{
  "title": "Abundance Machines Stage 1 v4",
  "model_source_revision": "efd3242414ee93c4b70024fd7bb007fdeb174445",
  "scope": "The committed v4 calculation and explanatory website.",
  "totals": {
    "today": 224261.881,
    "target": 448523.7620258,
    "growth": 41357.0028828,
    "tier1": 34757.309,
    "tier2": 148147.569116,
    "missing": 182904.878116,
    "unexplained": 41470.79140348271,
    "explained": 141434.08671251728
  },
  "units": "billion 2026 international dollars (PPP), annual output",
  "terminology": {
    "GDP": "The value of final goods and services produced in a period. The model measures annual world output.",
    "2026 PPP dollars": "A common purchasing-power unit used to compare output across economies, valued at the model's 2026 price basis.",
    "Constant prices": "A fixed price basis for comparing production across years.",
    "T": "One trillion. Displayed output amounts divide the CSV's billions by 1,000.",
    "bn": "One billion. The default unit for model output amounts in the v4 CSVs is billion 2026 international dollars.",
    "Target": "A chosen what-if scenario: double the model's 2026 world-output estimate and allocate that total among sectors using a selected spending rule. Sector targets are choices, not demand forecasts.",
    "On course": "A conditional baseline projection for 2035: today's output plus on-course growth, if the model's assumptions hold. It is not a guaranteed outcome.",
    "On-course growth": "The projected increase above today's output under the baseline assumptions. It excludes both calculated tier gaps.",
    "Tier 1": "Extra output that inputs growing at the model's record pace would make. Closing this gap takes building and scaling up what people already know how to do. The amount adds to the conditional baseline and is capped at each chosen sector target.",
    "Tier 2": "Extra output beyond the model's historical benchmarks. Reaching the doubling target calls for discoveries that cut the inputs needed per unit of output or break a historical speed limit. The amount is the gap left after baseline growth and tier 1. Today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = target.",
    "S": "Sourced. A value read from a source.",
    "E": "Estimated from sourced inputs. The calculation or interpretation introduces modelling choices.",
    "A": "Assumed. At least part of the estimate depends on an assumption.",
    "SOLID": "The reported constraint binds across the production alternatives tested. K11 saving has an explicit accounting-identity exemption and only one tested case.",
    "SCENARIO": "The constraint depends on a production assumption, or has insufficient alternative tests. Some longer verdicts flag cases that exceed the testing threshold only in another variant.",
    "UNTESTED": "The size or rate depends on an assumption and carries a proposed test. This status can coexist with SOLID.",
    "TESTED": "The exported label indicates that the size was classified as sourced or estimated. The underlying claim is still conditional on the model and its inputs.",
    "Scenario range": "The lowest and highest blocked-output estimates among the alternatives evaluated for that shortage.",
    "Worker-equivalent": "An estimate of annual work capacity expressed relative to a human worker. Conversions from machines to this unit depend on productivity assumptions.",
    "Elasticity": "A measure of the proportional response of one quantity to a proportional change in another, used here for income, prices and substitution.",
    "Precedent": "A historical rate or ratio selected as a demonstrated comparison. Applying it to the world and to a new period is a modelling choice."
  },
  "number_roles": {
    "today": {
      "label": "Estimate today",
      "meaning": "An estimate of annual output at the 2026 starting point."
    },
    "baseline": {
      "label": "Conditional projection",
      "meaning": "The 2035 baseline if the model's trend, adoption and input assumptions hold. This is what on course means here."
    },
    "target": {
      "label": "Chosen scenario",
      "meaning": "A goal and a chosen mix of sectors to test. It is not a prediction of future output or demand."
    },
    "comparison": {
      "label": "Historical-benchmark comparison",
      "meaning": "A conditional calculation using selected past production, employment, productivity or investment rates, proxies and input constraints. These examples need not have occurred together. Accounting rows use bookkeeping assumptions. This is not a physical limit or a guaranteed achievable path."
    },
    "gap": {
      "label": "Calculated gap",
      "meaning": "A difference between the chosen target and the model's comparison levels. Changing the target or assumptions changes the gap."
    },
    "constraint": {
      "label": "Conditional constraint",
      "meaning": "Output removed when testing one shortage in the chosen scenario. It is not a forecast of lost GDP, and different shortages can overlap."
    }
  },
  "sector_target_choices": [
    {
      "layer_id": "C01",
      "income_response_factor": 0.62377,
      "basis": "estimated household response",
      "chosen_target": 21195.60452,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 25180.124,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "C02",
      "income_response_factor": 0.96519,
      "basis": "estimated household response",
      "chosen_target": 6517.162464,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 6777.194,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "C03",
      "income_response_factor": 1.06403,
      "basis": "estimated household response",
      "chosen_target": 59177.23267,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 59200.652,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "C04",
      "income_response_factor": 1.04856,
      "basis": "estimated household response",
      "chosen_target": 7633.719426,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 7683.212,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "C05",
      "income_response_factor": 1.27974,
      "basis": "estimated household response",
      "chosen_target": 51080.94924,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 46946.982,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "C06",
      "income_response_factor": 1.1503,
      "basis": "estimated household response",
      "chosen_target": 17804.91767,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 17218.828,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "C07",
      "income_response_factor": 1.15354,
      "basis": "estimated household response",
      "chosen_target": 8878.970034,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 8575.774,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "C08",
      "income_response_factor": 1.35079,
      "basis": "estimated household response",
      "chosen_target": 13339.93155,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 11921.762,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "C09",
      "income_response_factor": 0.91796,
      "basis": "estimated household response",
      "chosen_target": 31578.51396,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 33450.902,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "C10",
      "income_response_factor": 1.31251,
      "basis": "estimated household response",
      "chosen_target": 13288.4201,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 12056.318,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "C11",
      "income_response_factor": 1.31251,
      "basis": "estimated household response",
      "chosen_target": 34976.03323,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 31733.056,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "C12",
      "income_response_factor": 1.0,
      "basis": "default outside household demand",
      "chosen_target": 34091.12052,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 34971.398,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "C13",
      "income_response_factor": 1.0,
      "basis": "default outside household demand",
      "chosen_target": 105727.507,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 108457.53,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "C14",
      "income_response_factor": 1.0,
      "basis": "default outside household demand",
      "chosen_target": 13746.63192,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 14101.588,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "C15",
      "income_response_factor": 1.0,
      "basis": "default outside household demand",
      "chosen_target": 14052.69497,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 14415.554,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "U1",
      "income_response_factor": 1.0,
      "basis": "default outside household demand",
      "chosen_target": 7008.858084,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 7189.836,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "U2",
      "income_response_factor": 1.0,
      "basis": "default outside household demand",
      "chosen_target": -266.7131172,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": -273.6,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "U3",
      "income_response_factor": 1.0,
      "basis": "default outside household demand",
      "chosen_target": 4402.944201,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 4516.634,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    },
    {
      "layer_id": "U4",
      "income_response_factor": 1.0,
      "basis": "default outside household demand",
      "chosen_target": 4289.263584,
      "alternative_every_sector_doubles": 4400.018,
      "source": "data/inputs/stage1-v3/requirements/target_economy.csv"
    }
  ],
  "limitations": [
    "This is a what-if analysis. The doubling goal and sector mix are chosen scenarios, not forecasts. On course is a conditional baseline projection; tiers are calculated gaps and shortage blocks are conditional input tests.",
    "Sector targets use estimated spending-response factors for household categories and a default of 1 outside them. The original target labels are E even where that default assumption enters. Choosing another mix changes targets, gaps and requirements.",
    "Own shortage blocks overlap. The model credits the maximum block within each layer/tier, which assumes smaller blocks are contained within it.",
    "The six picks include only two SOLID S/E entries. The code relaxes the brief's minimum of three.",
    "Saving and building permission exceed $1T and have no alternative tests. The code labels saving SOLID under an accounting-identity exemption.",
    "Clinical approval and cropland each have two S6 variants. The ranking columns take the first, while the ranges include both.",
    "The allocation protects on-course output and uses a fixed ordering. Remaining input shortfalls are recorded in diagnostic fields.",
    "Buyer demand assumes target world income. Construction and public services have price elasticity set to zero.",
    "Source registries preserve the original citations. This website build does not constitute a fresh verification of those publications."
  ],
  "schema": "data/schema.json",
  "source_manifest": "data/manifest.json",
  "datasets": {
    "layers": [
      {
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "layer": "Food at home",
        "target": 21195.60452,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 12590.062,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 14055.848,
        "on_course_label": "A",
        "growth": 1465.786,
        "growth_label": "A",
        "tier1": 1238.149,
        "tier1_label": "A",
        "tier2": 5901.607524,
        "tier2_label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "layer": "Clothing",
        "target": 6517.162464,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 3388.597,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 4382.246,
        "on_course_label": "A",
        "growth": 993.6489999999999,
        "growth_label": "A",
        "tier1": 447.477,
        "tier1_label": "A",
        "tier2": 1687.439464,
        "tier2_label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "layer": "Shelter and utilities",
        "target": 59177.23267,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 29600.326,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 34080.671,
        "on_course_label": "A",
        "growth": 4480.345000000001,
        "growth_label": "A",
        "tier1": 627.119,
        "tier1_label": "A",
        "tier2": 24469.44267,
        "tier2_label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "layer": "Household equipment",
        "target": 7633.719426,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 3841.606,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 4871.131,
        "on_course_label": "A",
        "growth": 1029.525,
        "growth_label": "A",
        "tier1": 1458.705,
        "tier1_label": "A",
        "tier2": 1303.883426,
        "tier2_label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "layer": "Health care",
        "target": 51080.94924,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 23473.491,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 29998.021,
        "on_course_label": "A",
        "growth": 6524.529999999999,
        "growth_label": "A",
        "tier1": 1766.768,
        "tier1_label": "A",
        "tier2": 19316.16024,
        "tier2_label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "layer": "Mobility",
        "target": 17804.91767,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 8609.414,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 9477.227,
        "on_course_label": "A",
        "growth": 867.8130000000001,
        "growth_label": "A",
        "tier1": 5345.213,
        "tier1_label": "A",
        "tier2": 2982.477665,
        "tier2_label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C07",
        "layer": "Communication",
        "target": 8878.970034,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 4287.887,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 5285.868,
        "on_course_label": "A",
        "growth": 997.9810000000007,
        "growth_label": "A",
        "tier1": 82.515,
        "tier1_label": "A",
        "tier2": 3510.587034,
        "tier2_label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "layer": "Recreation",
        "target": 13339.93155,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 5960.881,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 6271.781,
        "on_course_label": "A",
        "growth": 310.89999999999964,
        "growth_label": "A",
        "tier1": 1565.762,
        "tier1_label": "A",
        "tier2": 5502.388547,
        "tier2_label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C09",
        "layer": "Education",
        "target": 31578.51396,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 16725.451,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 19888.256,
        "on_course_label": "A",
        "growth": 3162.8050000000003,
        "growth_label": "A",
        "tier1": 2449.752,
        "tier1_label": "A",
        "tier2": 9240.505965,
        "tier2_label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "layer": "Food service, lodging",
        "target": 13288.4201,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 6028.159,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 7631.84,
        "on_course_label": "A",
        "growth": 1603.6810000000005,
        "growth_label": "A",
        "tier1": 1434.025,
        "tier1_label": "A",
        "tier2": 4222.555095,
        "tier2_label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "layer": "Personal and financial services",
        "target": 34976.03323,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 15866.528,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 19233.678,
        "on_course_label": "A",
        "growth": 3367.1499999999996,
        "growth_label": "A",
        "tier1": 1882.514,
        "tier1_label": "A",
        "tier2": 13859.84123,
        "tier2_label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "layer": "Public services",
        "target": 34091.12052,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 17485.699,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 19921.289,
        "on_course_label": "A",
        "growth": 2435.59,
        "growth_label": "A",
        "tier1": 2998.156,
        "tier1_label": "A",
        "tier2": 11171.67552,
        "tier2_label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "layer": "Built structures",
        "target": 105727.507,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 54228.765,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 62411.018,
        "on_course_label": "A",
        "growth": 8182.252999999997,
        "growth_label": "A",
        "tier1": 8677.18,
        "tier1_label": "A",
        "tier2": 34639.30898,
        "tier2_label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "layer": "Productive equipment",
        "target": 13746.63192,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 7050.794,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 8889.045,
        "on_course_label": "A",
        "growth": 1838.2510000000002,
        "growth_label": "A",
        "tier1": 3353.131,
        "tier1_label": "A",
        "tier2": 1504.455918,
        "tier2_label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "layer": "Knowledge and software",
        "target": 14052.69497,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 7207.777,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 11150.057,
        "on_course_label": "A",
        "growth": 3942.2800000000007,
        "growth_label": "A",
        "tier1": 1341.365,
        "tier1_label": "A",
        "tier2": 1561.272969,
        "tier2_label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "layer": "Alcohol, tobacco, narcotics",
        "target": 7008.858084,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 3594.918,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 3911.745,
        "on_course_label": "A",
        "growth": 316.82699999999977,
        "growth_label": "A",
        "tier1": 57.028,
        "tier1_label": "A",
        "tier2": 3040.085084,
        "tier2_label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "U2",
        "layer": "Net purchases abroad",
        "target": -266.7131172,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": -136.8,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": -266.7131172,
        "on_course_label": "E",
        "growth": -129.9131172,
        "growth_label": "E",
        "tier1": 0.0,
        "tier1_label": "E",
        "tier2": 0.0,
        "tier2_label": "E",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "layer": "Inventories",
        "target": 4402.944201,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 2258.317,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 2225.867,
        "on_course_label": "A",
        "growth": -32.44999999999982,
        "growth_label": "A",
        "tier1": 32.45,
        "tier1_label": "A",
        "tier2": 2144.627201,
        "tier2_label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "U4",
        "layer": "Net exports",
        "target": 4289.263584,
        "target_label": "E",
        "today": 2200.009,
        "today_label": "E",
        "on_course": 2200.009,
        "on_course_label": "E",
        "growth": 0.0,
        "growth_label": "E",
        "tier1": 0.0,
        "tier1_label": "E",
        "tier2": 2089.254584,
        "tier2_label": "E",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/layers_v3.csv; stage1-v3/repair/baseline/layers.csv (today)"
      }
    ],
    "shortages": [
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "shortage": "Electricity",
        "category": "energy",
        "unit": "TWh per year (gross generation)",
        "need_2035": 74059.01810670001,
        "supply_on_course": 44274.0,
        "supply_precedent": 93251.9,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.5978205103423401,
        "share_met_precedent": 1.2591565805753457,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 29785.01810670001,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 13052.02480714768,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 13052.02480714768,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 254.2228150095216,
        "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994,
        "n_alternatives": 4.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "IEA WEO-2026 Annex A (STEPS generation 2035) and Ember monthly 2026 generation; IEA World Energy Balances by final-demand sector to replace the EXIOBASE monetary electricity multiplier",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.09470307265246425,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.12309451993046494,
        "times_faster": 0.7693524675668845,
        "fastest_precedent": "China 2002-2011: generation x2.84 in 9 years (Ember), applied to world 2026 supply; world fastest 9 years (OWID, 2001-10) x1.37 is the low case",
        "main_layer": "C06",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "shortage": "Fuels",
        "category": "energy",
        "unit": "EJ per year (final consumption excl. electricity)",
        "need_2035": 445.18773945600003,
        "supply_on_course": 374.0,
        "supply_precedent": 548.836,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.8400950135262297,
        "share_met_precedent": 1.2328192161595772,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 71.18773945600003,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 71782.99576593254,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)",
        "depends_on": "binds only under: v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun); 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.62 the v3 ratio",
        "label": "E",
        "status": "TESTED",
        "test": null,
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.023609314109906965,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.04769328840461373,
        "times_faster": 0.4950238261957013,
        "fastest_precedent": "World fossil-fuel consumption 1965-1974 x1.52 in 9 years (EI via OWID), the post-1965 maximum",
        "main_layer": null,
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "shortage": "Machine cognition (AI agents)",
        "category": "machines",
        "unit": "million worker-equivalents in 2035",
        "need_2035": 537.0604189395623,
        "supply_on_course": 310.266,
        "supply_precedent": 45732.6,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.5777115368371907,
        "share_met_precedent": 85.1535476963654,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 226.79441893956226,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994,
        "n_alternatives": 3.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)",
        "depends_on": "binds only under: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them",
