks first | Input | Alternative | Output blocked | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $34.8T | Machine cognition (AI agents) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k03.html) | AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $34.8T | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $1.1T | AI compute (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k05.html) | AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $34.8T | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $34.8T | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them | $42.6T | Professional licensing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k16.html) | AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent | $25.4T S2 · humans keep cognitive tasks | Input | Alternative | Output blocked | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $13.1T | Machine cognition (AI agents) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k03.html) | humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $0bn | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $62.3T | AI compute (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k05.html) | humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $0bn | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $13.1T | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap | $30.4T | Professional licensing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k16.html) | humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent | $12.6T S3 · labour productivity on trend | Input | Alternative | Output blocked | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $13.3T | Machine cognition (AI agents) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k03.html) | v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $0bn | Physical machine labour (robots) (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k04.html) | v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $102.5T | AI compute (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k05.html) | v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $0bn | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $13.3T | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth | $33.8T | Professional licensing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k16.html) | v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent | $16.5T | Human workforce (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k18.html) | humans' share of work with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of the fastest 9-year growth | $10.0T S4 · v3 second sourced ratios | Input | Alternative | Output blocked | Electricity (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k01.html) | IEA STEPS 2035 footprint (v3 second ratio) + machine-labour electricity (v3 split) | $254bn | Fuels (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k02.html) | v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) | $7.2T | Copper (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k06.html) | v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $144bn | Lithium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k07.html) | v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn | Rare earths (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k08.html) | v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn | Steel (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k09.html) | v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) | $0bn | Cement (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k10.html) | v3 second ratio: Agent 4 rerun: 2026 intensity held outside C13; C13 at the baseline on-course tonnes per unit of value | $0bn | Grid connection approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k13.html) | IEA STEPS 2035 footprint (v3 second ratio) + machine-labour electricity (v3 split) | $254bn | Transformers and grid equipment (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k14.html) | IEA STEPS 2035 footprint (v3 second ratio) + machine-labour electricity (v3 split) | $5.5T | Construction trades (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k17.html) | v3 second ratio: construction output per worker on its 2014-24 trend (Agent 4 rerun) | $25.4T | Aluminium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k20.html) | v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 aluminium per unit of GDP (WEO 2025 A.5b) | $6.4T | Capital stock (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html) | v3 second ratio: lowest world capital-output ratio 1990-2023 (PWT, 2005): best demonstrated, the low case | $0bn | Cropland (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html) | v3 second ratio: crop output per ha on its 2014-24 trend | $138.5T | Buyers for built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c13.html) | demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.96) | $0bn | Buyers for public services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c12.html) | demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.91) | $1.3T S5 · 2026 intensities / K-Y trend | Input | Alternative | Output blocked | Fuels (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k02.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.62 the v3 ratio | $71.8T | Copper (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k06.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.10 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $283bn | Lithium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k07.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.53 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn | Rare earths (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k08.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.84 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion) | $0bn | Steel (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k09.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.29 the v3 ratio | $18.9T | Cement (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k10.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.35 the v3 ratio | $0.0m | Construction trades (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k17.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.08 the v3 ratio | $29.8T | Human workforce (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k18.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.69 the v3 ratio | $180.8T | Aluminium (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k20.html) | 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.12 the v3 ratio | $34.8T | Capital stock (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k21.html) | capital-output ratio on its 2013-23 trend: x1.096 today's (PWT capital growth 3.82% vs UN AMA GDP growth 3.03%) | $80.5T | Buyers for built structures (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c13.html) | demand from the UN AMA world income response 1994-2004 (elasticity 0.49) | $29.7T | Buyers for public services (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-buy-c12.html) | demand from the UN AMA world income response 1994-2004 (elasticity 0.76) | $4.4T S6 · land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation | Input | Alternative | Output blocked | Clinical approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k15.html) | only 27% of health output growth beyond the current-rule path comes from new technology needing approval; the rest is more of approved care | $4.9T | Clinical approval (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k15.html) | only 48% of health output growth beyond the current-rule path comes from new technology needing approval; the rest is more of approved care | $8.8T | Professional licensing (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k16.html) | humans take the licensed tasks first, machines the rest: licensing binds only if licensed work exceeds all human work | $0bn | Cropland (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html) | yield gaps closed to attainable yields: crop output per ha +45% on 2026 (x0.885 the v3 ratio) | $5.9T | Cropland (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/guide/shortage-k22.html) | yield gaps closed to attainable yields: crop output per ha +70% on 2026 (x0.755 the v3 ratio) | $806bn Source files · variants_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/variants_v4.csv) · ranking_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/ranking_v4.csv) · scenarios_v4.csv (https://metamachine.sukanthoriginal.com/data/scenarios_v4.csv)