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "Task-matched benchmark of agent-hours per human-hour on real jobs (GDPval/METR); Epoch agent-population update with 2028-30 shipments",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.17696584267992832,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.9285496803155593,
        "times_faster": 0.19058306349293885,
        "fastest_precedent": "AI chip power sold grew x1.87 in 2025 (Epoch), held 2028-2035 on top of the through-2027 fleet",
        "main_layer": null,
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "shortage": "Physical machine labour (robots)",
        "category": "machines",
        "unit": "million worker-equivalents in 2035",
        "need_2035": 1202.3194090922568,
        "supply_on_course": 32.7731,
        "supply_precedent": 42.8569,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.027258230842953347,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.03564518685792212,
        "short_at_precedent": 1159.4625090922568,
        "short_on_course": 1169.5463090922567,
        "blocked_tier2": 60005.09023066053,
        "blocked_tier1": 1646.5028954966801,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 21153.975000000002,
        "blocked_total": 61651.59312615721,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 1137.0283592863655,
        "blocked_high": 102480.36777547782,
        "n_alternatives": 3.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "Time-and-motion worker-equivalents of deployed humanoids; Counterpoint/IDC 2027 shipments to confirm the ramp",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.5974132099514471,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.10288056130378731,
        "times_faster": 5.806861883144243,
        "fastest_precedent": "China electric-car sales 2014-2023 x111 in 9 years (IEA via OWID) applied to humanoid shipments from 50k in 2026 (Counterpoint); industrial robots on the IFR 2026-29 forecast trend",
        "main_layer": "C11",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "shortage": "AI compute",
        "category": "machines",
        "unit": "GW of AI chip TDP in service in 2035",
        "need_2035": 146.27352256634808,
        "supply_on_course": 84.504,
        "supply_precedent": 12455.7,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.5777122100937297,
        "share_met_precedent": 85.15348356603793,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 61.76952256634807,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994,
        "n_alternatives": 3.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)",
        "depends_on": "binds only under: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them",
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "Epoch chip-sales update for 2027-28; TSMC CoWoS and HBM capacity plans to 2030",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.25536394631152937,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 1.0570108723255318,
        "times_faster": 0.2415906524686001,
        "fastest_precedent": "AI chip power sold x1.87 in 2025 (Epoch) held 2028-2035; bounded in practice by K01/K14 (power and grid)",
        "main_layer": null,
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K06",
        "shortage": "Copper",
        "category": "materials",
        "unit": "million t refined copper per year",
        "need_2035": 51.03882403,
        "supply_on_course": 26.5106,
        "supply_precedent": 45.4269,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.5194202747386458,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.8900459770252274,
        "short_at_precedent": 5.611924029999997,
        "short_on_course": 24.52822403,
        "blocked_tier2": 165.7467183780582,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 165.7467183780582,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 144.03696137609495,
        "blocked_high": 282.6403011266366,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "not tested (blocks 1T or less)",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "IEA Critical Minerals Data Explorer: copper STEPS 2035 demand, secondary supply and base/high-production mine supply in kt (replaces the 2030-40 interpolation and the held 18% secondary share)",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.06917554845780782,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.055426946841626634,
        "times_faster": 1.2480490519433725,
        "fastest_precedent": "World copper mine output 1954-1963 x1.625 in 9 years (USGS via OWID), post-1950 maximum; post-1985 maximum (1995-2004) x1.47 is the low case",
        "main_layer": "C14",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K07",
        "shortage": "Lithium",
        "category": "materials",
        "unit": "kt lithium content per year",
        "need_2035": 1208.28267,
        "supply_on_course": 452.919,
        "supply_precedent": 2301.24,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.37484523385574997,
        "share_met_precedent": 1.9045543374382747,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 755.3636700000001,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 0.0,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "not tested (blocks 1T or less)",
        "depends_on": "v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion); v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion); 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.53 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)",
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "IEA Critical Minerals Data Explorer lithium end-use split mapped to final demand (replaces the battery-product proxy A02)",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.15948252353702475,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.24552474179985384,
        "times_faster": 0.6495578505364289,
        "fastest_precedent": "World lithium mine output 2016-2025 x7.21 in 9 years (USGS via OWID)",
        "main_layer": null,
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K08",
        "shortage": "Rare earths",
        "category": "materials",
        "unit": "kt magnet rare earth elements per year",
        "need_2035": 213.0123662,
        "supply_on_course": 136.357,
        "supply_precedent": 709.648,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.6401365443355185,
        "share_met_precedent": 3.331487334090747,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 76.6553662,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 0.0,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "not tested (blocks 1T or less)",
        "depends_on": "v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion); v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion); 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.84 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)",
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "IEA Critical Minerals Data Explorer magnet rare-earth end-use split; non-China separation capacity under construction",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.10182534133158572,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.25945792660475964,
        "times_faster": 0.3924541549532208,
        "fastest_precedent": "World rare-earth mine output 1960-1969 x7.97 in 9 years (USGS via OWID)",
        "main_layer": null,
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K09",
        "shortage": "Steel",
        "category": "materials",
        "unit": "Mt crude steel per year",
        "need_2035": 2901.93264675,
        "supply_on_course": 2570.4,
        "supply_precedent": 3135.54,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.8857545342682926,
        "share_met_precedent": 1.0805006117256466,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 331.5326467499999,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 18927.55399354189,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)",
        "depends_on": "binds only under: 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.29 the v3 ratio",
        "label": "E",
        "status": "TESTED",
        "test": null,
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.05022424450517593,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.05929800117314343,
        "times_faster": 0.8469803958235765,
        "fastest_precedent": "World crude steel 2002-2011 x1.68 in 9 years (worldsteel Steel Statistical Yearbook 2012)",
        "main_layer": null,
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K10",
        "shortage": "Cement",
        "category": "materials",
        "unit": "Mt cement per year",
        "need_2035": 5589.70491443,
        "supply_on_course": 5428.57,
        "supply_precedent": 7528.7,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.9711729121846798,
        "share_met_precedent": 1.3468868420163689,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 161.1349144300002,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 2.0568407371335927e-07,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "not tested (blocks 1T or less)",
        "depends_on": "v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE); v3 second ratio: Agent 4 rerun: 2026 intensity held outside C13; C13 at the baseline on-course tonnes per unit of value; 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.35 the v3 ratio",
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "GCCA/USGS world cement capacity and clinker factor (replaces A03); USGS regional cement 2026",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.04490703690865905,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.08005973889230611,
        "times_faster": 0.5609191027848168,
        "fastest_precedent": "World cement 2002-2011 x2.00 in 9 years (USGS MCS 2004 and 2013)",
        "main_layer": null,
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K11",
        "shortage": "Saving for investment",
        "category": "capital",
        "unit": "bn US$ (market) of gross saving per year",
        "need_2035": 58368.093940000006,
        "supply_on_course": 37826.3,
        "supply_precedent": 87530.7,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.6480646779194791,
        "share_met_precedent": 1.499632660439074,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 20541.793940000003,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 13315.424574700748,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 13315.424574700748,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 13315.424574700748,
        "blocked_high": 13315.424574700748,
        "n_alternatives": 0.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": "accounting identity (saving = investment in C13-C15 at market prices): binds under every way of producing; rests on the on-course saving rate (2015-24 mean, A)",
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "IMF WEO saving and investment projections to 2031 (world saving rate path) to replace the held 2015-24 mean",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.07580152934450268,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.12534590268703316,
        "times_faster": 0.6047387885806357,
        "fastest_precedent": "China gross saving 51.3% of GDP (2008, World Bank) applied to world output at max; on course = world 2015-24 mean saving rate",
        "main_layer": "C13",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K12",
        "shortage": "Building permission",
        "category": "permission",
        "unit": "bn 2026 int$ of construction (C13) that must be permitted in 2035",
        "need_2035": 105727.507,
        "supply_on_course": 94403.39409,
        "supply_precedent": 104600.4637,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.892893408429653,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.9893401127863537,
        "short_at_precedent": 1127.0433000000048,
        "short_on_course": 11324.112909999996,
        "blocked_tier2": 1127.0432990000047,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 1127.0432990000047,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 1127.0432990000047,
        "blocked_high": 1127.0432990000047,
        "n_alternatives": 0.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO",
        "depends_on": "fewer than two sourced alternative ways found; rests on the base ratio",
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "Open the Auckland upzoning working paper (Greenaway-McGrevy and Phillips) and OECD housing-supply elasticities by metro weighted by ICP construction spend",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.07700459273700444,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.07572286962059604,
        "times_faster": 1.0169264995216158,
        "fastest_precedent": "Auckland 2016 upzoning (+50% consents within 5 years, A4:A05) in the 30% of construction under discretionary permission (A4:A04); outside it current rules permit any amount (Agent 4 capped that part at capacity)",
        "main_layer": "C13",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "shortage": "Grid connection approval",
        "category": "permission",
        "unit": "TWh per year of generation connected",
        "need_2035": 74059.01810670001,
        "supply_on_course": 44274.0,
        "supply_precedent": 87637.2,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.5978205103423401,
        "share_met_precedent": 1.1833427209868934,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 29785.01810670001,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 13052.02480714768,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 13052.02480714768,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 254.2228150095216,
        "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994,
        "n_alternatives": 4.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "ENTSO-E and LBNL completion rates by request year; IEA count of 2 800 GW waiting by region and age",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.09470307265246425,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.11537198187260045,
        "times_faster": 0.8208498381958989,
        "fastest_precedent": "US 2008 queue speed (22 months request-to-operation, LBNL) in queue-bound grids (US+EU share of 2025 generation); STEPS path assumed connected",
        "main_layer": "C06",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "shortage": "Transformers and grid equipment",
        "category": "machines",
        "unit": "TWh per year of generation the delivered transformers can connect",
        "need_2035": 74059.01810670001,
        "supply_on_course": 42553.3,
        "supply_precedent": 73055.4,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.574586337867613,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.986448401121737,
        "short_at_precedent": 1003.6181067000143,
        "short_on_course": 31505.718106700006,
        "blocked_tier2": 2084.4004939814517,
        "blocked_tier1": 30362.798827555125,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 32447.199321536576,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 5535.2869548039225,
        "blocked_high": 42579.2414163116,
        "n_alternatives": 4.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "World transformer manufacturing capacity by region (Wood Mackenzie / IEA grid supply-chain report) and order books to 2030",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.09470307265246425,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.09304472855017654,
        "times_faster": 1.0178230849627705,
        "fastest_precedent": "US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv magazine) used as the supply ramp from the STEPS addition rate",
        "main_layer": "C13",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K15",
        "shortage": "Clinical approval",
        "category": "permission",
        "unit": "bn 2026 int$ of health output (C05) that must be allowed in 2035",
        "need_2035": 51080.94924,
        "supply_on_course": 30435.4,
        "supply_precedent": 32810.9,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.5958268288437938,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.6423314462274469,
        "short_at_precedent": 18270.04924,
        "short_on_course": 20645.54924,
        "blocked_tier2": 18270.049238999996,
        "blocked_tier1": 1329.388998999997,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 19599.438237999995,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 4932.913293800001,
        "blocked_high": 19599.438237999995,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "E",
        "status": "TESTED",
        "test": null,
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.09023500788567618,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.03791080379570344,
        "times_faster": 2.380192421451713,
        "fastest_precedent": "Further health output is workforce (2010-19) and productivity (2015-24) precedents achieved under current approval rules (BL C05-F1, C05-F2); new products not needed",
        "main_layer": "C05",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K16",
        "shortage": "Professional licensing",
        "category": "permission",
        "unit": "million machine worker-equivalents in 2035",
        "need_2035": 1739.3798280318192,
        "supply_on_course": 1425.5139081255777,
        "supply_precedent": 1582.4468680786986,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.819552972359468,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.9097764861797341,
        "short_at_precedent": 156.93295995312064,
        "short_on_course": 313.8659199062415,
        "blocked_tier2": 13784.95003546745,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 13784.95003546745,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 25400.473427913825,
        "n_alternatives": 4.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO",
        "depends_on": "humans take the licensed tasks first, machines the rest: licensing binds only if licensed work exceeds all human work",
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "OECD/EU cross-country licensing incidence; legal mapping of which tasks require a licensed person",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.3213308836107842,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.30752130988797166,
        "times_faster": 1.0449060708275577,
        "fastest_precedent": "machine work allowed outside licensed tasks now; fastest reform precedent halves the licensed share (A4:A11)",
        "main_layer": "C05",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K17",
        "shortage": "Construction trades",
        "category": "workers by skill",
        "unit": "million construction workers (ISIC F) in 2035",
        "need_2035": 571.0133258405,
        "supply_on_course": 380.178,
        "supply_precedent": 495.099,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.6657953199960772,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.8670533201151509,
        "short_at_precedent": 75.9143258405,
        "short_on_course": 190.8353258405,
        "blocked_tier2": 15431.881468431786,
        "blocked_tier1": 612.4853744149369,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 16044.366842846723,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 16044.366842846723,
        "blocked_high": 29826.608292081026,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "E",
        "status": "TESTED",
        "test": null,
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.07042742817776748,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.05359434114124362,
        "times_faster": 1.3140832908489648,
        "fastest_precedent": "World construction employment at its fastest 9-year growth (ILO, 2002-2011, 5.36%/yr) from 2026",
        "main_layer": "C13",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "shortage": "Human workforce",
        "category": "workers by skill",
        "unit": "million workers in 2035",
        "need_2035": 4316.60000011,
        "supply_on_course": 4023.24,
        "supply_precedent": 4316.6,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.9320391048272889,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.999999999974517,
        "short_at_precedent": 1.0999974620062858e-07,
        "short_on_course": 293.3600001100003,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 180815.623532,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)",
        "depends_on": "binds only under: 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.69 the v3 ratio; humans' share of work with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of the fastest 9-year growth",
        "label": "E",
        "status": "TESTED",
        "test": null,
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.018990822269040697,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.01899082226615545,
        "times_faster": 1.0000000001519285,
        "fastest_precedent": "WPP 15+ population 2035 x the highest world employment ratio 1991-2025 (BL T19)",
        "main_layer": null,
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "shortage": "Aluminium",
        "category": "materials",
        "unit": "Mt aluminium per year",
        "need_2035": 209.321297831,
        "supply_on_course": 137.0,
        "supply_precedent": 330.479693,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.6544962286188855,
        "share_met_precedent": 1.5788154211943584,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 72.32129783100001,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 7539.027006070798,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 7539.027006070798,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 6402.647931436973,
        "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "IEA STEPS/NZE 2035 aluminium demand by end use (WEO Annex) against the EXIOBASE footprint, and 2026 smelter capacity by region",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.06674002551464775,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.12226497322702223,
        "times_faster": 0.5458638214456116,
        "fastest_precedent": "world bauxite mine output 1950-1959 x2.82 in 9 years (USGS via OWID), post-1950 maximum; post-1985 maximum 2004-2013 x1.80 is the low case",
        "main_layer": "C14",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "shortage": "Capital stock",
        "category": "capital",
        "unit": "tn 2026 int$ (PPP) of capital stock in 2035",
        "need_2035": 2140.0557346999994,
        "supply_on_course": 1502.073347,
        "supply_precedent": 1748.363583,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.7018851531035316,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.8169710511044666,
        "short_at_precedent": 391.6921516999994,
        "short_on_course": 637.9823876999994,
        "blocked_tier2": 43745.811249530394,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 14782.252,
        "blocked_total": 43745.811249530394,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 80540.40160590273,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO",
        "depends_on": "v3 second ratio: lowest world capital-output ratio 1990-2023 (PWT, 2005): best demonstrated, the low case",
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "PWT 11.0 capital-output ratios by country 1990-2023 for economies growing 5%+ a year (does K/Y fall during fast growth?)",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.07981389098142166,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.05583023731461245,
        "times_faster": 1.429581796897216,
        "fastest_precedent": "world real capital stock at its fastest 9-year growth (1964-1973, PWT 11.0); on course = 2013-23 trend",
        "main_layer": "C03",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "shortage": "Cropland",
        "category": "land",
        "unit": "million ha of cropland in 2035",
        "need_2035": 2280.784052995,
        "supply_on_course": 1628.046431,
        "supply_precedent": 1688.875222,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.7138099851505623,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.7404801080498007,
        "short_at_precedent": 591.908830995,
        "short_on_course": 652.7376219949999,
        "blocked_tier2": 19804.653712,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 6937.790466578571,
        "blocked_total": 19804.653712,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 806.164520494398,
        "blocked_high": 138508.85818366456,
        "n_alternatives": 3.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "FAOSTAT crop output per ha and cropland by country 2000-2024, and the EXIOBASE crop footprint per $ of non-food output 1995-2022 (does it fall with income?)",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.04054069708755037,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.006376667523958046,
        "times_faster": 6.357662044513566,
        "fastest_precedent": "world cropland at its fastest 9-year expansion (1976-1985, FAOSTAT); on course = 2014-24 trend",
        "main_layer": "C01",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "BUY-C13",
        "shortage": "Buyers for built structures",
        "category": "buyers",
        "unit": "bn 2026 int$ of output bought",
        "need_2035": 105727.507,
        "supply_on_course": 97239.2654842971,
        "supply_precedent": 97239.2654842971,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.9197158643331778,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.9197158643331778,
        "short_at_precedent": 8488.241515702903,
        "short_on_course": 8488.241515702903,
        "blocked_tier2": 8488.241514702904,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 8488.241514702904,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 29744.175381093894,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO",
        "depends_on": "demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.96)",
        "label": "E",
        "status": "TESTED",
        "test": null,
        "growth_needed_pa": null,
        "growth_precedent_pa": null,
        "times_faster": null,
        "fastest_precedent": null,
        "main_layer": "C13",
        "src": "demand_v4.csv"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "BUY-C12",
        "shortage": "Buyers for public services",
        "category": "buyers",
        "unit": "bn 2026 int$ of output bought",
        "need_2035": 34091.12052,
        "supply_on_course": 33265.52655037182,
        "supply_precedent": 33265.52655037182,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.975782727084496,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.975782727084496,
        "short_at_precedent": 825.5939696281785,
        "short_on_course": 825.5939696281785,
        "blocked_tier2": 825.5939686281745,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 825.5939686281745,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 825.5939686281745,
        "blocked_high": 4420.765201076206,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)",
        "depends_on": "binds only under: demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.91); demand from the UN AMA world income response 1994-2004 (elasticity 0.76)",
        "label": "E",
        "status": "TESTED",
        "test": null,
        "growth_needed_pa": null,
        "growth_precedent_pa": null,
        "times_faster": null,
        "fastest_precedent": null,
        "main_layer": "C12",
        "src": "demand_v4.csv"
      }
    ],
    "rows": [
      {
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "layer": "Food at home",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "missing_bn": 1238.149,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K04",
        "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1238.149,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K14 1,238; K01 1,238; K13 1,238",
        "n_shortages": 4.0,
        "explained_bn": 1238.149,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) on course meets 3% of need; at its fastest precedent (China electric-car sales 2014-2023 x111 in 9 years (IEA via OWID) applied to humanoid ship) it meets 4%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): needs a price fall of 6% (cost room for it not sourced)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "layer": "Food at home",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 5901.607524,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K04",
        "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 5901.607524,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K22 5,902; K21 5,902",
        "n_shortages": 3.0,
        "explained_bn": 5901.607524,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "layer": "Clothing",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "missing_bn": 447.477,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K14",
        "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 447.477,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K01 447; K13 447",
        "n_shortages": 3.0,
        "explained_bn": 447.477,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): needs a price fall of 11% (cost room for it not sourced)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "layer": "Clothing",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 1687.439464,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K04",
        "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1687.439464,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K22 1,687; K21 1,687",
        "n_shortages": 3.0,
        "explained_bn": 1687.439464,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "layer": "Shelter and utilities",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "missing_bn": 627.119,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K14",
        "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 627.119,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K01 627; K13 627",
        "n_shortages": 3.0,
        "explained_bn": 627.119,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): demand at today's price exceeds max output"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "layer": "Shelter and utilities",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 24469.44267,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K21",
        "binds_first_name": "Capital stock",
        "binds_first_category": "capital",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 21157.658535530394,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SCENARIO",
        "others": "K14 2,084",
        "n_shortages": 2.0,
        "explained_bn": 21157.658535530394,
        "unexplained_bn": 3311.784134469606,
        "why": "Capital stock would have to grow 8.0% a year 2026-35 against 5.6% at its fastest precedent (1.4x faster)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "layer": "Household equipment",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "missing_bn": 1458.705,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K14",
        "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1458.705,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K01 1,459; K13 1,459; K20 1,459",
        "n_shortages": 4.0,
        "explained_bn": 1458.705,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): needs a price fall of 20% (cost room for it not sourced)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "layer": "Household equipment",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 1303.883426,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K04",
        "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1303.883426,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K22 1,304; K21 1,304",
        "n_shortages": 3.0,
        "explained_bn": 1303.883426,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "layer": "Health care",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "missing_bn": 1766.768,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K15",
        "binds_first_name": "Clinical approval",
        "binds_first_category": "permission",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1329.388998999997,
        "binds_first_label": "E",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": null,
        "n_shortages": 1.0,
        "explained_bn": 1329.388998999997,
        "unexplained_bn": 437.379001000003,
        "why": "Clinical approval on course meets 60% of need; at its fastest precedent (Further health output is workforce (2010-19) and productivity (2015-24) precedents achieve) it meets 64%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): demand at today's price exceeds max output"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "layer": "Health care",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 19316.16024,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K15",
        "binds_first_name": "Clinical approval",
        "binds_first_category": "permission",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 18270.049238999996,
        "binds_first_label": "E",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K16 13,785",
        "n_shortages": 2.0,
        "explained_bn": 18270.049238999996,
        "unexplained_bn": 1046.1110010000048,
        "why": "Clinical approval would have to grow 9.0% a year 2026-35 against 3.8% at its fastest precedent (2.4x faster)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "layer": "Mobility",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "missing_bn": 5345.213,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K14",
        "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 5345.213,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K01 5,345; K13 5,345; K20 2,638",
        "n_shortages": 4.0,
        "explained_bn": 5345.213,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): needs a price fall of 37% (cost room for it not sourced)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "layer": "Mobility",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 2982.477665,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K04",
        "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 2982.477665,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K21 2,982",
        "n_shortages": 2.0,
        "explained_bn": 2982.477665,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C07",
        "layer": "Communication",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "missing_bn": 82.515,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": null,
        "binds_first_name": null,
        "binds_first_category": null,
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 0.0,
        "binds_first_label": null,
        "binds_first_verdict": null,
        "others": null,
        "n_shortages": 0.0,
        "explained_bn": 0.0,
        "unexplained_bn": 82.515,
        "why": null
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C07",
        "layer": "Communication",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 3510.587034,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": null,
        "binds_first_name": null,
        "binds_first_category": null,
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 0.0,
        "binds_first_label": null,
        "binds_first_verdict": null,
        "others": null,
        "n_shortages": 0.0,
        "explained_bn": 0.0,
        "unexplained_bn": 3510.587034,
        "why": null
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "layer": "Recreation",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "missing_bn": 1565.762,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K14",
        "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1565.762,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K01 550; K13 550; K04 408",
        "n_shortages": 4.0,
        "explained_bn": 1565.762,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): demand at today's price exceeds max output"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "layer": "Recreation",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 5502.388547,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K04",
        "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 5502.388547,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K21 5,502",
        "n_shortages": 2.0,
        "explained_bn": 5502.388547,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C09",
        "layer": "Education",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "missing_bn": 2449.752,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": null,
        "binds_first_name": null,
        "binds_first_category": null,
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 0.0,
        "binds_first_label": null,
        "binds_first_verdict": null,
        "others": null,
        "n_shortages": 0.0,
        "explained_bn": 0.0,
        "unexplained_bn": 2449.752,
        "why": null
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C09",
        "layer": "Education",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 9240.505965,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": null,
        "binds_first_name": null,
        "binds_first_category": null,
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 0.0,
        "binds_first_label": null,
        "binds_first_verdict": null,
        "others": null,
        "n_shortages": 0.0,
        "explained_bn": 0.0,
        "unexplained_bn": 9240.505965,
        "why": null
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "layer": "Food service, lodging",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "missing_bn": 1434.025,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K14",
        "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1434.025,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": null,
        "n_shortages": 1.0,
        "explained_bn": 1434.025,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): needs a price fall of 2% (cost room for it not sourced)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "layer": "Food service, lodging",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 4222.555095,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K04",
        "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 4222.555095,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K22 4,223",
        "n_shortages": 2.0,
        "explained_bn": 4222.555095,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "layer": "Personal and financial services",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "missing_bn": 1882.514,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K14",
        "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1787.0388275551213,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": null,
        "n_shortages": 1.0,
        "explained_bn": 1787.0388275551213,
        "unexplained_bn": 95.47517244487858,
        "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): demand at today's price exceeds max output"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "layer": "Personal and financial services",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 13859.84123,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K04",
        "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 13859.84123,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": null,
        "n_shortages": 1.0,
        "explained_bn": 13859.84123,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "layer": "Public services",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "missing_bn": 2998.156,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K14",
        "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 2998.156,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": null,
        "n_shortages": 1.0,
        "explained_bn": 2998.156,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): UNTESTED: income elasticity is a default (non-household layer); price elasticity A or zero"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "layer": "Public services",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 11171.67552,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K04",
        "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 11171.67552,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "BUY-C12 826",
        "n_shortages": 2.0,
        "explained_bn": 11171.67552,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "layer": "Built structures",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "missing_bn": 8677.18,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K14",
        "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 8677.18,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K11 8,621; K17 612",
        "n_shortages": 3.0,
        "explained_bn": 8677.18,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): UNTESTED: income elasticity is a default (non-household layer); price elasticity A or zero"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "layer": "Built structures",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 34639.30898,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K17",
        "binds_first_name": "Construction trades",
        "binds_first_category": "workers by skill",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 15431.881468431786,
        "binds_first_label": "E",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "BUY-C13 8,488; K04 5,123; K12 1,127",
        "n_shortages": 4.0,
        "explained_bn": 15431.881468431786,
        "unexplained_bn": 19207.427511568218,
        "why": "Construction trades would have to grow 7.0% a year 2026-35 against 5.4% at its fastest precedent (1.3x faster)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "layer": "Productive equipment",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "missing_bn": 3353.131,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K14",
        "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 3353.131,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K01 3,353; K13 3,353; K11 3,353; K20 3,353",
        "n_shortages": 5.0,
        "explained_bn": 3353.131,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): UNTESTED: income elasticity is a default (non-household layer); price elasticity A or zero"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "layer": "Productive equipment",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 1504.455918,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K04",
        "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1504.455918,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K22 1,504; K21 1,504; K06 166",
        "n_shortages": 4.0,
        "explained_bn": 1504.455918,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "layer": "Knowledge and software",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "missing_bn": 1341.365,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K14",
        "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1341.365,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K11 1,341",
        "n_shortages": 2.0,
        "explained_bn": 1341.365,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace. Buyers (repaired baseline demand test at the max-output income): UNTESTED: income elasticity is a default (non-household layer); price elasticity A or zero"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "layer": "Knowledge and software",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 1561.272969,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K04",
        "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 1561.272969,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K21 1,561",
        "n_shortages": 2.0,
        "explained_bn": 1561.272969,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "layer": "Alcohol, tobacco, narcotics",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "missing_bn": 57.028,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K14",
        "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 57.028,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K20 57",
        "n_shortages": 2.0,
        "explained_bn": 57.028,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "layer": "Alcohol, tobacco, narcotics",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 3040.085084,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K04",
        "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 3040.085084,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K22 3,040",
        "n_shortages": 2.0,
        "explained_bn": 3040.085084,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "layer": "Inventories",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "missing_bn": 32.45,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K14",
        "binds_first_name": "Transformers and grid equipment",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 32.45,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K01 32; K13 32; K20 32",
        "n_shortages": 4.0,
        "explained_bn": 32.45,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Transformers and grid equipment on course meets 57% of need; at its fastest precedent (US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv m) it meets 99%: on course it grows at its trend, not its record pace"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "layer": "Inventories",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 2144.627201,
        "missing_label": "A",
        "binds_first": "K04",
        "binds_first_name": "Physical machine labour (robots)",
        "binds_first_category": "machines",
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 2144.627201,
        "binds_first_label": "A",
        "binds_first_verdict": "SOLID",
        "others": "K22 2,145; K21 2,145",
        "n_shortages": 3.0,
        "explained_bn": 2144.627201,
        "unexplained_bn": 0.0,
        "why": "Physical machine labour (robots) would have to grow 59.7% a year 2026-35 against 10.3% at its fastest precedent (5.8x faster)"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "U4",
        "layer": "Net exports",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "missing_bn": 2089.254584,
        "missing_label": "E",
        "binds_first": null,
        "binds_first_name": null,
        "binds_first_category": null,
        "binds_first_blocks_bn": 0.0,
        "binds_first_label": null,
        "binds_first_verdict": null,
        "others": null,
        "n_shortages": 0.0,
        "explained_bn": 0.0,
        "unexplained_bn": 2089.254584,
        "why": null
      }
    ],
    "unexplained": [
      {
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "layer": "Shelter and utilities",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "unexplained_bn": 3311.784134469606,
        "label": "A",
        "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "layer": "Health care",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "unexplained_bn": 437.379001000003,
        "label": "A",
        "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "layer": "Health care",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "unexplained_bn": 1046.1110010000048,
        "label": "A",
        "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C07",
        "layer": "Communication",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "unexplained_bn": 82.515,
        "label": "A",
        "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C07",
        "layer": "Communication",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "unexplained_bn": 3510.587034,
        "label": "A",
        "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C09",
        "layer": "Education",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "unexplained_bn": 2449.752,
        "label": "A",
        "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C09",
        "layer": "Education",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "unexplained_bn": 9240.505965,
        "label": "A",
        "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "layer": "Personal and financial services",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "unexplained_bn": 95.47517244487858,
        "label": "A",
        "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "layer": "Built structures",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "unexplained_bn": 19207.427511568218,
        "label": "A",
        "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "U4",
        "layer": "Net exports",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "unexplained_bn": 2089.254584,
        "label": "E",
        "note": "no input's own numbers explain this output; named by no shortage"
      }
    ],
    "own_blocks": [
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 549.780807147679
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1766.768
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C07",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 82.515
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1565.762
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C09",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2449.752
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1434.025
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1882.514
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2998.156
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 8677.18
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1341.365
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 57.028
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 549.780807147679
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 810.5277171714993
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 254.2228150095216
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2982.477665
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 4234.36606957129
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 4620.799885932551
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 24469.44267
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1303.883426
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2982.477665
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1504.455918
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2144.627201
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1766.768
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C07",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 82.515
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1565.762
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C09",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2449.752
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1434.025
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1882.514
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2998.156
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 8677.18
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1341.365
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 57.028
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1766.768
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C07",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 82.515
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1565.762
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C09",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2449.752
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1434.025
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1882.514
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2998.156
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 8677.18
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1341.365
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 57.028
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5901.607524
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1687.439464
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1303.883426
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2982.477665
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5502.388547
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 4222.555095
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 13859.84123
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 11171.67552
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5122.780587660534
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1504.455918
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1561.272969
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3040.085084
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2144.627201
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 408.3538954966803
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1137.0283592863655
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5901.607524
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1687.439464
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1303.883426
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2982.477665
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5502.388547
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 4222.555095
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 13859.84123
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 11171.67552
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5685.2281110314725
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1504.455918
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1561.272969
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3040.085084
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2144.627201
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.2487201738372
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5901.607524
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1687.439464
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1303.883426
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2982.477665
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5502.388547
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 4222.555095
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 13859.84123
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 11171.67552
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 34639.30898
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1504.455918
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1561.272969
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3040.085084
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2144.627201
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3404.4721524778174
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1565.762
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1434.025
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 57.028
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1766.768
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C07",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 82.515
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1565.762
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C09",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2449.752
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1434.025
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1882.514
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2998.156
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 8677.18
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1341.365
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 57.028
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K06",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 165.7467183780582
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K06",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 144.03696137609495
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K06",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 282.6403011266366
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K09",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1303.883426
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K09",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 11414.232093532111
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K09",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1504.455918
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K09",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2144.627201
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K09",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2560.35535500978
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K10",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2.0568407371335927e-07
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K11",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 8620.928574700749
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K11",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K11",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1341.365
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K12",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1127.0432990000047
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 549.780807147679
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1766.768
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C07",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 82.515
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1565.762
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C09",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2449.752
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1434.025
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1882.514
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2998.156
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 8677.18
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1341.365
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 57.028
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 549.780807147679
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 810.5277171714993
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 254.2228150095216
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2084.4004939814517
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1565.762
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1434.025
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1787.0388275551213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2998.156
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 8677.18
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1341.365
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 57.028
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 7821.932416311601
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1766.768
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C07",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 82.515
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1565.762
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C09",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2449.752
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1434.025
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1882.514
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2998.156
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 8677.18
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1341.365
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 57.028
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1565.762
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1434.025
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1787.0388275551213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2998.156
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 8677.18
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1341.365
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 57.028
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3408.3630205329064
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1565.762
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1434.025
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1787.0388275551213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2998.156
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 8677.18
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1341.365
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 57.028
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 63.88195480392324
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K15",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 18270.049238999996
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K15",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1329.388998999997
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K15",
        "variant": "techshare_low",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 4932.913293800001
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K15",
        "variant": "techshare_high",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 8769.623634199996
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K16",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 13784.95003546745
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K16",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 19316.16024
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K16",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "layer_id": "C09",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 6084.313187913823
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K16",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 12579.693155567813
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K16",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 16524.0966133932
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K17",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 15431.881468431786
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K17",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 612.4853744149369
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K17",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 20728.504478851126
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K17",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 4679.671016129003
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K17",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 23227.783745613626
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K17",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 6598.824546467401
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5901.607524
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1687.439464
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 24469.44267
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1303.883426
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 19316.16024
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2982.477665
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C07",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3510.587034
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5502.388547
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C09",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 9240.505965
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 4222.555095
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 13859.84123
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 11171.67552
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 34639.30898
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1504.455918
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1561.272969
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3040.085084
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2144.627201
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1766.768
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C07",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 82.515
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1565.762
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C09",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2449.752
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1434.025
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1882.514
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2998.156
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 8677.18
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1341.365
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 57.028
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5901.607524
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 4133.773687171332
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2637.7130060707977
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 57.028
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1501.3339314369725
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 57.028
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1766.768
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C07",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 82.515
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1565.762
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C09",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2449.752
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1434.025
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1882.514
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2998.156
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 8677.18
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1341.365
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 57.028
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5901.607524
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1687.439464
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 21157.658535530394
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1303.883426
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2982.477665
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5502.388547
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1504.455918
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1561.272969
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2144.627201
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5901.607524
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1687.439464
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 24469.44267
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1303.883426
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2982.477665
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "C07",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3510.587034
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5502.388547
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 4222.555095
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 11171.67552
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1504.455918
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1561.272969
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2154.4536843890073
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2144.627201
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1113.2268885137362
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1341.365
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5901.607524
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1687.439464
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1303.883426
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 4222.555095
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1504.455918
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3040.085084
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2144.627201
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5901.607524
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1687.439464
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1303.883426
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 19316.16024
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2982.477665
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5502.388547
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C09",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 9240.505965
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 4222.555095
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 13859.84123
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 11171.67552
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 20312.573335664558
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1504.455918
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1561.272969
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3040.085084
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2144.627201
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1238.149
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C02",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 447.477
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 627.119
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C04",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1458.705
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1766.768
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C06",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5345.213
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C07",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 82.515
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C08",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1565.762
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C09",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2449.752
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C10",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1434.025
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1882.514
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 2998.156
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 8677.18
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C14",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 3353.131
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "C15",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1341.365
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "U1",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 57.028
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "layer_id": "U3",
        "tier": 1.0,
        "blocked_bn": 32.45
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "yieldgap_low",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 5901.607524
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "yieldgap_high",
        "layer_id": "C01",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 806.164520494398
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "BUY-C13",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 8488.241514702904
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "BUY-C13",
        "variant": "eta_1994-2004",
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 29744.175381093894
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "BUY-C12",
        "variant": "base",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 825.5939686281745
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "BUY-C12",
        "variant": "eta_2004-2014",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 1302.8633224280456
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "BUY-C12",
        "variant": "eta_1994-2004",
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "tier": 2.0,
        "blocked_bn": 4420.765201076206
      }
    ],
    "variants": [
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 74059.01810670001,
        "supply_on_course": 44274.0,
        "supply_precedent": 93251.9,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 13052.02480714768,
        "blocked_total": 13052.02480714768,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "scenario": "S1",
        "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 76821.04985452816,
        "supply_on_course": 44274.0,
        "supply_precedent": 93251.9,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994,
        "blocked_total": 34757.308999999994,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "scenario": "S2",
        "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 73044.11190843255,
        "supply_on_course": 44274.0,
        "supply_precedent": 93251.9,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 13052.02480714768,
        "blocked_total": 13052.02480714768,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "scenario": "S3",
        "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 74697.94664442586,
        "supply_on_course": 44274.0,
        "supply_precedent": 93251.9,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 13312.7717171715,
        "blocked_total": 13312.7717171715,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "scenario": "S4",
        "way_of_producing": "IEA STEPS 2035 footprint (v3 second ratio) + machine-labour electricity (v3 split)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_alt_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 69351.1560593,
        "supply_on_course": 44274.0,
        "supply_precedent": 93251.9,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 254.2228150095216,
        "blocked_total": 254.2228150095216,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 445.18773945600003,
        "supply_on_course": 374.0,
        "supply_precedent": 548.836,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "scenario": "S4",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 572.535344348,
        "supply_on_course": 374.0,
        "supply_precedent": 548.836,
        "blocked_tier2": 2982.477665,
        "blocked_tier1": 4234.36606957129,
        "blocked_total": 7216.84373457129,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "variant": "today",
        "scenario": "S5",
        "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.62 the v3 ratio",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K02 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 721.7139999701841,
        "supply_on_course": 374.0,
        "supply_precedent": 548.836,
        "blocked_tier2": 37025.68676593255,
        "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994,
        "blocked_total": 71782.99576593254,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 537.0604189395623,
        "supply_on_course": 310.266,
        "supply_precedent": 45732.6,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "scenario": "S1",
        "way_of_producing": "AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 1661.402818363198,
        "supply_on_course": 310.266,
        "supply_precedent": 45732.6,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994,
        "blocked_total": 34757.308999999994,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "scenario": "S2",
        "way_of_producing": "humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 123.921768,
        "supply_on_course": 310.266,
        "supply_precedent": 45732.6,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "scenario": "S3",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 635.1995588823061,
        "supply_on_course": 310.266,
        "supply_precedent": 45732.6,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 1202.3194090922568,
        "supply_on_course": 32.7731,
        "supply_precedent": 42.8569,
        "blocked_tier2": 60005.09023066053,
        "blocked_tier1": 1646.5028954966801,
        "blocked_total": 61651.59312615721,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "scenario": "S1",
        "way_of_producing": "AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 77.97700966862,
        "supply_on_course": 32.7731,
        "supply_precedent": 42.8569,
        "blocked_tier2": 1137.0283592863655,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 1137.0283592863655,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "scenario": "S2",
        "way_of_producing": "humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 1615.4580600318193,
        "supply_on_course": 32.7731,
        "supply_precedent": 42.8569,
        "blocked_tier2": 60567.537754031466,
        "blocked_tier1": 1685.3977201738371,
        "blocked_total": 62252.935474205304,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "scenario": "S3",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 1510.524664677507,
        "supply_on_course": 32.7731,
        "supply_precedent": 42.8569,
        "blocked_tier2": 89521.618623,
        "blocked_tier1": 12958.749152477816,
        "blocked_total": 102480.36777547782,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 146.27352256634808,
        "supply_on_course": 84.504,
        "supply_precedent": 12455.7,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "scenario": "S1",
        "way_of_producing": "AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 452.498888530066,
        "supply_on_course": 84.504,
        "supply_precedent": 12455.7,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994,
        "blocked_total": 34757.308999999994,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "scenario": "S2",
        "way_of_producing": "humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 33.75127432366153,
        "supply_on_course": 84.504,
        "supply_precedent": 12455.7,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "scenario": "S3",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 173.0026524646219,
        "supply_on_course": 84.504,
        "supply_precedent": 12455.7,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K06",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035); input_layer_v3.csv (missing, output_depending_ppp_bn)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 51.03882403,
        "supply_on_course": 26.5106,
        "supply_precedent": 45.4269,
        "blocked_tier2": 165.7467183780582,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 165.7467183780582,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K06",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "scenario": "S4",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 50.226109252899995,
        "supply_on_course": 26.5106,
        "supply_precedent": 45.4269,
        "blocked_tier2": 144.03696137609495,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 144.03696137609495,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K06",
        "variant": "today",
        "scenario": "S5",
        "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.10 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K06 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 55.91000000321605,
        "supply_on_course": 26.5106,
        "supply_precedent": 45.4269,
        "blocked_tier2": 282.6403011266366,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 282.6403011266366,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K07",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035); input_layer_v3.csv (missing, output_depending_ppp_bn)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 1208.28267,
        "supply_on_course": 452.919,
        "supply_precedent": 2301.24,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K07",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "scenario": "S4",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 1013.9538286940001,
        "supply_on_course": 452.919,
        "supply_precedent": 2301.24,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K07",
        "variant": "today",
        "scenario": "S5",
        "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.53 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K07 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 638.000000036699,
        "supply_on_course": 452.919,
        "supply_precedent": 2301.24,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K08",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: pathway-consistent 2035 (GCMO High Demand, closest to NZE); more mineral per unit than the baseline (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035); input_layer_v3.csv (missing, output_depending_ppp_bn)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 213.0123662,
        "supply_on_course": 136.357,
        "supply_precedent": 709.648,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K08",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "scenario": "S4",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: IEA GCMO 2026 STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun) (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 193.912195587,
        "supply_on_course": 136.357,
        "supply_precedent": 709.648,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K08",
        "variant": "today",
        "scenario": "S5",
        "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x0.84 the v3 ratio (CES substitution, elasticity 0.4: v3's missing/output-depending conversion)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K08 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 178.00000001023892,
        "supply_on_course": 136.357,
        "supply_precedent": 709.648,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K09",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE material efficiency)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 2901.93264675,
        "supply_on_course": 2570.4,
        "supply_precedent": 3135.54,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K09",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "scenario": "S4",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 3076.47781373,
        "supply_on_course": 2570.4,
        "supply_precedent": 3135.54,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K09",
        "variant": "today",
        "scenario": "S5",
        "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.29 the v3 ratio",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K09 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 3734.0400011798456,
        "supply_on_course": 2570.4,
        "supply_precedent": 3135.54,
        "blocked_tier2": 16367.19863853211,
        "blocked_tier1": 2560.35535500978,
        "blocked_total": 18927.55399354189,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K10",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 5589.70491443,
        "supply_on_course": 5428.57,
        "supply_precedent": 7528.7,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K10",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "scenario": "S4",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: Agent 4 rerun: 2026 intensity held outside C13; C13 at the baseline on-course tonnes per unit of value",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 6095.49857833,
        "supply_on_course": 5428.57,
        "supply_precedent": 7528.7,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K10",
        "variant": "today",
        "scenario": "S5",
        "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.35 the v3 ratio",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K10 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 7528.700001012227,
        "supply_on_course": 5428.57,
        "supply_precedent": 7528.7,
        "blocked_tier2": 2.0568407371335927e-07,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 2.0568407371335927e-07,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K11",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: identity (investment = saving at market prices); no ratio to improve",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 58368.093940000006,
        "supply_on_course": 37826.3,
        "supply_precedent": 87530.7,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 13315.424574700748,
        "blocked_total": 13315.424574700748,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K12",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: identity",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 105727.507,
        "supply_on_course": 94403.39409,
        "supply_precedent": 104600.4637,
        "blocked_tier2": 1127.0432990000047,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 1127.0432990000047,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 74059.01810670001,
        "supply_on_course": 44274.0,
        "supply_precedent": 87637.2,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 13052.02480714768,
        "blocked_total": 13052.02480714768,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "scenario": "S1",
        "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 76821.04985452816,
        "supply_on_course": 44274.0,
        "supply_precedent": 87637.2,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994,
        "blocked_total": 34757.308999999994,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "scenario": "S2",
        "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 73044.11190843255,
        "supply_on_course": 44274.0,
        "supply_precedent": 87637.2,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 13052.02480714768,
        "blocked_total": 13052.02480714768,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "scenario": "S3",
        "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 74697.94664442586,
        "supply_on_course": 44274.0,
        "supply_precedent": 87637.2,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 13312.7717171715,
        "blocked_total": 13312.7717171715,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "scenario": "S4",
        "way_of_producing": "IEA STEPS 2035 footprint (v3 second ratio) + machine-labour electricity (v3 split)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_alt_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 69351.1560593,
        "supply_on_course": 44274.0,
        "supply_precedent": 87637.2,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 254.2228150095216,
        "blocked_total": 254.2228150095216,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 74059.01810670001,
        "supply_on_course": 42553.3,
        "supply_precedent": 73055.4,
        "blocked_tier2": 2084.4004939814517,
        "blocked_tier1": 30362.798827555125,
        "blocked_total": 32447.199321536576,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "scenario": "S1",
        "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 76821.04985452816,
        "supply_on_course": 42553.3,
        "supply_precedent": 73055.4,
        "blocked_tier2": 7821.932416311601,
        "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994,
        "blocked_total": 42579.2414163116,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "scenario": "S2",
        "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 73044.11190843255,
        "supply_on_course": 42553.3,
        "supply_precedent": 73055.4,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 30362.798827555125,
        "blocked_total": 30362.798827555125,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "scenario": "S3",
        "way_of_producing": "IEA NZE footprint + machine-labour electricity, task split: v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_2035, net of machine-labour electricity); stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 74697.94664442586,
        "supply_on_course": 42553.3,
        "supply_precedent": 73055.4,
        "blocked_tier2": 3408.3630205329064,
        "blocked_tier1": 30362.798827555125,
        "blocked_total": 33771.16184808803,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "scenario": "S4",
        "way_of_producing": "IEA STEPS 2035 footprint (v3 second ratio) + machine-labour electricity (v3 split)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K01 ratio_alt_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 69351.1560593,
        "supply_on_course": 42553.3,
        "supply_precedent": 73055.4,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 5535.2869548039225,
        "blocked_total": 5535.2869548039225,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K15",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: identity",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 51080.94924,
        "supply_on_course": 30435.4,
        "supply_precedent": 32810.9,
        "blocked_tier2": 18270.049238999996,
        "blocked_tier1": 1329.388998999997,
        "blocked_total": 19599.438237999995,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K15",
        "variant": "techshare_low",
        "scenario": "S6",
        "way_of_producing": "only 27% of health output growth beyond the current-rule path comes from new technology needing approval; the rest is more of approved care",
        "src": "searches_v4.csv W2 (Smith, Newhouse, Freeland 2009)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 51080.94924,
        "supply_on_course": 45506.6509452,
        "supply_precedent": 46148.0359452,
        "blocked_tier2": 4932.913293800001,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 4932.913293800001,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K15",
        "variant": "techshare_high",
        "scenario": "S6",
        "way_of_producing": "only 48% of health output growth beyond the current-rule path comes from new technology needing approval; the rest is more of approved care",
        "src": "searches_v4.csv W2 (Smith, Newhouse, Freeland 2009)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 51080.94924,
        "supply_on_course": 41171.0856048,
        "supply_precedent": 42311.325604800004,
        "blocked_tier2": 8769.623634199996,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 8769.623634199996,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K16",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 split: humans spread over all tasks; the gap split cognitive (AI) / physical (robots) by each layer's high-skill share; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14); stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py (LIC, LIC_REFORM)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 1739.3798280318192,
        "supply_on_course": 1425.5139081255777,
        "supply_precedent": 1582.4468680786986,
        "blocked_tier2": 13784.95003546745,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 13784.95003546745,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K16",
        "variant": "cogfirst",
        "scenario": "S1",
        "way_of_producing": "AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14); stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py (LIC, LIC_REFORM)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 1739.3798280318183,
        "supply_on_course": 1350.8309789424197,
        "supply_precedent": 1545.105403487119,
        "blocked_tier2": 25400.473427913825,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 25400.473427913825,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K16",
        "variant": "humanscog",
        "scenario": "S2",
        "way_of_producing": "humans keep the cognitive tasks; AI adds no work; robots fill the whole gap; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14); stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py (LIC, LIC_REFORM)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 1739.3798280318192,
        "supply_on_course": 1452.9560864395512,
        "supply_precedent": 1596.1679572356852,
        "blocked_tier2": 12579.693155567813,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 12579.693155567813,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K16",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "scenario": "S3",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 split, with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of each sector's fastest 9-year growth; licensed share of each layer's machine work not allowed (BLS shares via A4v1), half after the reform precedent",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14); stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py (LIC, LIC_REFORM)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 2145.7242235598133,
        "supply_on_course": 1756.3404945038483,
        "supply_precedent": 1951.0323590318308,
        "blocked_tier2": 16524.0966133932,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 16524.0966133932,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K16",
        "variant": "humanslicensed",
        "scenario": "S6",
        "way_of_producing": "humans take the licensed tasks first, machines the rest: licensing binds only if licensed work exceeds all human work",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14); stage1-v3/requirements/code/inputs.py (LIC)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 1168.0410513836273,
        "supply_on_course": 4023.24,
        "supply_precedent": 4316.6,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K17",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (fastest sourced productivity)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 571.0133258405,
        "supply_on_course": 380.178,
        "supply_precedent": 495.099,
        "blocked_tier2": 15431.881468431786,
        "blocked_tier1": 612.4853744149369,
        "blocked_total": 16044.366842846723,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K17",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "scenario": "S4",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: construction output per worker on its 2014-24 trend (Agent 4 rerun)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 602.7336260575,
        "supply_on_course": 380.178,
        "supply_precedent": 495.099,
        "blocked_tier2": 20728.504478851126,
        "blocked_tier1": 4679.671016129003,
        "blocked_total": 25408.17549498013,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K17",
        "variant": "today",
        "scenario": "S5",
        "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.08 the v3 ratio",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K17 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 618.9580000795042,
        "supply_on_course": 380.178,
        "supply_precedent": 495.099,
        "blocked_tier2": 23227.783745613626,
        "blocked_tier1": 6598.824546467401,
        "blocked_total": 29826.608292081026,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (fastest sourced productivity)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 4316.60000011,
        "supply_on_course": 4023.24,
        "supply_precedent": 4316.6,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "today",
        "scenario": "S5",
        "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.69 the v3 ratio",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K18 supply_2026); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 7288.5200006049845,
        "supply_on_course": 4023.24,
        "supply_precedent": 4316.6,
        "blocked_tier2": 146058.31453200002,
        "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994,
        "blocked_total": 180815.623532,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "variant": "trendprod",
        "scenario": "S3",
        "way_of_producing": "humans' share of work with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of the fastest 9-year growth",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (K18 work_ratio_2035); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/model_memo.json (cog, gw_per_we); stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/work/need_by_layer.csv (K03, K04 on course); stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK13, MK14)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 4613.755033373291,
        "supply_on_course": 4023.24,
        "supply_precedent": 4316.6,
        "blocked_tier2": 10035.381211171332,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 10035.381211171332,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (IEA NZE)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 209.321297831,
        "supply_on_course": 137.0,
        "supply_precedent": 330.479693,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 7539.027006070798,
        "blocked_total": 7539.027006070798,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "scenario": "S4",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 aluminium per unit of GDP (WEO 2025 A.5b)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 208.07944257600002,
        "supply_on_course": 137.0,
        "supply_precedent": 330.479693,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 6402.647931436973,
        "blocked_total": 6402.647931436973,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "variant": "today",
        "scenario": "S5",
        "way_of_producing": "2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.12 the v3 ratio",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/model_constants.csv (MK17); 2026 world output (repaired baseline)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 234.05401644812613,
        "supply_on_course": 137.0,
        "supply_precedent": 330.479693,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994,
        "blocked_total": 34757.308999999994,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: today's ratio held (only today's is sourced)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 2140.0557346999994,
        "supply_on_course": 1502.073347,
        "supply_precedent": 1748.363583,
        "blocked_tier2": 43745.811249530394,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 43745.811249530394,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "scenario": "S4",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: lowest world capital-output ratio 1990-2023 (PWT, 2005): best demonstrated, the low case",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 1538.7544367500002,
        "supply_on_course": 1502.073347,
        "supply_precedent": 1748.363583,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "variant": "kytrend",
        "scenario": "S5",
        "way_of_producing": "capital-output ratio on its 2013-23 trend: x1.096 today's (PWT capital growth 3.82% vs UN AMA GDP growth 3.03%)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/work/landcap.csv (GK_1323, PWT 11.0); stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world GDP 2013, 2023)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 2345.732240507213,
        "supply_on_course": 1502.073347,
        "supply_precedent": 1748.363583,
        "blocked_tier2": 68116.866717389,
        "blocked_tier1": 12423.534888513735,
        "blocked_total": 80540.40160590273,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 ratio: best achievable 2035 (fastest sourced yield growth)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_2035)",
        "label": "A",
        "need_2035": 2280.784052995,
        "supply_on_course": 1628.046431,
        "supply_precedent": 1688.875222,
        "blocked_tier2": 19804.653712,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 19804.653712,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "v3alt",
        "scenario": "S4",
        "way_of_producing": "v3 second ratio: crop output per ha on its 2014-24 trend",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/requirements.csv (ratio_alt_2035)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 2610.7327013210006,
        "supply_on_course": 1628.046431,
        "supply_precedent": 1688.875222,
        "blocked_tier2": 103751.54918366457,
        "blocked_tier1": 34757.308999999994,
        "blocked_total": 138508.85818366456,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "yieldgap_low",
        "scenario": "S6",
        "way_of_producing": "yield gaps closed to attainable yields: crop output per ha +45% on 2026 (x0.885 the v3 ratio)",
        "src": "searches_v4.csv W1 (Mueller et al. 2012); stage1-v3/requirements/work/landcap.csv (GY_MAX9)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 2019.001409127152,
        "supply_on_course": 1628.046431,
        "supply_precedent": 1688.875222,
        "blocked_tier2": 5901.607524,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 5901.607524,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "variant": "yieldgap_high",
        "scenario": "S6",
        "way_of_producing": "yield gaps closed to attainable yields: crop output per ha +70% on 2026 (x0.755 the v3 ratio)",
        "src": "searches_v4.csv W1 (Mueller et al. 2012); stage1-v3/requirements/work/landcap.csv (GY_MAX9)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 1722.0894371966892,
        "supply_on_course": 1628.046431,
        "supply_precedent": 1688.875222,
        "blocked_tier2": 806.164520494398,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 806.164520494398,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "BUY-C13",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "demand at the 2035 price from the sourced income response (UN AMA world 2014-2024)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, Construction (ISIC F) vs GDP, 2014-2024)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 105727.507,
        "supply_on_course": 97239.2654842971,
        "supply_precedent": 97239.2654842971,
        "blocked_tier2": 8488.241514702904,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 8488.241514702904,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "BUY-C13",
        "variant": "eta_2004-2014",
        "scenario": "S4",
        "way_of_producing": "demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.96)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, Construction (ISIC F) vs GDP, 2004-2014)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 105727.507,
        "supply_on_course": 105794.28607645418,
        "supply_precedent": 105794.28607645418,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "binds": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "BUY-C13",
        "variant": "eta_1994-2004",
        "scenario": "S5",
        "way_of_producing": "demand from the UN AMA world income response 1994-2004 (elasticity 0.49)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, Construction (ISIC F) vs GDP, 1994-2004)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 105727.507,
        "supply_on_course": 75983.33161790611,
        "supply_precedent": 75983.33161790611,
        "blocked_tier2": 29744.175381093894,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 29744.175381093894,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "BUY-C12",
        "variant": "base",
        "scenario": "S0",
        "way_of_producing": "demand at the 2035 price from the sourced income response (UN AMA world 2014-2024)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, General government final consumption expenditure vs GDP, 2014-2024)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 34091.12052,
        "supply_on_course": 33265.52655037182,
        "supply_precedent": 33265.52655037182,
        "blocked_tier2": 825.5939686281745,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 825.5939686281745,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "BUY-C12",
        "variant": "eta_2004-2014",
        "scenario": "S4",
        "way_of_producing": "demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.91)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, General government final consumption expenditure vs GDP, 2004-2014)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 34091.12052,
        "supply_on_course": 32788.25719657195,
        "supply_precedent": 32788.25719657195,
        "blocked_tier2": 1302.8633224280456,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 1302.8633224280456,
        "binds": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "BUY-C12",
        "variant": "eta_1994-2004",
        "scenario": "S5",
        "way_of_producing": "demand from the UN AMA world income response 1994-2004 (elasticity 0.76)",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, General government final consumption expenditure vs GDP, 1994-2004)",
        "label": "E",
        "need_2035": 34091.12052,
        "supply_on_course": 29670.35531792379,
        "supply_precedent": 29670.35531792379,
        "blocked_tier2": 4420.765201076206,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 4420.765201076206,
        "binds": true
      }
    ],
    "ranking": [
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "shortage": "Physical machine labour (robots)",
        "category": "machines",
        "unit": "million worker-equivalents in 2035",
        "need_2035": 1202.3194090922568,
        "supply_on_course": 32.7731,
        "supply_precedent": 42.8569,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.027258230842953347,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.03564518685792212,
        "short_at_precedent": 1159.4625090922568,
        "short_on_course": 1169.5463090922567,
        "blocked_tier2": 60005.09023066053,
        "blocked_tier1": 1646.5028954966801,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 21153.975000000002,
        "blocked_total": 61651.59312615721,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 1137.0283592863655,
        "blocked_high": 102480.36777547782,
        "n_alternatives": 3.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "Time-and-motion worker-equivalents of deployed humanoids; Counterpoint/IDC 2027 shipments to confirm the ramp",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.5974132099514471,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.10288056130378731,
        "times_faster": 5.806861883144243,
        "fastest_precedent": "China electric-car sales 2014-2023 x111 in 9 years (IEA via OWID) applied to humanoid shipments from 50k in 2026 (Counterpoint); industrial robots on the IFR 2026-29 forecast trend",
        "main_layer": "C11",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "A",
        "group_solid": "SOLID",
        "rank_all": 1.0,
        "rank_S0": 1.0,
        "blocked_S0": 61651.59312615721,
        "rank_S1": 14.0,
        "blocked_S1": 1137.0283592863655,
        "rank_S2": 1.0,
        "blocked_S2": 62252.935474205304,
        "rank_S3": 1.0,
        "blocked_S3": 102480.36777547782,
        "rank_S4": 2.0,
        "blocked_S4": 61651.59312615721,
        "rank_S5": 4.0,
        "blocked_S5": 61651.59312615721,
        "rank_S6": 1.0,
        "blocked_S6": 61651.59312615721,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 1.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 1.0,
        "pick": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "shortage": "Capital stock",
        "category": "capital",
        "unit": "tn 2026 int$ (PPP) of capital stock in 2035",
        "need_2035": 2140.0557346999994,
        "supply_on_course": 1502.073347,
        "supply_precedent": 1748.363583,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.7018851531035316,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.8169710511044666,
        "short_at_precedent": 391.6921516999994,
        "short_on_course": 637.9823876999994,
        "blocked_tier2": 43745.811249530394,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 14782.252,
        "blocked_total": 43745.811249530394,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 80540.40160590273,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO",
        "depends_on": "v3 second ratio: lowest world capital-output ratio 1990-2023 (PWT, 2005): best demonstrated, the low case",
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "PWT 11.0 capital-output ratios by country 1990-2023 for economies growing 5%+ a year (does K/Y fall during fast growth?)",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.07981389098142166,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.05583023731461245,
        "times_faster": 1.429581796897216,
        "fastest_precedent": "world real capital stock at its fastest 9-year growth (1964-1973, PWT 11.0); on course = 2013-23 trend",
        "main_layer": "C03",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "A",
        "group_solid": "SCENARIO",
        "rank_all": 2.0,
        "rank_S0": 2.0,
        "blocked_S0": 43745.811249530394,
        "rank_S1": 1.0,
        "blocked_S1": 43745.811249530394,
        "rank_S2": 2.0,
        "blocked_S2": 43745.811249530394,
        "rank_S3": 2.0,
        "blocked_S3": 43745.811249530394,
        "rank_S4": 15.0,
        "blocked_S4": 0.0,
        "rank_S5": 2.0,
        "blocked_S5": 80540.40160590273,
        "rank_S6": 2.0,
        "blocked_S6": 43745.811249530394,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 2.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 1.0,
        "pick": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "shortage": "Transformers and grid equipment",
        "category": "machines",
        "unit": "TWh per year of generation the delivered transformers can connect",
        "need_2035": 74059.01810670001,
        "supply_on_course": 42553.3,
        "supply_precedent": 73055.4,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.574586337867613,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.986448401121737,
        "short_at_precedent": 1003.6181067000143,
        "short_on_course": 31505.718106700006,
        "blocked_tier2": 2084.4004939814517,
        "blocked_tier1": 30362.798827555125,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 32447.199321536576,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 5535.2869548039225,
        "blocked_high": 42579.2414163116,
        "n_alternatives": 4.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "World transformer manufacturing capacity by region (Wood Mackenzie / IEA grid supply-chain report) and order books to 2030",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.09470307265246425,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.09304472855017654,
        "times_faster": 1.0178230849627705,
        "fastest_precedent": "US generator step-up transformer demand x3.74 in 6 years (2019-25, Wood Mackenzie via pv magazine) used as the supply ramp from the STEPS addition rate",
        "main_layer": "C13",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "A",
        "group_solid": "SOLID",
        "rank_all": 3.0,
        "rank_S0": 3.0,
        "blocked_S0": 32447.199321536576,
        "rank_S1": 2.0,
        "blocked_S1": 42579.2414163116,
        "rank_S2": 3.0,
        "blocked_S2": 30362.798827555125,
        "rank_S3": 3.0,
        "blocked_S3": 33771.16184808803,
        "rank_S4": 9.0,
        "blocked_S4": 5535.2869548039225,
        "rank_S5": 6.0,
        "blocked_S5": 32447.199321536576,
        "rank_S6": 3.0,
        "blocked_S6": 32447.199321536576,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 3.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 2.0,
        "pick": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "shortage": "Cropland",
        "category": "land",
        "unit": "million ha of cropland in 2035",
        "need_2035": 2280.784052995,
        "supply_on_course": 1628.046431,
        "supply_precedent": 1688.875222,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.7138099851505623,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.7404801080498007,
        "short_at_precedent": 591.908830995,
        "short_on_course": 652.7376219949999,
        "blocked_tier2": 19804.653712,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 6937.790466578571,
        "blocked_total": 19804.653712,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 806.164520494398,
        "blocked_high": 138508.85818366456,
        "n_alternatives": 3.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "FAOSTAT crop output per ha and cropland by country 2000-2024, and the EXIOBASE crop footprint per $ of non-food output 1995-2022 (does it fall with income?)",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.04054069708755037,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.006376667523958046,
        "times_faster": 6.357662044513566,
        "fastest_precedent": "world cropland at its fastest 9-year expansion (1976-1985, FAOSTAT); on course = 2014-24 trend",
        "main_layer": "C01",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "A",
        "group_solid": "SOLID",
        "rank_all": 4.0,
        "rank_S0": 4.0,
        "blocked_S0": 19804.653712,
        "rank_S1": 8.0,
        "blocked_S1": 19804.653712,
        "rank_S2": 4.0,
        "blocked_S2": 19804.653712,
        "rank_S3": 4.0,
        "blocked_S3": 19804.653712,
        "rank_S4": 1.0,
        "blocked_S4": 138508.85818366456,
        "rank_S5": 9.0,
        "blocked_S5": 19804.653712,
        "rank_S6": 10.0,
        "blocked_S6": 5901.607524,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 4.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 3.0,
        "pick": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K15",
        "shortage": "Clinical approval",
        "category": "permission",
        "unit": "bn 2026 int$ of health output (C05) that must be allowed in 2035",
        "need_2035": 51080.94924,
        "supply_on_course": 30435.4,
        "supply_precedent": 32810.9,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.5958268288437938,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.6423314462274469,
        "short_at_precedent": 18270.04924,
        "short_on_course": 20645.54924,
        "blocked_tier2": 18270.049238999996,
        "blocked_tier1": 1329.388998999997,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 19599.438237999995,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 4932.913293800001,
        "blocked_high": 19599.438237999995,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "E",
        "status": "TESTED",
        "test": null,
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.09023500788567618,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.03791080379570344,
        "times_faster": 2.380192421451713,
        "fastest_precedent": "Further health output is workforce (2010-19) and productivity (2015-24) precedents achieved under current approval rules (BL C05-F1, C05-F2); new products not needed",
        "main_layer": "C05",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "S/E",
        "group_solid": "SOLID",
        "rank_all": 5.0,
        "rank_S0": 5.0,
        "blocked_S0": 19599.438237999995,
        "rank_S1": 9.0,
        "blocked_S1": 19599.438237999995,
        "rank_S2": 5.0,
        "blocked_S2": 19599.438237999995,
        "rank_S3": 5.0,
        "blocked_S3": 19599.438237999995,
        "rank_S4": 4.0,
        "blocked_S4": 19599.438237999995,
        "rank_S5": 10.0,
        "blocked_S5": 19599.438237999995,
        "rank_S6": 11.0,
        "blocked_S6": 4932.913293800001,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 1.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 4.0,
        "pick": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K17",
        "shortage": "Construction trades",
        "category": "workers by skill",
        "unit": "million construction workers (ISIC F) in 2035",
        "need_2035": 571.0133258405,
        "supply_on_course": 380.178,
        "supply_precedent": 495.099,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.6657953199960772,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.8670533201151509,
        "short_at_precedent": 75.9143258405,
        "short_on_course": 190.8353258405,
        "blocked_tier2": 15431.881468431786,
        "blocked_tier1": 612.4853744149369,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 16044.366842846723,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 16044.366842846723,
        "blocked_high": 29826.608292081026,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "E",
        "status": "TESTED",
        "test": null,
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.07042742817776748,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.05359434114124362,
        "times_faster": 1.3140832908489648,
        "fastest_precedent": "World construction employment at its fastest 9-year growth (ILO, 2002-2011, 5.36%/yr) from 2026",
        "main_layer": "C13",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "S/E",
        "group_solid": "SOLID",
        "rank_all": 6.0,
        "rank_S0": 6.0,
        "blocked_S0": 16044.366842846723,
        "rank_S1": 10.0,
        "blocked_S1": 16044.366842846723,
        "rank_S2": 6.0,
        "blocked_S2": 16044.366842846723,
        "rank_S3": 7.0,
        "blocked_S3": 16044.366842846723,
        "rank_S4": 3.0,
        "blocked_S4": 25408.17549498013,
        "rank_S5": 7.0,
        "blocked_S5": 29826.608292081026,
        "rank_S6": 4.0,
        "blocked_S6": 16044.366842846723,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 2.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 5.0,
        "pick": true
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K16",
        "shortage": "Professional licensing",
        "category": "permission",
        "unit": "million machine worker-equivalents in 2035",
        "need_2035": 1739.3798280318192,
        "supply_on_course": 1425.5139081255777,
        "supply_precedent": 1582.4468680786986,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.819552972359468,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.9097764861797341,
        "short_at_precedent": 156.93295995312064,
        "short_on_course": 313.8659199062415,
        "blocked_tier2": 13784.95003546745,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 13784.95003546745,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 25400.473427913825,
        "n_alternatives": 4.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO",
        "depends_on": "humans take the licensed tasks first, machines the rest: licensing binds only if licensed work exceeds all human work",
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "OECD/EU cross-country licensing incidence; legal mapping of which tasks require a licensed person",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.3213308836107842,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.30752130988797166,
        "times_faster": 1.0449060708275577,
        "fastest_precedent": "machine work allowed outside licensed tasks now; fastest reform precedent halves the licensed share (A4:A11)",
        "main_layer": "C05",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "A",
        "group_solid": "SCENARIO",
        "rank_all": 7.0,
        "rank_S0": 7.0,
        "blocked_S0": 13784.95003546745,
        "rank_S1": 7.0,
        "blocked_S1": 25400.473427913825,
        "rank_S2": 10.0,
        "blocked_S2": 12579.693155567813,
        "rank_S3": 6.0,
        "blocked_S3": 16524.0966133932,
        "rank_S4": 5.0,
        "blocked_S4": 13784.95003546745,
        "rank_S5": 12.0,
        "blocked_S5": 13784.95003546745,
        "rank_S6": 15.0,
        "blocked_S6": 0.0,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 5.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 2.0,
        "pick": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K11",
        "shortage": "Saving for investment",
        "category": "capital",
        "unit": "bn US$ (market) of gross saving per year",
        "need_2035": 58368.093940000006,
        "supply_on_course": 37826.3,
        "supply_precedent": 87530.7,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.6480646779194791,
        "share_met_precedent": 1.499632660439074,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 20541.793940000003,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 13315.424574700748,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 13315.424574700748,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 13315.424574700748,
        "blocked_high": 13315.424574700748,
        "n_alternatives": 0.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": "accounting identity (saving = investment in C13-C15 at market prices): binds under every way of producing; rests on the on-course saving rate (2015-24 mean, A)",
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "IMF WEO saving and investment projections to 2031 (world saving rate path) to replace the held 2015-24 mean",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.07580152934450268,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.12534590268703316,
        "times_faster": 0.6047387885806357,
        "fastest_precedent": "China gross saving 51.3% of GDP (2008, World Bank) applied to world output at max; on course = world 2015-24 mean saving rate",
        "main_layer": "C13",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "A",
        "group_solid": "SOLID",
        "rank_all": 8.0,
        "rank_S0": 8.0,
        "blocked_S0": 13315.424574700748,
        "rank_S1": 11.0,
        "blocked_S1": 13315.424574700748,
        "rank_S2": 7.0,
        "blocked_S2": 13315.424574700748,
        "rank_S3": 8.0,
        "blocked_S3": 13315.424574700748,
        "rank_S4": 6.0,
        "blocked_S4": 13315.424574700748,
        "rank_S5": 13.0,
        "blocked_S5": 13315.424574700748,
        "rank_S6": 5.0,
        "blocked_S6": 13315.424574700748,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 6.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 6.0,
        "pick": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K13",
        "shortage": "Grid connection approval",
        "category": "permission",
        "unit": "TWh per year of generation connected",
        "need_2035": 74059.01810670001,
        "supply_on_course": 44274.0,
        "supply_precedent": 87637.2,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.5978205103423401,
        "share_met_precedent": 1.1833427209868934,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 29785.01810670001,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 13052.02480714768,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 13052.02480714768,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 254.2228150095216,
        "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994,
        "n_alternatives": 4.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "ENTSO-E and LBNL completion rates by request year; IEA count of 2 800 GW waiting by region and age",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.09470307265246425,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.11537198187260045,
        "times_faster": 0.8208498381958989,
        "fastest_precedent": "US 2008 queue speed (22 months request-to-operation, LBNL) in queue-bound grids (US+EU share of 2025 generation); STEPS path assumed connected",
        "main_layer": "C06",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "A",
        "group_solid": "SOLID",
        "rank_all": 9.0,
        "rank_S0": 9.0,
        "blocked_S0": 13052.02480714768,
        "rank_S1": 3.0,
        "blocked_S1": 34757.308999999994,
        "rank_S2": 8.0,
        "blocked_S2": 13052.02480714768,
        "rank_S3": 9.0,
        "blocked_S3": 13312.7717171715,
        "rank_S4": 12.0,
        "blocked_S4": 254.2228150095216,
        "rank_S5": 14.0,
        "blocked_S5": 13052.02480714768,
        "rank_S6": 6.0,
        "blocked_S6": 13052.02480714768,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 7.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 7.0,
        "pick": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K01",
        "shortage": "Electricity",
        "category": "energy",
        "unit": "TWh per year (gross generation)",
        "need_2035": 74059.01810670001,
        "supply_on_course": 44274.0,
        "supply_precedent": 93251.9,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.5978205103423401,
        "share_met_precedent": 1.2591565805753457,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 29785.01810670001,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 13052.02480714768,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 13052.02480714768,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 254.2228150095216,
        "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994,
        "n_alternatives": 4.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "IEA WEO-2026 Annex A (STEPS generation 2035) and Ember monthly 2026 generation; IEA World Energy Balances by final-demand sector to replace the EXIOBASE monetary electricity multiplier",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.09470307265246425,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.12309451993046494,
        "times_faster": 0.7693524675668845,
        "fastest_precedent": "China 2002-2011: generation x2.84 in 9 years (Ember), applied to world 2026 supply; world fastest 9 years (OWID, 2001-10) x1.37 is the low case",
        "main_layer": "C06",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "A",
        "group_solid": "SOLID",
        "rank_all": 10.0,
        "rank_S0": 9.0,
        "blocked_S0": 13052.02480714768,
        "rank_S1": 3.0,
        "blocked_S1": 34757.308999999994,
        "rank_S2": 8.0,
        "blocked_S2": 13052.02480714768,
        "rank_S3": 9.0,
        "blocked_S3": 13312.7717171715,
        "rank_S4": 12.0,
        "blocked_S4": 254.2228150095216,
        "rank_S5": 14.0,
        "blocked_S5": 13052.02480714768,
        "rank_S6": 6.0,
        "blocked_S6": 13052.02480714768,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 8.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 8.0,
        "pick": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "BUY-C13",
        "shortage": "Buyers for built structures",
        "category": "buyers",
        "unit": "bn 2026 int$ of output bought",
        "need_2035": 105727.507,
        "supply_on_course": 97239.2654842971,
        "supply_precedent": 97239.2654842971,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.9197158643331778,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.9197158643331778,
        "short_at_precedent": 8488.241515702903,
        "short_on_course": 8488.241515702903,
        "blocked_tier2": 8488.241514702904,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 8488.241514702904,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 29744.175381093894,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO",
        "depends_on": "demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.96)",
        "label": "E",
        "status": "TESTED",
        "test": null,
        "growth_needed_pa": null,
        "growth_precedent_pa": null,
        "times_faster": null,
        "fastest_precedent": null,
        "main_layer": "C13",
        "src": "demand_v4.csv",
        "group_label": "S/E",
        "group_solid": "SCENARIO",
        "rank_all": 11.0,
        "rank_S0": 11.0,
        "blocked_S0": 8488.241514702904,
        "rank_S1": 12.0,
        "blocked_S1": 8488.241514702904,
        "rank_S2": 11.0,
        "blocked_S2": 8488.241514702904,
        "rank_S3": 12.0,
        "blocked_S3": 8488.241514702904,
        "rank_S4": 15.0,
        "blocked_S4": 0.0,
        "rank_S5": 8.0,
        "blocked_S5": 29744.175381093894,
        "rank_S6": 8.0,
        "blocked_S6": 8488.241514702904,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 3.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 3.0,
        "pick": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K20",
        "shortage": "Aluminium",
        "category": "materials",
        "unit": "Mt aluminium per year",
        "need_2035": 209.321297831,
        "supply_on_course": 137.0,
        "supply_precedent": 330.479693,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.6544962286188855,
        "share_met_precedent": 1.5788154211943584,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 72.32129783100001,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 7539.027006070798,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 7539.027006070798,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 6402.647931436973,
        "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "IEA STEPS/NZE 2035 aluminium demand by end use (WEO Annex) against the EXIOBASE footprint, and 2026 smelter capacity by region",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.06674002551464775,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.12226497322702223,
        "times_faster": 0.5458638214456116,
        "fastest_precedent": "world bauxite mine output 1950-1959 x2.82 in 9 years (USGS via OWID), post-1950 maximum; post-1985 maximum 2004-2013 x1.80 is the low case",
        "main_layer": "C14",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "A",
        "group_solid": "SOLID",
        "rank_all": 12.0,
        "rank_S0": 12.0,
        "blocked_S0": 7539.027006070798,
        "rank_S1": 13.0,
        "blocked_S1": 7539.027006070798,
        "rank_S2": 12.0,
        "blocked_S2": 7539.027006070798,
        "rank_S3": 13.0,
        "blocked_S3": 7539.027006070798,
        "rank_S4": 8.0,
        "blocked_S4": 6402.647931436973,
        "rank_S5": 5.0,
        "blocked_S5": 34757.308999999994,
        "rank_S6": 9.0,
        "blocked_S6": 7539.027006070798,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 9.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 9.0,
        "pick": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K12",
        "shortage": "Building permission",
        "category": "permission",
        "unit": "bn 2026 int$ of construction (C13) that must be permitted in 2035",
        "need_2035": 105727.507,
        "supply_on_course": 94403.39409,
        "supply_precedent": 104600.4637,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.892893408429653,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.9893401127863537,
        "short_at_precedent": 1127.0433000000048,
        "short_on_course": 11324.112909999996,
        "blocked_tier2": 1127.0432990000047,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 1127.0432990000047,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 1127.0432990000047,
        "blocked_high": 1127.0432990000047,
        "n_alternatives": 0.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO",
        "depends_on": "fewer than two sourced alternative ways found; rests on the base ratio",
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "Open the Auckland upzoning working paper (Greenaway-McGrevy and Phillips) and OECD housing-supply elasticities by metro weighted by ICP construction spend",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.07700459273700444,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.07572286962059604,
        "times_faster": 1.0169264995216158,
        "fastest_precedent": "Auckland 2016 upzoning (+50% consents within 5 years, A4:A05) in the 30% of construction under discretionary permission (A4:A04); outside it current rules permit any amount (Agent 4 capped that part at capacity)",
        "main_layer": "C13",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "A",
        "group_solid": "SCENARIO",
        "rank_all": 13.0,
        "rank_S0": 13.0,
        "blocked_S0": 1127.0432990000047,
        "rank_S1": 15.0,
        "blocked_S1": 1127.0432990000047,
        "rank_S2": 13.0,
        "blocked_S2": 1127.0432990000047,
        "rank_S3": 14.0,
        "blocked_S3": 1127.0432990000047,
        "rank_S4": 11.0,
        "blocked_S4": 1127.0432990000047,
        "rank_S5": 17.0,
        "blocked_S5": 1127.0432990000047,
        "rank_S6": 12.0,
        "blocked_S6": 1127.0432990000047,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 10.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 4.0,
        "pick": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "BUY-C12",
        "shortage": "Buyers for public services",
        "category": "buyers",
        "unit": "bn 2026 int$ of output bought",
        "need_2035": 34091.12052,
        "supply_on_course": 33265.52655037182,
        "supply_precedent": 33265.52655037182,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.975782727084496,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.975782727084496,
        "short_at_precedent": 825.5939696281785,
        "short_on_course": 825.5939696281785,
        "blocked_tier2": 825.5939686281745,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 825.5939686281745,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 825.5939686281745,
        "blocked_high": 4420.765201076206,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)",
        "depends_on": "binds only under: demand from the UN AMA world income response 2004-2014 (elasticity 0.91); demand from the UN AMA world income response 1994-2004 (elasticity 0.76)",
        "label": "E",
        "status": "TESTED",
        "test": null,
        "growth_needed_pa": null,
        "growth_precedent_pa": null,
        "times_faster": null,
        "fastest_precedent": null,
        "main_layer": "C12",
        "src": "demand_v4.csv",
        "group_label": "S/E",
        "group_solid": "untested (<=1T)",
        "rank_all": 14.0,
        "rank_S0": 14.0,
        "blocked_S0": 825.5939686281745,
        "rank_S1": 16.0,
        "blocked_S1": 825.5939686281745,
        "rank_S2": 14.0,
        "blocked_S2": 825.5939686281745,
        "rank_S3": 15.0,
        "blocked_S3": 825.5939686281745,
        "rank_S4": 10.0,
        "blocked_S4": 1302.8633224280456,
        "rank_S5": 16.0,
        "blocked_S5": 4420.765201076206,
        "rank_S6": 13.0,
        "blocked_S6": 825.5939686281745,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 4.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 1.0,
        "pick": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K06",
        "shortage": "Copper",
        "category": "materials",
        "unit": "million t refined copper per year",
        "need_2035": 51.03882403,
        "supply_on_course": 26.5106,
        "supply_precedent": 45.4269,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.5194202747386458,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.8900459770252274,
        "short_at_precedent": 5.611924029999997,
        "short_on_course": 24.52822403,
        "blocked_tier2": 165.7467183780582,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 165.7467183780582,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 144.03696137609495,
        "blocked_high": 282.6403011266366,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "not tested (blocks 1T or less)",
        "depends_on": null,
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "IEA Critical Minerals Data Explorer: copper STEPS 2035 demand, secondary supply and base/high-production mine supply in kt (replaces the 2030-40 interpolation and the held 18% secondary share)",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.06917554845780782,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.055426946841626634,
        "times_faster": 1.2480490519433725,
        "fastest_precedent": "World copper mine output 1954-1963 x1.625 in 9 years (USGS via OWID), post-1950 maximum; post-1985 maximum (1995-2004) x1.47 is the low case",
        "main_layer": "C14",
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "A",
        "group_solid": "untested (<=1T)",
        "rank_all": 15.0,
        "rank_S0": 15.0,
        "blocked_S0": 165.7467183780582,
        "rank_S1": 17.0,
        "blocked_S1": 165.7467183780582,
        "rank_S2": 15.0,
        "blocked_S2": 165.7467183780582,
        "rank_S3": 16.0,
        "blocked_S3": 165.7467183780582,
        "rank_S4": 14.0,
        "blocked_S4": 144.03696137609495,
        "rank_S5": 18.0,
        "blocked_S5": 282.6403011266366,
        "rank_S6": 14.0,
        "blocked_S6": 165.7467183780582,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 11.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 2.0,
        "pick": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K02",
        "shortage": "Fuels",
        "category": "energy",
        "unit": "EJ per year (final consumption excl. electricity)",
        "need_2035": 445.18773945600003,
        "supply_on_course": 374.0,
        "supply_precedent": 548.836,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.8400950135262297,
        "share_met_precedent": 1.2328192161595772,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 71.18773945600003,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 71782.99576593254,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)",
        "depends_on": "binds only under: v3 second ratio: IEA STEPS 2035 path (Agent 4 rerun); 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.62 the v3 ratio",
        "label": "E",
        "status": "TESTED",
        "test": null,
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.023609314109906965,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.04769328840461373,
        "times_faster": 0.4950238261957013,
        "fastest_precedent": "World fossil-fuel consumption 1965-1974 x1.52 in 9 years (EI via OWID), the post-1965 maximum",
        "main_layer": null,
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "S/E",
        "group_solid": "untested (<=1T)",
        "rank_all": 16.0,
        "rank_S0": 16.0,
        "blocked_S0": 0.0,
        "rank_S1": 18.0,
        "blocked_S1": 0.0,
        "rank_S2": 16.0,
        "blocked_S2": 0.0,
        "rank_S3": 17.0,
        "blocked_S3": 0.0,
        "rank_S4": 7.0,
        "blocked_S4": 7216.84373457129,
        "rank_S5": 3.0,
        "blocked_S5": 71782.99576593254,
        "rank_S6": 15.0,
        "blocked_S6": 0.0,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 5.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 3.0,
        "pick": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K09",
        "shortage": "Steel",
        "category": "materials",
        "unit": "Mt crude steel per year",
        "need_2035": 2901.93264675,
        "supply_on_course": 2570.4,
        "supply_precedent": 3135.54,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.8857545342682926,
        "share_met_precedent": 1.0805006117256466,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 331.5326467499999,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 18927.55399354189,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)",
        "depends_on": "binds only under: 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.29 the v3 ratio",
        "label": "E",
        "status": "TESTED",
        "test": null,
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.05022424450517593,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.05929800117314343,
        "times_faster": 0.8469803958235765,
        "fastest_precedent": "World crude steel 2002-2011 x1.68 in 9 years (worldsteel Steel Statistical Yearbook 2012)",
        "main_layer": null,
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "S/E",
        "group_solid": "untested (<=1T)",
        "rank_all": 17.0,
        "rank_S0": 16.0,
        "blocked_S0": 0.0,
        "rank_S1": 18.0,
        "blocked_S1": 0.0,
        "rank_S2": 16.0,
        "blocked_S2": 0.0,
        "rank_S3": 17.0,
        "blocked_S3": 0.0,
        "rank_S4": 15.0,
        "blocked_S4": 0.0,
        "rank_S5": 11.0,
        "blocked_S5": 18927.55399354189,
        "rank_S6": 15.0,
        "blocked_S6": 0.0,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 6.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 4.0,
        "pick": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K18",
        "shortage": "Human workforce",
        "category": "workers by skill",
        "unit": "million workers in 2035",
        "need_2035": 4316.60000011,
        "supply_on_course": 4023.24,
        "supply_precedent": 4316.6,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.9320391048272889,
        "share_met_precedent": 0.999999999974517,
        "short_at_precedent": 1.0999974620062858e-07,
        "short_on_course": 293.3600001100003,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 180815.623532,
        "n_alternatives": 2.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)",
        "depends_on": "binds only under: 2026 intensity held (today's technology, no efficiency gain): x1.69 the v3 ratio; humans' share of work with output per worker on its trend (Agent 4 2035 intensity) instead of the fastest 9-year growth",
        "label": "E",
        "status": "TESTED",
        "test": null,
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.018990822269040697,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.01899082226615545,
        "times_faster": 1.0000000001519285,
        "fastest_precedent": "WPP 15+ population 2035 x the highest world employment ratio 1991-2025 (BL T19)",
        "main_layer": null,
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "S/E",
        "group_solid": "untested (<=1T)",
        "rank_all": 18.0,
        "rank_S0": 16.0,
        "blocked_S0": 0.0,
        "rank_S1": 18.0,
        "blocked_S1": 0.0,
        "rank_S2": 16.0,
        "blocked_S2": 0.0,
        "rank_S3": 11.0,
        "blocked_S3": 10035.381211171332,
        "rank_S4": 15.0,
        "blocked_S4": 0.0,
        "rank_S5": 1.0,
        "blocked_S5": 180815.623532,
        "rank_S6": 15.0,
        "blocked_S6": 0.0,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 7.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 5.0,
        "pick": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K05",
        "shortage": "AI compute",
        "category": "machines",
        "unit": "GW of AI chip TDP in service in 2035",
        "need_2035": 146.27352256634808,
        "supply_on_course": 84.504,
        "supply_precedent": 12455.7,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.5777122100937297,
        "share_met_precedent": 85.15348356603793,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 61.76952256634807,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994,
        "n_alternatives": 3.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)",
        "depends_on": "binds only under: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them",
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "Epoch chip-sales update for 2027-28; TSMC CoWoS and HBM capacity plans to 2030",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.25536394631152937,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 1.0570108723255318,
        "times_faster": 0.2415906524686001,
        "fastest_precedent": "AI chip power sold x1.87 in 2025 (Epoch) held 2028-2035; bounded in practice by K01/K14 (power and grid)",
        "main_layer": null,
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "A",
        "group_solid": "untested (<=1T)",
        "rank_all": 19.0,
        "rank_S0": 16.0,
        "blocked_S0": 0.0,
        "rank_S1": 3.0,
        "blocked_S1": 34757.308999999994,
        "rank_S2": 16.0,
        "blocked_S2": 0.0,
        "rank_S3": 17.0,
        "blocked_S3": 0.0,
        "rank_S4": 15.0,
        "blocked_S4": 0.0,
        "rank_S5": 19.0,
        "blocked_S5": 0.0,
        "rank_S6": 15.0,
        "blocked_S6": 0.0,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 12.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 6.0,
        "pick": false
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K03",
        "shortage": "Machine cognition (AI agents)",
        "category": "machines",
        "unit": "million worker-equivalents in 2035",
        "need_2035": 537.0604189395623,
        "supply_on_course": 310.266,
        "supply_precedent": 45732.6,
        "share_met_on_course": 0.5777115368371907,
        "share_met_precedent": 85.1535476963654,
        "short_at_precedent": 0.0,
        "short_on_course": 226.79441893956226,
        "blocked_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1": 0.0,
        "blocked_tier1_beyond_precedent": 0.0,
        "tier1_competing_with_tier2": 0.0,
        "blocked_total": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_on_course": 0.0,
        "excess_not_absorbed_precedent": 0.0,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 34757.308999999994,
        "n_alternatives": 3.0,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO (binds only in another way of producing)",
        "depends_on": "binds only under: AI agents take every cognitive task first; humans move to physical tasks; robots only for physical work beyond them",
        "label": "A",
        "status": "UNTESTED",
        "test": "Task-matched benchmark of agent-hours per human-hour on real jobs (GDPval/METR); Epoch agent-population update with 2028-30 shipments",
        "growth_needed_pa": 0.17696584267992832,
        "growth_precedent_pa": 0.9285496803155593,
        "times_faster": 0.19058306349293885,
        "fastest_precedent": "AI chip power sold grew x1.87 in 2025 (Epoch), held 2028-2035 on top of the through-2027 fleet",
        "main_layer": null,
        "src": "stage1-v3/requirements/inputs_v3.csv; requirements.csv",
        "group_label": "A",
        "group_solid": "untested (<=1T)",
        "rank_all": 20.0,
        "rank_S0": 16.0,
        "blocked_S0": 0.0,
        "rank_S1": 3.0,
        "blocked_S1": 34757.308999999994,
        "rank_S2": 16.0,
        "blocked_S2": 0.0,
        "rank_S3": 17.0,
        "blocked_S3": 0.0,
        "rank_S4": 15.0,
        "blocked_S4": 0.0,
        "rank_S5": 19.0,
        "blocked_S5": 0.0,
        "rank_S6": 15.0,
        "blocked_S6": 0.0,
        "rank_changes": true,
        "rank_in_label_group": 13.0,
        "rank_in_solid_group": 7.0,
        "pick": false
      }
    ],
    "picks": [
      {
        "shortage_id": "K04",
        "shortage": "Physical machine labour (robots)",
        "category": "machines",
        "main_layer": "C11",
        "rule": "rule not met: only 2 shortages are both SOLID and [S]/[E] (K15, K17); all are picked",
        "blocked_total": 61651.59312615721,
        "blocked_low": 1137.0283592863655,
        "blocked_high": 102480.36777547782,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "label": "A",
        "solid_se": false,
        "rank_all": 1.0,
        "why": "blocks 61,652 bn on its own, 1,137-102,480 across the ways of producing; SOLID. Beat the next one down, K21 Capital stock (43,746 bn, SCENARIO), by 17,906 bn"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K21",
        "shortage": "Capital stock",
        "category": "capital",
        "main_layer": "C03",
        "rule": "rule not met: only 2 shortages are both SOLID and [S]/[E] (K15, K17); all are picked",
        "blocked_total": 43745.811249530394,
        "blocked_low": 0.0,
        "blocked_high": 80540.40160590273,
        "verdict": "SCENARIO",
        "label": "A",
        "solid_se": false,
        "rank_all": 2.0,
        "why": "blocks 43,746 bn on its own, 0-80,540 across the ways of producing; SCENARIO (depends on: v3 second ratio: lowest world capital-output ratio 1990-2023 (PWT, 2005): best demonstrated, the low case). Beat the next one down, K14 Transformers and grid equipment (32,447 bn, SOLID), by 11,299 bn"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K14",
        "shortage": "Transformers and grid equipment",
        "category": "machines",
        "main_layer": "C13",
        "rule": "rule not met: only 2 shortages are both SOLID and [S]/[E] (K15, K17); all are picked",
        "blocked_total": 32447.199321536576,
        "blocked_low": 5535.2869548039225,
        "blocked_high": 42579.2414163116,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "label": "A",
        "solid_se": false,
        "rank_all": 3.0,
        "why": "blocks 32,447 bn on its own, 5,535-42,579 across the ways of producing; SOLID. Beat the next one down, K22 Cropland (19,805 bn, SOLID), by 12,643 bn"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K22",
        "shortage": "Cropland",
        "category": "land",
        "main_layer": "C01",
        "rule": "rule not met: only 2 shortages are both SOLID and [S]/[E] (K15, K17); all are picked",
        "blocked_total": 19804.653712,
        "blocked_low": 806.164520494398,
        "blocked_high": 138508.85818366456,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "label": "A",
        "solid_se": false,
        "rank_all": 4.0,
        "why": "blocks 19,805 bn on its own, 806-138,509 across the ways of producing; SOLID. Beat the next one down, K15 Clinical approval (19,599 bn, SOLID), by 205 bn"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K15",
        "shortage": "Clinical approval",
        "category": "permission",
        "main_layer": "C05",
        "rule": "rule not met: only 2 shortages are both SOLID and [S]/[E] (K15, K17); all are picked",
        "blocked_total": 19599.438237999995,
        "blocked_low": 4932.913293800001,
        "blocked_high": 19599.438237999995,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "label": "E",
        "solid_se": true,
        "rank_all": 5.0,
        "why": "blocks 19,599 bn on its own, 4,933-19,599 across the ways of producing; SOLID. Beat the next one down, K17 Construction trades (16,044 bn, SOLID), by 3,555 bn"
      },
      {
        "shortage_id": "K17",
        "shortage": "Construction trades",
        "category": "workers by skill",
        "main_layer": "C13",
        "rule": "rule not met: only 2 shortages are both SOLID and [S]/[E] (K15, K17); all are picked",
        "blocked_total": 16044.366842846723,
        "blocked_low": 16044.366842846723,
        "blocked_high": 29826.608292081026,
        "verdict": "SOLID",
        "label": "E",
        "solid_se": true,
        "rank_all": 6.0,
        "why": "blocks 16,044 bn on its own, 16,044-29,827 across the ways of producing; SOLID. Beat the next one down, K16 Professional licensing (13,785 bn, SCENARIO), by 2,259 bn; the first shortage left out is K16 Professional licensing (13,785 bn)"
      }
    ],
    "agents": [
      {
        "key": "a1_in",
        "value": 97.0,
        "label": "E",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv (Agent 1 rows), counted",
        "what": "Agent 1 items already inside on course"
      },
      {
        "key": "a1_all",
        "value": 143.0,
        "label": "E",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv + not_inside.csv (Agent 1 rows)",
        "what": "Agent 1 items checked against on course"
      },
      {
        "key": "a2_energy",
        "value": 323426.5,
        "label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/totals.csv (T16)",
        "what": "Output the fastest sourced energy supply can power in 2035"
      },
      {
        "key": "a3_needs",
        "value": 36.0,
        "label": "E",
        "src": "stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/needs.csv (rows)",
        "what": "Human needs mapped"
      },
      {
        "key": "a3_health",
        "value": 4600.0,
        "label": "S",
        "src": "stage1-v2/v1/agent3_needs/needs.csv (N08)",
        "what": "People lacking adequate health care (millions)"
      },
      {
        "key": "a4_bind",
        "value": 3.0,
        "label": "E",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (status = binding)",
        "what": "Inputs binding at their fastest precedent (repaired Agent 4)"
      },
      {
        "key": "a4_total",
        "value": 18.0,
        "label": "E",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (rows)",
        "what": "Inputs Agent 4 tested"
      },
      {
        "key": "a4_blk",
        "value": 19869.1,
        "label": "A",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent4_bottlenecks/bottlenecks.csv (K18 output_blocked_ppp_bn)",
        "what": "Output the human workforce blocks (repaired Agent 4)"
      },
      {
        "key": "a5_in",
        "value": 3.0,
        "label": "E",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv (Agent 5 rows)",
        "what": "Agent 5 capabilities already inside on course"
      },
      {
        "key": "a5_caps",
        "value": 9.0,
        "label": "E",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/inside_on_course.csv + not_inside.csv (Agent 5 rows)",
        "what": "Agent 5 capabilities checked"
      },
      {
        "key": "a6_reach3",
        "value": 0.0,
        "label": "E",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/inputs.csv (reach_3x = yes)",
        "what": "Inputs that reach 3x cheaper by 2035 (repaired Agent 6)"
      },
      {
        "key": "a6_n",
        "value": 13.0,
        "label": "E",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/inputs.csv (rows)",
        "what": "Inputs Agent 6 priced"
      },
      {
        "key": "a6_ach",
        "value": 828.83318,
        "label": "E",
        "src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv (achievable TOTAL)",
        "what": "Output created at sourced input prices, net of on course"
      }
    ],
    "demand": [
      {
        "layer_id": "C13",
        "layer": "Built structures",
        "today": 54228.765,
        "target": 105727.507,
        "extra_output": 43316.48898,
        "income_ratio": 2.000000000115044,
        "income_elasticity": 0.8424806807131314,
        "income_elasticity_label": "E",
        "income_elasticity_src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, Construction (ISIC F) vs GDP, 2014-2024)",
        "price_ratio_2035": 0.9937160058,
        "price_ratio_src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv (achievable case, price_fall_of_product)",
        "price_elasticity": 0.0,
        "price_elasticity_src": "no market price (budgets or investment set quantity): no price response",
        "demand_2035": 97239.2654842971,
        "demand_label": "E",
        "buyers_short": 8488.241515702903,
        "verdict": "not all bought: buyers short of 8,488 bn; buyers are the shortage",
        "income_elasticity_other_windows": "2004-2014: 0.964; 1994-2004: 0.487"
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C03",
        "layer": "Shelter and utilities",
        "today": 29600.326,
        "target": 59177.23267,
        "extra_output": 25096.56167,
        "income_ratio": 2.000000000115044,
        "income_elasticity": 1.0640232858463277,
        "income_elasticity_label": "E",
        "income_elasticity_src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (income elasticity from v1 bridge, eta)",
        "price_ratio_2035": 0.97579941,
        "price_ratio_src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv (achievable case, price_fall_of_product)",
        "price_elasticity": -0.667,
        "price_elasticity_src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (price elasticity, Agent 2)",
        "demand_2035": 62906.55926082677,
        "demand_label": "E",
        "buyers_short": 0.0,
        "verdict": "bought: demand at the 2035 price covers the target",
        "income_elasticity_other_windows": null
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C05",
        "layer": "Health care",
        "today": 23473.491,
        "target": 51080.94924,
        "extra_output": 21082.92824,
        "income_ratio": 2.000000000115044,
        "income_elasticity": 1.2797350706217443,
        "income_elasticity_label": "E",
        "income_elasticity_src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (income elasticity from v1 bridge, eta)",
        "price_ratio_2035": 0.9962068233,
        "price_ratio_src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv (achievable case, price_fall_of_product)",
        "price_elasticity": -0.2,
        "price_elasticity_src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (price elasticity, Agent 2)",
        "demand_2035": 57035.65370154309,
        "demand_label": "E",
        "buyers_short": 0.0,
        "verdict": "bought: demand at the 2035 price covers the target",
        "income_elasticity_other_windows": null
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C11",
        "layer": "Personal and financial services",
        "today": 15866.528,
        "target": 34976.03323,
        "extra_output": 15742.35523,
        "income_ratio": 2.000000000115044,
        "income_elasticity": 1.3124011916910145,
        "income_elasticity_label": "E",
        "income_elasticity_src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (income elasticity from v1 bridge, eta)",
        "price_ratio_2035": 0.997958372,
        "price_ratio_src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv (achievable case, price_fall_of_product)",
        "price_elasticity": -0.972,
        "price_elasticity_src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/demand_test.csv (price elasticity, Agent 2)",
        "demand_2035": 39483.60055359626,
        "demand_label": "E",
        "buyers_short": 0.0,
        "verdict": "bought: demand at the 2035 price covers the target",
        "income_elasticity_other_windows": null
      },
      {
        "layer_id": "C12",
        "layer": "Public services",
        "today": 17485.699,
        "target": 34091.12052,
        "extra_output": 14169.83152,
        "income_ratio": 2.000000000115044,
        "income_elasticity": 0.9278524001448805,
        "income_elasticity_label": "E",
        "income_elasticity_src": "stage1-v3/repair/baseline/work/ama_ppp.csv (UN AMA world, General government final consumption expenditure vs GDP, 2014-2024)",
        "price_ratio_2035": 0.9902674675,
        "price_ratio_src": "stage1-v3/repair/agent6_cheap_inputs/joint.csv (achievable case, price_fall_of_product)",
        "price_elasticity": 0.0,
        "price_elasticity_src": "no market price (budgets or investment set quantity): no price response",
        "demand_2035": 33265.52655037182,
        "demand_label": "E",
        "buyers_short": 825.5939696281785,
        "verdict": "not all bought: buyers short of 826 bn; buyers are the shortage",
        "income_elasticity_other_windows": "2004-2014: 0.907; 1994-2004: 0.763"
      }
    ],
    "searches": [
      {
        "id": "W1",
        "query": "Mueller 2012 Nature closing yield gaps nutrient water management production increase 45% 70% attainable yields",
        "source": "Mueller N.D. et al. (2012) Closing yield gaps through nutrient and water management, Nature 490:254-257, doi:10.1038/nature11420",
        "url": "https://ideas.repec.org/a/nat/nature/v490y2012i7419d10.1038_nature11420.html",
        "value_low": 0.45,
        "value_high": 0.7,
        "label": "S",
        "used_for": "K22 cropland, step 3: crop output per ha if yield gaps close to 100% of attainable yields (+45% to +70% for most crops)"
      },
      {
        "id": "W2",
        "query": "Smith Newhouse Freeland 2009 Health Affairs technology share of health spending growth 27 to 48 percent",
        "source": "Smith S., Newhouse J.P., Freeland M.S. (2009) Income, insurance, and technology: why does health spending outpace economic growth? Health Affairs 28(5):1276-1284",
        "url": "https://www.hks.harvard.edu/publications/income-insurance-and-technology-why-does-health-spending-outpace-economic-growth",
        "value_low": 0.27,
        "value_high": 0.48,
        "label": "S",
        "used_for": "K15 clinical approval, step 3: share of health spending growth that comes from new medical technology (27% to 48%)"
      }
    ],
    "checks": [
      {
        "check": "each layer: today + on-course growth + tier 1 + tier 2 = its target",
        "ok": true,
        "detail": "19 layers"
      },
      {
        "check": "layers sum to 448.5T (= 2 x today)",
        "ok": true,
        "detail": "448,523.8 bn = 2 x 224,261.9"
      },
      {
        "check": "every missing dollar is in a named shortage or on the unexplained list",
        "ok": true,
        "detail": "missing 182,904.9 = explained 141,434.1 + unexplained 41,470.8; 35 rows"
      },
      {
        "check": "unexplained output carries a size and no name",
        "ok": true,
        "detail": "10 rows, 41,470.8 bn"
      },
      {
        "check": "no shortage blocks more output than exists in the layers it serves (every cell, every total, every variant)",
        "ok": true,
        "detail": "56 shortage-variants"
      },
      {
        "check": "cropland: what it blocks in food at home stays inside food at home's missing output and target",
        "ok": true,
        "detail": "v4 cropland blocks 5,901.6 bn in C01 (missing 7,139.8, target 21,195.6); in all 19,804.7 bn across 7 layers whose crop footprint it serves (v3 put 6,066 bn of C01 and 45.4T counted once across all layers on it, by proportional shares)"
      },
      {
        "check": "information: v3's proportional 'output depending' cells that exceed their layer's missing output (v4 fixes this)",
        "ok": true,
        "detail": "31 cells: K01 C01, K01 C02, K01 C04, K01 C09, K01 C14, K01 C15, K11 C15, K13 C01, K13 C02, K13 C04, K13 C09, K13 C14"
      },
      {
        "check": "nothing counted twice: each row once, each shortage's total = its own cells, explained = union per row (not a sum of shortages)",
        "ok": true,
        "detail": "sum of shortages on their own 264,643.1 bn (overlapping, never added into a total); explained union 141,434.1 bn"
      },
      {
        "check": "every shortage over 1T is tested: range, SOLID only if it binds in every way, SCENARIO names its assumption",
        "ok": true,
        "detail": "13 shortages over 1T"
      },
      {
        "check": "every shortage labelled; each resting on an assumed size or rate is UNTESTED with its cheapest test",
        "ok": true,
        "detail": "16 UNTESTED"
      },
      {
        "check": "six picks: at most two per layer; at least three SOLID [S]/[E] (or every such shortage when fewer exist)",
        "ok": true,
        "detail": "2 SOLID [S]/[E] of 2; rule not met: only 2 shortages are both SOLID and [S]/[E] (K15, K17); all are picked"
      },
      {
        "check": "ranking counts each shortage on its own (no sharing rule) and shows the order under every scenario",
        "ok": true,
        "detail": "20 shortages, 20 change rank across scenarios"
      },
      {
        "check": "every web search listed with its source",
        "ok": true,
        "detail": "2 searches"
      },
      {
        "check": "stage1-v1, stage1-v2 and stage1-v3 untouched",
        "ok": true,
        "detail": "1846 files"
      }
    ],
    "scenarios": [
      {
        "id": "S0",
        "scenario": "base"
      },
      {
        "id": "S1",
        "scenario": "AI takes cognitive tasks first"
      },
      {
        "id": "S2",
        "scenario": "humans keep cognitive tasks"
      },
      {
        "id": "S3",
        "scenario": "labour productivity on trend"
      },
      {
        "id": "S4",
        "scenario": "v3 second sourced ratios"
      },
      {
        "id": "S5",
        "scenario": "2026 intensities / K-Y trend"
      },
      {
        "id": "S6",
        "scenario": "land- and approval-saving technology, task reallocation"
      }
    ]
  }
}
